Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

New respect for Sweatheart blades

Posts

New respect for Sweatheart blades

#1

New respect for Sweatheart blades

arw01


>Out of stuborness, and fear, I completely reshaped the bevel on a No 6 that will become only a shooting board plane to a shallower angle.

I started with a diasharp course and made it about halfway down the bevel in several HOURS of work over a couple of weeks.

Then I went to 120 grit drywall screen, my favorite for gross work, whic h took another few thousand strokes to get me close to the edge.

Then I moved to 120 Norton 3 times until I got a wire edge across the whole blade. From there a quick succession to 180 drywall screen.

Back to my diamond stone, which took another few hundred strokes to bring the polish out to the edge, and a few passes on the back of the iron.

THEN the real sharpening began, 1000 shapton in a few hundred strokes, followed by a couple hundred on a 5000.

A sweat edge started to show, the bevel polished to pore counting capabilties after a couple hundred strokes with the Shapton 8000.

Ofcourse a few arm hairs were sacraficed an offering to the sharpening gods!

How does it work on wood? I don't know! Gotta find that Hock Chip Breaker I bought yesterday, hmm where did I put that bag...

Alan

Re: New respect for Sweatheart blades

#3

Re: New respect for Sweatheart blades

Christopher Schwarz


>Alan,

Honest here, are you serious about a couple hundred strokes on something? Or are you prone to Southern hyperbole (as I am)?

I'd give up woodworking if it were that time-consuming to get an edge. I think a grinder is in order. Even a hand-crank, if you're cranky about it. Honestly, an electric grinder and a band saw are the Neanderthal's best anachronistic friends.

cms

Re: New respect for Sweatheart blades

#4

Re: New respect for Sweatheart blades

arw01


>I meant to put that I had fear of overheating the edge on my 3250RPM grinder with the white wheel when making the bevel longer. Most of the time spent making strokes was while watching movies, tivo, and turning videos.

A veritas MkII jig makes it possible to use just one hand to work the blade against the stone.

Alan

Re: New respect for Sweatheart blades

#5

Norton 3X!

Christopher Schwarz


>Alan,

You might want to try the Norton 3X blue wheels that Joel sells. The #60 is the cat's meow. It keeps the edge really cool and really removes the steel fast. And it is reasonably priced.

Chris

Re: New respect for Sweatheart blades

#6

What I do in 2 minutes

Jim Reed @ Tallahassee


>Take a nasty blade with nicks, grind it flat on white wheel with frequent quinching (15 sec), set angle bevel and grind the first 1/16" with frequent quenching (20 sec), flat the first 1/8" of the back on #220 paper (30 sec), draw a wire edge on the bevel (20 sec), lap off the wire using 400 paper (10 sec). Sharpening should be quick; woodworking should linger. Good luck, hope you can pick up the speed.

Re: New respect for Sweatheart blades

#7

Dumb question...

Joe in a Cleveland suburb


>Um. What's a Sweatheart blade?

Joe

Re: New respect for Sweatheart blades

#8

Chris,

HC Sakman - Victoria, BC-CDN


>You mean the cubic zirconium paper?

Chico...

Re: New respect for Sweatheart blades

#9

Re: Chris,  *LINK*

david.marcus.brown



3x wheels

Re: New respect for Sweatheart blades

#10

SWEETheart he means

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA


>In the early years of the last century - someone else will know the exact era - Stanley used a logo that has "SW" and a heart shape, after a Mr. Hart who was a respected executive there. These are considered by many to be when Stanley produced some of its best tools.

Re: New respect for Sweatheart blades

#11

Re: Dumb question...

arw01


>After that many hours by hand, I dubbed it sweatheart. But Bill is correct on it's proper name!

Re: New respect for Sweatheart blades

#12

Re: New respect for Sweatheart blades

William Duffield, on the Cohansey


>You certainly do win the Stubornness prize.

I'm not sure I understand why you would feel the need to decrease the bevel angle on a bevel-down bench plane blade, unless somehow your bevel angle was so high that your clearance angle was less than about 7�. If you were in need of shooting end grain with a bevel up plane blade that had been adapted for smoothing, I would understand.

