Re: Toolchest and furniture bottoms
Adam Cherubini, NJ
>I think the way my friend Paul did it is fine- especially if his cleat really sandwiches the bottom and contacts the ground.
Here's the general problem- in any carcass where you have a base mold (plinth) whose grain runs horizontally, you must be careful in its attachment. Conceivably the entire weight of the case will be transmitted through this joint. In addition to the shear, there's a couple/moment between the thickness of the base mold and the thickness of the carcass sides. In good furniture this is NEVER ignored. Most typically, vertical or stacked glue blocks (really feet) are placed behind each of the corners of the base mold to take the weight of the case. These may have originally extended beyond the base to carry 100% of the weight or the base mold may have shrunk in relation.
The other problem is the drag load case where the piece is pushed and the overturning moment cracks the feet off. For this situation the glue blocks are often roughly the shape of a quarter of a cone (the wide upper portion reacts the moment).
& & &
There are only a few documented 18th c chests, all of them different and none of their construction is published. I've never seen any of them. So I had very little to go on when I built my chest. So I relied on my engineering background, realizing my chest needed to hold hundreds of pounds of tools and should be a sturdy seat for 2 large people. Moving the chest was an inevitability and prooved to be every bit the problem I expected.
So the plinth/base mold is attached flush with the bottom with reversed dovetails as Paul described- glued and screwed from the inside out (screws are 1-1/4" from the bottom. The carcass is a full 1" thick so that's 2" thick bottom edge. No over couple/moment
Then I added a 3/4" cleat again flush with the bottom and agaion screwed in place from the inside- this row of screws is 1/2" or so up from the bottom forming a neat staggered double row of screws. I put no glue in this joint.
The bottom is dry T&G which I think provides some shrink swell forgiveness (I assume my pine will always shrink- a decent assumption). That bottom sits down on the cleats concealing the row of screws 1-1/4" up from the bottom. Its held down by a the board the till sits on- which goes from the bottom of the till to the top of the bottom. That piece is glued in place and the screws that hold the handles on the side pass thru it more or less like the seaton chest except my handles are horizontal like the earlier chests (and rock maple).
So if you've followed me there should technically be a gap between the floor's long edge and the sides (there isn't yet) but the floor's end grain gap is covered by the piece that supports the till. So its a little like Paul's at the ends except that I have one extra thickness (the till slide piece).
If this isn't clear, email me and I'll make some drawings this weekend.
Sorry so long-
Adam
P.S. I'm not convinced this was the best or most traditional way to treat this. The earliest chests probably just nailed the bottom on from underneath (like a drawer from the period), covering its edge and end grain with a bit of molding. But that could also be why there are only 3 such tool chests in existence. You could treat this like a piece of furniture- maybe employ a Newport sub-base which is a separate horizontal M&T frame with the base glued and nailed to its sides (no x-grain construction) and glue blocks/feet. The carcaass then sat into the top half of the base mold.