Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Dilemmas, Demons, and Design

Posts

Dilemmas, Demons, and Design

#1

Dilemmas, Demons, and Design

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native now in Jax Fl.


>Well after managing to somehow completely waste away 3 out of the 4 days of my long weekend I finally got around to starting making my new workbench today, and sure enough, and as usual, I realized a few difficulties that I hadn't forseen. The new bench will be six inches lower than my current bench and I had intended to put it to the right side of my current bench. This I now realize is not going to work out as I forsee some interference on the end where the two benches would meet. Pretty much the same problem if I put it to the left of my current bench.

Than I realized that with the much shorter legs most of the drawers that I had built to put under it will not be able to be used.

So know it comes to solution time, what to do what to do, hmmmmmmmmmmmm. I've come up with two ideas: 1) lower the cutrrent bench to the height of the new bench and have about a 12' bench, or put the new bench on flip up/down wheels so it can be rolled out to clear the current bench. I'm leaning towards #1.

Ahhhhhhhhhhhhh the joys of designing by the set of the pants eh? Been doing it the entire time I've been WWing, and always manage to come out on top.

Came up with another Grand Idea---entirely by accident I musr confess. came up with what I call "Plane Towers". In essence, they are boxes that will hold an entire set of bench planes. The box can be as wide or as narrow as you desire, but I am leaning towards them to be wide enough to hold a #6, 7, and 8 on the bottem tier, than put in whatever planes will fit on the second tier, say a #5, 5.25 and 5.5, than on the third tier a #3, 4, 4.5. Between each plane will be a thin slat that would run from top to bottom, thus creating a "cubby" for each plane. I can't decide if the towers will be tapered from top to bottom to accomadate the shorter planes or not. I think they'll not only be a great storage system, but a great transport case when I move. Oh yes, it's not a matter of IF I move as it is WHEN I move.

I can forsee having several of these towers sitting on my bench top, spaced apart with shelving in between them. We'll see bum-by eh.

Todd O.

Re: Dilemmas, Demons, and Design

#2

Re: Dilemmas, Demons, and Design

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX


>Why not use the plane boxes to bridge the different bench levels?

Pam

Re: Dilemmas, Demons, and Design

#3

Or

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX


>why not cantilever an extension to the current bench to sit above the new bench?

Pam

Re: Dilemmas, Demons, and Design

#4

What I'm seeing

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native now in Jax Fl.


>Pam,

Thanks for the suggestions, but I'm not 100% sure you're seeing the problem correctly---or perhaps I'm not, which is of no matter as what I'm going to do is build the new bench than solve any problems from there.

I plane from right to left, and like to clamp my wood on the left end of my bench, so if I put the new bench to the right of the old one, than I'd be bumping into the current bench. Putting the new bench to the left of the current bench might be the best option unless of coarse I want to plane something that is longer than the new bench. At present time I'm not concerned about this, I just found it to be curious that I didn't forsee this in my minds eye while thinking up the new bench. Just when you think you've got it all worked out a Demon pops up with a new Delimma.

T.O.

Re: Dilemmas, Demons, and Design

#5

My 2 cents.

Vlad


>You've really done it this time Critter!

Todd, can you put wheels on the new bench and run it up a 6" incline/stage (for the lack of a better term) to mate with the old bench? I'd certainly want the drawers to work especially after making them. Or am I confused.....as usual...

I'm sure you'll do a fine job with whatever you do.

Vlad

Re: Dilemmas, Demons, and Design

#6

Re: What I'm seeing

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX


>I thought the obvious problem would be the different heights; but I also didn't know that you wanted to plane across the benches, which would be impossible however you arranged them, due to the height differences.

