Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Splitting the line - A misnomer?

Posts

Splitting the line - A misnomer?

#1

Splitting the line - A misnomer?

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.


>In basically all the dovetail articles and videos that I've seen, this expression is used to indicate where one should saw the second part relative to the layout mark that was made from the first part (either knife, pencil, or awl).

To me it doesn't make sense.

No matter what was used to mark the second part from the first, that mark is always on the "good" side, so splitting it (i.e. cutting half of it, as I understand the procedure) would lead to a loose joint. One needs to leave the line, not split it (in which case using a pencil is preferable, because cutting next to a knife or awl scribe will make the saw want to ride on it).

From memory, only Klausz makes a passing reference to this.

Am I splitting hairs?

DC

Re: Splitting the line - A misnomer?

#2

Re: Splitting the line - A misnomer?

James Watriss


>Splitting hairs? Maybe.

I've had pretty decent luck with the whole splitting the line theory, though. The thickness of a pencil line is usually pretty thin, and it doesn't always completely touch the wood you're tracing around anyway. Cut on the waste side of the line, and you'll be left with half a line thickness past the edge of the part you traced. The gaps, if there are any, should be very, very small.

Then there's test fitting, which compresses fibers a little bit. And then the wood swells back up when you apply the glue, which helps fill in those pesky little gaps.

Re: Splitting the line - A misnomer?

#3

Re: Splitting the line - A misnomer?

Thom D


>Three things:

a) One can knife a line off the first part of the joint, or during initial layout, and actually run the line side teeth of a good Japanese saw right down the line. So it literally splits the line. I don't feel the knife line guides it. So theoretically a line can be split. I am not making a performance claim, but saying this can be done, and when done tight joints can result. I prefer pencil lines though.

Does anyone argue that the chisel should not split the line for the Cutting gage marks.

b) If one lays a pencil line on a workpiece, one either cuts inside it leaving all the line, and some wood. cuts outside it leaving no hint of whether the cut was good or bad, or one cuts it down the middle in which case there is a visual clue as to what happened. So that would be a cool reason to attempt it one part of the joint.

My feeling is that some of the art of transferring lines is tolerance. Getting fit is a mater of developing a process whereby you put lines and saws in a place where when you cur them the joint goes together and for me it took some experience or feel to do it. There are lots of ways of partially underplacing the lines from a pencil so they will allow themselves to be cut in half and fit will result. Set back of the pins in my case.

c)The biggest leap forward I made in cutting dovetails was when I tried to not focus on the lines at all. They are there, of course, at least for the transferred marks, but do you look at them and do you try to follow them or do you do something else? Like the question of do you drive your car in immediate alignment with the lane lines, or do you look well down the road at the vanishing point and the car just stays between the lines on the road. I'm fascinated by how aiming works. It's a very subtle subject.

Also, if you are using pencil lines you do need to have the kind of accuracy that splitting a line implies. A line, even a sharp one covers a lot of real estate, so it probably a good mindset.

Re: Splitting the line - A misnomer?

#4

Re: Splitting the line - A misnomer?

David Charlesworth


>Dennis,

Unless some offset marking technique is used, I think you are spot on.

David Charlesworth

Re: Splitting the line - A misnomer?

#5

Re: Splitting the line - A misnomer?

paul womack


>Unless some offset marking technique is used, I think you are spot on.

I think there's a lot of experience and tolerancing going on.

I will assuming the second piece is marked from the first piece.

The first question is - how much of a gap should there be in the final joint? Since wood has some spring, even a "negative" gap might be defensible (i.e. an overlap).

In practise I suspect a small gap is desired - enough for a bit of glue, and enough to allow for finite sawing and chiselling skills.

Second - while a single bevel knife CAN make a mark exactly where the "master" piece is, a pencil line will have it's EDGE where the "master" piece is, and the centre of the pencil line will be half the line thickness away.

So, in short, I think the whole procedure actually involves judged tolerances.

When I make the second cuts for DT's, from a knifed line I "know" where I have to place the saw to get the joints to fit; I'm not sure I could usefully describe it. But it's not on the line.

