Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

junk or treasure?

Posts

junk or treasure?

#1

junk or treasure?

Bill Nichols


>I picked these 3 plaines up at a yard sale Saturday and was wondering if they will be worth anything after I get them cleaned up. I know the small one will not be worth much , the one in the middle is a Bailey #4 and the other one says Stanley Handyman.

Thanks for any info you can share. Bill


img

Re: junk or treasure?

#2

Pic # 2 

Bill Nichols



img

Re: junk or treasure?

#3

Re: junk or treasure?

Steve Mackay


>Oh Mama ! Gimme, gimme ! Those are PRIME starters ! Don't listen to ANY ONE tell 'Ya different. If you can't stand to look at 'em too long just send 'em my way ! You a lucky one !

Re: junk or treasure?

#4

Treasure

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away


>Bill,

As Steve so enthustasically stated they are in fact Prime starters. I'd rehab them and put 'em back to work. The #5 Handyman is pretty much a POS, but I'd still rehab it to a functional condition.

I enjoy bringing tools in this condition back from the grave.

What's the story behind them? Looks live been adbandoned for a long time.

Todd O.

Re: junk or treasure?

#5

Re: Treasure

Kevin French, Antrim, NH


>Now THIS is what I've been preaching, Three Butt ugyly starter planes for the about 1/100 the price of an LN You're going to learn a lot about planes.

Cleaning, tuning and shapening.

Maybe I don't want to spend this much time, Cleaning, tuning and shapening.

These planes are junk, maybe I want an LN

At least you didn't go straight to LN and find out you have no use for hand planes and be out several hundred dollars.

I have a copy of all three of those planes, Clean'm, tune'm and shapen'm and Use'm. While you're doing all this keep your eyes open for cheap better ones

One more thing read about'm

http://216.239.57.104/search?q=cache:0WVHxTjgm1cJ:www.amgron.clara.net/

http://www.geocities.com/plybench/plane.html

http://www.geocities.com/plybench/plane.html

to date the #4

http://www.hyperkitten.com/tools/stanley_bench_plane/dating/

http://www.popularwoodworking.com/features/fea.asp?id=1020

http://www.geocities.com/plybench/flatten.html

When you want to make thos planes work a little better

http://www.hocktools.com/

Re: junk or treasure?

#6

Re: Treasure

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native now in Jax Fl.


>Actually Bill, that "small one" may really surprise you. Looks like a Stanley 110 block plane to me. clean it up, sharpenen it, and use it.

If you're new to planes these are excellent starters, and are very much like you'll find them in the Wild. As Kevin said, you'll learn much much about planes by fooling with these. Remember, when finding rust in the wild, try to contain yourself, looked them over for any missing parts or damage. Even if you can get one that is missing parts for just a few dollars take them as you can always either have a parts stash, trade them, or sell them, unless of coarse you have been poisioned by too many Dancing Teapots! ;~)

Next thing you know you'll be as bad as Steve and completely re-japanning them. It is a sickness and we as users/collectors/accumulators have to make some decisions as to what degree we want to rehab a user grade plane. Unfortunately, it is decisions that only YOU can make.

How many quid did these planes set you back?

All three of them are as common as dirt no question about it, but hey, what better to get educated on than ones that are dirt common? Matter of fact, on that note, if you know absolutly nothing about planes I'd start on that Handyman as it is the most worthless one of the 3. For rusted in screws be patient and use something like PB Blaster to get them out, or zap them. Also, and this is important--get yourself the screwdrivers that fit all the various slots perfectly This will allow you get a bit more torque on them and greatly reduce the chances of cam out.

Follow all of the Links that Kevin provided and you'll be plane savvy in no time.

BTW Kevin, nice post.

T.O.

Re: junk or treasure?

#7

An education in the rough

Bob Hackett


>As previously stated,these will serve to acclimate you to the slope and help you develope skills that will hold you in good stead when the really choice rust comes your way.

That little block plane when properly sharpened will make a good apron plane and later serve duty when there may be knots or hidden hardware in a carpentry job around the house.Think of it as a sacrificial plane to be used when there`s a chance of chipping the Hock iron in your favorite small plane.

Tune that Handyman #5 up and you may be surprised.If not then you can always convert it into a scrub till you come across an old #40 or 40 1/2.

That #4 doesn`t look like it`s pitted in the pics.It should shape up to be a good bench plane with just alittle work and maybe later a thicker iron.

All in all I`d say it was a good find and a gloatable haul.

Then again you can always just break `em up,put `em on ebay and become instantly rich.;^)

Mainely,Bob-Merrily adding to the hands at your back pushing you down the slope.

Re: junk or treasure?

#8

Re: junk or treasure?

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI


>It is hard to tell from a picture how rusted that #4 is, but it can certainly be made to function again and also look pretty good. You may or may not enjoy the work depending on your personality. Depending on how much you paid for these planes, they could be broken up for parts and exchanged for more tool money.

Re: junk or treasure?

#9

Re: junk or treasure?

