Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

My results

Posts

My results

#1

My results

thomd


>OK I took the LV BU plane I had used for the deflection testing. I grabbed a piece of maple about 12 inches wide by 1.1". by the length of the plane It's stock for some plane handles and is in mill state. I put it in my Tucker vise which made the whole thing a little high and I planed away the rough surface which was also about 1/16" longi concave. The plane was taking very nice 3 thou shavings.

When I initially got the surface barked back, it was very slightly longi concave, even though I took full length passes. I have a 36" Rabone Chesterman machinist's straight edge. Under closer inspection I noticed I had dusted off the approach for a few inches presumably by not holding down on the infeed enough. So I took some more full passes very carefully and ended up with a longi concave surface. I backed out the curve so that it rubbed the full length.

Then I ran the test, I got the same result both times after the full passes: I had a flat edge no rounding of the approach. No light, peeking through. I don't have a very strong light source, I'm sure something would show with a direct light, but I saw nothing with just the overhead lamp from behind the straight edge.

The only thing I can say about that result is it's the one I wanted. I didn't try to give the plane any English, but my assumption is the edge would be flat, and that is what I ended up with, which is what I expect.

If I get some time I may run the same test with a few other jointers.

Re: My results

#2

I am thinking.....

HC Sakman


>Hi Thom,

You went and tried it out, fine.

I am wondering, what's the translation/application of this to the real world situation? So what if there's a few thou bump or not over the 3 or 4 feet of length? (If the board is any longer and it'd matters less.) Wood is somewhat flexible material and a few thou (99% of the time) will not make any difference IMO.

Chico...

Not so inquiring mind had decided to balance in between want & know. ;-)

Re: My results

#3

knowledge

bill tindall


>the objective of the experiment was to learn more about the details of how planes work with the obvious vaiables of technique and equipment, and maybe wood and the response whether the plane took the same thickness shaving along the edge length. It is what science is all about and engineering is not.

I haven't read all the responses as this is not a topic of practical importance to my woodworking but the experiments did perk my curiosity. Can someone provide a conclusion? It seemed like the conclusion was tending to inconclusive. I was comforted by the fact that some considered the power jointer the standard for making a starting straight edge.

Re: My results

#4

Re: knowledge

thomd


>I don't know. It's David's experiment. If you have seen his tapes you know he uses planes the same length as the pieces he is working on (at least for the purposes of the tapes) to transfer the sole shape to the workpiece shape. Since the inherant characteristic of the plane is to create a hollow, and this can be calibrated to a few thou, you can turn out workpieces that are accurate within a few thou over the length of the plane, though beyond that length things change.

I was actually surprised I didn't overall dub the approach, so maybe I could do rubbed joints, this way. The only rubbed joints I do are in soundboards and I don't really need a routine other than the one I currently use. It gives an invisible joint without clamps.

I think it is practical to identify the baseline performance. As I like to say "what is this a mold for".

Re: My results

#5

Re: I am thinking.....

Ron in Kokomo


>Yes.....I do agree that learning is good..

It is interesting that many of the folks who are drawn to hand tool usage... or for some of them, hand tool discussion.... come from very high tech occupations... including the occasional rocket scientist. They can't help bringing in techniques and values from their occupation to their avocation... even in some cases when the application is of questionable value.. I am for precision that the eye can see. And I believe that if you have to ask " is this good enough?" it probably isn't. But, to me, it seeems pointless to talk about a "thousandth" when the human eye can't see it... and the medium moves and changes dimensions. Just my $.02

Re: My results

#6

Re: I am thinking.....

Frank D. in Montreal


>It's clich� to say it but everything is relative. On the thickness of a shelf the eye won't see a thousandth difference. When light goes through a crack the eye can see less than a ten-thousandth. On the shoulder of a mortise and tenon joint, a thousandth gap is a gaping hole that looks quite bad.

Re: My results

#7

The real world

Dan Clermont in Burnaby


>Hi Chico

For allot of us (including myself) hand tools provide a challenge and we have no time restraints nor are we looking for the quickest way to complete a project to put some money on the table. So "experimenting" is what we like to do and I enjoyed David's challenge along with Sgian's challenge regarding sole flex.

If I made a living woodworking my attitude may be different but because I might get 1 hour in my shop a night. The challenge for me is to make hand crafted projects and not tell anyone it too k me 20 hours to build it when a power tool guy did it in 8.

I do agree with you and have seen on several occasions my flatten board ain't so flat the next day when I continue on with my project

Cheers

Dan Clermont

Re: My results

#8

Joints are excluded

HC Sakman


>When it comes to joints, I count every thou or 1/10th of a mm. What I was referring to the flatness of the boards or their edges.

