Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Knots!!!!!

Posts

Knots!!!!!

#1

Knots!!!!!

Gerry D.


>The Roubo Bench project is finally getting off the ground, or more accurately, the garage floor.

Material is construction grade pop/fir from the local HD and Lowe's. Could not find a source for SYP in the Chicago area. Even with an approximate 75% rejection rate of 10 x and 12 x stock, this stuff is sad. Knots, twist, checking, you name it. I'm planning to try to bury the knots in the glue ups.

The project so far: Built a temp 8' bench using the I-beam and box set up from Woodworking Magazine. Ripped boards to approx width using TS (Mea culpa, mea culpa, mea maxima culpa.) Clamped a temp planing stop to end of bench, shim board as needed, hit high spots with jack, check with winding sticks and level, run the 7 lengthwise, check, mark thickness with gauge, flip and repeat. Went well with the first couple of boards, which were the best of the lot.

Now here's the rub. A good portion of the remainder has some serious knots. Massive, gnarly, ugly, harder than O2 steel, blade chipping knots. For pop/fir, I would never have expected such evil, tenacious, vile growths. I have never tried to hand plane such ugly creatures. Last night I attacked one with a card scraper. It did take the knot down, but estimated time to finish the project in this manner reaches into the next millennium. I do not have a scraper plane, but do own an 80 which I have not sharpened or used yet.

Other than hauling all of this over to Slav's and running it through his power jointer and planer, any suggestions from the galooterati?

Thanks,

Gerry

Re: Knots!!!!!

#2

Re: Knots!!!!!

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI


>The knot direction does not necessarily follow the grain direction. So your knot might plane easier if you plane "against the grain". It is usually easy to tell which way a knot is leaning by flipping the board and seeing where the knot exits the other side. I found pine knots to plane relatively easily once I planed in the right direction, and virtually impossible when attempted in the wrong direction. YMMV . The other option is a chisel. I think attacking a knot with a scraper is probably a pretty futile exercise although I have never actually tried it. Slav is a good guy though, and always a viable option ;)

Re: Knots!!!!!

#3

Re: Knots!!!!!

Gerry D.


>Moses,

Thanks. I'll give it a shot tonight, but after last nights attempts I don't know if these knots have a "plane-able angle of attack." I don't know if I can articulate just how nasty these knots are. Actually though about just drilling them out, but figured that would destroy the structural integrity of the bench, especially the top.

I can always haul the load to Slav's and burn electrons, but I can never seem to walk out of there without picking up a new toy...tool, necessary tool.

Gerry

Re: Knots!!!!!

#4

Re: Knots!!!!!

thomd coralseacat@yahoo.au


>I sure wouldn't want to see you coming with O1 chipping knots. It's a lot more trouble to sharpen a planer...

What I do when converting that kind of crap into boat lumber is I either scarph out the knots, rip out the core and only use the outside bits, or I drill the knot out and either leave the holes in the core or use a standard plug size to patch them. Working around them is only worthwhile if they are an asset.

I don't think I would have bought this stuff, in chicago there has to be a pro source or even a source of non-construction at a cheaper price. I can buy a lot of hardwood here in Toronto for 1-2 dollars a BFT. In the case of Douglas fir I can buy 18 wheelers worth at about 4 dollars stuff that is so beautiful it would make you cry (that's not the minimum, there is just an endless supply).

Re: Knots!!!!!

#5

Re: Knots!!!!!

thomd coralseacat@yahoo.au


>"Ripped boards to approx width using TS"

Attached is a photo of typical garbage from HD. better than 1/32" rings outboard, and like 1/4" in the center. So I don't rip to width, I rip the junk out of the middle and glue back together.

Also, for what it is worth, the history of tools and wood are tied together, hand tool woodworking looses a lot of practicality as the wood looses quality. This arms race has been going on for thousands of years, and is not a recent phenomenon. Most wood is really too poor to handle by hand. A good discussion of this is in the book "The Way of the Carpenter".

Re: Knots!!!!!

#6

Re: Oops

thomd coralseacat@yahoo.au

Re: Knots!!!!!

#7

Re: Third time lucky 

thomd coralseacat@yahoo.au



img

Re: Knots!!!!!

#8

Sometimes...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA


>You can skew the plane to sneek up on knots.

Otherwise, killing someone else�s electrons is better than killing your own.

Re: Knots!!!!!

#9

Re: Sometimes...

les winter


>When I built my Ruobo I used soft construction grade maple which had all manner of defects. In order to salvage some of the boards, which were 4/4, I needed to cut them narrow. When you look at the underside of my table, there are some slots, where the board was cut narrow and didn't extend down full width. Doesn't affect the performance at all. So if your table is to be four inches thick, it won't hurt if a few of the boards are only three inches thick, thereby allowing you to cut out the knots. I hope this all made sense.

Good luck.

Les

Re: Knots!!!!!

#10

Hell, that's better than what I'm working with!!

Gerry D.

Re: Knots!!!!!

#11

Yyuuummmm...the succulent center cut

jimreed@tallahassee


>it used to be called firewood.

Re: Knots!!!!!

#12

I hate knots!

jimreed@tallahassee


>They destroy planes and blade edges with a hard jolt. Not good on your joints either. As I see it, you can: 1)Chisel them out, 2)Cut them out and plug the holes with real wood, or 3)Sand them into submission. Good luck.

Re: Knots!!!!!

#13

Darrell in Oakville

Re: cross-hatch before planing

Darrell in Oakville


>Gerry,

I've had good luck using a chisel to cross-hatch the knot prior to planing. I guess this is kind of like using a toothing plane on it. You just have to be careful not to chop too deep...

Darrell

Wood hoarder, Blade sharpener, and Occasional tool user

Re: Knots!!!!!

#14

Re: Funny you should say that...

thomd


>The best wood I get these days is from, my fire pile of red oak in the country.

Re: Knots!!!!!

#15

Power planing knots = projectiles!

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA


>If you decide to move around some electrons to plane down the boards, just make sure your not standing in front of or behind the planer. I've put some stuff with knots through the lunchbox and occasionally one chips off or rips completely free and gets thrown around the shop. Not a good thing. Not quite like kickback from the table saw, but I still wouldn't want to get hit by it.

I used to be stuck with the same, always looking at big box stores for wood. Then I started finding some local hardwood dealers, or saw mill owners. Search them out, you get better wood at much cheaper prices. Trouble is, you'll think the wood is too good to use just for a bench.

Re: Knots!!!!!

#16

beltsander

david.marcus.brown


>It's a workbench. Just get 'er done however it takes. ;-)

Re: Knots!!!!!

#17

Re: Knots!!!!!

Al DaValle


>Kirkland Saw Mill in Kirkland, IL has a great selection of SYP and at good prices. It is an hour or so outside of Chicago on Route 72 but it is well worth the trip of you want quality material for your bench.

Re: Knots!!!!!

#18

Knots Suck! *LINK*

Dan Clermont in Burnaby


>I built this crude closet organizer carcass out ot a coupla "cheap boards" from a local sawyer.

The knot up above was about 5" in diameter and the knot down below about 7" They were attacked with a low angle jack and then a light pass with a smoothing plane

Dan Clermont


Knot Hell!