Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Tool chest bottoms (attn: Adam Cherubini)

Posts

Tool chest bottoms (attn: Adam Cherubini)

#1

Tool chest bottoms (attn: Adam Cherubini)

John in Baltimore


>Hi All.

I am making a tool chest to organize my hand tools and keep the sharp stuff away from the curious little ones in my house. The chest follows a fairly conventional approach by employing dovetailed sides and a f&p bottom.

I have completed dovetailing the sides and need to make a bottom panel to fit in the 3/8" w X 3/8" d groove that runs along the lower inside of the case. As a tool chest can become very heavy when loaded, I am a little concerned about using a raised 3/4" white pine panel for the bottom.

Does this thickness pose a problem? I'd hate to pop out or split the bottom panel during transport.

I've noticed (from FWW) that Adam Cherubini's tool chest bottom is pine. I'd love to hear from Adam about its thickness and any construction techniques employed to ensure its strength and stability.

Also, since we are on the subject, I plan to add a plinth to the chest. Is anyone familiar with plinth provided "joists" or cleats to help support (or catch) the chests's bottom panel.

Any tips would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks, John

Re: Tool chest bottoms (attn: Adam Cherubini)

#2

Re: Tool chest bottoms (attn: Adam Cherubini)

Paul in NJ


>I recently completed a pine chest. While it is not for tools it is a similar size and construction. I did not use a groove to hold the bottom. The bottom molding or plinth has a cleat that wraps around the inside. The bottom sits on this cleat. The sides of the chest rest on the bottom. Both the sides and cleat are glued and nailed to the inside of the plinth, the bottom is free to float between them. The plinth molding is also dovetailed for strength with the tails perpendicular to the tails of the sides.

Paul Dzioba

Re: Tool chest bottoms (attn: Adam Cherubini)

#3

Re: Tool chest bottoms (attn: Adam Cherubini)

John in Baltimore


>Thanks for your reply. It sounds like the nailed on cleats and chest sides create a groove-like feature on the inside plinth surface. If I have this wrong let me know. How thick is the bottom panel?

Also, very cool idea regarding orthogonal dovetail orientations for the chest and plinth! Where did you get that idea?

Re: Tool chest bottoms (attn: Adam Cherubini)

#4

Re: Tool chest bottoms (attn: Adam Cherubini)

thomd coralseacat@yahoo.au


>The best thing you can do is place the long grain across the short dimension, but if you do that you increse your wood movement problems. There are ways of dealing with that, but it sounds more complicated than what would be typical.

Re: Tool chest bottoms (attn: Adam Cherubini)

#5

Re: Tool chest bottoms (attn: Adam Cherubini)

Paul in NJ


>John,

You interpeted the construction correctly. My bottom is ~3/4 thick. I think this is plenty strong for a tool box. As far as the dovetail orientation I think I got that from Adam when doing the "Challenge". Search the handtool archives for "Adam's Handtool Challenge".

Paul Dzioba

Re: Tool chest bottoms (attn: Adam Cherubini)

#6

If I were doing it

jim reed @ tallahassee


>I would use 4/4 lumber on the ends and cut a 3/8 dado for the bottom so it could move. If you attach a cleat you risk splitting the side because of the cross grained wood attachment. For front and back I would attach a long cleat that would match the dado bottoms on the ends. If you make this cleat large, say 2", then you could dovetail a stretcher midway to keep the chest from bowing. Good luck with your project.

Re: Tool chest bottoms (attn: Adam Cherubini)

#7

Re: If I were doing it

John in Baltimore


>Thanks for your reply Jim!

Please forgive any lack of clarity in my earlier post.

To hopefully clarify things, I am making a tool chest similar in design to a Shaker blanket chest. Therefore, the grain runs horizontal on the front, back, and sides. I can't quite visualize the cross grain issue you raise in your post.

There is already a 3/8" plowed groove on the inside of the case (front, back, and sides) to accommodate a bottom panel that is rougly 36" long and 18" wide. My concern is whether using approx 3/4" thick (planed down 4/4 stock) is sufficiently strong.

If I add any cleat or "joist" to support the bottom panel, it would probably be in the plinth or base, which would also have a horizontal grain construction.

Re: Tool chest bottoms (attn: Adam Cherubini)

#8

Re: Tool chest bottoms (attn: Adam Cherubini)

Jamey Amrine in Ann Arbor


>How about building it just like you planned with the floating panel for a floor, but run cleats (maybe skids is a better word) front the front panel to the back panel, nailed into the bottom of those panels. They could be maybe 4" wide and you could run 4 of them acorss the width of the chest. The ones on the ends could also be nailed to the side panels since the grain direction would be the same, but I suspect that is not necessary.

These would be hidden by the plinth which would extend the thickness of the skids below the sides of the chest. That way, the panel is primarily supported by the chest panels, but it would be secondarily resting on the tops of the skids. These skids would provide some support for the chest so that it is not resting entirely on the plinth.

If you ever ding up the plinth, it can be replaced, but you do not risk tearing up the bottom edge of your main chest panels.

I can't pull off the ASCII art for this, so if it is not clean, let me know and I will draw something and post.

Re: Tool chest bottoms (attn: Adam Cherubini)

#9

Re: Toolchest and furniture bottoms

Adam Cherubini, NJ


>I think the way my friend Paul did it is fine- especially if his cleat really sandwiches the bottom and contacts the ground.

