Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

Posts

Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

#1

Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ont.


>Hi

I have been working through a few shop projects this summer, one is to build a space to store my planes. So I pulled them all out and placed them on a board to mark out the real estate. After a few iterations I took a day off of the project to concentrate on other things. Last night I went back to the Plane project and had this realization, I do not use many of the planes I have.

I have a variety of bench planes including the following, 603, 604, 605, 606 and 607, Bailey 3(2 of them), 4, 4 � , 5, 5 � , 6 (3 of them). A variety of shoulder planes, block planes and scraper planes. I easily do not use the 3�s, 4, 5, 6�s and seldom the 606 or the 607. Am I crazy for selling them off? I guess I�m a practical type of woodworker, why would I keep tools I do not use?

Is this a function of where we start, where we think we need to be and finally realizing what we want to be with respect to hand tools?

I am putting off building my plane storage till I work this out, I do not want to add more clutter to my shop.

So how many of you have been down the rationalization path, selling off what you do not need�.

Thanks.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

#2

Re: Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

Norman (Ottawa, Ont.)


>Jim,

What you are saying has truth in it. Sometimes it makes sense to sell a rareyyl used tool or a few of them,, to be able to purchase a tool you really will use. Our skills and tool requirements evolve over time, so I see this as a natural progression.

It is akin to upgrading or replacing power tool equipment after

we outgrow the machine or our requirements change.

Interesting, a few of us were discussing this very same subject regarding rarely used hand tools last evening after our monthly woodowrking club meeting.

Norman

Re: Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

#3

Danger Will Robinson!

Bob Hutchins in central TX


>The day after you sell it, you'll need it - no, HAVE to it for a project - and pay twice as much for its replacement.

DAMHIKT

BobH

Re: Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

#4

Re: Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod


>Jim -

I have a shelf near my bench for my commonly used hand planes - jointer, jack, smoother, shoulder plane, block planes and so on. Away from my bench, where storage space is less precious, I keep my collect ... um ... infrequently used planes.

Ed

Re: Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

#5

Re: Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI


>I think it was Bob Key's tool box page that I read that stated he wanted to make sure he had room in his tool box to hang all 8 bench planes. I of course blindly thought this was a great idea. Now I realize that this is a lot of wasted tools. I think I will readust my tool box at some point to hold a #2, #3 or #4 (probably not both, and probably the #3) #4-1/2, two #5s (one with relatively small radius blade, another with larger radius), #5-1/2, and #7 or #8 (not both, and probably a #7), and a #40-1/2 scrub. I am sure a person could get by with a lot less. I probably will not sell the excess tools I have. I have started thinking what I really need is a small shed that would store all the incidentals I don't use but really can't get rid of. This would free my shop of any clutter, and leave room for the tools I use, materials for the project I am working on, and work benches. This would leave a lot of room for tool display. I really like old tools, and getting them out once in a while and dusting and waxing them is a very pleasant hobby. I can still remember where I found most of them, and some of them are very dear friends. It is really the hunt that gets my blood going though; even if I sold off all the tools I dont' use, I would still continue to hunt for more.

Re: Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

#6

Let's see...

HC Sakman


>...what kind of a shrine you'll come up with to house your S&S planes!!!! Yeah, Baileys won't look good there! ;-)

Chico...

Re: Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

#7

Re: Planes, For Work or to Look Good? *LINK*

Mike Hamilton


>Jim, Jim, Jim,

Don't go dumping tools until you've given this a lot of thought. For instance, consider the need to have a traveling toolkit as well as the one in the bench room. Wouldn't want to expose your 'go to' shop tools to the general public and unpredictable work environs. I was quite attracted to Ralph Brendler's toolbox for taking to Shaker box demos. When I read his writeup, I had all the justification I needed for adding a 3 and a 6 to my coll... inventory. Try the link and click mid-page.

On the other hand

if you have must lighten the load,

I am still

in acquisition mode.

Regards,

Mike Hamilton

Plainfield, IN


Ralph's toolbox

Re: Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

#8

Re: Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

Dan Donaldson


>

If you do sell off any, keep me in mind. I am looking for a #3 sized plane. I do mostly small stuff and have small hands. I like the smaller planes for most stuff I do. ;-)