Chico...

Re: My results

#9

OK, but

Frank D. in Montreal


>Hi Chico,

geting back to the edge of a board...

Chico said: "what's the translation/application of this to the real world situation? So what if there's a few thou bump or not over the 3 or 4 feet of length?

In my results (which if I understood correctly were similar to DC's)I had a dip at each end of the board of a one or 2 thou (except for the smoother), starting at about 3 inches from the end. The rest of the board seemed flat. Could this not cause a problem when gluing up an edge joint? If the hump was gradual it would just bend out with clamps, but couldn't a 4 or 5 thou gap 3 inches from each end (the same dip times 2, on each of the two boards) cause problems in the long run (split ends, or joint failure)? I don't really know, but I'd probably redo the joint if I saw such a gap right at the ends before gluing up.

Doing the test once (it only took me 20 minutes or so) also let me know where I stood with respect to my flattening technique. I did the experiment a total of 9 times. Each time I took my convex edge and made it flat again with the plane I had in my hands. By the time the experiment was over, I knew that two stopped shavings, stopped 3 inches from each end, followed by two full length shavings, would get me a totally flat edge. I didn't have a problem prior to this but I still learned a little about my own technique which might help me get the results I want more quickly next time.

FWIW

Re: My results

#10

Re: I am thinking.....

Paul Kierstead


>When it comes to the *practice* of woodworking, I am 100% in agreement with you. It gets under my skin when someone says that something *needs* to be 0.001" or other such stuff. It needs to be good enough to look good and work correctly, period.

However, one doesn't have to focus purely on the practice of woodworking, and ultimately some good science (as it were) behind it can make the practice better. It is the nature of research that an awful lot of it will not be directly (or often even indirectly) applicable, but it is still a worth pursuit. I think it is important to not confuse the two though.

Re: My results

#11

Re: OK, but

HC Sakman


>Hi Frank,

I was referring to "the gradual slight bump of a very few thou in the middle of a board."

Now, if this is a very stiff board like zebrawood, it'd make a difference. If it's at the end of a board, again it'd be a problem for most woods. I was saying it's not a big matter if it's in the middle of a board. There are places where a one thou will be too much, of course. Obviously joints are excluded, where there should be no gap of any size.

I hope this clears it up.

Chico...

PS: I am all for the knowledge as well. It always expands the horizons and open up new doors to pass, new windows to let the light in.

Re: My results

#12

OK

Frank D. in Montreal


>Yes Chico,

Thanks for taking the time. Hope I didn't appear confrontational or belligerent...just trying to provoke a little discussion...that's how I learn. All in good faith.

Cheers

Re: My results

#13

Re: OK

thomd


>- FIrst of all you can see a thou. I have feeler gage and while it's thin, it's there. I agree people won't see it in the sides of the cabinet, maybe in the fit of the drawers.

- You can't say "well joints are excluded", because in the most comon means of laying out, the sides of the stock are used as a reference for joint layout, as are the ends. There are better ways of laying out, but squares and gages are the method we most comonly use.

- It's not slower to cut to these dimensions, it's faster.

- It should be a confidence builder to people to know they can do these kinds of things n auto pilot. It's all about shaping your parts to the design requirements. If you can saw, plane and chop to a line it's all a lot easier.

- These dimensions over short runs become much bigger over long runs

- You can't/shouldn't spring all surfaces together a 36 x 72 inch table top made out of 6 x 6" pieces is one thing. Try to join two 18 inchers, those pieces are 27 times stiffer. So flexing the six inchers is one thing, the 18 inchers is a totally different mater. And with power or hand tools you would probably glue up the halves first in order to take advantage of the planer or bench size. Gluing up a guitar top is like jointing two 26 x 72 boards 80 times tiffer on a proportional basis than the 6 inchers. So having a simple means of nailing the straightness to a thou or better is real world stuff.

- There has been a huge amount of talk about smothers and really radical performance criterion, that are fun to play with. I have been playing with than stuff nearly 30 years, but the places where I can really use a 4/10000" surface in the kind of work I do are few and far between. I can use that degree of edge jointing accuracy every day of the year.

Re: My results

#14

Re: The thing about science...

thomd


>is that in the West, people just don't listen to a word you say unless you bring forward a solid technical basis for things. Even then you mostly don't get through.

The internet makes that worse, since a pecking order on the net and what would rapidly establish in a workshop are two entirely different things. And wordy arguments are all we really have here.

If I was your apprentice you could just show me over and over day by day how you did what you do, and I would pick it up over time. We don't have that all that much. Even in workshops. It needs to get broken down for the take-away piece.

