Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

? on Veritas� Iron Edge-Trimming Plane

Posts

? on Veritas� Iron Edge-Trimming Plane

#1

? on Veritas� Iron Edge-Trimming Plane

Hoa Dinh in Alameda


>If you already have a Veritas� Bevel-Up Jointer Plane (maybe with a Veritas� Bevel-Up Jointer Fence), how often do you use the Veritas� Iron Edge-Trimming Plane?

I have neither of them, just trying to put together an order to LV, but not wanting to go overboard.

-- Hoa

Re: ? on Veritas� Iron Edge-Trimming Plane

#2

Overboard?

Jerry Nicholson


>You don't want to go overboard? That's a violation of the code - of course you want to go overboard! I have the new edge planer but I don't have the bevel up jointer. I haven't actually needed the edge planer yet but I expect to use it to clean up edges after they have been through the power jointer. I have played with it a bit and the blade is quite sharp right out of the box. I will, however, hone it a bit before I do anything serious with it.

Jerry

Re: ? on Veritas� Iron Edge-Trimming Plane

#3

Re: ? on Veritas� Iron Edge-Trimming Plane

Dan Clermont in Burnaby


>Hi Hoa

Personally I think you could get away with just a jointer plane and a home made wooden fence and a magnet.

A jointer plane can do so much more work when compared to an edge plane

Dan Clermont

Re: ? on Veritas� Iron Edge-Trimming Plane

#4

Re: ? on Veritas� Iron Edge-Trimming Plane

Brent Smith in Montreal


>Right now the question is academic. The iron edge trimming plane is BO until sometime in late October.

Re: ? on Veritas� Iron Edge-Trimming Plane

#5

Academic?

Hoa Dinh in Alameda


>No. The question is for real. I plan to place an order with LV and wonder whether I should add both, one, or no plane.

-- Hoa

Re: ? on Veritas� Iron Edge-Trimming Plane

#6

Re: Academic?

Denny


>Hoa,

I have the BU Jointer, and I don't see a need (yet) for the new edge trimmer. It can't be used for jointing, just squaring as far as I can tell, and the BU Jointer does a great job of squaring with the fence attached. I suppose the edge trimmer would be handy for squaring small pieces, but I can shoot them square now. So I don't see it as necessary for the work I'm doing. On the other hand, there are some interesting new wooden Japanese shaping planes on the web site...

Denny

Re: ? on Veritas� Iron Edge-Trimming Plane

#7

Re: ? on Veritas� Iron Edge-Trimming Plane

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)


>Hoa

Keep in mind that a jointer and an edge plane are intended for different sized areas. The jointer will cover 2 1/4" (BUJ) - 2 3/8 (#7) - 2 5/8" (#8), while the edge planes cover 7/8" (LN) and 1" (LV).

Try balancing a 2+" wide plane on a skinny 1/4" wide board!

or planing a 2" wide board with a 1" wide blade.

I was given the LN edge plane set for a birthday present in January this year. At the time I thought that they would be an extravagence but they have had a lot of use. I guess that one could make do without them (I used to use my Record #778 for jointing narrow boards) but they will find a place in the workshop.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: ? on Veritas� Iron Edge-Trimming Plane

#8

Re: ? on Veritas� Iron Edge-Trimming Plane

Tony - Memphis


>I ordered mine the other day and I got it a few days later, so they are sending some out. Anyway, I sharpened it up and played with it last night. I really like it so far. I like it because it is small and easy to handle. I think I'll get a lot of use out of it. Cuts like a dream.

Tony

Re: ? on Veritas� Iron Edge-Trimming Plane

#9

I have both

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.


>And as someone else here mentioned, it's not a case of either/or. The trimming plane will work great with thin/short pieces, whereas the jointer is for larger pieces. Try getting a straight edge on a 4" long, 1/4" thick piece with a jointer...

OTOH, I wouldn't rely on the trimming plane to joint the edge of a 4' long board because of its short sole, it would be too easy to create dips and bumps along the edge of the board.

Bottom line, you should get both IMHO. If you must get only one, the jointer would go first on my list, but that trimming plane is sweet (and on sale now).

Two things bugged me with the trimming plane when I first played with it: knucklehead that I am, I had trouble getting the blade to take a square cut because there's no Norris adjuster on the plane, unlike most other Veritas planes. It took a while to realize that a few hammer taps on the side of the blade did the trick (brain was VERY slow that night). Also, I chose the O1 blade with my plane, and while the cut was silky smooth, I ended up sharpening the blade four or five times in one evening, seems that the edge doesn't last very long (but I did plane quite a bit of stuff with it, like taking an inch off the edge of a 12" long BE maple). Maybe I got a bum blade or it's just the way of life with O1, but I've ordered the A2 blade for comparison.

