Burr vs no burr? (rambling & unedited
Thom D
>"I often wonder if a card or scraper plane blade, with a hook, works because it is a sharp blade with an imperceptibly close set, very steep chipbreaker. The C/B, being the flat side of the blade, is at a high angle. i.e. the shaving has to climb a slope of about 90 degrees, in the 112 and 80 setup, if I have worked it out correctly..... the transition between sharp edge and C/B might also be a very tight radius cutve?"
One could always look at the cutting edge end of things. One of the constituents of cutting power is edge thickness. The scythe might be a better example than comparisons to planes. With the scythe a very thin blade to start with, maybe 1/32", is further thinned by peening (cold drawn by hammer and anvil), and is finally sharpened. The sharpening is pretty cursory by woodworking standards. The scythe, like a card scraper, is made of softer metal to allow the peening, and the sharpening peening cycles are repeated often. The worker takes his stone and peening tools into the field to keep the edge in form. Maybe the soft metal and cold forming aspects of the scraper point to a similar cutting principle, of a sharpened feather edge. If Barnett is correct that the shaving is not breaking in accordance with the tighter breaker geometry, then my vote is for the increased cutting power.



