Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Shapton vs. Norton Water Stones

Posts

Shapton vs. Norton Water Stones

#1

Shapton vs. Norton Water Stones

John Clifford in Chicago


>Anybody who has used both care to tell which seemed to get their tools sharper? I have Norton's but am considering getting the Shapton 8000 grit stone for my final honing. I'm not completely satified with the edge I'm getting from my Norton 8000 grit and I recall reading somewhere that the Shapton produces a finer edge. Any thoughts? Thanks in advance, John.

Re: Shapton vs. Norton Water Stones

#2

Re: Shapton vs. Norton Water Stones

Thom D


>Thee are a lot of caviats realtive to the tools you have and the results you get. But since there are shapton stones that are much finer than the Norton it should well be true. One guy I respect prefered the Takenoke (sp) stone to the norton. The best norton is probably the 4000. I think he is now using the Shaptons.

On the other hand, I have used the shapton stones and wasn't bowled over, at the end of the day they were just stones. Maybe if I use up the king, bester, takenoke, Norton, I already have I may get some shapton. So far I'm loosing that race.

The Shaptons are harder and they promote SC flatening. So I think if your very beginer they are probably easier to get up to speed on. But obviously you already have stones. A lot of experienced guys use them also. And Japanese tool snobs turn their noses up at all synthetic stones. There isn't any real winning. The thing that makes the shaptons special is they are different. All the other stones seem pretty much the same. They may cut faster wear faster or sharpen finer but they all seem like the same kind of thing. Shaptons are different, mainly hard and a little glazed feeling. But not that I could see any particularly better.

I get pretty excited about new coarse stones. They are cheap to play with and they really make a difference if you find a stone that is much faster cutting.

On the Things That Make You Go Hmm front, Hirade had a lot of natural stones also. Don't know what to make of that.

Re: Shapton vs. Norton Water Stones

#3

Re: Shapton vs. Norton Water Stones

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI


>A very nice natural stone is an object of great beauty. Whether anything can actually put a better edge on an iron than the Norton 8000 grit stone I guess will be revealed at the planing contest. If I get beaten I will find out what stones the guy/gal is using ;)

Re: Shapton vs. Norton Water Stones

#4

Re: Shapton vs. Norton Water Stones

Todd Stock


>IMO -

8000 Norton and equivalent Shapton stones provide an edge that is good for sub-.0007 shavings and a finish-ready surface from most woods. What you are buying with a finer stone is the potential for a slight increase in edge life and perhaps a marginally smoother surface should you choose not to finish the wood. Once a finish is applied - particularly a film-forming finish - the differences are moot.

Most woodworkers do not achieve edges nearly as sharp or as durable as their gear should allow, which suggests that more time be spent learning to sharpen and less debating the merits of stones that provide meaningful performance increases for some tiny fraction of their users. This is not to say your skills and desired surface quality do not merit these finer stones; however, for most folks it won't make a difference in anything other than their wallet.

Re: Shapton vs. Norton Water Stones

#5

Re: Shapton vs. Norton Water Stones

Thom D


>Planing contest is a contest. For instance a planing contestant wouldn't care if their stone was 10% slower sharpening than another stone as long as they won the contest.

I'm with you, I have yet to see anything beat my 8000 king as far as edge sharpness, yet there are legions of guys who just despise those stones and have the background to back it up... Probably they are all just shining us on.

Re: Shapton vs. Norton Water Stones

#6

Re: Shapton vs. Norton Water Stones

Thom D


>Completely agree. I've had .0004 shavings in pine off of King 8000.

Each finer stone takes longer to polish out, though I realize we are talking about the "same" stone here. I think there is a reason why the standard stones end at 8000, and most people spend about 1-5% of the required time on them. (comparing time to establish grit and remove burr to the amount of time one could spend)

Re: Shapton vs. Norton Water Stones

#7

Pssst...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.


>If you want to go beyond the Norton 8000 (and probably others too), try the LV 0.5 micron paper. You'll feel the difference...

DC

Re: Shapton vs. Norton Water Stones

#8

Re: Shapton vs. Norton Water Stones

Ron


>I have a couple of King and a couple of Norton waterstones. I switched to Shapton a year or so ago. First, they all work. I have used oil stones and they also work but I prefer waterstones. One of the big pains with waterstones(most of them) is keeping them soaked and ready for use. The Shapton can be kept dry and watered just befor using them. I can throw them in my tool bag and take them with me. They stay flat a very long time. They are expensive but I understand they have a smaller less expensive version available.

I feel they are worth the money but there is nothing wrong with King or Norton and in the right hands they will all probably produce the same result in the same range of stones.