Re: Depends - long but meaty
thomd coralseacat@yahoo.au
>Hand tool woodworking is not necessarily lower space/volume than power tool woodworking. A workbench is about the size of a planer, contractor's saw and jointer. Sure you can have a small workbench, but then one is into the realm of constricting project size which is probably the simplest solution.
I tend to look at woodworking as either production or a hobby. You either are trying to make something or just have fun. If it's 100% fun then you can specialize and keep everything within a particular size. If the answer to the request "honey the kids need blanket boxes", is a hum of activity then you need some power tools or some means of keeping ahead until the next project appears. On the other hand, you could probably make violins in a closet, remember those prisoners in Colditz who built an airplane in the attic above their cells to fly out with. They did make the plane though they didn't get a chance to fly it.
I think that if you have a workbench, then you won't greatly miss a jointer. I rarely pull mine out these days. As a tool for preparing edges it is inferior to a plane, and as a means of flattening the first surface, it is inferior and not enormously more efficient. Often a relatively small amount of cleaning on the first surface will prepare it for the planer, so you aren't really stuck doing all that much grunt work. Just get the twist out and prepare a sufficient patch for the planer table and off you go. Where the hand planes shine is their ability to control the angle of the first surface far better than a jointer, allowing you to squeeze more use out of the board, or get a better angle to the figure.
Getting rid of the planer is a totally different kettle of fish. There is nothing available to the hand tool worker that will waste dry hardwood at that rate. You can use bandsaw, chain saw, axes, and adzes, but realistically what the planer does in terms of layout and stock removal is really important. Some of the "portable" planers have become too large to be portable, and about the size of smaller cast iron machines, but the smallest planers are very useful and about the size of a couple of lunchboxes. An electric hand plane at least would be useful.
I've owned 2 jointers and 5 planers over the years, and the planer is on my essential power tools list, the only other tool there is the bandsaw. I sold my cabinet table saw and a day never goes by when I don't realize how little I miss it. I wouldn't own a chopsaw, that's embarrassing. I really couldn't agree less, though with respect, with Pam's list of planer grudges:
- You would have to be a moron to loose your fingers to a planer. I give a pass to anyone putting in an 8 hour day, but the planer is one of the safest power tools around if a few minor details are attended to
- Size limits applied to every tool, and there are workarounds. It's a fair enough point but really an argument to buy big!
- I never change blades they last for years and then I just buy a new planer. OK that's how it worked out though there were other reasons for various up and downgrades. I've always had HSS blades and I don't find they need much sharpening. But if they do then you are getting a ton of work in return
- This is one case where boring is good, as far as safety and productivity is concerned, but on the other hand it comes down to the hobby/production issue. If you don't need to get the job done then why inflict the noise on yourself, if you do need to move ahead then you just have to suck it up.
- I don't worry about snipe this again is the productivity/hobby thing at play. Why is it no problem removing 1/2" of board thickness by hand but too much work removing a few thou, that's not logical. It drives you crazy in a production setting because you need to adjust your process to capture that time, but in a hand tool shop, we are gripping about a few thou!!
- It's not really difficult to adjust the knives. On my Inca they actually designed it right and it was a walk in the park. Sadly all the cheap eastern tools are designed from the Delta type dinosaur tools that are about model T ford sophistication. I used my magnetic tool rack to set my jointer knife, and it was so easy I swore I would make a mag setter, but I eventually got around to buying one when it was on sale. A lot of the portable planers use plug and play knives, which I find kinda offensive, and I won't buy them, but it's probably a good idea, and actually as a smith I could probably find something to do with the cast-off knives. I don't doubt if I get another portable it will have those knives.
About a year ago I was crying about the need to sell off a lot of tools in my shop (still a good idea), because I really could hardly move around in there, though it's about 42, by 14 with a second story. Anyway, this year I lost my boat storage and had to park a 26'x8.5' sailboat in my drive. This was starting to become a problem since I can get a summons from the city for that kind of thing. Guess what. I tidied up and now have the boat in my shop and more walk around room than before. I still have a lot of work to do, but it's amazing what one can do in a given space.
If you do get stuck without a planer, then invest in/make some serious hogging planes. They are certainly a lot of fun.