Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Smoothing Plane Mass

Posts

Smoothing Plane Mass

#1

Smoothing Plane Mass

Lyn J. Mangiameli


>With reference to the L-N Bronze threads below:

Derek:

Whether it [mass] is a factor in producing a better surface finish is one issue, but whether it makes for an easier time of achieving a fine finish compared to a plane with less mass is a much easier point to answer

Dave:

There are two qualities I believe extra mass brings to the arsenal: holding the smoother bedded to the wood (&) maintaining inertia. [snip] I'm sure everyone has experienced a sudden small unexpected grain switch in wood that stalls the movement of the plane.

Lyn:

I just ran a Pearson two tailed correlation between weight in grams and quality of surface finish on 31 plane/effective cutting angle combinations. Results: Correlation of .318 with a failure to achieve the usual standards of statistical significance (.081). Weights ranged from a low of 776 grams (Mujingfang) to a high of 2850 grams (SMT).

I ran it again on 13 plane/effective cutting angle combinations where the effective cutting angle was restricted to 55 degrees or higher. Results: Correlation of .096 (essentially none at all) with a significance of .756 (a total failure to achieve statistical significance).

When I restrict it to 9 plane/effective cutting angle combinations where the effective cutting angle was between 60 and 65 degrees. Results: Correlation of -.039 (absolutely none at all) with a significance of .920 (again a total failure to achieve a statistical significance).

So at least based on my assessments of surface finish (based on a combination of direct and single blind ratings), reporting on 31 plane/angle combinations (that is some planes were examined in more than one effective cutting angle configuration), weight simply did not become a significant factor. That said, Derek and Dave both make the point that there may be handling and technique differences which may result in a personal preference for a more massive plane.

However, I would point out that not everyone shares that preference. Keep in mind that the force used to overcome the resistance of the wood fibers has two components: mass and acceleration. So the speed at which the plane is moved, an issue of technique, can play a major role in how much one perceives mass to be of benefit. Also keep in mind that inertial mass makes it more difficult to change the direction of a plane once it is in motion. [Both of these are further affected by the body mass and muscular strength, as well as coordination, of the person planing]. Put more simply and practically, when you are used to planing in relatively slow linear strokes, you are apt to prefer a more massive plane for smoothing. If you are accustomed to making rapid strokes that shift in direction to accommodate grain patterns or wood contours, a lighter plane may seem preferable. In the past, my preference was always for heavier planes (particularly a little infill that weighs just shy of 6lbs 10oz�the same as that Bronze L-N 4.5), but once I accustomed myself to the planing techniques most suitable for the lighter planes, I found I can be equally happy with them. Either way, the surface finish I obtain is not determined by plane weight, but by a combination of other factors.

Now stepping back out of the arena.

Re: Smoothing Plane Mass

#2

Re: Smoothing Plane Mass

Dan Clermont in BUrnaby


>Hi Lyn

I have a preference for heavier planes. I also am a large fan of sole lubrication. The mass of a heavier plane can still exist without the friction common to a heavy plane and the acceleration generated by a lubricated sole can make it move like a wooden plane or a much lighter smoothing plane.

Just my Opinion

Dan Clermont

Re: Smoothing Plane Mass

#3

Re: Smoothing Plane Mass

thomd


>"So the speed at which the plane is moved, an issue of technique, can play a major role in how much one perceives mass to be of benefit"

This is one reason why I like bronze it is very slipery on wood compared to Iron.

Geometry is a big factor in how well the plane hooks up if the plane is pulled through the wood it hooks up like and anchor, rather that feeling like it wants to skip up out of the cut. Japanese planes come to mind but they are not the only type a little biased to the pull action, the horned euro planes also seem to favor pulling in my hands. I push them but the action is a tractor action not a pusher action. If the plane hooks up well in the wood then weight is of very little importance.

Re: Smoothing Plane Mass

#4

Research proposal

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)


>Great response Lyn. Now we need a correlational study that explores plane mass, plane accelleration, and wood finish. All we must control for is the bench height, strength, height and reach of the woodworker, number of years of using handplanes, frustration tolerance, and bank balance. Is there an equivalent of the Nobel Prize in Science for woodworkers, or should it be a Peace Prize? :)

It is great to see you back here.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Smoothing Plane Mass

#5

Welcome Back! Nice to see you here.