Here's the general problem- in any carcass where you have a base mold (plinth) whose grain runs horizontally, you must be careful in its attachment. Conceivably the entire weight of the case will be transmitted through this joint. In addition to the shear, there's a couple/moment between the thickness of the base mold and the thickness of the carcass sides. In good furniture this is NEVER ignored. Most typically, vertical or stacked glue blocks (really feet) are placed behind each of the corners of the base mold to take the weight of the case. These may have originally extended beyond the base to carry 100% of the weight or the base mold may have shrunk in relation.

The other problem is the drag load case where the piece is pushed and the overturning moment cracks the feet off. For this situation the glue blocks are often roughly the shape of a quarter of a cone (the wide upper portion reacts the moment).

& & &

There are only a few documented 18th c chests, all of them different and none of their construction is published. I've never seen any of them. So I had very little to go on when I built my chest. So I relied on my engineering background, realizing my chest needed to hold hundreds of pounds of tools and should be a sturdy seat for 2 large people. Moving the chest was an inevitability and prooved to be every bit the problem I expected.

So the plinth/base mold is attached flush with the bottom with reversed dovetails as Paul described- glued and screwed from the inside out (screws are 1-1/4" from the bottom. The carcass is a full 1" thick so that's 2" thick bottom edge. No over couple/moment

Then I added a 3/4" cleat again flush with the bottom and agaion screwed in place from the inside- this row of screws is 1/2" or so up from the bottom forming a neat staggered double row of screws. I put no glue in this joint.

The bottom is dry T&G which I think provides some shrink swell forgiveness (I assume my pine will always shrink- a decent assumption). That bottom sits down on the cleats concealing the row of screws 1-1/4" up from the bottom. Its held down by a the board the till sits on- which goes from the bottom of the till to the top of the bottom. That piece is glued in place and the screws that hold the handles on the side pass thru it more or less like the seaton chest except my handles are horizontal like the earlier chests (and rock maple).

So if you've followed me there should technically be a gap between the floor's long edge and the sides (there isn't yet) but the floor's end grain gap is covered by the piece that supports the till. So its a little like Paul's at the ends except that I have one extra thickness (the till slide piece).

If this isn't clear, email me and I'll make some drawings this weekend.

Sorry so long-

Adam

P.S. I'm not convinced this was the best or most traditional way to treat this. The earliest chests probably just nailed the bottom on from underneath (like a drawer from the period), covering its edge and end grain with a bit of molding. But that could also be why there are only 3 such tool chests in existence. You could treat this like a piece of furniture- maybe employ a Newport sub-base which is a separate horizontal M&T frame with the base glued and nailed to its sides (no x-grain construction) and glue blocks/feet. The carcaass then sat into the top half of the base mold.

Re: Tool chest bottoms (attn: Adam Cherubini)

#10

Re: Tool chest bottoms (attn: Adam Cherubini)

John in Baltimore


>Thank you everyone for your help with my question. I'm grateful that this forum exists.

Re: Tool chest bottoms (attn: Adam Cherubini)

#11

Re: If I were doing it

thomd coralseacat@yahoo.au


>If you think of it as an engineering problem like a wooden footbridge. There are longitudinal stringers in the bridge span(sorry I don't know any bridge terminology), when it comes to nailing the deck on you take your often 4/4 wood and run it is a transverse direction, from stringer to stringer. If you ran it lengthwise across the span, even with bearing at the edges it would not be as strong. So if your box were 18" x 36", you have the choice of running the grain across 18" or 36" and generally the 18" span is going to be hugely stronger, because your failure mode starts when the bototm sags. But the problem is you end up with 36 inches of panel width to expand and contract in a 3/8" groove. So the simple solution is loose boads with tongue and groove, They support each other, and yet the T&G will provide some expnasion and contraction room and the long grain aligned with the short distance would probably support your weight in a 6" board, so plenty of strength for your tools.

I recognize there are other more traditional or elegant solutions, but you already have your groove, and something like a T&G panel would represent 3/8" sidegrain supporting all this weight, Etc... engrain engaging a groove in a vertical side is about as strong as this design gets, until you start to add a lot of other stuff as bandaids, like blocking or stringers.

Re: Tool chest bottoms (attn: Adam Cherubini)

#12

Re: Tool chest bottoms (attn: Adam Cherubini)

Paul in NJ


>John,

Adam's construction of course is the sturdiest and will safely carry the most weight without relying on glue or fasteners. While my bottom rests on a cleat that rests on the floor, there is a chance that my bottom could shrink a bit in thickness. The bottom would still be supported by the cleat and ultimately the floor but the chest itself would rely on the glue and fasteners that attach it to the base molding.

I am not too worried; the chest I built is for my wife's charity and most likely hold pillows or Teddy Bears.

Paul Dzioba


img

Re: Tool chest bottoms (attn: Adam Cherubini)

#13

very nice.

John in Baltimore


>I really like the proportion between the base height and the top (lid & moulding) height. Can you share a few of its measurements with us?

Thanks!

Re: Tool chest bottoms (attn: Adam Cherubini)

#14

Re: very nice.

Paul in NJ


>The chest dimensions are 15" high by 24" wide by 18-3/4" deep. The top molding including the top is 2" and the bottom molding is 3". The verticle dimensions are based on the Ionic column order. The front dimensions (15 x 24) are golden section. I am not sure how the depth dimension plays into all this. I will have to ask my good friend who explained this to me!

Paul Dzioba