Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Router

Posts

Router

#1

Router

Vlad


>Good morning,

I'm building more furniture for kids #1 and #3 (#2 has all our IKEA furniture that I bought when I was single) and decided that I need a router. Should I look for an older model Stanley for (insert price here)or break down and purchase the LV for ($150 plus tax).

Will the Stanley do everything the LV can do?

Do I need the fence?

I'm thinking of buying a Stanley but cost + shipping may stop me from pursuing that option.

Any other comments.

Thank you in advance.

Vlad

PS. If you have a spare and want to get rid of it, pls ping me.

Re: Router

#2

Re: Router *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)


>Should I look for an older model Stanley for (insert price here)or break down and purchase the LV for ($150 plus tax).

Will the Stanley do everything the LV can do?

Do I need the fence?

Hi Vlad

There is no two ways about it, the LV is far better made (better finished and ductile vs grey iron), nicer to use (just feels more solid), has a few advanced features that the Stanley lacks (such as the adjustment system and depth stop) - and is prettier too. But they still do the same job. If you have the spare cash, get the Veritas - you will not regret it. But if the cost is a factor, the Stanley will work as well. Hell, you could even make your own. Check out Alf's website for a step-by-step article.

I find the fence very useful, for example in planing grooves for drawers. Again, the fence in the LV is a better design than the Stanley.

Have a read of my review of the LV Router. I made several comparisons with the Stanley. Link below.

Regards from Perth

Derek


LV Router Plane - a review

Re: Router

#3

Re: Router

paul womack


>Depending on what you're trying to do an OWT may serve, for very low cost.

BugBear

Re: Router

#4

Re: Router

Vlad


>Hi Paul,

What's an OWT?

Cheers.

Re: Router

#5

Re: Router *LINK*

mikew


>Old Woman's Tooth:


Alf's OWT link

Re: Router

#6

Re: Router

Vlad


>Thanks Mike. This might be fun - I may use steel and brass though...

Re: Router

#8

Re: It's prettier?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)


>Hi Scott

I guess it is a case of "one man's meat is another man's poison" :)

I do think that the LV is prettier than the Stanley #71. This is not really fair comparison since the LV was based on the #71 1/2, which has nice lines as well. In the prettiness stakes my vote goes to a brass #71 1/2, which I have. It was probably cast by a patternmaker many years ago. Some of the OWT I have seen would also rank high on the list.

Here are the router planes I own. LV, Stanley #71 and brass #71 1/2 along with the dinky Stanley #271.



Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Router

#9

Re: Router

paul womack


>Since OWT's have the blade at a steep angle, they can work narrower holes (front to back) than metal "low angle" routers, and also have less tear out.

Of course, most surfaces you cuts with a router are eventually hidden, so tear out isn't normally important.

BugBear

Re: Router

#11

Please explain

jim reed @ tallahassee


>what you do with that neato blade.

Re: Router

#12

Re: Please explain

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)


>Hi Jim

I built this with the intention of cutting grooves for stringing. So far I have not used it for this, but I have found that it makes a great "bullnose" router plane and can cut in any direction (with and against the grain). I have used for stop grooves very successfully. This one is 3/8" and I am going to make a few more in a variety of sizes.

Here is a picture of cutting with and across the grain.



And here is one that shows off the quality of the shavings it can take. The wood is Karri, which is more difficult to plane without tearout than Jarrah!



Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Router

#13

Ah Ha!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA


>That's why your 71 1/2 looks different than mine. Expecally the handles. I think the 71 1/2 is much nicer looking than the hump backed 71.