Paul Kierstead

Re: Smoothing Plane Mass

#6

Yo, tambien amigo.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

Re: Smoothing Plane Mass

#7

Friction differs from inertia

Bill Houghton, retired fun in Sebastopol, CA


>I'm a fan of waxing plane soles myself, but I think Lyn's point is that the inertia generated by a heavier plane may make it more difficult to switch directions quickly. More or less regardless of road conditions, a light sports car will change directions more nimbly than an SUV; same concept with a light plane versus a heavy one.

I've certainly experienced this myself in maneuvering a No. 6 versus a No. 4.

Re: Smoothing Plane Mass

#8

Re: Research proposal

thomd


>Good job for the technical forum!

Re: Smoothing Plane Mass

#9

Re: Smoothing Plane Mass

Dave Thompson


>Well Lyn, I am certainly glad to see you back. It�s been a while (Badger Pond days for me), and I hope you will have time to drop in more frequently. We've been talking about you here while you've been away.

FWIW, I�m not aware that anyone is making an argument in the recent threads that increased mass is related to surface finish which I believe was the focus of your study. I certainly would like to know more about your study with regards to what constituted a count, technique used, and wood properties involved.

My arguments were with regards to risk reduction rather than surface finish, which is a very different thing. If issues do not occur while planing, I believe the surfaces will be equal. Further my assertion was risk reduction may occur using other techniques besides increasing the mass, of which I pointed a few out. If one is employing these techniques then naturally, increasing the mass has less effect at reducing risk, possibly to the point of being statistically insignificant.

Put in other terms, if you do A,B,C,&D all the time bad thing are unlikely to happen. If your tool has X quality, then maybe you can forget to do C&D and still reduce the chance of bad thing from occurring. If you do A, B, C, & D and have quality X in your tool, X may of course seem pointless... ...until you accidentally screw up and forget about D one time.

Lyn: Keep in mind that the force used to overcome the resistance of the wood fibers has two components: mass and acceleration. So the speed at which the plane is moved, an issue of technique, can play a major role in how much one perceives mass to be of benefit. [snip] Put more simply and practically, when you are used to planing in relatively slow linear strokes, you are apt to prefer a more massive plane for smoothing. If you are accustomed to making rapid strokes that shift in direction to accommodate grain patterns or wood contours, a lighter plane may seem preferable. In the past, my preference was always for heavier planes (particularly a little infill that weighs just shy of 6lbs 10oz�the same as that Bronze L-N 4.5), but once I accustomed myself to the planing techniques most suitable for the lighter planes, I found I can be equally happy with them


Momentum being mass * velocity, a 3 lbs smoother has half the momentum of a 6lbs smoother moving at the same speed. With a 6 pounder, one could go half the speed of a 3 pounder, or one could go almost as fast and mitigate a stall mid cut. Regarding the technique of not going in straight lines with light smoothers, i.e. steering around the bad parts, I would think anyone would do this who is aware of what to avoid regardless of smoother mass, though easier if lighter. The trick is in seeing the bad parts before one goes over them and not missing the mark. In some uniform colored figured woods, these are not so easily visible before hand, nor are the boundaries well defined. Further, I might know where to avoid, but accidentally go ~� inch to far. I can reduce my risk of stalling by increasing my momentum. Increasing the speed creates a control issue, increasing the mass is more of a fatigue issue. Choose your poison. One can always take a rest break.

Dave

Re: Smoothing Plane Mass

#10

Glad to see ya Lynn!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA


>Back among the living eh ;^) I for one missed ya!

Now I actully need to read your post!

Cherrs!

Re: Smoothing Plane Mass

#11

Re: Glad to see ya Lynn!

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native now in Jax Fl.


>concur 100% with Scott. Wonderings have been made as to your whereabouts. Seems there was some mention that you may of had some health issues in the recent past. Any truth to that? If so I certainly hope that they are behind you now.

A discussion or two has came up that we felt required your inputs so we turned on the Lyn Bat-light but we got no response. Perhaps you just didn't see it from your dungeon lab eh? ;~)

Todd O.