not

    far

          enough

                     down

                           the

                                 slope

                                       yet ;-) Wheeeeeeeeeeeee


Re: Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

#9

Re: Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

dave caudill


>Well here is my take on the whole thing and I too have given it a lot of thought over the last couple of years. I think we all go through a great gathering period where we just keep buying all of the tools we can get our hands on thinking we may not see another one out there. Well seldom does that happen at least with the commonly used planes, saws, chisels, etc. In addition to my shop I have closets with tools in them, tools under my bed, on display in my house and so on. I'm not an advocate of selling everything off except those very ones you use daily or weekly whatever the case but I am an advocate of clearinf space both in the house and the mind that extra tools tend to create clutter. Its like my old kayak that I don't use anymore. It not only takes up space but it also requires a certain amount of mental space and time every time I see it. We all spend a lot of time tending to all those extra things in our lives that we dont' use. Again I don't think we should dump everything but the bare essentials but enough is enough and at times we have to do some real honest thinking and make soem hard decisions. Or at least I do. When I moved back in December and realized how many boxes of tools I had I decided it was crazy. So I high graded and sold off a number of them. I don't miss them and no you will not need it as soon as you sell it because you have several of each. I still have dozens of saws and would sell some but no one really wants to pay for them so I will keep them. Also I have a thing for chisels so I have many a set and will sell one now and then but only because I have another or a better one. I think you will be surpised at one how little you miss those extra tools and how much mental space you create by not feeling like you should do something with that box of planes, saws or whatever it is lying around. And like I said I still have a number of planes and usually at least doubles if not ore of all of them but 3, 5, 7....of each too much. That is if your not collecting and you actually would like to use the ones you have. Try it. I'm sure there are many willing buyers here who would give you a fair price for them.

Okay just my 2 cents and more.

Dave

Re: Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

#10

Re: Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

Dan Clermont in Burnaby


>I for one don't have the space to store allot of extras nor can I justify "maintaining" allot of extra tools as I hate rust and live on the Wet Coast. I do have a coupla planes I am fond of but will sell them off when my new Bronze plane shows up.

Dan Clermont

Re: Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

#11

Look good, of course!

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.


>Come on, Jim, no one here actually use their planes, it's all smokes and mirrors to entice the customers to pay the big bucks for some "handmade" furniture that was actually built with a router and a sander...

Allright, hold the flames, I was joking... :)

Seriously, I know what you're going through (I just don't own that many planes...).

I'm working on building my "hand tool alcove", and the dimensions I have to deal with are 42 x 27 x 15". This space will have to host most of my hand tools and accessories. I'm reserving space in there for about a dozen bench planes, no more. Anything that will not be used on a regular basis will not be welcome to the alcove, it'll go to a box or get sold.

I have done this exercise with some of my power tools, selling what I wasn't using anymore, I think I could do another round with these...

I've been in a cluttered shop for too long, now I'm getting rid of the stuff that "made sense" at purchase time but never got used...

But I must say that it's painful at times to part with some of that stuff...

DC

Re: Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

#12

Re: Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

thomd coralseacat@yahoo.au


>I've never been that good at selling personal belongings. It always seems that even if the thing in question is just weighing me down, It's worth more to me than others will pay. There may be a few exceptions, power tools move well, as do, maybe, LNs.

I have always kept my tool storage pretty flexispce. I have a lot more stuff than I regularly use, but I do rediscover different things about the stuff. Like last year when I said I had never liked by early LN 4.5 (or whatever it is). I realized I didn't like the blade and the chipper so I converted it to a mono-iron plane. I enjoy having that kind of realization, but so far not even that has manifested itself into 1 square foot of planed wood that I wouldn't have had by some other means. I always devide my work into hobbie vs. production, and maybe also I should ad. vs collectivitis/tool obssession.

Re: Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

#13

Re: Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

Frank D. in Montreal


>Hi Jim,

I've thought about that a few times too. Try increasing the camber on the blades you don't use. That way you'll have different planes, not duplicates. Works for me!

;)

Re: Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

#14

Rationalization? What rationalization?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)


>So how many of you have been down the rationalization path, selling off what you do not need�.

There are days when I look at my handtool collection and feel a strong sense of guilt for my gluttony. I mean, just how many smoothers/block planes/jacks/jointers does one need? Isn't one dovetail saw enough? And 4 chisels should be sufficient to see off most tasks (as proof, do you not also grab the nearest sharp chisel regardless of size?).

This usually occurs after a non-handtool (especially non-tool) visitor has stared open-mouth at the cabinet. Or after seeing pictures of Asian street woodworkers who use a leg as a vise and own one chisel and one shopbuilt plane yet create such intricate work.

I have to remind myself that these tools are necessary and all are used (even if that means once-per-year!), or it is in the aid of research (for "reference" dear). < grin >

The recent eBaying of a Jim Krenov plane was actually a meaningful moment for me. Not that I hanker for one of his planes (it would be nice but defeating the purpose of its meaning for me). JK's plane stated that the work was the thing and that nice tools can be a distraction. Mmmm ... Well there is a part of me that is a minimalist - truly - and I am very happy when I am either building something by making one tool go further than intended - just making do - or when using tools I have made.

But there is also a part that just enjoys experiencing and mastering different tools, and often I will just enjoy some time doing so. It is not even necessary to actually build something.

It helps to know that I live in Old Tool Hell and that decent handtools are hard to find. I may have a wide collection today, but this actually has few multiples, A few years ago, in a fit of guilt, I sold a few of the tools I had carefully hunted down. And quite cheaply too. Later I really regretted such impulsivity.

If I were a professional woodworker, rather than the hobbiest I am, I might have a different attitude to the tools I have accumulated. In my day job I resist buying new tools. I have a library of neuropsychological tests that I use regularly. Catalogues of new and promising tests arrive daily in the mail, and are quickly binned. In my job all I need are the tools I am familiar with, my 25 years of experience, and an enquiring mind. More fancy tests will not necessary help in my job. Understanding and applying existing tools is really all that is necessary.

