Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Blue steel vs. white steel

Posts

Blue steel vs. white steel

#1

Blue steel vs. white steel

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.


>What I read from various sites seems contradictory... Which one is the better steel?

DC

Re: Blue steel vs. white steel

#2

Article by Paul Jordan *LINK*

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.


>Hi Denis,

Paul Jordan wrote up a good article back on BP about this, here is teh Link

Take care,

Jim


Japanese Chisel Article by Paul Jordan

Re: Blue steel vs. white steel

#3

Paul Jordan, a good man...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.


>Back in the BP days, I made an inquiry about the bearings of my Jesada rabbetting set that were "rough" running. He stepped up to the plate, indicated that his company manufactured the bearings for that router bit set, and sent a replacement set to me out of the goodness of his heart.

Then, a while later, he went all around Rochester to get me three pairs of the Radio Shack drivers recommended for the Rat Pipes (that I still have to build...).

A very good man indeed...

Thanks Jim,

DC

Re: Blue steel vs. white steel

#4

Re: Paul Jordan, a good man...

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.


>He is Denis,

I spoke to him awhile ago, he has been too busy to do much woodworking lately.

Always a friend,

take care,

Jim

Re: Blue steel vs. white steel

#5

Re: Blue steel vs. white steel

Dave Burnard


>Yes I remember back in the late 80's we used to hear that blue paper steel was harder to work with and more likely to produce an edge that chips and that white was easier to work with and produced a keener edge. Not many tools were made out of blue paper steels back then. Nowadays we hear that the blue steels are easier to work with than white steels and you don't hear much about one chipping more or less than the other.

According to some toolmakers I have spoken to - these steel compositions were modified around 15 or so years ago to better accomodate the changing types of wood used and style of woodworking done in Japan. So my take is that this is what accounts for the apparent flip-flop. I don't know how this applied to specific blue and white steels - but it's what I was told.

White vs Blue - which is better? It's not a very useful question. It's similar to asking which is better between O1, A2. or Ron Hock's carbon steel, or.... It depends a lot what you're going to be doing with the tool, your skill level, your sharpening skills, the toolmakers skills, etc. For many users it may be hard to even notice a difference.

Re: Blue steel vs. white steel

#6

Re: Blue steel vs. white steel

thomd coralseacat@yahoo.au


>C = 1.1 - 1.2%, Si = 0.1 - 0.2%, Mn = 0.2 - 0.3%, Cr = 0.2 - 0.5%, W = 1.0 - 1.5%, P < 0.025%, S < 0.004%.

That's the blue steel formula.

I agree with Dave that the explanations are all over the map with this stuff. Largely reveal the ignorance of the person talking about them. The Jordan article has some chesnuts in it, like packing.

I bought most of my tools in blue steel because it was what folks were pushing back in 1979 when I bought the bulk of my tools. It was supposed to hold an edge better though a little harder to sharpen. I have since run into folks who prefer the white steel. As Dave says it is very O1 vs A2 reminiscent, though I don't feel the differences are that wide. I like steel that is free cutitng on stones it makes it easier to get the best out of the tool at least at my level of skill or patience. In that regard I'm not sure the blue steel matches my temperment. For the same reason I like O1, and Cast Steel. I start to loose confidence if it feels like I am not cutting, but if one is just thrashing away with a jig, I don't think that would mater. The majority of the tools I sharpen can't be jigged so I'm stuck with my hands.

I would try and find some recomendations for particular tool types I was interested in rather than pursue the colours route. There are smiths making top quality chisels out of white steel, the cheap end of the market is also white steel, and I have had problems there. But among the better tools it's all good.

A third option one hears little about is HSS. There are chisels and planes made out of this (whatever it may be) and often it is towards the cheap end of the spectrum, for cheap tools the HSS tools I have bought are my prefered tools to me they perform right up there for a lot less money. Unfortunately I can't give any brands guidance. I have just bought several planes worth, and a set of chisels and they were all good. Dicks sells some HSS. This is another steel that I don't really like the feel of when sharpening. But it cuts great.

Re: Blue steel vs. white steel

#7

Re: Blue steel vs. white steel

Gary B in Central NY


>Come on DC, don't you remember from the rosewood conference? Craig Stevens was talking about it....it's just oil hardened versus water hardened. jeesh.....lol

Gary

Re: Blue steel vs. white steel

#8

HSS = High speed steel = tool steel

Ian (in Sydney, Australia)


>Thinking back to 1st year engineering (way too long ago), HSS was used when cutting (on a lathe or end mill) normal mild steel.

I have no recollection of it's composition, but it's primary property was that the tool didn't go blunt when it got hot.

One of our exercises was to turn a cylinder from mild steel. One of my fellow students turned the "final" diameter in one cutting pass � the resulting cylinder was noticably undersize due to thermal expansion while cutting, but the HSS tool tip didn't appear any blunter than those used at the recommended feed rate.

I suspect HSS wasn't used in the past because it is too hard to sharpen without recourse to modern abrasives.

I hope this makes sense

Re: Blue steel vs. white steel

#9

Re: Blue steel vs. white steel

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX


>So, what's this "Super Blue Steel" that Funahiro uses in his Genju Funahiro chisels? I had one crack about 1/2" up when mortising black walnut (very clean break, btw), but no problems with its replacement or a couple or three others bought at the same time.

Pam

Re: Blue steel vs. white steel

#10

Re: Blue steel vs. white steel *LINK*

Todd from San Jose


>I will claim ignorance on which one is better, as I own a mixture of Matsumura white and blue steel chisels. I will say that I cannot tell the difference in their performance or durability- which I could not be happier with. I've chopped hundreds of dovetails in them in hardwood, and they hold an edge remarkably longer than my Marples chisels. But between the blue and white, they perform very much the same. I would guess that the difference between blue and white is not as great as the difference between japanese and western steels.

This is from the Japan Woodworker website: "Aogami Hagane means "blue steel" and is a more complex steel than Shirogami Hagane or "white steel". Edge tools made from "blue steel" give the most durable edge possible, particularly in hard, abrasive woods such as teak and exotic hardwoods."

Someone once told me that blue steel holds an edge longer than white steel, but is more brittle and prone to chipping. I have not had any significant issues with my blue steel chipping.

As an aside, if you don't want to mortgage your home to buy a set of japanese chisels, the Matsumuras are the real deal. They're the ones that were rated #1 by FWW a number of years back, and they're about $40 each, on average. If memory serves, FWW rated the white steel just better than the blue, but I can't recall the details as to why.

Todd


Matsumura at Japan Woodworker

Re: Blue steel vs. white steel

#11

Re: HSS = High speed steel = tool steel

thomd coralseacat@yahoo.au


>That's what it is, but there are many type of HSS, so unlike the White and Blue that are basically like O1 in their marketing, HSS could be a variety of steels. Actually the lathe cutters that cost a few bucks are usually really nice steel, I made a rebate plane out of one.

It's not all that bad to sharpen, just worse than carbon. The good part about it is you can't ruin it with modern methods, grind away!

Re: Blue steel vs. white steel

#12

Re: Blue steel vs. white steel

thomd coralseacat@yahoo.au


>Uug, that test was so bad!

Re: Blue steel vs. white steel

#13

Re: Blue steel vs. white steel

Todd from San Jose


>That may be true, but it was the best info I had to go on, before buying my Matsumuras.

The proof is in the pudding- the Matsumuras work very well. Granted, all I have them to compare to are Marples, but the difference is remarkable. The Marples did fine in soft woods, but when I tried to chop dovetails in walnut, they didn't last 2 minutes. It would not be an exxageration to say that the Matsumuras' edges last more than an order of magnitude longer than my blue cheapies, between sharpenings.

As a mechanical engineer, I also understand the benefits of the hardness of japanese steel (Rc 64, in the case of the Matsumuras) and the benefits of a properly forged grain structure. And hardness is directly related to strength. I don't believe that there is a western chisel maker that acheives this level of hardness or strength.