There is also the fact that woodworking is really mostly about ideas. Who really cares about your spice rack. The big props come from coralling off part of the argument and tacking it onto your name. So if you think of all the big names some theory or area of mental real estate is attached to them, they are the owners of particular parts of woodworking. John Alexander owns green woodworking joinery, and Nakishima owns the idea of the big piece of wood figure melded with asian joinery styles (amoung others). Japanese planes used to own fine surfacing, but the brand wasn't strong enough and "Infils" have taken over. Kirby owns stress skin shelves and the jointer plane for everything. In some cases the owner is the inventor, like Ellsworth, or the populariser like Raffan with the hollowing move on eggcups. And so it goes.

Re: My results

#15

Re: The thing about science...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX


>Not true, Thom. When Richard said he twisted his plane knobs together we all took him seriously. I think there's a lot of room for credible people to make credible claims about their processes. It's easier if it sounds intuitive, but that's not even necessary.

And to anyone paying attention, no one owns a process, even though they personally may or may not make such a claim. I don't think John Alexander owns green joinery, but he has done much to bring it to our attention, therefore we listen.

Pam

Re: My results

#16

Re: The thing about science...

Sgian Dubh


>I hope people took me seriously Pam. I know now for certain that I can bend a long metal Stanley Bailey type plane in use and feel I can use that to advantage in my work.

I was careful to point out though that the testing I did was not rigorously scientific. But I do believe the rough and ready numbers I found are reasonable and believable. Certainly other people can repeat my experiments and I'd expect them to be able to achieve similar results. Slainte.

Re: My results

#17

Please...oh man oh man....

HC Sakman


>Hi Thom,

Please stop taking what said to some situation that would be in 100% conflict. I never said a few thou won't be noticable for drawer fitting or any other joint type of situation. All I said was for over the length of 3~4 feet or longer boards' edge or top. That's where it doesn't really matter. I never referred to 6 or 18 inch long pieces, where a few thou would be problematic.

For the record: I never had any problems with edge joints (short or long -around 2 feet- long) having bumps or drops. I believe it'd happen over the longer pieces, which are negligable as I already have said above.

Chico...

Re: My results

#18

No problem Frank.

HC Sakman


>I knew where you were coming from.

Chico...

Re: My results

#19

Re: Where's the beef?

thomd


>I agree that is not a good rhetorical approach. So why did it come up in a thread on tests where the objective is to discover a few thou. of bump in a workpiece the same length as the plane?

Anyway. I thought I pointed out that there is a connection between the few thou over 18" and much large gaps over the longer pieces. They are connected as I pointed out in text and several CAD drawings.

Re: My results

#20

Re: The thing about science...

thomd


>I agree with your first statement. I was possibly alone in taking him seriously enough to try to quantify the result. My comment is much broader brush. Say something like proving global warming. Political aspect aside, we would still expect loads of scientific evidence.

As to the second part. Ownership not in a legal sense. But in the sense that you heart goes pitter pat when you hear he is giving a conference. Mindshare. And please, it's not necessary to point out he doesn't literally share my mind.

Re: My results

#21

Re: The thing about science...

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX


>Ah, well, I wasn't implying that you and John have done a mind meld. As to my conference attraction, you must know that there may be many reasons for wanting to see John in action, only one of which is the green joinery. I'm simply not that simple. :)

As to global warming, I don't need all that much in terms of scientific evidence. It's enough to know that our ice caps are melting. Of course, it's somewhat scientific that we know that the ice caps are melting. Now, as to whether or not that means the warming is caused by man or natural earth processes, it doesn't matter. I moved from Cape Cod, at more or less sea level, to Austin at 700-800 feet above sea level because the ice caps are melting. I much prefer having ocean view property to being in the ocean.

Also, I gain no joy from personally experiencing hurricanes, one or two per lifetime is enough. And now I take great pains to use as little of our fossil fuels as possible, never use spray products, bought a new refrigerator, don't use air conditioning, eat organically and locally grown food to the extent I can afford them, etc. Just in case, as is likely, that it's caused and/or exacerbated by man.

Pam

Re: My results

#22

Re: The thing about science...

paul womack


>is that in the West, people just don't listen to a word you say unless you bring forward a solid technical basis for things. Even then you mostly don't get through.

I think the most dangerous thing is when a practising expert, who really, genuinely and truly can "walk the walk" puts forwards incorrect reasons as to *WHY* their technique works.

Because of the credibility bought by results, the reasons are given equal credence.

BugBear

Re: My results

#23

On the bbq, cooking!

HC Sakman