Re: Extremely subjective.... and here's an alterna
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>In the right situation, I think the additional weight has it's merit. With the woods I use, I'd take a total SWAG and say the extra mass come into play 10% of the time for me, though I'm sure I'll use it much more often than that. The rest of the time it would just be exercise.
Dave, I think that is a great summary of the added value of a heavier smoother.
A few years ago now, Lyn Mangiameli wrote that marvellous article on high angle smoothers. His research results demonstrated that the mass of a smoother was not a factor in performance on woods with demanding figure. Since I am inclined to accept that Lyn achieved these results with rigorous scientific methodology, I must also accept that mass is not truely the make-or-break in smoothing performance (witness how well received are the woodies of Steve Knight, HNT Gordon, Mujingfang, and C&W). Obviously there are other factors at play, and we know some of them: thickness of blade, sharpness, stability of bedding, cutting angle, etc. In my own experience with Australian hardwoods, which do place greater demands on a smoother than average (in my presumption), there is no doubt that extra mass is very welcome. Whether it is a factor in producing a better surface finish is one issue, but whether it makes for an easier time of achieving a fine finish compared to a plane with less mass is a much easier point to answer (it does).
I am battling to avoid the temptation of getting a bronze #4 1/2 myself.
Dave (who'd also love to get his hands on a bronze LV BU smoother with cocobolo handles should they ever decide to make one.)
At the risk of sounding like a commercial (I have absolutely no interest here), the closest to this is the Marcou smoother I reviewed. Damn it is good!
Regards from Perth
Derek