HTH,

DC

Re: ? on Veritas� Iron Edge-Trimming Plane

#10

Re: I have both

Dan Clermont in Burnaby


>To get a straight square ode on a 4" long piece 1/4" wide you could just use a block plane or a #1 with a make shift fence brazed to the side of it(kidding about the #1)

Don't think an edging plane is truly a tool everyone needs.

Dan Clermont

Re: ? on Veritas� Iron Edge-Trimming Plane

#11

Drifting OT...On skinny short boards

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA


>A 5-1/4 excells at jointing these little critters.

Re: ? on Veritas� Iron Edge-Trimming Plane

#12

Re: I have both

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.


>Oh, I never said one absolutely needs it, but it's a good tool to have in your arsenal.

And if you send me that #1 before you put the heat to it, I'll send you the trimming plane :)

DC

Re: ? on Veritas� Iron Edge-Trimming Plane

#13

Re: small skinny pieces

Paul in NJ


>.....Try getting a straight edge on a 4" long, 1/4" thick piece with a jointer....

Put your jointer in a vice upside down and move your 4" long 1/4" piece across the plane like you would on power jointer. Watch your finger tips!

Paul Dzioba

Re: ? on Veritas� Iron Edge-Trimming Plane

#14

Re: I have both

Dan Clermont in Burnaby


>Hi Denis,

I don't have a #1 nor would I buy one unless it was a smoking deal at a garage sale.

Take Care

Dan Clermont

Re: ? on Veritas� Iron Edge-Trimming Plane

#15

The top thousand planes

Warren in Lancaster, PA


>If my shop had burned down yesterday and I were making a list of planes I would like to have, the edge trimming plane would not make the top thousand. It is not very versatile and its function can easily be accomplished with other tools.

Re: ? on Veritas� Iron Edge-Trimming Plane

#16

Re: The top thousand planes

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.


>Seriously? Can you give me that thousand plane list? I'm curious... :-)

DC

Re: ? on Veritas� Iron Edge-Trimming Plane

#17

Re: The top thousand planes

Warren in Lancaster, PA


>Some people have a thousand molding planes, but I suppose my use of that number was a way of saying that the edge trimmer would not be on my list. Here is a quick list of a hundred or so. They are all useful, but not all necessary.

3 smoothers, 2 foreplanes, jointer, trying, 4 rabbet, 2 moving fillesters, badger, 2 ploughs, combination, router plane, compass plane, 4 dado planes, bullnose, 6 sash planes, 32 hollows and rounds, 8 ogee, 8 ovolo, 10 beading, 4 nosing planes, 6 tongue, 6 groove, 4 dado planes. I may have forgotten some obvious ones.

Re: ? on Veritas� Iron Edge-Trimming Plane

#18

Chris Scholz

Re: The top thousand planes *LINK*

Chris Scholz


>The museum of Takenaka Carpentry Tools Museum states relating to the "Golden Age of Japanese Carpentry Tools":

"[in 1943] It was reported that a skillful [Japanese] carpenter had about 179 individual tools in his standard set. They consisted of 49 chisels, 40 planes, 26 gimlets and 14 types of tools for marking and ruling. However, in the case of low-budget construction, the total was only 72 pieces, with only 9 planes."

Makes me wonder what the NON-standard set would have looked like...


History of Carpentry Tools

Re: ? on Veritas� Iron Edge-Trimming Plane

#19

Re: I have both - LV blade query

Miles


>I have the Veritas apron plane, bought a few months ago, and I have been rather annoyed at how fast it blunts - so much so that I was going to do some testing and then ask Rob if it was OK. The A2 blade I have in an LN 62 1/2 is very long lasting by comparison, as are various old laminated blades & a Clifton Victor blade in a No5.

The apron plane hardly gets heavy use - and the wear bevel appears almost immediately. May be that the holm oak I'm using is abrasive but nothing else seems to be suffering unduly.

Miles

Re: ? on Veritas� Iron Edge-Trimming Plane

#20

Don't forget a few scrubs

Neal in San Jose

Re: ? on Veritas� Iron Edge-Trimming Plane

#21

shoulder planes too

Tom Sontag - St. Louis