Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Winter's coming...

Posts

Winter's coming...

#1

Winter's coming...

Edward in Vancouver


>Tuned up the furnace today, and as I put the tools back into the garage, my thoughts turned to the garage itself. Only have been really into woodworking since this spring, bought my first waterstones in April and they're sitting nicely in a s/s tub under my bench. Vancouver isn't exactly Alaska, but it'll probably get below freezing at some point during the winter, garage is insulated but I never figured it would be necesary to heat it.

My question is, what do you guys do with your waterstones in the winter? Soak them only when necesarry? Rig up something with an engine block, battery blanket, or aquarium heater? Go to oil stones?

Re: Winter's coming...

#2

Re: Winter's coming...

Dan Clermont in Burnaby


>Hi Edward,

My shop is the furnace room so I don't share your problem but soaking the stones during a woodworking session would be best IMO. It only takes 5 minutes to get them ready for use.

Dan Clermont

Re: Winter's coming...

#3

I'm in denial

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN


>Vancouver isn't exactly Alaska, but it'll probably get below freezing at some point during the winter

Indiana isn't Alaska either but there is no doubt it will get below freezing - like for weeks at a time. As a matter of fact there have been days when Fairbanks was a LOT warmer than Indianapolis.

But to address your question...

If the garage is insulated, why not install some kind of a heater? Gas or propane heaters are a little (but not much) harder to install than electric ones but may be cheaper to operate in the long run. I say may because I work for a natural gas supplier and have seen a number of people convert to electric heat due to high gas prices. One house kept the old gas furnace in the system so they could switch back to it if electic rate went up too much and gas prices went down. So far they haven't gone back to gas.

Some people seem to get by with kerosene heaters but with the price of kerosene staying around the three dollar mark it might be the most expensive option.

I have a vented propane ceiling mounted heater in a very well insulated shop and the shop is about the warmest place I have on a lot of days.

Re: Winter's coming...

#4

Re: I'm in denial

Bruce, a MN Galoot


>Minnesota experiences some sub-freezing days, too, even months. I'm just glad I don't live in northern MN, where the temps get cold enough to make you change your religion.

I was discussing the requirements to insulate my garage with the city building inspector and asked him what he had done to heat his own. He said he doesn't heat his garage, because the residual heat from the engines in his two cars was enough to keep the garage from freezing, except when the temp got really cold (-20F or colder). If freezing is the only concern, that might be something to consider.

I move my waterstones inside, as well as glue and some finishes.

Bruce

Re: Winter's coming...

#5

Re: Winter's coming...

William Duffield, on the Cohansey


>You are in a maritime climate, Sunset zone 6, average minimum January temperature 32.5�, in an insulated shop. That's similar to my situation, except my insulation isn't complete, and my windows leak. I have a propane heater, but the tank has been empty for about three years, because it's gotten too expensive to try to keep the shop warm. The bench dog's water bowl has never frozen over in my shop, and I've never noticed any frost damage to glue, paints or other finishes. I've never noticed the thermometer in the shop go below the mid 40's. You probably have lots of lights in your shop, too, that you could leave on on really cold nights to keep the shop above freezing. If you are really concerned, get or build a cabinet to put the finishes and stones in, and put a small light bulb in it, near the bottom, that you can turn on on really cold nights. When I need to work in there when it's really cold, I use an electric radiant heater, that I move around to keep it pointing at me whereever I'm working. I think you would be better off keeping your stones completely submerged, instead of trying to dry them between uses. There will always be a bit of water left inside. The thermal mass of an exposed stone is much less than a whole tub full of stones and water. If you have a temporary drop in temperature below freezing, the exposed stone is much more likely to freeze than one protected by the tub. This advise does not apply to Minnesota, Wisconsin, North Dakota, Manitoba, etc. which have extended periods (maybe weeks) during which the temperature never goes above 0� Farenheit.

Re: Winter's coming...

#6

Re: Winter's coming...

Dave Thompson


>There's a little corner in my house where I bring my sharpening equipment into, and do sharpening over the winter. It's primarily for fear of cracking the wet frozen stones. Though also it's no fun to be in contact with near freezing water and be sharpening in the shop. I usually bring my clamps and glue into the basement, so that I can still do glue ups in the winter. For stains and varnish I usually hold off until Spring.

