Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Berg Chisels

Posts

Berg Chisels

#1

Berg Chisels

dave caudill


>I was at our big Biennial tool meet in Portland two weekends ago and there was a set of six Berg chisels for sale for $100. I have always heard that Berg chisels are about as good as they get. I of course always recommend buying old chisels and rehabbing them as opposed to buying new. I considered these chisels but they had one problem. Most of the handles were trashed. Split with eletrical tape on them and all, just a mess. So my question is would it be worth buying these Berg chisels and putting new handles on them everything else about them being okay? I'm sure I can get them a little cheaper than the asking price but wasn't sure how easy it would be to put handles on them since I think the Berg chisels are tanged. Anyone have any experience with these?

Dave

Re: Berg Chisels

#2

Re: Berg Chisels

Dan Clermont inBurnaby


>Hi Dave

I love Berg chisels. At $100 they are over priced.

Rehandling Berg Socket and Tang chisels can be done wtih no problem. The Tangs are like most Tang chisels and LV sells replacement Boxwood handles (I believe)

Most of mine are Socket chisels and they can also be rehandled but you need to pay close attention to the taper when making them

Good Luck

Dan CLermont

Re: Berg Chisels

#3

My 2 cents

Vlad


>I did an in depth study on chisels - which I'll post on my site in the next weeks - I hope I can say that....

... and the Bergs did VERY well. Especially in the toughness test where they blew the competition away. I did not test any other old chisels as the Bergs are my users (I wanted to see how they did) and were used as the reference standard. Newer chisels did better in edge retention.

Cheers

Vlad

Re: Berg Chisels

#5

Re: Berg Chisels

Dave Thompson


>Hi Dave, fwiw, Berg made tang and socket chisels. If the backs were flat, and there was good length, and they were socket type chisels, I would buy them. I enjoy putting my own personalized handles on. A new handle can really spiff up a nice old chisel. Being tang chisels would tip the balance for me. It's just a little more work than I want to do, but that's a personal call.

Other choices common with sockets are Withery and Swan. GreenLee and Pextos are pretty cheap (read as good value). I'm not sure how much functional value there is in having them all the same brand.

enjoy,

Dave

Re: Berg Chisels

#6

Re: Berg Chisels

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI


>I think paying more than $16 per chisel for chisels that need a new handle is ridiculously high. You can get a brand spanking new Lie Nielsen chisel for only $24 more, and you would probably spend at least an hour per chisel putting on new handles. For myself personally, I wouldn't pay more than $7 for a chisel that needed a new handle, no matter how good the brand name. I can often times pick up Witherbys for $1 if they need a handle or have a slight chip. I have noticed Bergs get high reviews by most people, and I have a really nice Berg mortice chisel if I remember right, but I still think the price is too high. -

Re: Berg Chisels

#7

A buck for a Witherby???

Dave Thompson


>I'll give you five for each one you send my way....

;-)

Re: Berg Chisels

#8

Re: Berg Chisels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)


>I'm sure I can get them a little cheaper than the asking price but wasn't sure how easy it would be to put handles on them since I think the Berg chisels are tanged. Anyone have any experience with these?

Hi Dave

I am not sure that I should be drumming up interest - and the price! - of old Berg chisels, but the fact is that they make superior paring chisels.

Many of the ones I own came with reasonably good handles which I have kept. Frankly I am not sold on the original handles and, because these chisels will never make collector status, I plan to re-handle them all at some stage.

Is this worth it? My opinion is that we are woodworkers, and working wood is no effort. It is a pleasure. And I look forward to designing a set that suits my hand.

In fact I also have a set that I re-handled for dovetailing (these started out as un-handled orphans - 1/8", 1/4", 3/8" and 1/2"). Did I say that these are superb chisels for dovetailing? They have very narrow sides and get inside angles easily. They are true paring chisels (unlike much on the market that are termed "paring" chisels).

Here are the re-handled Bergs (I have posted them a few times before, so avert your eyes if you are bored). The bevels are ground at 20 degrees, and they do a great job of holding an edge bearing in mind that they are used (pushed) predominantly in hardwood.



Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Berg Chisels

#9

If you don't count my time

Bill Houghton, foggy mornings in Sebastopol, CA


>I've paid $1 for a Witherby too (just one, I think), and 50 cents to $1 for multiple Buck (of the deer logo persuasion) chisels, one Winchester (5/8", a size I didn't have), three Pextos, and multiple socket-handle Stanleys. But this is over some years of haunting garage sales with likely rust.

If you count my time, they're probably $15 tools.

Re: Berg Chisels

#10

OK folks, you've demonstrated my ignorance...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.


>Can anyone give me a rough history of Berg Chisels? Never heard of those before...

TIA,

DC

Re: Berg Chisels

#11

Re: OK folks, you've demonstrated my ignorance...

Dan Clermont in Burnaby


>Berg Chisels were made in Eskilstuna Sweden up till around 1950. In Canada they used to be sold at Eatons (I believe)

The steel is high carbon and is known for taking a keen edge. Are they better then the Sorby's, PS and W's and other chisels? I don't know but I sure like mine.


img

Re: Berg Chisels

#12

A short overview of A.E.Berg

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)


>Erik Anton Berg was a blademaker in Eskiltuna, Sweden, from about 1850 - 1959. Eskilstuna is located about 100km west of Stockholm.

Eskilstuna was home to a large number of blademakers, much like Sheffield in the UK.

A.E. Berg was well known for not only chisels but also planes (and their blades), plus a variety of handtools, such as a pliers, etc. The emblem on the blades is a shark.