BugBear

Re: Splitting the line - A misnomer?

#6

Line as reference

jim reed @ tallahassee


>I use lines as reference marks and how I cut depends on how I made the mark. Sometimes the mark is made using another piece, ie tail board. In that case I know the pins should be larger. In general sawing operations, however, I try to split the line.

Re: Splitting the line - A misnomer?

#7

Re: Splitting the line - A misnomer?

John Pappas


>Denis, My logic on this, for what it's worth. Assume one used a calligrapy pen, which made a crisp line one eighth inch wide, to mark the mating piece. Clearly the crisp edge of this line would represent the edge of the mating piece, and the desired saw cut would just "kiss" this fat line. However, with a thin line whether one is kissing the line or splitting the line might just be a matter of perception.

Re: Splitting the line - A misnomer?

#8

Re: Splitting the line - A misnomer?

Thom D


>"Second - while a single bevel knife CAN make a mark exactly where the "master" piece is, a pencil line will have it's EDGE where the "master" piece is, and the centre of the pencil line will be half the line thickness away.

So, in short, I think the whole procedure actually involves judged tolerances."

Bingo

Re: Splitting the line - A misnomer?

#9

Re: Splitting the line - A misnomer?

George Makowski


>Denis, Lately, I have realized that the carpentry I learned as a young man taught me more than I knew at the time. I often was the man that did the cutting for our crew and we regularly cut "Fat" or "Thin/Scant" measurments and yes--split the line with a circular saw or hand cross-cut saw. As the other posts indicated it is a matter of tolerances and necessary adjustments to accomodate irregularities in the reality of what you are building and how you derive you measurements.

You can split the line, take the line, or leave the line as required by your task. Experiment with what works best for the job at hand.

Good cutting,

George in AL

Re: Splitting the line - A misnomer?

#10

misnomer or red herring

Adam Cherubini, NJ


>I don't think its a misnomer. You can split a line. I think the issue with dovetail fit up is the baseline. So where is that in relation to the other board and where does the joint end up?

Okay maybe not a red herring, but you can't discuss this without discussing that.

Here's my example:

I like to leave a little bit at the base line and undercut (when working soft secondary woods).

Since I don't plane end grain, my end grain is usually too rough to see a knife line when marking my tails. So I often use an awl then pencil the awl line (usually). And its pretty fat. If I leave the line, I can't get my joint together. So I need to saw the line out. At that, I have to tap the joint together.

Rereading that's kinda confusing- okay. So all I want to say is how you saw and how you mark the baseline and chop are related. I don't put my chisels in that gauged base line when I'm working softwoods.

Does that make sense?

Adam

Re: Splitting the line - A misnomer?

#11

Re: Splitting the line - A misnomer?

Robert LaPlaca


>Denis,

I have a video produced by Lonnie Bird. Lonnie says you should saw to the waste side of the knive mark, leaving the mark, I have seem other videos and descriptions talk about spliting the mark.

I will say after watching Lonnie's video the quality of the fit of my dovetails have gotten much better..

Re: Splitting the line - A misnomer?

#12

Re: The rule is

Thom D


>I have this rule: when everyone does it a different way and they all work (we are all talking about what we do and it works nicely, right? not just what we think we saw on a video), then there isn't any one right way.

I don't even think it's an interesting argument to hear someone describe how they don't do something and therefore it doesn't work. It's slightly interesting if they do do it and it does work.

Adam, I think what your talking about is a perfect example, you have certain issues with your material and you have a certain way of putting stuff together and it all works out nicely. Good deal. Next person is totally different again.

There may be a right way, but we would need a dovetail cutting contest, like the lumberjack games. Speed and accuracy. Then maybe certain processes would filter to the top. Then the competition would morph off into impractical specialities and we would be back to knowing nothing.

Re: Splitting the line - A misnomer?

