Re: Vlad's clone
Thom D
>Another limitation is that so far I have only seen the one, small size. It is still larger than the Tucker.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: Vlad's clone
Thom D
>Another limitation is that so far I have only seen the one, small size. It is still larger than the Tucker.
Bench vise distribution
Dirk Vogel
>Ok, so let's have a look at what can be done with regard to the vises I'd like to use.
What I learned, among other things, from the previous thread ("Workbench top design") is that :
1. I want a bench with 2 different sides : one that fixes workpieces with vises, and one more in the Roubo style, where workpieces are fixed with dogs, holdfasts and maybe battens.
2. Vises are good (because you fix workpieces with them) and bad (because they get in your way). So I must choose carefully where they'll be placed, as they tend to hinder access to the bench.
3. Wooden vises rack more easily than I'd have thought.
About vises : I'm going to have a Tucker vise, and I want a large twin screw vise (distance between screws : about 26"). This twin vise should generate rows of dogholes. I also want a tailvise with a row of dogholes, perpendicular to the twin screw vise's.
Now, to the distribution. There're several cases to treat here. I won't describe them all, you can see them. Which one is the best in your opinion ? The upper side is the one I would like to do things like edge joint/match plane, or to use fenced planes without the vises interfearing. Three times I use bench stops, three times front vises on that "Roubo" side of the bench. Figure D presents a wooden front vise, just in case the Tucker vise cannot be flushed at the bench edge.
Half of the drawings present dogholes, but they're not precise � it's only to give an idea.
Those six possibilities are not all you can build with the vises I'll have. But I hope somebody may have an idea of certain advantages or, quite the contrary, be aware of criteria why some drawings won't work.
Re: Another source you may already have
Dirk Vogel
>Hi Mike ! Yes, I know the Landis exemple. Its only "problem" is that you have to attach it to the bench with clamps, wich I found less elegant compared to a solution where my wooden screw would fix itself in some kind of socket. Thanks nevertheless ! Is the Wearing's Book worth to be bought, anyway ?
Foolish idea n. 1
Dirk Vogel
>"The golden section is a critical design element but it is often not something one can aesthetically appply to a whole."
That's for sure ! It's not what I was having in mind, anyway.
"'m darn near perfect!"
I was noticing that already by your responses :-)
"How about a rubber traction strip down the middle!" That reminds me of a foolish idea :-) Thom, you told me once : "If I was making a wide bench I think I would make one side at a different height than the other. That would be cool and have some real value." What if we cut my bench in two, creating that traction strip, but building one half noticeable higher than the other ?
I wanted to present that project later, after having had a response to my question I asked in "Need for width ?" elsewhere in this thread. Because it wouldn't be a bad idea to do so : the only occasion where I imagine to be in need of a large bench is planing large shelves. But that will happen less often than sawing little stuff, where you like to see better what's going on, without bending down all the time. And if there's a workaround for large shelves, two different heights IS definitively useful for a bench. And don't tell me to build two benches : to be stable, a high bench would have to be large and big � you can't just build some small bench high, it would fall over when you'd mortise.
Speaking about height : I planned to build a rather high bench, being tall myself (6' 2 1/2"), and on occasions of planing, where I'd have to apply force, I could mount on some lumber myself ... But that's perhaps not ideal. What do you think ?
Re: Need for width ?
Thom D
>""If you have some real need for a wide bench that is totally different. We all work at various scales, and the bench should support that.""
What I was getting at is a steady purpose, like grand pianos. Take the Acorn bench makers, who I think are covered in the Landis book. All they make are benches, presumably, and if they need a workbench large enough to handle a workbench, maybe that needs to be bigger than normal, every day. But if you are just imagining a need, I wouldn't sweat it. I don't personally have a workbench that is larger than my current workbench, by which I built it...
"Dear Thom, the problem is I can't forsee this precisely what I'm putting myself into here. :-) I doubt I'll have to, or want to, build anything that exceeds a width of 32". For me, even tables should stay within this limit. If one day I'm going to build something really big, I'll articulate it in smaller (= narrower) pieces. Even the bed I was told to build has to be decomposable, and I think this is a good approach for nearly every kind of big and wooden furniture."
So as they say, if this is your heartfelt belief, then maybe you should start "eating your own cooking" right away. Imagine going into the shop of a cabinetmaker who has a 32x96x7 monolythic benchtop, who rattles on about demountable furniture, with real passion. I like to design a bench that really projects what it is I am all about. These days it is the showpiece of people's shop. Unfortunately my woodwork doesn't have a consistant image so it is a bit of a lost cause.
