Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Sharpening woes and questions. [borders on long]

Posts

Sharpening woes and questions. [borders on long]

#1

Sharpening woes and questions. [borders on long]

Joe in a Cleveland suburb


>Hello.

My A2 Hock blade and chipbreaker for my trusty old #4 finally arrived. Took over a week via USPS 1st Class. Geesh.

I'm not doing very well trying to polish it and hone it. Here's what I did last night and I spent about 1-1/2 hours doing it. Using my 1000/6000 water stone I started with the 1000 side trying to polish the back (about 1/2� to 1� worth up from the bevel � not the entire back of course). Once I had consistent scratches I moved over to the 6000 grit side (I also used a nagura on the 6000 side). I kept the stone wet with a slurry and I believe it is flat (by using drywall mesh on glass). I also used a piece of scrap wood over the iron to keep a consistent amount of pressure on the iron.

I kept doing it trying to get it really polished. I kinda gave up when I didn't see it getting any better then turned my attention to honing the bevel using the same stone and a honing jig thingy. The angle the honing jig was set was honing about 1/8� of the bevel. Not the entire bevel.

The back does not have that mirror polished look. Neither does the bevel. It will shave hair off for what that's worth. I know I can do it (get the mirror polish) because I've seen it on my chisels and ordinary Stanley irons. I put the iron in the #4 and it's set for a very fine cut. I used it on a piece of scrap Walnut. It works ok but really doesn't seem any different than the original blade that was in it. I don't think this Hock blade is nearly as sharp as I should be able to get it though. Also, btw, I think this #4 is reasonably well tuned as well.

With this Hock blade, should I/can I expect a mirror polish with a 1000/6000 stone? Is the jump from 1000 to 6000 to extreme?

I have a bunch of adhesive backed sandpaper from when I used paper to sharpen. I have P2000, 3M 15mic, 3M 50mic, 3M 120mic, and 3M 30mic paper. I also have some sheets I bought at the same time I bought the other 3M paper that has no marking on it at all. I have no idea what grit it is now. One is a grayish green color and is extremely smooth (like smooth leather) and the other is a lighter slate gray color with very minimal grit. Any clue what this stuff is anybody? I wish I remember what the two un-marked papers grits are.

I bring up the paper because I was wondering if I should use that in combination with the stone. But I don't know where those micron grits fall in around the 1000/6000 stone. Any ideas?

Thanks as usual everyone for any advice.

Joe

I came up from the basement (my shop) last night and my wife was standing at the sink facing the faucet. I told here I can�t get this sharp enough. She said I�ve never been too sharp and no matter how hard I try will never be sharp. I think she thought I was pointing at my head and not the iron. She never turned away from the sink to look�

Re: Sharpening woes and questions. [borders on long]

#2

Re: Sharpening woes and questions. [borders on lon *LINK*

mikew


>Does it cut wood and leave a finish on the wood which is good for the purpose?

If so, stop and merely use the thing, sharpen when dull. It is fine.

If not, make sure to remove the scratches from a previous grit on both the front and back, but don't worry about a mirror finish.

If you cannot remove the scratches form the 1k going to the 6k or it is taking to long, use an intermediate grit. The link has a chart of grits between media.

Take care, Mike


Grit chart

Re: Sharpening woes and questions. [borders on long]

#3

speculation

bill tindall


>A2 is more abrasion resistant than your original blade. It may be that the jump between grit sizes is too large to get best edge refinement on your fine grit. We see this in the even more abrasion resistant steels like 3V. Sharpening schedules that work for cabon steel leave 3V dull.

You don't have 3M sheets fine enough. 15 micron is coarse for final honing; it is more a grinding grit size. I use 1 or 3 and others use even smaller for honeing.

The mirror appearance is no indication of sharpness. Differnet steels scratch different and ditto for different abrasives.

Re: Sharpening woes and questions. [borders on long]

#4

Re: Sharpening woes and questions. [borders on lon

woodburnbob


>I agree with you, Joe, it doesn't sound right. Try this: re-flatten the 6K surface (dry). Then use the stone dry, or at least without any slurry forming. Use very light pressure...nearly no pressure. Loose the wood stick here. Polish a minute or two. Then remove grit by polishing on a clean flat piece of newsprint. No pressure again.

Your wife sounds like a lippy peach who's always ready to play on words. Mine too.

Re: Sharpening woes and questions. [borders on long]

#5

Performance

jim reed @ tallahassee


>An original Stanley is high carbon and (except for chatter) should pull about the same shaving as the Hock on the first pass. Performance will degrade after that because it will start to dull immediately. The true value of the Hock is less chatter and longer sharp edge retention.

Re: Sharpening woes and questions. [borders on long]

#6

Understood - thank you.

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Re: Sharpening woes and questions. [borders on long]

#7

Thanks Bob - will try that and let you know.

Joe in a Cleveland suburb