Even so, it seems that you could do most of the rough material removal using a white or pink wheel (or even using one of the even cooler blue Norton wheels, in even less time), at a couple of degrees less than your target bevel angle, being careful to stay away from the cutting edge, where heat buildup becomes a major issue, and then use a stone, by hand, to refine the edge with a microbevel.

An alternative to the wheel, if you don't mind sacrificing a few electrons to the cause, is a belt sander, but it is a bit trickier with one of these to get the hollow grind that minimizes the time spent by hand on the stone to refine the edge.

Re: New respect for Sweatheart blades

#13

Misery loves company...

Dave Thompson


>I did something like this once, but it was with a 2" chisel. I believe I bought a wet grinder the following week.... My vague recollection was that there was over 8 hours of work into it spread over many days. Unlike raising, lowering the bevel angle is an unbelievable deceptive killer. The closer the bevel gets, the longer it takes. You think you're almost there, and since you've gone this far, might as well go a little further.... It starts to make one wonder how much one values their time.

Additionally, it'll likely lead to a much earlier demise of your honing jig... at least that's what happened to my first Veritas jig.

enjoy,

Dave

Re: New respect for Sweatheart blades

#14

No-discourse on Norton wheels

bill tindall


>Norton developed a new abrasive particle( seeded sol gel). Little pieces of the abrasive particle break off almost continuously exposing new cutting edges. Dull particles rub and heat the tool, sharp particles mill and take heat away with the chip. The alternaive is the use a "soft" wheel and have the whole dull particle break away, (eg LV white wheel). Either approach results in cooler grinding but the Norton particle results in a longer lasting wheel because it sheds its abrasive particles slower.

The industrial version of this abrasive is called Norton 5G and it is costly(to make and buy) unless one is doing a lot of grinding, eg a tool maker. This is the wheel to own if you are making tool steel tools. Norton dveloped a cheaper consumer version that has 30% of the improved particle and 70% white aluminium oxide like white wheels. This wheel is called 3X. I tried one and it works well. I have not tried the LV wheel but its specifications suggest it is a very cool running wheel too. With care one should not get burning with either wheel. I grind plane irons at 3600 rpm with out burning routinely. A light touch and touch and go grinding is necessary.

see Grinding in WC articles

Re: New respect for Sweatheart blades

#15

Re: And a thickness planer....

Paul Kierstead

Re: New respect for Sweatheart blades

#16

OK, I'm confused....

Gerry D.


>Disclaimer: I'm one of those morons whose garage/shop is filled with water-stones, lapping plates/grits, oil stones, plate glass/granite plates and paper, and still hasn't mastered the technique of obtaining a polished back on a plane blade or wide chisel.. I also suffer from some sort of delusional thinking that it's kind of cool to rehab the original blade that came with the plane. I have spent countless hours attempting to flatten the backs of old irons and chisels with extremely limited success.

I do use a jig for the bevels, either the generic grey, Veritas I, or Veritas II. I don't hollow grind, because I know I will @#$% it up.

To the point, I actually look forward to doing the bevel on the blade. Compared to the hours spent on the back, the bevel seems to be a breeze. I don't think I've ever had the rough bevel take more than a 1/2 hour on either SC on glass or a DMT. What am I missing?

Gerry

Re: New respect for Sweatheart blades

#17

back flatening

bill tindall


>I have become convinced that it is impossible to flatten a back unless the abrasive format is flat and stays flat. This requirement rules out sandpaper. I don't know about water stones. But the first time I ever got a back really flat was with diamond on a surface ground cast iron plate. I presume a fixed diamond plate would work as well. I can see the attraction of the "ruler trick", (which I don't use) given the difficulty.

