WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

Emerald Ash Borer - Paranoia or Pragmatism?

Posts

Emerald Ash Borer - Paranoia or Pragmatism?

#1

Emerald Ash Borer - Paranoia or Pragmatism?

David Miller from Iowa


>This bugger was supposed to be quarantined in the Detroit area, but it has broken out at least to Chicago (see link or google emerald ash borer).

I have three wooded acres on a nice river about 300 miles from Chicago. I've become very concerned since about 90% of my mature trees are white ash (the remaining ones are American elm which the fungus will get at some point).

Been debating with folks about this and I have taken the position that the emerald ash borer will ultimately decimate all of America's ash trees - may take decades, but I'm thinking it is inevitable. I'm considering the launch of an agressive biodiversity program of planting varied varieties of fast growing trees and systematically taking out the ashes with the goal of getting my ash population below 30% within 10-15 years.

SWMBO says I'm paranoid and doesn't like the idea of thinning the grove for this purpose. She says that even if they get here, we can medicate, but it looks like one has to do it every year in perpetuity.

Your thoughts?

David

Re: Emerald Ash Borer - Paranoia or Pragmatism?

#2

Re: Emerald Ash Borer Link  *LINK*

David Miller from Iowa



Emerald ash borer info

Re: Emerald Ash Borer - Paranoia or Pragmatism?

#3

Re: Emerald Ash Borer - Paranoia or Pragmatism?

Dave Thompson


>Thanks for the informative link. Half of the trees on my property are ash, so I'm a bit concerned. It will be a pity to see the really mature ones go. Biodiversity sounds like the most pragmatic solution. Perhaps a woodmiser might be in your future ;-)

good luck,

Dave

Re: Emerald Ash Borer - Paranoia or Pragmatism?

#4

45's or trees, that is the question

Gerry D.


>David,

Just received a quote from an arborist last night. I have 6, 30-year old soft maples on the lot. The one in the front yard, a behemoth which shades the whole front of the house, started shedding bark on one of the limbs. Quote was $265.00 to inoculate all 6 trees from borer's (what the arborist states is causing the damage), $400.00 to feed all 6 in the fall (due to the damage from last years draught.) I consider it money well spent.

I'd check with a local arborist to see what an inoculation program would cost before you employ the Agent Orange and chain saw. Price would probably be considerably cheaper than what I'm paying. (I believe your familiar with the "Naperville tax.")

It would be a shame to lose mature trees when you could inoculate the entire state of Iowa by parting with 1/4 your collection of 45's.

Gerry

Re: Emerald Ash Borer - Paranoia or Pragmatism?

#5

Re: Emerald Ash Borer - Paranoia or Pragmatism?

Dave OH


>Oh, it's not just moving west. It is in Ohio in the northwest, ALL firewood from Michigan is banned in Ohio with heavy fines. Ohio is using the only sure method to prevent further spread, clear cutting ash forests. Do not take this bug lightly.

Dave

Re: Emerald Ash Borer - Paranoia or Pragmatism?

#6

Still need the A45:)

David Miller from Iowa

Re: Emerald Ash Borer - Paranoia or Pragmatism?

#7

Re: Emerald Ash Borer - Paranoia or Pragmatism?

Thom D


>The michigan bugs are in southern Ontario. I will say it's a pretty bug. Any trout action?

Re: Emerald Ash Borer - Paranoia or Pragmatism?

#8

Dale Lenz

Re: Emerald Ash Borer - Paranoia or Pragmatism?

Dale Lenz


>Dave,

As a professional forester I strongly advise you to contact a forester in your area for advice. Might start with one of your State Foresters.

Let us know what you decide to do...Dale

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.