Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Bronze LN 4.5

Posts

Bronze LN 4.5

#1

Bronze LN 4.5

Rocky Cleveland,TN


>I've decided to buy a LN 4.5. The new anniversary plane looks very tempting but is it worth the extra money? Does anyone think the extra pound of mass is going to raise the performance enough to warrent the $125 difference? I know this is a pretty subjective question but I would appreciate your opinions. Thanks.

Rocky

Re: Bronze LN 4.5

#2

Re: Bronze LN 4.5

Dan Clermont in Burnaby


>Hi Rocky

The price difference if you are buying directly from LN is $100US. Maybeo somebody out there like the Fine Tool Journal has the LN 4.5 (non-Bronze for less) but you may have to wait as from what I have heard they can sometimes be out of stock

The Bronze comes with Cocobolo handles already which would make the price difference $75. The extra weight is also nice and as Derek Cohen recently commented on his Marcoux Smoother review it helps with demanding woods. I personally like my LN 5.5 for its added weight and paid $25 more over the LN 5 and LN 4.5 to have that. So now the price difference is $50.

If you don't like the LN 4.5 Bronze or decide later on you want just a regular LN 4.5 or a LV or a C & W or what have you. I'll guarantee you will get more then or close to $400 for your Bronze 4.5

Matter of fact, their is already a Bronze 4.5 on the Bay selling for almost $400 and it has about 8 days left in the auction.

Guess what I am saying is, if you have the money and think $400 is something your better half won't disapprove off go for it.

I have one on order even though I like my LN 5.5 allot

Dan Clermont

Re: Bronze LN 4.5

#3

Extremely subjective.... and here's an alternative

Dave Thompson


>Does anyone think the extra pound of mass is going to raise the performance enough to warrent the $125 difference?

I think that's purely subjective. It's cheaper just to epoxy some lead ingots to your smoother. I think you can get them cheaply at Wallmart in the fishing section. Could probably do that for under $5. I don't mean to sound flip, but from a purely functional view with regards to weight, I see this as equivalent.

The extra mass done in an aesthetic way was the argument for me... at least that's what I tell myself. I know others like the limited edition aspect of it. Also, while I was interested in the additional mass, I believe many aren't too interested in lugging a 6 3/4 lbs smoother. Historically speaking, a nearly 7lbs smoother is on the extreme end. I'd venture a guess and say 99% of the smoother out there are lighter. I have #3-size Ohio woodie coffin smoother weighs in around 1 1/2 lbs, and who knows how long some wood workers might have been satisfied with that.

In the right situation, I think the additional weight has it's merit. With the woods I use, I'd take a total SWAG and say the extra mass come into play 10% of the time for me, though I'm sure I'll use it much more often than that. The rest of the time it would just be exercise.

There are many other features that LN4.5B has besides weight, though depending on your current aresenal that may or may not be worth considering.

enjoy,

Dave (who'd also love to get his hands on a bronze LV BU smoother with cocobolo handles should they ever decide to make one.)

Re: Bronze LN 4.5

#4

Re: Bronze LN 4.5

Rocky Cleveland,TN


>Dan,

Thanks for the response. I think I'll show my wife your post so she understands it's only a $50 difference and a great investment. Luckily she really doesn't care what I spend on tools. I guess that's all the convincing I needed and will be contacting LN tommorrow. I take it you haven't gotton your plane yet. I hope you give us your impressions after you've been able to use it. Thanks again.

Rocky

Re: Bronze LN 4.5

#5

Re: Bronze LN 4.5

Dan Clermont in Burnaby


>Hi Rocky

I have been on the Bronze 4.5 bandwagon way before Tom LN mentioned on the WoodCentral chat he was thinking about doing it for the 25th Anniversary.

My conversations with LN USA and LN Canada led me to believe it was going to be around $500US if they EVER did make one. When the LN Bronze 4.5 was offered at $400 WITH the Cocobolo tote it seemed to be such a small investment above and beyond buying jsut the LN 4.5 which everybody has and as I mentioned before I like the weight of my LN 5.5 but would like a shorter heavy plane.

I ordered my LN 4.5 Bronze on June 30th and was the thrid in Canada to order one according to LN Canada. I don't want to call and bug Rob Cosman about it anymore cause he knows I am sitting on pins and needles but until he gets some Bronze 4.5's I am gonna have to wait paitiently.

Sure is hard though watching others show pics of their new Bronze 4.5's on other forums. Maybe I'll get a cool number like 499 or 500 ;)

I'll post my impressions when I get mine. When you call tomorrow do me a favour and ask how many are left.

Dan Clermont

Re: Bronze LN 4.5

#6

Re: Extremely subjective.... and here's an alterna

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)


>In the right situation, I think the additional weight has it's merit. With the woods I use, I'd take a total SWAG and say the extra mass come into play 10% of the time for me, though I'm sure I'll use it much more often than that. The rest of the time it would just be exercise.

Dave, I think that is a great summary of the added value of a heavier smoother.