Re: New respect for Sweatheart blades

#18

How flat is flat enough?

jim reed @ tallahassee


>RE:*a flat back is impossible with sandpaper*...I guess it depends on what you think is a good margin of error for normal woodworking. I use sandpaper on a marble floor tile and get good results. Since the true cutting edge is less than 1/64" wide, I would suggest that any flatness beyond that point is wasted effort. Why do you think extreme flatness is required? Am I missing something?

Re: New respect for Sweatheart blades

#19

Re: How flat is flat enough?

Gerry D.


>My understanding, as a novice, was that the first 1/2" or so of the back was to be flattened and polished. My understanding was that this was a one time chore, and that if the blade was treated properly, would never have to be repeated.

If I remember correctly, D. Charlesworth stated the old-timers felt that one should be able to count their nose hairs in the reflection off the back. I suppose one could try this on 1/64" band, but my eyes aren't that good.

This all presupposes that you're not using the "ruler trick", which I have now resorted to using on almost all of my bench planes.

Gerry

Re: New respect for Sweatheart blades

#20

Re: back flatening

Warren in Lancaster, PA


>I think it is wrong to suggest that diamond surfaces ,white wheels , et cetera are necessary for preparing or maintaining edges. With care these chores can be done with oilstones or waterstones alone. They were done successfully this way long before electric grinders or surface ground plates were available.

For a beginner who is buying a set of tools, shaping and flattening chores may seem endless, but unless one is a collector or a dealer these chores become rare as time goes on. I sharpen tools daily, but I would have trouble remembering the last time I had to work on a "nasty edge with nicks" or the last time I flattened the back of an iron that was never trued up before.

Re: New respect for Sweatheart blades

#21

But...

Christopher Schwarz


>I think that foot-powered grindstones were widely available. Hand-cranked grinders are pretty common on the secondary market in the Midwest. I find them all the time at the fleas.

Also, a usable (if not perfect) new and electric grinder can be bought for less than a medium-grit waterstone (I see grinders at Big Lots for $35 to $40!).

Plus grinders have more uses than just for hand tools. Lathe tools, shaping hardware, shortening screws and so forth.

Love my grinder.

Chris

Re: New respect for Sweatheart blades

#22

abrading iron

bill tindall


>I recently had at all my plane irons in one sitting. It is so easy to grab a different plane rather than stop and sharpen. Anyway, they were all dull and I was procratinating a tedious fitting task. I sharpened a traditional carbon steel iron, an A2 and a 3V. WOW, the carbon steel cut easy (by comparison). I might imagine sharpening carbon steel, especially a thin one, on an oil stone. I can not imagine being very productive with an oil stone on a thick A2. They are so slow I don't even shapren a knife on them anymore.

I agree on the back issue. I go for about an inch and hope I never have to do that again. I put it in the same category as trimming sheep feet, something I don't look forward to.

Re: New respect for Sweatheart blades

#23

Re: New respect for Sweatheart blades

Tom Price


>Well, I have a 1/2 speed electric grinder and all that but I find that I use my hand-cranked grinder with 8" wheel and Veritas toolrest almost all the time. I can crank the grinder fast enough to burn steel, if I want to, and can go real slow as well. This is an older picture, I have a better wheel on it now.

Goes along with my peculiar interest in trying to stick to hand processes in my shop.

That's a James Swan chisel in the toolrest, I ground it to about a 17 degree bevel. Great (non-dovetail) paring chisel. Tough steel.

- Tom


img

Re: New respect for Sweatheart blades

#24

grinding wheel

Warren in Lancaster, PA


>I use my grinding wheel for hatchets, hoes, shears and the like. For plane irons I start with 800 grit and I'm on the next stone in 30 - 40 seconds. At 90 seconds, I've gone through four stones and a strop. I cannot see that a wheel would increase efficiency or precision.

Bill. I've trimmed more sheep hooves than I've flattened plane irons. Each sheep has four double hooves and needs to be trimmed once or twice a year. I have plane irons and chisels I haven't flattened except as part of routine sharpening for 20 or 30 years.

Re: New respect for Sweatheart blades

#25

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Ideal setup

Jim in Burlington On


>I really like the old meets the new all by hand setup. Great pic.