Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Does a flat sole guarantee a flat board?

Posts

Re: Does a flat sole guarantee a flat board?

#26

Re: Other wasy to skin some fat cats

William Duffield, on the Cohansey


>Having a mixed power and hand tool shop, and access to even more tools at work or at a shipyard, I can suggest a couple other techniques for really crooked edges and for really long boards.

Instead of trying to take all the bow out of a really crooked board with the jointer (electric or hand), I will often draw a straight line with a long straight edge, and cut close to the line on the bandsaw. Another tool that works well for rough straigtening of the edge is a Festool circular saw with the rail/straightedge it rides on. With the integrated dust collection system, the price of one of these is up there with the L-N #8. Most bandsaws don't work very well on very long boards, so you might want to hunt down a ship's saw, which is a huge bandsaw with a tilting frame as opposed to a tilting table. The one at Hearne's Hardwoods that came from the Philadelphia Naval Yard is the eighth wonder of the world. It's probably older than any #7 in any of our collections, but has been upgraded, just a bit. If you are away from a power source, you might try removing most of the bow with a frame saw, but a bit of skill with an axe, as recommended by Adam and Chris, can be a lot quicker.

Re: Does a flat sole guarantee a flat board?

#27

Re: What kind of mold is it

thomd coralseacat@yahoo.au


>Well actually I think you are asking the exact right question: "What kind of mold is it". With any tool I want to know at least two things: What does it do by it's very nature; what else can I do with it?

So a 5/8" wrench is a lot better at wrenching on 5/8" bolts than anything else, in a pinch I might use it on a 15mm head, or maybe as a lever or an impact tool, it's a pretty specific kind of tool and I do need all the other wrenches in the set.

Molding planes are a mold for their exact transverse contour, and not much else. All tools have some spcific use, like a given gouge has one shape it cuts as a pure funtion of it's sweep, one might use it to cut all sorts of contours in addition but there is one shape it perfectly mirrors.

In that regard a long plane is like a feeler gage for setting spark plugs it lets you build a precise gap into a pair of boards. A shorter plane will do the exact same gap but only with thinner shavings. So for instnace Krenov's jointer is 18" long. That's the perfect length for the smaller pieces he made at the time his books came out, and with a very fine blade set. Most of the jointing in his pieces is for bookmatched panels, and those have a low aspect ratio compared to say a bunch of 6 foot pieces 6" wide and they can't be flexed into place for clamping, so you need a very fine shaving (tearout is also a factor)and you don't really need a long body. I came across this same formula for a jointer for the backs of guitars, though shooting them is more sensible really.

So I think the longer planes have their uses. I have a really long antique jointer I do wonder what it's original owner used it for.

Re: Does a flat sole guarantee a flat board?

#28

Re: Other wasy to skin some fat cats

Dean J in MN


>

If you are away from a power source, you might try removing most of the bow with a frame saw, but a bit of skill with an axe, as recommended by Adam and Chris, can be a lot quicker.


I'll echo this -- a nice hatchet is a very handy tool in a cabinetmakers shop. I'm amazed how often I use mine now that I own one. As William said, a chalk line and hatchet is much faster than a rip saw for crooked edges. You'll find more uses once you start using it.

-Dean

Re: Does a flat sole guarantee a flat board?

#29

Nah

John in New Mexico


>Not offended. Just thought it a strange route to your ultimate question.

One of the odd thing about forum structures is its not like a conversation where the evolution of ideas and thoughts tend to be understood from the context of the discussion. Though this is certainly a discussion, for me it read more like a script because I didn't get around to reading it until there were already several posts and responses. From that point of view it tends to seem a bit more organized than a verbal discussion would be.

Both questions are quite legitimate and interesting of course, especially considering the somewhat bewildering array of planes available both new and used. I often skip some of the more esoteric seeming plane discussions, but in this case I'm curious about jointers (and the tote discussion above), as I've got a nice chunk of 12/4 mahogany I'm thinking of making a jointer out of. On the other hand, I've got an old #7 that works ok, and perhaps I should use the wood for chair legs or something.

John

Re: Does a flat sole guarantee a flat board?

#30

Thanks

Dave Thompson


>I like the bandsaw idea William. Seems obvious in hind site, but I didn't think of it all these years. I don't expect the length to be an issue with some free standing rollers for support. I suppose a laser pointer device or chalk line would be pretty handy for scribing a guide line.

I think I might have to find and blow the cobb webs off my hatchet too.

Thanks,

Dave

Re: Does a flat sole guarantee a flat board?

#31

Re: Thanks

William Duffield, on the Cohansey


>My first success with the bandsaw at this task came about serendipitously. Instead of a crooked board, what I actually started with was a straight edge, off the jointer, but with figure that wouldn't match up with any of the other boards that needed to be glued up into the table top. They happened to be flat sawn ash, which has very pronounced cathedral figure. I finally found a reasonable fit, but one that would require a large wedge to be taken off of one board, after laying the adjacent board on top of the nonconforming one, and drawing a line on it. While sawing it to the line on the bandsaw, I realized this would work for crooked boards as well as boards that were straight but in the wrong direction.