Smoothing Plane Mass
Lyn J. Mangiameli
>With reference to the L-N Bronze threads below:
Derek:
Whether it [mass] is a factor in producing a better surface finish is one issue, but whether it makes for an easier time of achieving a fine finish compared to a plane with less mass is a much easier point to answer
Dave:
There are two qualities I believe extra mass brings to the arsenal: holding the smoother bedded to the wood (&) maintaining inertia. [snip] I'm sure everyone has experienced a sudden small unexpected grain switch in wood that stalls the movement of the plane.
Lyn:
I just ran a Pearson two tailed correlation between weight in grams and quality of surface finish on 31 plane/effective cutting angle combinations. Results: Correlation of .318 with a failure to achieve the usual standards of statistical significance (.081). Weights ranged from a low of 776 grams (Mujingfang) to a high of 2850 grams (SMT).
I ran it again on 13 plane/effective cutting angle combinations where the effective cutting angle was restricted to 55 degrees or higher. Results: Correlation of .096 (essentially none at all) with a significance of .756 (a total failure to achieve statistical significance).
When I restrict it to 9 plane/effective cutting angle combinations where the effective cutting angle was between 60 and 65 degrees. Results: Correlation of -.039 (absolutely none at all) with a significance of .920 (again a total failure to achieve a statistical significance).
So at least based on my assessments of surface finish (based on a combination of direct and single blind ratings), reporting on 31 plane/angle combinations (that is some planes were examined in more than one effective cutting angle configuration), weight simply did not become a significant factor. That said, Derek and Dave both make the point that there may be handling and technique differences which may result in a personal preference for a more massive plane.
However, I would point out that not everyone shares that preference. Keep in mind that the force used to overcome the resistance of the wood fibers has two components: mass and acceleration. So the speed at which the plane is moved, an issue of technique, can play a major role in how much one perceives mass to be of benefit. Also keep in mind that inertial mass makes it more difficult to change the direction of a plane once it is in motion. [Both of these are further affected by the body mass and muscular strength, as well as coordination, of the person planing]. Put more simply and practically, when you are used to planing in relatively slow linear strokes, you are apt to prefer a more massive plane for smoothing. If you are accustomed to making rapid strokes that shift in direction to accommodate grain patterns or wood contours, a lighter plane may seem preferable. In the past, my preference was always for heavier planes (particularly a little infill that weighs just shy of 6lbs 10oz�the same as that Bronze L-N 4.5), but once I accustomed myself to the planing techniques most suitable for the lighter planes, I found I can be equally happy with them. Either way, the surface finish I obtain is not determined by plane weight, but by a combination of other factors.
Now stepping back out of the arena.



