Re: Splitting the line - A misnomer?
Thom D
>Three things:
a) One can knife a line off the first part of the joint, or during initial layout, and actually run the line side teeth of a good Japanese saw right down the line. So it literally splits the line. I don't feel the knife line guides it. So theoretically a line can be split. I am not making a performance claim, but saying this can be done, and when done tight joints can result. I prefer pencil lines though.
Does anyone argue that the chisel should not split the line for the Cutting gage marks.
b) If one lays a pencil line on a workpiece, one either cuts inside it leaving all the line, and some wood. cuts outside it leaving no hint of whether the cut was good or bad, or one cuts it down the middle in which case there is a visual clue as to what happened. So that would be a cool reason to attempt it one part of the joint.
My feeling is that some of the art of transferring lines is tolerance. Getting fit is a mater of developing a process whereby you put lines and saws in a place where when you cur them the joint goes together and for me it took some experience or feel to do it. There are lots of ways of partially underplacing the lines from a pencil so they will allow themselves to be cut in half and fit will result. Set back of the pins in my case.
c)The biggest leap forward I made in cutting dovetails was when I tried to not focus on the lines at all. They are there, of course, at least for the transferred marks, but do you look at them and do you try to follow them or do you do something else? Like the question of do you drive your car in immediate alignment with the lane lines, or do you look well down the road at the vanishing point and the car just stays between the lines on the road. I'm fascinated by how aiming works. It's a very subtle subject.
Also, if you are using pencil lines you do need to have the kind of accuracy that splitting a line implies. A line, even a sharp one covers a lot of real estate, so it probably a good mindset.