I don't heat my shop. I find it easy enough to dress warmly with some very fasionable carharts body suit and a hat. Sometimes I spend a couple of full days in the shop in January when it's below freezing. By not heating my shop, I also don't incur the large temperature swings associated with that, which would cause condensation and rust on cast iron. Regardless, in late fall, I also usually apply paste wax to all cast iron in my shop.

enjoy,

Dave

Re: Winter's coming...

#7

Re: Winter's coming...

Paul Kierstead


>My garage is only partly insulated; probably has the foam outside, but no fiberglass inside. Door is wood, doesn't dump *too* much heat (like say a all-metal uninsulated door). Ceiling is insulated (living space above). My garage is almost always 10 degrees Celsius warmer then the outside temperature during the winter, unless I was to leave the door open quite a long time. I very much doubt (but this advice is worth what ya paid for it) that your garage will ever get below freezing in Vancouver (I live in Ottawa)

Re: Winter's coming...

#8

Re: Winter's coming...

thomd coralseacat@yahoo.au


>You guys in BC are so self-absorbed. The idea it will freeze in your garage, with the azelias in full bloom outside is a little retarded. If your lucky enough to have one of those leaky condos Just leave the stones in the middle of the family room.

Ok regional envy outbreak aside. My Garage is insulated and heated. However it's not much fun working there if the temperature really dives. One year I turnned the minimal heat off for a month of -20-30 C, and one day I was out in the garage checking things out and I noticed that I had left a glass of water next to the grinder for cooling hot tools. It had stood out in the garage with no heat other than the heat in the concrete slab, for aver a month of seriously cold weather and it was not frozen.

My general feeling is that you will not want to use the waterstones because it's just miserable to use them, water doesn't dry easily and is more likely to rust your tools when the weather is near freezing. When winter comes I generally use sandpaper scarry sharp style, or I have a full set of oilstones I use also. This is the time of year when I like tools that are easy to sharpen, and take a fast edge, compared to the onse that feel like they are riding on carbide ballbearings over the stone.

Re: Winter's coming...

#9

Re: Winter's coming...

Paul Kierstead


>I should say that the 10 degrees is the half of the garage by the house. The half nearest the door is quite a bit cooler. I keep my beer right near the house and it never freezes :) (mind you, freezing point for beer is a fair bit below zero)

Re: Winter's coming...

#10

Re: Winter's coming...

Warren in Lancaster, PA


>I work in a shop that is heated with a woodstove. I keep my 800 stone in water all the time, and put the next stone in while using the 800. The water has frozen overnight with the stone in it hundreds of times. I usually put some hot water from the woodstove in to melt the ice. Even if the water has not frozen and is just cold, its nice to put warm water in.

Re: Winter's coming...

#11

Oh Edward...

Victor P


>You suck. Freezing? I have to run the A/C in my shop occasionally even in January. Sorry can't help. In the summer I have to drain the water to keep the algi growth to minimum :>(

Victor in Hot & Humid Houston

Re: Winter's coming...

#12

Re: Oh Edward...

Edward inVancouver


>Thanks for the responses, gentlemen. Victor, if you want some rain, swing by here in mid October to about end of April. You get algae in the water? By January my neighbor's roof is so covered in moss/mould that he could start a pitch n' putt up there, and his cedar deck turns from brown to slippery green...

I've only read advice on not storing waterstones in water at freezing temps. But if others say that they've had stones in frozen water and not affecting the stones, I'll take their word for it. OTOH I have no desire to design my own custom-made slipstones... Having grown up in Saskatchewan, I do have a healthy respect for freezing temperatures, "square tires", "plugging the car in", and avoiding the kid with the hose flooding the local rink were just part of a normal day...

Re: Winter's coming...

#13

Re: Oh Edward...

thomd coralseacat@yahoo.au


>You shouldn't let them freeze, which is why people move to Vancouver, that and the baracuda fishing.

Re: Winter's coming...

#14

Re: Oh Edward...

William Duffield, on the Cohansey


>At least, in Vancouver, they don't eat the poisonous coral.