" And shelves this large (near 30") can't be treated (e. g. plained) but in two passes (treating one half, turning the shelf around and treating the other half) anyway, can they ? "
Right, in essence you are making hundreds of passes and you have to stand wherever it makes sense for each. I think if I ended up with an incredibly huge piece I might end up surfacing it on the floor.
"That's why my original bench projects turned around a 32" width. After all the modificatioins they suffered, I'm less sure about everything, bench width included ;-) What I don't know is : does it really give many advantages if what you're working on can be fully placed on your bench, or doesn't it matter if a certain percentage of your piece of wood is protuding the bench edge ?"
If the piece is really stiff like 1.5" then it can take care of itself somewhat. Thinner material will deflect easily. If you have a wide short piece like 48x32 you could easily handle that on a narrow bench, and this is where dogs shine because you can keep dogging it over and supporting it right on the benchtop.
The concept you are dealing with here is "capacity". Capacity is really hard to meet. I always want the larger bench, saw, or lathe. Getting more than you need is an ongoing problem, getting too little often just hurts now and again.
Another concept would be "purpose". Part of the purpose is capacity related, as in holding pieces of the size you need to hold. Another purpose is a flat bench that will allow you to mold the work you have on it so that it is flat. It may be harder for you to maintain the flatness you need if the bench is too big.
Re: Another source you may already have *LINK*
Pete Ducklow
>Hi Dirk -
Have you seen how Ken Vaughn has made a little auxilliary vise on his bench for doing dovetails?
I'm sorry if this has been posted before - I didn't bother to go back through all the messages in these threads.
Ken Vaughn
Another picture
Pete Ducklow
Re: Vlad's clone
Vlad
>Hi Denny,
I like my clone very much, but haven't been able to use it. The handle is sad. While making a new one I injured myself and thus haven't been able to use it.....much. I'll be putting wood jaws with rare earth magnets on it or thick leather. Not sure which yet.
The castings appear to be fine. I can't see them breaking for any normal WW use. The emmert is about 30lbs heavier and bigger and I would have preferred it but $$ is an issue with 3 kids in daycare. I would certainly recommend it for $200 US or $230 CAD approx. If this is your first bench I would simply go with the large front vise from LV as I did on my first bench. However, if you're doing a lot of unusual work and like the gadget factor of the emmert, go for the clone. If you have deep pockets go for the Kindt Collins....:o)
I hope this helps. Ping me if you need anything else.
Vlad
Re: Bench vise distribution
Thom D
>I'm for D, but with the Tucker where the small face vise is, drop the face vise since it can be installed anytime if you really need it, I would just do those two vises and see what you need, and add it later.
I'm mostly guessing since I don't think anyone knows from all those options. My feeling is there is more to be gained by having both tail and face vise on one side, as long as the length is sufficient. One might do something as in the current FWW dovetail article, like plane the board for final thickness in the tail vise, then take one board and cut pins in the Tucker, then take another board and cut the tails as per Swenssons method flat on the top held transvers in the tail vise. I don't want to walk ten miles chasing around the bench for every step.
I'm rejecting all Tucker on the end options, I'm not doing any Tucker inset options, or your half lap L-vise, though I am otherwise considering the layouts.
I think your tail vise in D is a good option, I like that configuration except that it would be tedious having to open and close it all the time so a quick release would be ideal.
By the way, Speaking of the handle being lined up with the dog holes on the tail vise, If the handle is too close to the front it can end up positioned where it will catch you in an unpleasant location...
Re: Another source you may already have
Michael Recchione
>The cool thing about having one that clamps to the bench is that it can be moved to any position on the bench (not just a discrete set of positions) and doesn't require any holes - all it requires is that the bench have a top that you can clamp something to. You can come up with a more attractive clamping scheme if you like.
I like the Wearing book a lot - he's got a lot of simple solutions to a lot of woodworking problems, and really fits in with my more recent philosophy regarding hobbyist work benches, i.e. make the bench simple and optimize it for the most common operations, but make it easy to customize for special purposes using removable add-ons. I did that with the small bench I made for my "summer shop" (known to others as "the garage"). The face vise is set out from the bench a little, as Wearing recommends, and one of it's main functions is to hold other special purpose work-holding devices and attachments, e.g. a carving extension, a birds-mouth, a 360-degree adjustable bench vise, etc. But I think my philosophy and yours are pretty different, so I don't know how much you'd like the book.
Re: Foolish idea n. 1
Thom D
>Aw schucks.
"What if we cut my bench in two, creating that traction strip, but building one half noticeable higher than the other ?"
I can think of a bunch of ways of doing it.
