Rationalization? What rationalization?
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>So how many of you have been down the rationalization path, selling off what you do not need�.
There are days when I look at my handtool collection and feel a strong sense of guilt for my gluttony. I mean, just how many smoothers/block planes/jacks/jointers does one need? Isn't one dovetail saw enough? And 4 chisels should be sufficient to see off most tasks (as proof, do you not also grab the nearest sharp chisel regardless of size?).
This usually occurs after a non-handtool (especially non-tool) visitor has stared open-mouth at the cabinet. Or after seeing pictures of Asian street woodworkers who use a leg as a vise and own one chisel and one shopbuilt plane yet create such intricate work.
I have to remind myself that these tools are necessary and all are used (even if that means once-per-year!), or it is in the aid of research (for "reference" dear). < grin >
The recent eBaying of a Jim Krenov plane was actually a meaningful moment for me. Not that I hanker for one of his planes (it would be nice but defeating the purpose of its meaning for me). JK's plane stated that the work was the thing and that nice tools can be a distraction. Mmmm ... Well there is a part of me that is a minimalist - truly - and I am very happy when I am either building something by making one tool go further than intended - just making do - or when using tools I have made.
But there is also a part that just enjoys experiencing and mastering different tools, and often I will just enjoy some time doing so. It is not even necessary to actually build something.
It helps to know that I live in Old Tool Hell and that decent handtools are hard to find. I may have a wide collection today, but this actually has few multiples, A few years ago, in a fit of guilt, I sold a few of the tools I had carefully hunted down. And quite cheaply too. Later I really regretted such impulsivity.
If I were a professional woodworker, rather than the hobbiest I am, I might have a different attitude to the tools I have accumulated. In my day job I resist buying new tools. I have a library of neuropsychological tests that I use regularly. Catalogues of new and promising tests arrive daily in the mail, and are quickly binned. In my job all I need are the tools I am familiar with, my 25 years of experience, and an enquiring mind. More fancy tests will not necessary help in my job. Understanding and applying existing tools is really all that is necessary.
So sometimes the extra tools are just for fun, just part of the hobby. And unless you have made a glutton of yourself you do not need to justify them.
Rationalization? What rationalization? < grin >
Regards from Perth
Derek