We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>This is all rather fascinating and exciting. I love it when people toss around terminology and a level of detail suggesting they did not spend their entire youth in a pool room. Gives me faith in humanity.
Anyway, I always thought burrs formed when grinding or honing edge-last (as opposed to honing with the pointy edge leading the movement across the stone). I mean, this is when I see them. I've never noticed a burr issue on anything ground or honed edge first/away from the edge. Does a very tiny burr form even when honing edge first?
>The short answer is 'yes', you can get a burr when grinding and honing in either direction, and yes, you should produce a burr moving the edge into the abrasive. Sometimes this doesn't happen due to inconsistent angular presentation, a poor match of abrasive to steel, and so on. Also, if a decent burr is initially produced, it may be gone by the time you've moved through progressively finer abrasives and even when you jump from coarse to very fine, such as when moving direct from a 1000-grit med/coarse water stone to a 6000-grit finishing stone, given that sufficient time was spent at each level with consistent angles.
Generally, drawing the edge away from the abrasive is said to produce a longer burr more difficult to cleanly remove. I often grind, sharpen, hone, and polish (strop) tool edges on a rotating horizontal lap (and for larger tools, a vertical 1" belt sander). I'm apt to present the edge into the grain when a tool is sufficiently jigged, but a smaller tool with its pointy cross-sectional density can usually be more safely drawn. With a new coarse belt on the sander, freehand feeding the arris edge-first can be 'interesting'.
I'm sure others can better explain this and hope they do.
As for my previous verbiage, it's just that. When I don't take the time to adequately and simply describe things, I'm apt to spew whatever jargon, facts and sources I've retained just to get it out and posted before the thread wanes. It really doesn't show any especial knowledge or accomplishment but moreso a fair recall for esoterica and trivia and I deserve no vicarious credit beyond my having remembered and imparted it. It's worth exactly what you paid for it. And I'd gladly have spent more time hanging at the pool hall if I hadn't so completely sucked at the game.
>I thought I had a lot of stuff, and I could unpack in a couple days. I say if you are unpacking for a couple months it might be a good idea to just have a garage sale ;)
>Burr formation, and being able to feel the burr, is one of the secrets to good sharpening. I read a lot about sharpening and everyone talked abut a burr, and then I would go out to my shop and feel the edge and say "Duh, where is the burr?". I am not sure what it took to really grasp the idea and be able to feel the burr, but now I can feel the burr even on an 8000 grit stone. You know you have honed long enough when a burr is formed across the entire width of the blade. I then flip the iron and take the burr off on my 8000 grit stone, then go to the next grit level and hone until a burr is formed all the way across.
>I was introduced to the burr by my oboe teacher when I was 12 years old {1962}. In those days he would sharpen his reed knife about 200 times a week. By the time I took up woodworking in 1974, I had sharpened a reed knife about fifty thousand times. It was a great advantage to start out with sharp tools.
Today I still worry about the burr. I think treatment of the burr has a lot to do with the performance of the edge. Those final acts of sharpening are really important.
>There is much to ponder in that article. Beyond contemplating that a relatively soft ARK stone might leave a hardened surface on the steel these same abrasive processes are relevant to dulling. The thought that the chemicals in wood might be removing atoms of tool steel as the plane glides over the wood is intriguing.
>At least that works for me. Of course, it ruins the edge.
I started thinking about all this, in part, because I noticed that even after I took off a burr as a visible wire resting behind on a white Arkansas stone -- according to the tradition method, I would inevitably reform a burr as I kidded myself that I was polishing the edge "a little more".
Tom, I'm sure you already have a feeler gage set, but for those of you who don't, pick one up at Sears or whereever. Probably something like $5. These are hardened steel. Pull out the 0.0015, which is the thinnest. See how sharp you think the edge is. Bend the gage in your fingers to get a sense of how flexible 0.0015 of steel is. Yes, of course, the nay sayers will answer that it bends so much because of beam length. But, think about how much thinner the tip of a cutting edge has to be in order to be sharp. Think about how flexible it, therefore, must be.
So, David's conceptual approach notwithstanding, it seems fair to wonder about what's going on at the edge in terms of flexing and metal failure when we're going through "sharpening".
As for "bullshit" in prose: I think of it as something vague, incomplete, illogical, pretentious, and deceptive. I find David's prose the opposite. I agree, some, including myself, will have to slow down their reading rate a little, and perhaps bother to make use of a dictionary.
There's a cute new gift book out on the market. Doesn't cost much. Tiny. Written by a philosopher. Title: "On Bullshit". I have it upstairs. I'll post on it later, so anyone interested in further expansion of their technical concepts of bullshit can find it in a bookstore.
Now I've got to go back and finish reading that Beilby, et al piece.
>That's like saying it takes surprisingly little pressure to separate a shaving of wood from the main balk, because I may not be pushing hard myself, the pressure at the edge is pretty high.
It's interesting/wonderful to hear what is happening in terms of light emisivity etc... at the edge. But I'm certainly not buying the idea that melting is principly resposible for forming the burr. I'm pretty sure I have seen burrs large enough to determine their colour and there wasn't any evidence of heat build up at all. While I have seen many fine metal shaving taken with insuficient lubricant and they had turned blue and were very hot to the touch.
Re: It takes surprisingly little pressure... *LINK*
David Barnett - SW Florida
>"But I'm certainly not buying the idea that melting is principly resposible for forming the burr. I'm pretty sure I have seen burrs large enough to determine their colour and there wasn't any evidence of heat build up at all."
Of course. All I was trying to say is temperature rise from pressure and friction at the microns-thin unsupported edge can be surprisingly high and are a part of burr formation. Without added pressure and/or heat these temperatures are quickly dissipated and do not significantly traverse those ultrathin junctures to cause significant rise at the rapidly increasing sectional density behind the forming burr.
For a purely mechanical description of burr formation, try "Apparatus for precision edge refinement of metallic cutting blades", US Pat�nt #6863600. I couldn't find this link yesterday when I first stepped into this but finally disinterred it from one of too many boxes of such stuff. I'm surprised I hadn't pitched it -- I've been trying to divest myself of such flotsam and jetsam (and for good reason, as I stayed up damned near all night reading biomed patents) -- but it was recent enough to have escaped The Purge.
At any rate, Thom, you may be right and I may've even come to agree with you and then forgot, given my current addled state.
>Be careful splurging on this book everyone. Rather than the Slate review, a better survey on the nature of the book can be found among the Amazon reader reviews.
I noticed an error right away from the The Slate reviewer. He said that in contrast to bullshit, horseshit is always a noun, never a verb. That's bullshit! Rick Ostrom, a friend of mine in the '60s, was horseshitting me constantly. And, I'm suspious he has distant relatives posting on this very forum occasionally.
>A very interesting thread to which I can contribute a couple of images - see the link below.
The plane blade in question is actually made of CPM 3V, the tool steel mentioned by Bill Tindall earlier.
The journal article linked by woodburnbob earlier is very interesting - very understandable with a little time. In particular the picture of the fracturing that occurs when grits of different sizes are scratched across a crystal surface give me a feeling for the issues involved.
Anyway, a link to some microscope images of actual plane blade burrs: