Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Small totes long planes

Posts

Small totes long planes

#1

Small totes long planes

thomd coralseacat@yahoo.au


>Picking up on the Jointer thread, I have been wondering about the small closed totes on these planes, in classic form. I'm aware that some folks use the closed totes on all their planes, but it seems more comon to do as C&W is doing and have open totes on the smaller coarse planes, and closed totes on the fore planes, jointers, etc... I was watching something from Williamberg te other day and the joiner had a nice big handle on his jack, but his fore plane had this mingy handle he could only wind a few fingers into. These were repro planes, I think, maybe C&W, so it wasn't as though he was compromising for the sake of using some old plane that fit people who were "smaller back then".

So what is a tightly fitted closed tote on a big plane good for? The only thing I can think of is picking up and putting dowm. If you only use the jointer for a few strokes to joint the edge you really aren't holding on to it for long and the tight fit makes it come and go more easily. I wouldn't want that handle if I was using the jointer on a "it slices, it dices, it does it all..." basis, just not comfortable. It also gets the hand lower, but to some extent the bunching up of the fingers in negative for that. You can go much lower on an open grip just spreading your hand out and dropping it down.

Any Ideas? I don't have much experience with these classic planes partly because I don't find them comfortable. I was a little taken aback to see the repros fit so tight...

Re: Small totes long planes

#2

I think

jim reed @ tallahassee


>it all comes down to manufacturing. A closed tote like a sawhandle is pretty easy to mortice into a jointer plane body. Seems pretty common on planes of yore. Easy to do for someone who worked with wood to make the plane body. Just get a jig saw, cut out the tote and mortice it in place. Stanley metal planes used a rod (#1-#4) or a rod and screw (#5-#8). This required metalworking machining skills and was thus was a team factory job. The Stanley tote also required special machines to construct. Just some random thoughts.

Re: Small totes long planes

#3

Re: I think

Dean J in MN


>Jim --

FWIW, my woodie open totes are mortised into the body just like the closed tote handles.

What I haven't seen is the open totes being smaller than closed totes. My fore(jack) plane is open tote, and my try is closed. Looks like the C&W jointer had the same tote as the try plane? Larry?

There is pleny of room for the last three fingers to wrap around my totes, index finger extended a la a saw grip. A control grip? What I find interesting is the open totes on woodies don't give your index finger a place to rest. Perhaps more powerful grip was desired on open tote planes? On an open tote metal plane I find my index finger resting on the frog.

My 2 cents...

-Dean

Re: Small totes long planes

#4

Re: I think

thomd coralseacat@yahoo.au


>Thanks all

I agree about the CW totes on their website. On the episode of the WWS I saw the two handles looked really different in size like he could only squeeze his first three fingers in there. I do like to plane sometimes with my little finger on the top of the plane and the whole thing lower in the handle. It's just something I've noticed in old planes but I always put it down to smaller hands. It's 2006 and what is left over int he way of planes may just be the ones that don't fit too well. In the WWS it's one pair of hands and what look like two new planes. It's hard to be sure what with the size of my TV and all the other uncertainties.