Ernie Miller


>That was a pretty stupid thing to do. You haven't taken them out to you shop yet have you? if you haven't there may still be time. I would have a garage sale this weekend and get rid of them as soon as possable. If they are in you shop seperate them and put them in the bottom of unused boxes of tools to never see the light of day. sure them may have been cheap and you have allways wanted to learn to use planes. but them three cheap planes are going to multiply as soon as you turn into another sale or get board some evening and cruse eBay. I predect befor it's over them three cheap planes are going to cost you between $5-10,000 in sharpening stones, blades, more planes, chisels, and other unmentable rust. and God forbid if any one ever lets you use an infill. Go kiss you wife and tell her you are sorry and you will never buy another one. The first ones are allways cheap or free. then the next thing you know you are living in a van below a bridge.

Re: junk or treasure?

#10

Junk

Todd Hughes


>The first plane looks like it is a Stanley handyman plane , these are cheap low quality planes aimed at the home owners market originaly. Yours looks to be in rather rough condition, even when found in nice condition I don't understand why anybody would fool with one since it is so easy to get a better quality plane that will serve you better.The small block plane on the other end is about the same thing, a cheap low quality plane [looks like a Stanley 110 or knock off]. Personaly I would not only not buy either one of these I wouldn't even bother bending over to pick them up if I dropped them esp. if i wanted a plane to use.

The plane in the middle looks to be a older stanley no. 4 a real classic high quality tool that if in good condition would make you a nice plane to use and that would probably perform as good as any plane. Unfortunatly it looks to be in what I would say is Poor rough condition, with lots of work maybe can be put back into using condition if the blade isn't to pitted but you will still have a rough plane.This is a very common tool and examples in much better condition are easy to find for $5-$15 pretty easy. I'm cheap as anybody but I don't understand taking time and effert to fixing up crap like that when you can get better condition examples so cheap. You may be able to use it for parts for future planes that could use them though many here think that is some sort of crime against tooldom.

Sure you can spend lots of time and trouble to fix this junk up but why? In the end you will be better served by buying better condition quality tools that probably won't cost you much more then you paid for these.....Todd

Re: junk or treasure?

#11

Re: junk or treasure?

Bill Nichols


>Thanks for the responses, especially the links Kevin. Yes, this in a new venture for me and i'm sure it will indeed be an educational experiance. I gave $30.00 for all three and even if they are junk as Todd says, I believe I will have a much greater appreciation for a real quality plane such as a LN after spending time reconditioning these .

Re: junk or treasure?

#12

ALL the help you need at WC !

Steve Mackay

Re: junk or treasure?

#13

Re: junk or treasure?

Kevin French, Antrim, NH


>$30 is a bit much for what you got, BUT, I've done worst. It's all part of the learning curve. Tha'st why I said learn what to look for and keep your eyes open for the 'deals'.

Todd is right, yet wrong. The planes you have are junk/not worth restoring, except to someone who hasn't used plane before. This is not the way to collect a set of planes. It's is a great way to learn about planes.

good luck with them

Here's one more link

http://www.sover.net/~nichael/nlc-wood/stanref-num.html

Re: junk or treasure?

#14

Re: junk or treasure?

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native, Presently Away


>Sorry Bill Kevin is right, you did pay too much for these planes. for the #5 Handyman, and the block, I'd of given no more than $3 each, and I'd of given no more than $10 for that #4 in that condition, and assuming that it is complete,has no damage or pitting in the sole, and all parts that are suppose to move, do in fact move.

As Kevin said, Todd is right to a point. You will learn much from these planes which will be well worth the add'l $14 that you paid for these planes.

Mess with the #5 first, than the block, than the #4 as the #4 is the best one of the 3.

Ernie gave you some sage advise as well, but hey, living in a van under a bridge really isn't so bad. ;~)

T.O.

Re: junk or treasure?

#15

OK

Todd Hughes


>So why is restoring cheap,rough, rusty junk planes like these such a great way to learn about planes ? In the end what will you wind up with?...Clean , Cheap , Rough , Junk planes. Sort of like a guy showing a picture of cheap piano with the side busted out, no keys or strings and being told " Hey that will be a great piano to learn to play on"..Would it really?

Wouldn't a better way to learn about planes be to buy some decent, quality planes that when you get done "learning" about them you will have a quality tool that will perform well for you for years to come. I could almost understand it if a plane like this was hard to find or expensive but they ain't. Even if you don't want to take the trouble to find them yourself for this $30 you could get a very nice no. 4 off the ebay that probably will need very little done to it [at least compared to these planes] to work well.

As always the best time to learn about what planes [or anything else for that matter] to buy is befor you buy them....well thats the way I think at least...Todd

Re: junk or treasure?

#16

At last, an honest response!!!

Gerald J. Doll

Re: junk or treasure?

#17

Just kidding with you, but . . .

Steve Mackay


>What might you find under the tote ?

Why will the bolts / screws holding your woods tighten only so far?

Have your woods ever been repaired and prone to cracking ?

Why would your iron not slip nice in the mouth?

Why might your frog "wobble" in the body ?