1) Split height permanent. Just different height sides to the trestle. I think that would work fine.
2) One half folds down. I would make it so it lowered lengthwise with a windlass.
3)A lower panel that folds up. When in the down position the dog holds could hold edge planing boards to the correct height.
"you can't just build some small bench high, it would fall over when you'd mortise."
You can with the right weight distributiom.
"Speaking about height : I planned to build a rather high bench, being tall myself (6' 2 1/2"), and on occasions of planing, where I'd have to apply force, I could mount on some lumber myself ... But that's perhaps not ideal. What do you think ?"
Either works but the cool factor of a platform on the floor is less, and efficiency wise you have to climb up and down on it, and sweep around it, and trip over it.
Small wooden screws
Dirk Vogel
>Hi Mike, what you say about the advantage of the clamping solution is true ... As you already know, my problem with certain solutions is elegance :-) The photo Pete sent me is more convincing in this case, but I have no idea if small wooden screws can develop enough force to fix a shelf correctly ... I'll think all that over, promised. :-)
elegance
Michael Recchione
>"Elegance" is a subjective thing. I suspect our definitions of "elegant" may be very different. I'm an engineer, so to me the most elegant solution is the simplest and cheapest one that does the job. My esthetic sense is also very much derived from the notion that form follows function - not to the extent that I don't approve of adornment - I love carvings, decorations, beautiful lines, etc. - but only when they don't detract from function. What I don't like is a design that comprimises function for some (perhaps ill-advised) esthetic benefit. A bench that can quickly and easily be customized for many different purposes by simply clamping some simple thing to it is an idea that appeals to my sense of elegance.
But it's your bench, so do what makes you happy.
Take care,
- Mike
Tool tray and top expansion
Dirk Vogel
>Hi Thom, I'm thinking about some information you gave me here : "A tooltray creates some architectural interest in a bench". You also sent me a drawing I repost below a little modified (two versions). Studying your drawing, I thought a tooltray may resolve a problem I just don't know how to treat otherwise.
As you know, I like the idea of a 3" wide apron, and also the idea of a large tail vise (maybe 6" ?) because you told me once the clamping surface between the tail vise end and the apron is precious and justifies the construction of a tail vise. Now, if my apron gets that dark color, it would have been nice to do the tail vise in the same wood. Only that propotions don't match anymore in this case ... So maybe the tooltray may be the excuse to widen the apron to tail vise dimensions ? What do you think ? This way there'd be even enough apron width to permet my L-form vise with wooden screw ...
By the way : why didn't you flush the Tucker and twin vises to the lateral bench edges ? Is it becaus doghole rows would start in the bench wood instead of apron wood ?
Exposy is the solution ? Is it that easy ?
Dirk Vogel
>"You can bond everything with epoxy which limits moisture uptake. Your central beams need to be planed also So that rather than be solid 3xlumber only the top cm is exposed to the the weather the rest is really all boxed in epoxy."
You caught me by surprise there, Thom :-) So we're discussing for two weeks how to prevent my poor acorn benchtop to explose out of a nasty walnut apron, evoking dovetail and finger joints, grain direction, using glue only to a certain extent, including a tool tray or not � and now you're telling me that the right glue resolves everything ! Am I right here ?
Re: Tool tray and top expansion
Thom D
>I think you have reinvented the discontinous load path zig zag, not so bad in this case. If you can zig that zag inward, why is it a bad thing if the L of the L vise zigs outward, thereby making your life easier. However I think you could do what you have drawn. It looks pretty practical to me. I think the L wants to be a little deeper than what you have. Also I don't think the wider tail vise is a good idea. At least not wider than normal wide, it just increases doghole racking. However I think you are in the ballpark here. I like the solid coloured tail vise. If you look at the way they handled the colour in the Fortune vise, and imagine your apron in the same colour, I think that will be nice.
I don't flush the Tucker vise for two reasons. I think it looks nice in a line drawing, in real life I think it will look like you beavered into the beam, and the hole will be massive when the vise it twirled vertical. One advantage when they inset the record vise is that you can clamp to the front of the bench, but to do that here, you will end up with alignment problems since the vise is also free to move.
Insetting the vise will interfere with dog holes, but so does not insetting the vise, so I wouldn't worry about that.
Theoretically you can use the vise shape as a bench hook though I haven't done it myself.
Re: Need for width ?
Dirk Vogel
>"Imagine going into the shop of a cabinetmaker who has a 32x96x7 monolythic benchtop, who rattles on about demountable furniture, with real passion."
