Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Bench hold-down . . .

Posts

Bench hold-down . . .

#1

Bench hold-down . . .

Steve Mackay


>Finally tired of bar-clamping plank to the bench to chop it up. Time to up-grade. I saw a "hold-down" in GW but cant remember what they called it. Its not really a dog. Inverted "L" shape, the leg drops into a hole in the bench and the arm kind of acts like a leaf spring to apply tension/preasure to the work surface. Probably a stupid trivia question for today !

Re: Bench hold-down . . .

#2

Re: Bench hold-down . . .

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native in FL. Exile :~(


>Sounds to me like one of those mechanical HOLDFAST like the ones LV carries.

Todd O.

Re: Bench hold-down . . .

#4

By Golly, Thats it ! Thanks much !

Steve Mackay

Re: Bench hold-down . . .

#5

Re: By Golly, Thats it ! Thanks much !

Thom D


>I forged my own, Now I have a record, an LV, and a hand made, none of which is installed in my bench, I hate holes in my bench...

Re: Bench hold-down . . .

#6

That said . . .

Steve Mackay


>after you bend and form the stock how do you "treat" it ? Just heat and cool ? Like many, I'm pretty handy but you mentioned forging. I would'nt have the skills. I know you have to "re-form" the crystals (anneale ?) or some such alchemy.

Re: Bench hold-down . . .

#7

Re: That said . . .

William Duffield, on the Cohansey


>Ask Joel what he does. It seems that similar steel and heat treatment as one would use for vehicular leaf or coil springs would be just about perfect.

Another option is the import ductile iron hold downs carried by Woodcraft. If ductile iron is tough enough for L-N, Veritas and Clifton plane bodies, it's good enough for a holdfast.

A third option is the work-of-art hand forged ones made by Jake the Russian in Galena, Alaska.

A third option, way down on the list, are cast iron import hold fasts. I currently have one that still works, and another that snapped off in use, after a lot fewer cycles and a lot less stress than your typical Sunday afternoon auto race. Cast iron is too brittle for this application.

Re: Bench hold-down . . .

#8

Are the Veritas Bench Hold-Downs any good? *LINK*

Ian Smith (Sydney Australia)


>Hi all,

Can anyone here tell me whether or not the Veritas Bench Hold-Downs (see link) are any good? They are a bit expensive compared to the Gramercy Holdfasts sold by Joel at Tools for Working Wood but are they worth it.

Regards,

Ian.


http://www.leevalley.com/wood/page.aspx?c=3&cat=1,

Re: Bench hold-down . . .

#9

You can still buy the Record Holdfast here, Ian

Andrew F in Australia


>The one that the Veritas is modelled off.

And yes, they work well. I paid about AUD110 for mine, from CarbaTec in Auburn about 18 months ago, but I've seen them elsewhere - any problems locating one, email me offline.

Saves a bit on postage, also.

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: Bench hold-down . . .

#10

Yes indeed

Wiley Horne


>Ian,

I have two, which are always in use. My bench has a deep thick apron, drilled for holddowns, and the Veritas is used to secure the off-end of stock being edge jointed for example. You rest the offend on the shank of the holddown and then clamp it up against the apron. And they're used on the benchtop for the usual purposes.

What I like about the Veritas product is, first, that it doesn't miss. It doesn't care what wood it's being secured in. Always gets a death grip because of the scales milled into the shank. Second thing is that you can modulate the pressure with that brass turn screw. It holds tight but you can apply pressure at the rate you want, so it doesn't mar the work. And the pad has no tendency to slide sideways as it gets to full pressure, further to the point of not marring the work.

I wasn't aware of the Record ones that Andrew mentions, but can tell you that the Veritas holddown is a great tool.

Wiley

Re: Bench hold-down . . .

#11

I like mine...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA


>It's very well made, and nice to look at too. One day I'd like to get a second one.

Re: Bench hold-down . . .

#12

Re: I like mine...

Ian Smith (Sydney Australia)


>Thanks for the responses Andrew, Wiley and Scott.

Regards,

Ian.

Re: Bench hold-down . . .

#13

I don't care for mine...

Paul Kierstead


>It doesn't hold down 3/4" stock so well; the mechanism tends to get in the way. Adjustments are bothersome compared to traditional hold downs. You have to crank it fairly tightly to get it to work. It tends to catch in the holes as it is withdrawn; if you don't have countersunk dog-holes, it tends to catch on the top bit of wood on the bench, or the finish of the bench.

All in all, it is usually more of a pain then it is worth, so I don't use it too much. Of course YMMV and some people love it.

Re: Bench hold-down . . .

#14

Re: That said . . .

Thom D


>I made mine out of cold rolled, or maybe hot rolled steel. I didn't heat treat it I don't believe it is required, it is mighty thick stuff and has quite a bit of bite as is. This was one of the first projects I did on an anvil. I had minimal idea of what i was doing. It worked almost perfectly right out of the blocks, then I made a small change and had to fight back to what it needed to be.

Basic process was heat the end, hit with hammer until it is flatenned, you can read up on drawing out, and various types of peen. In fact I have some stuff to make a guilotine tool and that would be perfect, though in this case I want it as much wide as out so a regular hammer works fine. Then you flip it over and hammer a curvature in the pad over the anvil. and take it to the angle you want. Then heat back a bit, and when you get that heat, take the main bend over the narrow point of the anvil. Periodically sight foot body alignment for whatever degrees you are shooting for. That simple.

By the way, what I do is take some plasticine and go through the process with a small hammer or block of wood. It's the same with the metal when it comes time to forge. I didn't do that here, this hold down is just too easy to make.

If you want one of those leaf ends, you just need to buy or make the die. There is a guy on ebay who sells them, but basically you just heat a block of metal to a good heat and use a cold chisel (hot chisel in this case) to cut the stalk and vein, then weld it to a hardy hole piece of stock. you can make the chisels out of hot forged rod, and quench them is super quench for a touch of additional hardness.

I got all my tips from the article in Woodworking, they did a shootout. When you make your own, the big deal about a particular HD is no biggie. You can make tiny adjustents if it isn't perfect for what you want or your specific hole size or top thickness. Maybe there is a super HD that works in the widest range of benches, but when you make your own you won't care.

The cast ones never seem to come through reviews all that well. Ductile Iron is the industry standard for sewer pipe, that doesn't make it bad, but I'm not taking the Rah Rah to seriously either, I'm not paying extra... It's like this spinning wheel I am modeling mine after; there is a big surcharge for a wheel made out of solid MDF vs solid hardwood. It actually spins really well...