A few years ago now, Lyn Mangiameli wrote that marvellous article on high angle smoothers. His research results demonstrated that the mass of a smoother was not a factor in performance on woods with demanding figure. Since I am inclined to accept that Lyn achieved these results with rigorous scientific methodology, I must also accept that mass is not truely the make-or-break in smoothing performance (witness how well received are the woodies of Steve Knight, HNT Gordon, Mujingfang, and C&W). Obviously there are other factors at play, and we know some of them: thickness of blade, sharpness, stability of bedding, cutting angle, etc. In my own experience with Australian hardwoods, which do place greater demands on a smoother than average (in my presumption), there is no doubt that extra mass is very welcome. Whether it is a factor in producing a better surface finish is one issue, but whether it makes for an easier time of achieving a fine finish compared to a plane with less mass is a much easier point to answer (it does).

I am battling to avoid the temptation of getting a bronze #4 1/2 myself.

Dave (who'd also love to get his hands on a bronze LV BU smoother with cocobolo handles should they ever decide to make one.)

At the risk of sounding like a commercial (I have absolutely no interest here), the closest to this is the Marcou smoother I reviewed. Damn it is good!



Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Bronze LN 4.5

#7

Re: Bronze LN 4.5

Ian Smith (Sydney Australia)


>I'm with Dan on this one. I like my Lie-Nielsen 5.5 but in the end I couldn't resist the bronze 4.5. I reckon the weight and the high angle frog will make it a great plane. I ordered one last Monday (09/25).

Regards,

Ian.

Re: Bronze LN 4.5

#9

Ahhh....

Rob Lee


>... that 'cause he starts with a good blade .... :)

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Bronze LN 4.5

#11

What mass brings, and some alternative techniques

Dave Thompson


>I think we're in agreement. Regarding Lyn's article, I don't recall reading that one, though I often enjoyed his thoroughness. I do think it's a very difficult thing to measure, and highly subjective to the particular wood qualities at hand, so I find it entirely likely that one would and would not be able to measure a benefit. As I mentioned in my earlier note, in my usage the benefits would occur only a small percentage of the time. There are two qualities I believe extra mass brings to the arsenal:



  1. holding the smoother bedded to the wood

  2. maintaining inertia


Whether or not this kind of assistance is helpful depends on a few factors. I think added technique and careful selection of wood can compensate for the need, but it's nice to make life easier when possible. Here are some details, and alternatives techniques to increased mass.

Regarding inertia maintenance, I'm sure everyone has experienced a sudden small unexpected grain switch in wood that stalls the movement of the plane. Of course this is far more common in figured wood. Often the stalling of the plane is from planing against the grain in a tiny area. Not a good idea, but unexpected is the key word. Of course tearout in this instance would be highly likely. I believe that as this tearout is occurring, the slower the plane moves, the greater the damage that this tearout will be. An alternative technique for reducing this issue is to use lighter cuts, and probably the most effective. Carefully inspecting ones wood and taking note for planing direction change can help, though uniformity of grain color may hide this. Using a ROS is another way to avoid this issue;-)

Re: Bronze LN 4.5

#12

LV bronze BU smoother

Dave Thompson


>Dave (who'd also love to get his hands on a bronze LV BU smoother with cocobolo handles should they ever decide to make one.)

Derek: At the risk of sounding like a commercial (I have absolutely no interest here), the closest to this is the Marcou smoother I reviewed.


I know that was just a drive by....but those of us still paying down the principle on our house and find it difficult to justify to the spouse, a beautiful made to order one off plane, are currently out of luck. ;-)

The variable pitch use of a BU smoother in my mind makes it even more benefitted by a higher mass. Frankly, I much prefer the size of a 164 to a 62 for planing end grain. I would be surprised if anyone wouldn't welcome extra mass for planing end grain. As I mentioned in my note below, a high angle pitch, commonly used on an LV BU smoother, would have the most benefit. I think the added mass is even a better fit with 164ish type plane than a bailey because of it's higher likely hood to be used as a low angle end grain cutter and a high angle pitch plane.

I would venture a guess that these benefits were well thought out and believed by Rob and his engineers too since they came out with a 1.5 lbs heavier LV 164.5 after a traditional LV 164.

Dave

Re: Bronze LN 4.5

#13

Re: Bronze LN 4.5

Ian Smith (Sydney Australia)


>I ordered direct from Lie-Nielsen USA. I find that even after postage it works out a little cheaper with the exchange rate where it is at the moment. This is the first time I've ordered something from them though that doesn't ship straight away so I'm counting on the Australian dollar holding its value for at least a few more months.

Regards,

Ian.

Re: Bronze LN 4.5

#14

Re: Bronze LN 4.5

Dave Thompson


>This is the first time I've ordered something from them though that doesn't ship straight away so I'm counting on the Australian dollar holding its value for at least a few more months.


Are you kidding? With the way the US trade deficit is going, I would imagine there are many increasingly cheaper LN's in your future.

Re: Bronze LN 4.5

#15

Re: Bronze LN 4.5

John Hoffman


>Hey, I have the regular 4.5 LN signed by the man. If you get the aniversay 4.5 and don't like it, contact me and we will trade (I will give you some cash).

Regards

JH

Re: Bronze LN 4.5

#16

sent you an e-mail

Rocky Cleveland,TN