Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Collings guitars *LINK*

Posts

Re: Collings guitars *LINK*

#26

Re: Some good books

Thom D


>The one bad thing about archtops is the wood is really expensive. Benedetto made a good instrument out of constrution grade materials. Looked interestign also. You could probably find a nice medium in temple/workshop offcuts, not knotty, but nice.

Save yourself a lot of time using a guttering adze etc... etc... to blow out the top and back. It' really sad to see people beavering away at those things with the smallest sloan violin plane.

By the way. Those small plane blades Japan woodworker sells make a nice violin sized plane.

On archtops/violins, the materials are pretty contrasty, and they normally get a finish coat with a little dye in it to unify the look.

Re: Collings guitars *LINK*

#27

Re: Some good books *LINK*

Todd Stock


>The Selmer and Selmer-Maccaferris were ladder braced flattops - here's a link to Stew-Mac's plans for them. In common with archtops, they use a tailpiece to hold the strings and a floating bridge, but Cumpiano would be the place to start for basic flattop steel string construction.

Might go to MIMF for more info - the library there is pretty extensive and can be used to fill in the info holes and update Cumpiano, etc. for developments like radiused dishes for back and top construction, tenoned neck construction, etc. Cumpiano also had a lot of updated material on his website, including the improved neck design that many folks now use instead of dovetails or his earlier pinned tenon.


Selmer & Selmer-Maccaferri Plans

Re: Collings guitars *LINK*

#28

Bridge glue

Paul M. in San Diego


>Hi Thom,

String tension on a classical is about 100 pounds, and on a steel about 200. The steel has some anchoring structure so the weight bears less on the bridge. Anyway. The glue used is real important, because while many glues are strong, creep resistance is a little rarer. A standard is basic titebond glue. LMII luthiers white glue is good, and hide glue is aother option. Then there are various exotics.

Many years back, my classical exploded in a hideous noise. The glue kept it's hold to the surface layers of the spruce top. The spruce itself lost integrity and came apart. I heard the noise down the hall and then saw my pathetic guitar had released it's tension when I looked for the source of the noise. Luckily it was just the surface layer of the spruce, and there wasn't any gaping hole where the bridge should have been.

I epoxied that bugger down. It hasn't budged since. ;-) Probably not the best glue to use for that purpose, but it was only a $35 unnamed guitar in the first place. It still sounds just like it did before (which isn't saying much) so no harm done.

Re: Collings guitars *LINK*

#29

Selmer plans

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX


>Thanks, Todd, love that StewMac site. It appears, based on album covers, that he did play one of these, or something close; but he also played an f-hole archtop, see the above post.

Pam

Re: Collings guitars *LINK*

#30

Re: Some good books *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX


>Guttering adze I've got, also a set of small Japanese planes, but from Dieter rather than JWW, that set of nine at the bottom of the page below, they work great. But in defining that link I notice that he's also got micro and mini sets now (top of the page below) which look really cool. Maybe when the dollar gains strength. :) Right, looks like it will be a while. Also, in my seeming quest to corner the market in Japanese blades (meaning conspicuous consumption), I've bought several small blades and one big 6" wide one to cut down; but every time I think about cutting that 6" one I think of a 100 other uses for it, end up setting it aside again.

The miser in me hates all the wasted woood in archtops. I keep thinking there should be a way to steam and/or laminate them instead, then realize that that would probably muck up movement/sound, then I go back to sleep. :)

Pam


Dieter's small Japanese planes

Re: Collings guitars *LINK*

#31

Laminated archtops

wilbur


>There are many laminated archtops out there, although they almost universally have a pickup(s) and are primarily designed to be amplified. (Although these days the vast majority of jazz guitar players are amplified as well.) And just in case you think it's just crap guitars that fit into this category, the Gibson ES-135, ES-137, ES-175, and ES-335 all are laminated maple guitars. Granted, unamplified they will not sound as good as an archtop with a solid spruce top (and some of that is due to the fact that the body cavity of these guitars are not as large as, say, a 1930's Super 400), but they are great sounding guitars plugged in.

Re: Collings guitars *LINK*

#32

Re: Selmer plans

Todd Stock


>I was referring to Thom's comment on the Selmer - should have appended his note.

I've seen pics of Django playing everything from classicals to Stella 12 strings; however, the Selmers are what are most strongly associated with his style during the Hot Club years - most wartime group shots highlight the Selmers. 'Djangology' and a few other covers feature archtops, but I'm not certain if this was not the case of broader post-war appeal of archtops over an instrument associated with a narrower ethnic jazz style. Could be he just played the Selmers to piss off the Nazis.

Stew Mac also carries Benedetto's book and tapes, as well as scaled drawings.

Re: Collings guitars *LINK*

#33

Re: Laminated archtops

Todd Stock


>Martin/American Archtop are building laminated top archies, and Charley Fox is selling $8000 Ergos with tops made of two layers of 1/32" spruce laminated to Nomex honeycomb. After Taylor's packing crate guitars and Benedetto's lumberyard archtop, most folks get it that luthiers - not the tonewood - make the difference.

Re: Collings guitars *LINK*

#34

Re: Laminated archtops

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX


>Thanks, Wilbur and Todd, you've expanded my horizons, very interesting.

Pam

Re: Collings guitars *LINK*

#35

Django's guitars

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX


>Based on album covers, he played a lot of guitars, as one would expect; but of those, he did play f-hole archtops.

Pam


img

Re: Collings guitars *LINK*

#36

Re: Django's guitars

Todd Stock


>Yup...during the post-war years, some of the publicity shots show the archtops; however, Django = Selmer for many folks, so you might have to build both! The first Selmers were available in 1932, so early shots show a wide range of instruments, while solo pictures later in his career show the more popular, less ethnic American-made archtops (a uniquely American development of the Spanish guitar). The shot is a public domain image of Django w/ a trapeze tailpiece, round soundhole flat-top...he def got around.

Django played a non-resonator D hole Selmer-Maccaferri through the early years of the Quintet. The classic small oval Selmers began showing up in 1934, and many later Hot Club pics show these (there were several) guitars. Both types are very popular with fans of Django-style 'gypsy jazz'.

The Selmers were built with laminated backs and sides to improve resistance to cracks, and many players attributed the instrument's projection to that construction. Django appeared to have passed on keeping the funky resonator installed, if shots of the D hole instruments are any indication.

Michael Dregni's 2004 biography, 'Django', has some discussion of his relationship with various instrument builders, as well as Rienhardt's various battles with personal tragedy, such as loss of full use of his ring finger and pinky on his left hand due to a burn sustained as a teen - he reinvented his playing to compensate, doing all fingering for solos with index and middle fingers! I have fully functional fingers, and I don't think I could play two notes as sweetly as Reinhardt. Good read.


img

Re: Collings guitars *LINK*

#37

Re: Django's guitars

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX


>Great bio reference, I hadn't heard of it. I'll get it at the library this weekend.

Django = Selmer for many folks, so you might have to build both!

Yeah, sure. :) You know, I've been listening to Django and Stephane for about 40 years now, even managed to see Grappeli perform in Chicago a couple of decades ago. Great stuff, but being an autodidact has it's shortcomings. It's a real education just reading all the stuff I don't know about guitars.

Pam