In the recent past A.E. Berg were bought out by Bahco, who were in turn bought by Sandvik. Unfortunately, the quality of the blades produced by the latter owners was not maintained.

Basically, as far as I am aware, there are four ranges of Berg chisels available (most typically through eBay): wooden handles with either tangs or sockets, red plastic handled tangs, and socketed wooden handles re-badged for the Canadian market (Badger? or something). It is very likely that a number of other brands are really re-badged Bergs.

Here in Oz the one�s that seem most common are the tanged version. These are the ones which I chose to collect towards a set. This runs nearly complete from 1/8� � 2�. I think that the later generation of Berg chisels were marked in metric sizes. Here are a few Berg chisels (top) alongside a few of my Witherbys (bottom row).



The Witherbys have a harder steel than the Bergs. However, the Bergs have a more pronounced taper at the sides and are overall thinner chisels, so better suited to paring dovetails.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Berg Chisels

#13

Re: OK folks, you've demonstrated my ignorance...

Mark Nowicki


>"In Canada they used to be sold at Eatons (I believe)"

That might explain why they are easy to find at garage sales on the West Island part of Montreal. This used to be Viking territory.

Regards

Mark Nowicki

Re: Berg Chisels

#14

Re: Berg Chisels

Todd Hughes


>This might would be a Good [but not great] Retail price for them if the handles were fine but if they have bad handles it is I would consider a very high price. Lack of handles really affects a chisel prices very much downward and this is esp. true with a chisel like a Berg which has a very distinctive handle which you can not duplicate. Pick up a Witherby or a Stanley 750 with bad wood and isn't to much trouble to find the "correct" handle but you ain't going to be finding many Berg type handles to easy. Sure you can make your own handles but this shouldn't affect the price you pay for somthing.

Even in the old tool hell I live in it is pretty easy to find nice high quality chisels with good handles for $10 or so, ones with no handles go for even less of course.Around here most seem to live in the 50 cent and $1.00 junk boxes ......Todd

Re: Berg Chisels

#15

money to be made....

Dave Thompson


>I'm not clear whether these are argument for what the going rate of an unhandled Witherby is, or are they just meant as special case gloats that required significant rust hunting. In my mind, the going rate for an unmushroomed, unhandled Witherby with minimal/no pitting on the back is at least $10. If it's a dollar in your area, then I suspect someone has an opportunity to make a bundle buying them up and reselling to those of us in old tool hell.

Re: Berg Chisels

#16

Beaver!

Brad in Ottawa


>The pesky critter is a Beaver not a Badger! The beaver is one of Canada's National Symbols.

Re: Berg Chisels

#17

Thanks guys!

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

Re: Berg Chisels

#18

What's the diff between toughness

Chuck Nickerson


>and edge retention? On first thought, they seem the same to me.

Re: Berg Chisels

#19

dammit, Dan

Bruce, a MN Galoot


>I swear you post this picture every time you think I need to get my blood pressure up!

This is pure tool porn to me.

Bruce, Bergless in MN

Re: Berg Chisels

#20

Thanks for clearing that up, Derek

Bruce, a MN Galoot


>A friend of mine has a set of Sandvik chisels, and I was wondering whether the blade quality was the same as Bergs. Now I know. Thanks. I won't go looking for any.

Bruce

Re: Berg Chisels

#21

My 2 cents - Part Deux

Vlad


>I describe toughness as the ability of the steel to resist fracture when it impacts a test media and quantified. For example, pounding a mortise chisel into maple.

Edge retention is where the ability of the steel to retain a sharp edge is tested against a media and quantified. For example, paring end grain.

Microscopically I suppose it would be the same thing (macro vs micro) except I find that you need to determine both, as chisels are used in various woodworking applications - paring and mortising.

Vlad is logging out.

Re: Berg Chisels

#22

Re: Berg Chisels

dave caudill


>You know Todd I typically would not pay this and of course didn't but wondered if I missed an opportunity. Berg chisels come up pretty irregularly and seem to be highly sought after. I have many sets of other chisels including Witherby(my personal favorite), Swans, P.S.& W., Lie-Nielsen, Stanley Everlasts( both wood handle and composite), and a large set of Japanese chisels I put together over time as well. Oh and my latest purchase a set of paring chisels from Dave Jeske of Blue Spruce variety. I'm not hurting for chisels and in fact just enjoy trying new chisels to see how they fit into the overall fray when it comes to chisel quality and how they feel to use. I would like to get a set of Bergs to go with the others I have but am not sure I want to pay this much. I can easily rehandle them I'm sure but was wondering what experience others have had with them and whether or not that price was too out of hand.

By the way thanks for all of the replies.

Dave

Re: Berg Chisels

#23

I cry foul!

Dave Thompson


>What's with this? You already have all of the premium contemporary and old chisels??? Well then ofcourse you should pass on the Bergs!

Sheesh, you have the same problem I do with planes. ;-)

By the way, there's this set of six Millers Falls planes... The knobs could use some rework, but I'm wondering if I should buy them or not.... ;-)

Re: Berg Chisels

#24

Re: dammit, Dan

Dan Clermont in Burnaby


>Bruce,

I still have you in mind whenever I hit local garage sales looking for Berg's

Dan Clermont

Re: Berg Chisels

#25

I appreciate that, Dan,

Bruce, a MN Galoot


>my city has its annual city-wide garage sale this weekend, and I'll bet there's not so much as one Berg chisel, other than mine, in this whole town of 13,000.

Bruce