Why does your adjustment knob / yoke assy turn REALLY hard ?

I know, I know . . . I'm just the Rookie here but I like the "why" as much as the "how".

Besides . . . when your done "PIMPING" it, YOU did it, and NUTH'N compares with that.

Re: junk or treasure?

#18

Re: crusty

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI


>When I first started looking for planes in this area I thought they were as scarce as nice east coasters. Boy did I over pay for some junk! Some of the things I bought and what I paid for them would give you fuel to laugh at me for years. But I did learn how to use planes, and I enjoyed the path I took. I wouldn't do anything different if I had to do it all over again, except that I would work harder at getting a better job much earlier in life so I had a little bit more money to waste early on. This spring I saw three planes that were really pretty nice at a flea market, and I asked the guy how much. When he said "$5 each" I decided to just take the two #5-1/4 planes and leave the #5, so he just gave me the #5. Another thing I found this year is the #18 bevel gauge in really good shape for $1. But if it wasn't for the years of looking for tools, learning what to look for and how much to pay, and learning about tools, I would not have found any of these bargains. If I started out buying brand new LN or LV planes, I would never have apreciated these tools when I finally do get the money to buy them.

Re: junk or treasure?

#19

Re: crusty

William Duffield, on the Cohansey


>If I started out buying brand new LN or LV planes, I would never have...

Aw, heck! And I thought Todd's argument could somehow be interpreted as being in favor of buying L-N and Vertitas planes :^)

Re: junk or treasure?

#20

Volkswagens

Bill Houghton, foggy mornings in Sebastopol, CA


>Back in the days of the aircooled Volkswagen, people used to say that they were great cars on which to learn how to work on cars. True - they broke down so frequently that you got lots of opportunities to practice, an important part of learning a new skill.

From what I can see in the picture, Bill, you paid more than you should have - so be it; I have done the same, even more recently than when I started out. I suggest you spend a little time with the cutting iron on the middle one (the No. 4, it's called). If you can't get it smooth after cleaning it (it may not be shiny bright - old steel often darkens - but it's critical that it be smooth), accept that you paid some tuition and keep looking around for a plane in better shape to learn on. If you can, the plane is probably worth cleaning up (I use SOS pads, then spray WD-40 all over everything, and wax all the surfaces after I dry it off with paper towels).

I look for:

1. The tote, which is what the rear handle is called, should be full oval, no flat sides.

2. When you remove the lever cap and iron, the frog (bed) on which the iron sits should run all the way down to the sole.

3. The plane, if it's a Stanley, should say "Bailey" on the sole, usually near the front knob.

Go to your local library and get out all the books you can find on hand tools; read them. You'll get a more comprehensive overview of handtool work than you ever will on the web.

Re: junk or treasure?

#21

Come on now Todd

Bob Hackett


>I don`t think either you or your shed would be near as interesting if you had started and stayed with LN planes or thier equivalent in other areas.

MB

Re: junk or treasure?

#22

Nope, Ole Man Hughes Would Rather

Bob Hutchins in central TX


>sell you a plane he bought for $3 and spent 10 minutes cleaning. It's all about market mind control.

"Can't learn nothin' 'bout no stinkin' planes by rehabbin' 'em. Nosirree Bob! You gotta buy this here rare and beautiful Stanley pre-1990 beauty created by modern computer controlled milling machines with soft steel in the blade to make honing easier. Why it's even been reassembled from parts that were carefully salvaged to ensure you got the best components. Why ever'body knows that the best year for frogs was 1969. You'll really learn a LOT 'bout planes with one of these babies. They are REAL hard to find here in OTH. An' my reserve on ebay (a modest $230) don' hardly cover what I got in it. My standard shippin' fee is $50 in town and $100 out of town."

BobH, doin' a little Todd bustin'

Re: junk or treasure?

#23

Re: Nope, Ole Man Hughes Would Rather

Todd Hughes


>Well I understand this post was some attempt at humor [a rather feable one IMO] but it really is pretty monsensical as I never advocated anything at all like this. Rather said that a quality , good plane could be picked up easly and cheaply and even if you had to buy one on the ebay you could still probably do it for less then the $30 spent on these. You are on the moon hinting that I charge some exhorbent shipping fees for what I sell on ebay because if you knew anything about what you were talking about you know I put in all my auctions that I charge actually postage...and I do.

I do appreciate the trouble you took to post this though as I imagine it was quite difficult to type it with your nose while wearing a straight jacket, eh?.......Todd

Re: junk or treasure?

#24

Lighten Up and Enjoy Your Reputation, Old Man!

Bob Hutchins in central TX


>We wouldn't kid you if we thought you couldn't take it!

BobH

Re: junk or treasure?

#25

Re: Lighten Up and Enjoy Your Reputation, Old Man!

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native now in Jax Fl.


>Bill,

See all the trouble you've stirred up!? In future, stick to the easy questions like "Which is better, LN or LV" Sheeeeeeeeeeeesh!

Todd O.

Who once tried typing with my nose, but my Neanderthal forehead kept bumping the keys first.

Todd, you're a real gas