Tool Collecting
Dave Thompson
>Interesting comparison of hobbies.... I've used the sailing argument before applied to my whole interest in wood working. Enjoyment being the same, it's not a dollar for dollar. With golfing, the money is gone. With wood working, you get furniture back, and 20 years later, the stationary power tools and hand tools may sell near what you paid for them.
You're not the only weird one... I've been accused of being among the only ones at an MWTCA national without gray hair.
Regarding the too expensive argument, I agree, but perhaps not in the sense you meant. Personally, I don't have a big interest in the really collectable tools (yet). About the only exotic tools I have a hankering for are perhaps one of those beautiful and unique Wayne Anderson planes, and maybe an odd-ball Sargent ladybug. Everything else is motivated by an interest in learning a new way to approach problems, studying and learning from their attributes or short falls.
A first bench hand plane is very expensive, if it's going to be anything more than a paper weight. One needs a sturdy workbench, a sharpening method, a time commitment to learn how to use the plane, time to learn to properly sharpen it, and the sacrificial wood. I've always thought the Norm vs. St Roy division of wood working silly, until I thought about this expensive monetary and temporal hump. Buying that first used hand plane at a meet for a neanderthal-newbie can be risky if one doesn't know what qualities to look for. With LN and LV, A first time user doesn't have to worry about getting burned, or learning first to tune before they have their first positive experience. They're a good first step to being a collector. After one has learned to finely tune a plane the used market starts looking pretty attractive. $10 try plane or a $20 #32 looks pretty darn good value compared to a LN/LV #7 if one can tune them up to perform the same. Getting to that point and developing an interest can take some time... hence the gray hair. ;-)
Not sure how to best promote tool meets. Gloats on on-line hand tool forums probably help. So what did you buy??
Dave