Ok, so far I thought the general approach to workbench dimensions was "the bigger the better" � surely for length, as far as width is concerned, I heard different opinions. But well, if my shop permits to put an 8' bench in, why should I settle for a 6' bench ? Even the argument of an impossible-to-relocate weightmay be overridden if I really am going to have a 6" tool tray, as you proposed :-) And the tool tray gives also the answer to the width : I'll be able to reach my tools from each side, so why limit myself to 24" ? Particularly with regard to my idea to use both sides differently ...
I didn't realise so far that the dimensions I imagined are already monolithic :-) But well, maybe you're right, and I should build something smaller ...
"I like to design a bench that really projects what it is I am all about."
This is a sentence I like ! And if my bench is too big for what I'm planning to do, I and my projects will have to grow :-) No, really, I have a good feeling with these proportions. Maybe I'll build a 90" x 30" bench instead of 96" x 32", but certainly not smaller.
Re: Exposy is the solution ? Is it that easy ?
Thom D
>Sure. You're the guy who wants his bench to use the best of 18th century technology. :0)
It is a little more complicated than just substituting one glue for another. Re-read my post. if you are seriously interested we can get into it.
Re: Bench vise distribution
Dirk Vogel
>"I'm rejecting all Tucker on the end options, I'm not doing any Tucker inset options, or your half lap L-vise"
Now you surprised me once more :-) Could you please tell me why a Tucker vise is not a tail vise for you ? Does it lack the stability to clamp against dogs (I'm thinking of two doghole rows, of course) ? My idea was simply to leave the large bench edges as free as possible, as you and other experts told me that vises can be in the way ...
Well, you remember I wanted one side of the bench for edge jointing of long shelves (Roubo style) ? If I'm not mistaken, it would be good to be able to fixate the shelf against the bench. If my Tucker is the front vise of that side, and I won't mount it with the inset that flushes his jaw at the apron, how should I manage the gap between (vertical) shelf and apron ?
And you're rejecting my half-lap L-vise because the apron is not strong enough for the L ? I hope to be on the right track with the idea I presented in "Tool tray and top expansion *PIC*". I really like the idea of a classic tail vise, and I designed the included tail vises only because of a row of dogholes in the middle of the bench, or because I didn't want two classic tail vises ...
Another question : is it a good idea to use the twin vise with rows of dogholes that goes in the direction of the bench's short side ?
Re: Tool tray and top expansion
Dirk Vogel
>"If you can zig that zag inward, why is it a bad thing if the L of the L vise zigs outward, thereby making your life easier."
Do you remember my "Why easy if you can do it the complicated way" rule ? :-) Ok, joking aside, I really would prefer the L to zig inwards because it would be the only little wooden piece to interrupt the general rectangular form of the bench top. There's nothing bad but aesthetics � in my eyes, of course.
Ok, and you think this time my drawings are not really bad for some aspect, that's something I'm really pleased about :-) And an 6" large tail vise is possible, too ? Perfect.
Now I can also understand your reasons for not flushing the Tucker vise. Maybe it would give an horrible sight if the vise moves out of position ... I wouln't like that, you're right.
"Theoretically you can use the vise shape as a bench hook"
I'm not planing to do that. Bench hooks could be something like the little lateral pieces of wood in the Frank Klausz bench � I thought already something of that style, but much nicer. That's a point I never understood : Klausz' bench is wonderful, and then he didn't hesitate to SCREW (with visible metal screws !!) his bench holds in such a beautyful object (see Schleining p. 104) ... Ts ts ts. ;-) I'll show you my design later.
Re: Exposy is the solution ? Is it that easy ?
Dirk Vogel
>Of course I'm seriously interested ! What post do I have to re-read ? You luckily wrote so many ... ;-)
Re: elegance
Dirk Vogel
>Of course you're right, Mike. And I hope to be not too far away from that form follows function stuff. Only that sometimes a simple and easy solution can look � how to say that � cheap. Yes, I think that's the word, and in such cases I try to find something with more beauty, even if it gets complicated. I'll give you a few exemples.
Look at the photos below. Ok, they're extreme exemples. The one in black and white seems the best, but how do you explain the plastic wheel and the metal screw nut ? I couldn't do this � if there must be metal involved, I'd try to hide it, and the plastic wheel may just work fine, but a wooden one would have been something else. I think the other two exemples explain itselves clearly enough.
Now, the photo of Landis (p. 134) you were referring to isn't that bad, of course. What I'm sorry a bit is the fact that you have to fix a clamp with other two clamps. Maybe it works perfevtly, maybe it's easy and useful � I just think about a better looking solution, to say so.