Pam

Re: Dilemmas, Demons, and Design

#7

Re: What I'm seeing

Ernie Miller


>Why do you need two benches? make the new one and religate the old one to the power tool shop or the sharpening shop or the tool rehab shop. We all know you have more than one shop so just seperat the benches and the problem is gone. If the drawers are to deep to fit the new bench cut them shorter. You amaze me some time no wonder they ran you out of Maine I'm suprised Florida let you in the state. but in there defense they probably thought you were just visiting at the time. When do we get some pictures that may help us understand you problem.

Re: Dilemmas, Demons, and Design

#8

Re: What I'm seeing

Thom D


>Is it your body or your workpiece catching on the other bench?

Re: Dilemmas, Demons, and Design

#9

I dig the flippy wheel idea !

Steve Mackay

Re: Dilemmas, Demons, and Design

#10

I'd seperate them.

Raymond in Trenton, NJ


>Todd-O,

I probably don't understand the full situation, but why do the two benches have to be *right next* to one another? Just giving a bit of space between them (on either side) will give you the clearance for approach or launch. I'd opt for the higher bench on the 'launch' side of the stroke as I do very little planing after the vice. Can you afford the space to set them apart by 18" or so?

Also, put as many drawers under the new bench that will fit. The others can be used somewhere else. We all know you won't waste them. You can use them as Ernie suggests out back in the sharpening shop (unless your smithy is done by then).

If you do end up building pyramidal towers please remember, these structures have to be critically aligned with true north and other such things.

Raymond

Re: Dilemmas, Demons, and Design

#11

Re: I'd seperate them.

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native Now in FL. :~(


>Ahhhhhhhhhhhh Ray, I am getting quite space challenged these days, and I want a large bench. I got the basic frame pieces cut and temporily assembled using clamps. I see I'm gonna have to post pics of this otherwise Ernie will never get any sleep trying to fiqure this out.

Actually, with the new bench framed up I got to thinking that perhaps I could in fact completely do away with the current bench, but than again it does provide a decent amount of storage. Demons, Demons, Demons.

T.O.

Re: Dilemmas, Demons, and Design

#12

Here's another idea

Raymond in Trenton, NJ


>Todd-O,

Having just visited you and your shop I don't know why I didn't think of this sooner. Leave your existing bench where it is against the wall. Put you new bench in that big empty space between all four walls. Make it freestanding. You'll probably realize a lot more flexibility not only with the bench, but your shop as well.

Raymond

who's searching for more coffee

Re: Dilemmas, Demons, and Design

#13

Why

Ron in Kokomo


>Why would you give up bench top space for tool storage?

Why not keep the planes out of the way till needed?

Re: Dilemmas, Demons, and Design

#14

Re: Why

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native Now in FL. :~(


>Ron,

The biggest reason for "giving up benchtop space" for tool storage would simply be for convience. I hate to have to open a drawer to get out another plane especially when I have something edge clamped to the front of the bench. It never fails that either the clamps or the board itself has to be moved. Drives me mad.

Ray,

I hear ya brother, Lima-Charley, unfortunately as you know, my shop does double as the garage and I like to keep it open enough to at least get the wifes Blazer into in case of destructive weather. How about a giant sized Murphy Bench like a Murphy Bed eh?

One day my dear friend Ray, one day, I will have a dedicated WWing shop. I am getting some "vibes" from the Mrs. lately that she isn't so keen about being here in Hell anymore. She works for Walgreens drug store as head photo tech in her store and she is tired of dealing with most of the customers. She asks me all the time, "How can these people be so stupid and still survive". Now she is starting to see one of the reasons I didn't want to retire here.

I snapped a picture of the basic frame work of my new bench in the spot I had intened for it to go. I will post the picture when I get home tonight. Gotta say that once I put it in place I realized just how big it is and said to myself "Oh, this is goooooooooooooooood!!

T.O.

Re: Dilemmas, Demons, and Design

#15

Alignment with true north

Bill Houghton, foggy mornings in Sebastopol, CA


>but only the plane in the very center of the pyramid would stay sharp.

Yes, another silly 1960's reference.