#13

Re: The rule is

Adam Cherubini, NJ


>I agree with what you're saying. Here's the point I was trying to make:

In my experience, guys says stuff but don't tell the whole story. Here's an example:

I might say (and have said)

"tail vises are a waste of time and only dummies use them. They are completely and totally useless. You don't need one to plane wood. You just use a simple planing stop."

That's the typical sort of banter we all engage in. Now if you try planing against a single planing stop, you may find it doesn't work so well. So you might find you go from person to person to find a technique that's "right for you".

Well that's okay. Or you could try to understand why a technique works. In this example, only a trip to my shop would reveal that I have holdfasts to stop rotation of planed stock, my bench is lower than normal and I lean over my planes pushing the work down against the rough unpolished surface of my bench.

So if you had problems with my technique, its probably because I didn't explain the WHOLE thing. And I think that's exactly the case here. You SHOULD split the line EVERY time (provided you position the baseline this way, chop the waste a certain way etc etc.) All those importnat qualifiers were left out of the instructions (or weren't sufficiently emphasized). You know what i mean?

I find this frustrating because I encounter it SO often.

The folks who surf woodcentral in 2020 won't have this problem. They'll all have web cams in their shops and they'll be better woodworkers for it!

Adam

Re: Splitting the line - A misnomer?

#14

Sorry Adam, you're losing me here

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.


>This is not a question of technique or preferences, but one of geometry. No matter what you use to transfer one piece to the other, splitting the line means that you are taking part of the good side of the second piece, which can only lead to a loose joint.

Either I'm missing something, or we don't use the same definitions...

DC

Re: Splitting the line - A misnomer?

#15

Sorry

Adam Cherubini,NJ


>When you take some of the "good" material, you're taking it off a wedge, right? But you can move the wedge in and out (at the baseline). So whatever you're doing with your saw and that line, its related to what you did with your chisel and the baseline.

I think a lot of folks teach you to put your chisel in the baseline when you chop. Have you heard that one? Well that's really the same as splitting the line. Technically, (by your thinking- which I agree with btw) you should leave that line too, right? But a lot of guys don't. They take out that line which moves the wedge back.

Over simplifiying, if you take out one line, you'll have to leave the other. But you can't view either line by itself and make pronoucements about it. They go together. Is that clearer?

I can't wait for those webcam woodworking forums.

Adam

Re: Splitting the line - A misnomer?

#16

Re: Sorry

Dean J in MN


>Denis --

I used to be in your camp, that you if you took any line out you were going to have a lose fit. There was a thread a while back where I said as much. On cue Adam came to the rescue and confused me with his split the line reponse. I couldn't see how splitting the line would work, because when I did my joints were loose. So I went to the shop, to prove him wrong, and started cutting dovetails. You know what -- Adam was right. That is, Adam was right if you cut dovetails like Adam cuts dovetails. Turns out others are right if you cut/mark them like they do. I have to "kiss" the line to get a good fit. That means I must cut my baselines different than others, or I am using softer wood where I can get away with a little compression.

Same goes for cutting tenons after marking them with your mortise gauge. How much of the line do you leave? That depends on how you set the gauge and the shape of the gauge pin.

-Dean, setting up shop webcam...

Re: Splitting the line - A misnomer?

#17

Re: Sorry Adam, you're losing me here

Thom D


>Adam's approach That involves cutting back of the line obviously changes the geometry. But it would also disturb the visuals of the joint lining up with the scribe line. A lot of old work I have seen seems to look that way, though I bet I see less than 1% of the amount Adam sees. One can simply set the alignment forward a tad, kinda the leigh jig principle.

What works for me is just pencilling with a very narrow point at an angleessentially under the tails, If one angles the point in it tends to undercut the tail, then they go together fine. If I was cutting together ebony and maple I would use a knife.

Adam sorry to put you in my ill tempered earlier response, even as a paragon. When I was more into designning canoes than I am now, there were two schools of thought on whether the boat should be symetrical with a bias forward (fish headed) or back, (arrow headed) There is a right answer relative to specific circumstances but in general canoing it is pretty irrelevant. An example of my rule, so my response was to just make my boats symetrical about the center, except if the loading was off center. It all works.