Todd

Re: Blue steel vs. white steel

#14

Re: Blue steel vs. white steel

Dave Burnard


>Super blue has a few more carbide forming alloying elements. Here's the typical chemistry:

White #1 1.2-1.3%, Mn 0.2-0.3%

Blue #1 1.2-1.3%, Mn 0.2-0.3% , Cr 0.3-0.5%, W 1.5-2.0%

Super Blue: C 1.4-1.5%, Mn 0.2-0.3%, Cr 0.3-0.5%, W 2.0-2.5%, Mo 0.3-0.5%, V 0.3-0.5%

Super blue is the same theory as Blue - just more carbon plus more of the harder wearing carbide forming alloys to try to add edge holding ability to the steel - but low enough to still allow a very keen edge (and be a water/oil hardening steel). (A2 has about 7-8% added alloy carbide formers - mostly chrome. HSS varies but is typically 15% and more. )

The occasional chisel that chips or breaks during normal use is not the fault of the type of edge steel chosen, more likely a flaw in the steel or backing material, a flaw in heat treatment, or some other exceptional circumstance.

Re: Blue steel vs. white steel

#15

Re: Blue steel vs. white steel

Dave Burnard


>It's more complicated that what you do or could harden it in. We know O1 as an oil hardening steel. The most important industrial benefits of oil hardening over water hardening are dimensional stability and through hardening. But what do either of those contribute to a chisel or plane where the cutting steel is only a millimeter or two thick.

For edge holding, what matters are the alloy carbide formers. In small amounts they change the phase diagrams enough that you *can* harden in a slower quenching oil. The harder carbides are what matter - and at the levels used in steels for japanese edge tools, most are actually hardened in water.

Re: Blue steel vs. white steel

#16

Re: Red steel

thomd coralseacat@yahoo.au


>Red: C.9 Mn 1.3 Cr.50 W.50 V.20

Anyway, what I want to know is what colour the paper is on the Super Blue!

Another thing to keep in mind about a lot of average weekend warrior types is that they just trash these chisels. It's sad to see what gets returned. It doesn't take any special skill not to wreck these chisels, just some respect. It's like leaving a wet beer glass on a polished table. They should blister pack the 10 chisel set with a pair of paint can openers. So all the "this type of steel chipped" stories should just wash over you.

Not to say chisels don't break. I managed to split open the socket one a cryo HT US chisel. It's like wood, it has a grain and sometimes the joints surprise you.

Re: Blue steel vs. white steel

#17

Re: Blue steel vs. white steel

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX


> The occasional chisel that chips or breaks during normal use is not the fault of the type of edge steel chosen, more likely a flaw in the steel or backing material, a flaw in heat treatment, or some other exceptional circumstance.

That's what I'd thought, too, especially given the clean, square break. Thanks for the confirmation and the definition of super blue steel.

Pam

Re: Blue steel vs. white steel

#18

Re: Blue steel vs. white steel

thomd coralseacat@yahoo.au


>As an engineer did it not strike you as odd how they ploted the volumetric erosion (i'm not an engineer so excuse my french). But as an engineer would you bid 200 buck to carry away the 200 foot pyramid and 400 bucks to carry away the 400 foot tall pyramid? Admitedly the 400 foot tall pyramid is bigger, and a better buy if you want a lot of rubble. That's just one of the problems with that test. Nothing wrong with the chisels you bought.

Re: Blue steel vs. white steel

#19

Re: Blue steel vs. white steel

Todd from San Jose


>It's been a few years since I read that article, and I will yield to your greater experience on the validity of their testing methods.

But sometimes you can extract valuable information even from a flawed test, and I feel it helped me choose a good set of chisels. I felt like I would more likely choose the right chisels for me, based on their recommendation, than if I were to just ask a couple of my woodworking buddies.

Re: Blue steel vs. white steel

#20

Re: Blue steel vs. white steel

thomd coralseacat@yahoo.au


>Depends on the buddies. I don't have any aquaintances who know anything about Japanese woodworking. The test was fairly accurate as a ranking so it did work that way. The amplitude of the difference was flattened in my view, and the norming of sharpening might have changed the ranking, though that is the kind of procedural issue that would be very difficult to actually adress. I just hate these tests they are always badly designed and yet they gain enormous currency.

Re: Blue steel vs. white steel

#21

Re: Red steel

Dave Burnard


>Red? Never heard that one before. Pretty sure that chemistry is what we call O1. Lots of manganese.

Re: Blue steel vs. white steel

#22

Re: Red steel

thomd coralseacat@yahoo.au


>Bingo! it has a red label.