So sometimes the extra tools are just for fun, just part of the hobby. And unless you have made a glutton of yourself you do not need to justify them.

Rationalization? What rationalization? < grin >

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

#15

Rationalization? What rationalization?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)


>So how many of you have been down the rationalization path, selling off what you do not need�.

There are days when I look at my handtool collection and feel a strong sense of guilt for my gluttony. I mean, just how many smoothers/block planes/jacks/jointers does one need? Isn't one dovetail saw enough? And 4 chisels should be sufficient to see off most tasks (as proof, do you not also grab the nearest sharp chisel regardless of size?).

This usually occurs after a non-handtool (especially non-tool) visitor has stared open-mouth at the cabinet. Or after seeing pictures of Asian street woodworkers who use a leg as a vise and own one chisel and one shopbuilt plane yet create such intricate work.

I have to remind myself that these tools are necessary and all are used (even if that means once-per-year!), or it is in the aid of research (for "reference" dear). <

Re: Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

#16

Re: why not "AND" ?

paul womack

Re: Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

#17

Steve Kubien

Re: Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

Steve Kubien


>Hi Jim,

I'm going to come at this from a slightly different angle... Like many, I started in this hobbie with little money (some things don't change). I bought a garage-sale smoother and got hooked. Money was still tight so I saved and picked a really top-notch (IMHO) smoother and jointer. I had my Dad's no-name jack and could make a scrub. A nice LA block was a Xmas gift and that's pretty much where I have stayed. Oh yeah, built a shoulder during the neander meander and recently picked up the new router plane (but those are more specialty planes, not "bench" planes). That's all I've got and I don't need anymore. Sure, a low-angle somethingorother would be nice for shooting end-grain but I do not need it.

Pare it down and go simple.

cheers,

Steve Kubien

P.S. Now, you wouldn't do something crazy like lighten the saw collection would you? I mean, that's just nuts! You DO need each and every one of those. Braces? Yup, probably need at least a dozen of those.......

Re: Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

#18

Re: Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

Ernie Miller


>I don't as a rule keep duplicates. I am allways looking for more but will sell of one of them if it is a duplicate. Planes usualy sell pretty well. Things I get that I don't need and don't sell well are another problem they come in the box with the planes at an auction or sale. Rules, cheaper saws, auger buits, Screw drivers? I have been tossing them in a box with like items but there has to be an end some where. I bought a small stach of hand saws the other day and there was a cream seperator in with the lot? what the heck am I going to do with that?

Re: Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

#19

buy a cow ;-)

Dan Donaldson

Re: Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

#20

What I do

David Miller from Iowa


>is buy any decent plane that I can find if it is a good price. Doesn't matter if I have it and the word "need" is quite irrelevant. I can't help doing this and there is no 12 step program of which I am aware that will aid my illness.

What I end up with is a number (a large number) of common planes - #4s and #5s especially. Then, in a less compulsive moment, I will identify an expensive plane that I *want* and I will sell 10 $25 planes to buy a $250 plane. I could never justify dropping $250 on a plane out of the blue, but using this sophisticated model has helped me build a nice collection. This collecting strategy is called cognitive dissonance.

David

Re: Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

#21

Two thoughts

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA


>1. Donation: you may find a local charity that would be thrilled to get your boxes of things that don't sell well. They may be able to sell them for 50 cents or a dollar; it wouldn't be profitable for you, but works for them. My wife works at the local Hospice thrift store, and tells me they're always glad to get tools because they sell quickly; but the local Habitat chapter has just opened a building-related thrift store, and I'm more inclined to donate there (planning to take another box over tomorrow from cleaning out our storage shed - not that I cleaned out much).

2. I inherited nine or ten Popular Mechanics Shopnotes from my uncle, from the late 1930s and early 1940s, at the time that the availability of trucks and the increased quality of the roads had resulted in the centralization of milk processing in town, leading to a lot of surplus cream separators. Up to the war, every one of those Shopnotes tips collections offered some ingenious new tool to make from a cream separator. But these were the 6-foot-tall monsters - you're probably talking about a more portable one.

Re: Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

#22

Re: Two thoughts

thomd coralseacat@yahoo.au


>50 cents!!! Why not just give me the name of the restaurant and I will take them there directly. At least that way I can visit them...

Re: Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

#23

Re: What I do

thomd coralseacat@yahoo.au


>"cognitive dissonance."

No that's the rattling sound I get in my head when I think about it!

Actually makes a lot of sense, except in my case I would just end up with 11 planes. That's the one good thing: I don't feel the least interested in the early age of iron or the beech age. Otherwise I would be able to build my walls out of planes and mortar. Just lucky I guess.

Re: Planes, For Work or to Look Good?

#24

Re: Two thoughts

Ernie Miller


>This is a 6' behimith and the crank is froze up. I'm thinking yard art. but my wife keeps saying not in her yard?