My results
thomd
>OK I took the LV BU plane I had used for the deflection testing. I grabbed a piece of maple about 12 inches wide by 1.1". by the length of the plane It's stock for some plane handles and is in mill state. I put it in my Tucker vise which made the whole thing a little high and I planed away the rough surface which was also about 1/16" longi concave. The plane was taking very nice 3 thou shavings.
When I initially got the surface barked back, it was very slightly longi concave, even though I took full length passes. I have a 36" Rabone Chesterman machinist's straight edge. Under closer inspection I noticed I had dusted off the approach for a few inches presumably by not holding down on the infeed enough. So I took some more full passes very carefully and ended up with a longi concave surface. I backed out the curve so that it rubbed the full length.
Then I ran the test, I got the same result both times after the full passes: I had a flat edge no rounding of the approach. No light, peeking through. I don't have a very strong light source, I'm sure something would show with a direct light, but I saw nothing with just the overhead lamp from behind the straight edge.
The only thing I can say about that result is it's the one I wanted. I didn't try to give the plane any English, but my assumption is the edge would be flat, and that is what I ended up with, which is what I expect.
If I get some time I may run the same test with a few other jointers.