I'm aware it's dangerous to begin a discussion about aesthetics. Well, maybe I made myself a bit clearer nevertheless. Thanks for your contributions, I like them very much. :-)
Re: Need for width ?
Thom D
>"""Imagine going into the shop of a cabinetmaker who has a 32x96x7 monolithic benchtop, who rattles on about demountable furniture, with real passion."
Ok, so far I thought the general approach to workbench dimensions was "the bigger the better" � surely for length, as far as width is concerned, I heard different opinions."
Three things:
1) your first design was over the top which led people to consider that possibly your instinct for size was just part of that instinct for excess...
2) You should build whatever dimensions that fit the work you are doing
3) Both the work you are doing, and the bench you are doing your work on, have to deal with the fact that wood is a dimensionally stable material in one direction only.
""But well, if my shop permits to put an 8' bench in, why should I settle for a 6' bench ?:"Imagine going into the shop of a cabinetmaker who has a 32x96x7 monolithic benchtop, who rattles on about demountable furniture, with real passion." "
So here the contrast is that the piece is too one piece, rather than simply too large.
"But well, if my shop permits to put an 8' bench in, why should I settle for a 6' bench ? Even the argument of an impossible-to-relocate weightmay be overridden if I really am going to have a 6" tool tray, as you proposed :-) And the tool tray gives also the answer to the width : I'll be able to reach my tools from each side, so why limit myself to 24" ? Particularly with regard to my idea to use both sides differently ... "
That's why I suggested it.
"I didn't realise so far that the dimensions I imagined are already monolithic :-) But well, maybe you're right, and I should build something smaller ... "
By now you know this isn't the point
""I like to design a bench that really projects what it is I am all about."
This is a sentence I like ! And if my bench is too big for what I'm planning to do, I and my projects will have to grow :-) No, really, I have a good feeling with these proportions. Maybe I'll build a 90" x 30" bench instead of 96" x 32", but certainly not smaller. "
So in this instance if you are Mr. Knockdown furniture then you might consider a nice demountable bench. In my case I like structure, so I emphasized the relationship to the beam and also the simple joinery, enjoyment of different kinds of tools and so forth.
Re: Exposy is the solution ? Is it that easy ?
Thom D
>Just three above, where I think I laid out how the top would have to be parsed, not merely substituting epoxy for other glue.
I'm surprised you didn't jump all over the epoxied studs. If you had you could bond in epoxy threaded rods connected to rod connectors and mount your vises all over the place and move them with ease.
Re: Bench vise distribution
Thom D
>""I'm rejecting all Tucker on the end options, I'm not doing any Tucker inset options, or your half lap L-vise"
Now you surprised me once more :-) Could you please tell me why a Tucker vise is not a tail vise for you ? Does it lack the stability to clamp against dogs (I'm thinking of two doghole rows, of course) ? My idea was simply to leave the large bench edges as free as possible, as you and other experts told me that vises can be in the way ..."
I just don't like working on the end of the bench, it's as though after arguing about how large a bench I should have I am now down to a bench that is thirty inches long and 96" wide, exactly the wrong direction. Possibly four tucker vises would be better than one, but if it is one them I want it left front.
I think the vise is strong enough certainly for an end vise so that isn't the problem. But at whatever it costs, it seems too expensive to use for that position. I can have a perfectly fucntional end vise for about 50 bucks.
I think one free side is fine, but both my full benches have face vise left and tail right. A lot of this complaining about the crowding of vises is because people have 5 or 6 foot benches, which I didn't like about my Frid, so I built a longer one.
Some of the stuff we talk about I think is fundamental like allowing for grain expansion, other stuff is personal. To me this end vise is maybe a bit in-between, doesn't make sense to me but it's not going to cause your bench to go "crack!" overnight.
"Well, you remember I wanted one side of the bench for edge jointing of long shelves (Roubo style) ? If I'm not mistaken, it would be good to be able to fixate the shelf against the bench. If my Tucker is the front vise of that side, and I won't mount it with the inset that flushes his jaw at the apron, how should I manage the gap between (vertical) shelf and apron ?"
I mount my wide boards in the vice and just stick my four leg stool under the rear end of it. I realize it's not as snazzy as some rigs but it works fine for me. Another option is a thing in the rear vise, or using the Tucker as a hook.
"And you're rejecting my half-lap L-vise because the apron is not strong enough for the L ? I hope to be on the right track with the idea I presented in"
I didn't reject any of those layouts just that stage of your vise idea.
"Another question : is it a good idea to use the twin vise with rows of dogholes that goes in the direction of the bench's short side ?"
I think that can be fine. Maybe if a person does stuff like chair seats. I haven't ever used mine that way.