Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

plane cuts a groove

Posts

plane cuts a groove

#1

plane cuts a groove

jvairin


>I have a 2nd-hand Stanley Handyman plane that I used the other day. I then removed the blade and honed it on an oilstone, carefully paying attention to keep the bevel and flattened the back. I reassembled the plane and attempted to smooth a rough-cut board face, but after inspecting the board in better light (it was getting dark), I found that I had put grooves with each stroke of the plane. I disassembled and reassembled the plane blade and iron, made several adjustments up and down, fooled with the frog and the lateral adjustments, and still am cutting grooves with the edge of the plane blade. What am I doing wrong?

Re: plane cuts a groove

#2

Re: plane cuts a groove

Marc in Luxembourg


>Maybe...

That's normal because your edge is straight. If you had a cambered edge on the blade you'd take off swaths, slight hollows of shavings and not making marks with square edges. Only guesswork,

Marc

Re: plane cuts a groove

#3

Steve Kubien

Plane tracks

Steve Kubien


>I think what you are getting sound like 'plane tracks' which, as Marc said, are caused by having an iron which is dead-straight across. With such an iron, I find it VERY difficult to avoid these grooves. Consider knocking down the corners of the iron a wee bit. As you sharpen and hone, apply a little extra pressure to one corner of the iron for a few strokes, then switch to the other corner. Repeat this a few times and you will have a cambered iron. And, you should have no more plane tracks.

Yup, you can use this technique with a honing guide as well. A side-clamping guide (Ellipse, I think they're called) is really easy to use because the roller is so narrow, like about 1/2" - 3/4". Guides with wider rollers, like the Veritas, are a little more difficult, but not impossible.

Hope this helps,

Steve Kubien

Re: plane cuts a groove

#4

Spirit possession?

woodburnbob


>I don't understand how this can happen, if all you say is true, and your plane isn't haunted. But you haven't quite given enough information for a good diagnosis. Are you saying you get a groove from the plane edge and it doesn't vary in depth by adjusting the lateral? That doesn't make sense.

I'd expect you to get a groove on one side, then when you adjust the lateral to lean the blade away from that side, the groove shifts to the other side as you pass through an intermediate zone of no grooves on either side. The sole isn't deeply concave is it?

If you have a groove on both sides, the cutting edge is concave. Take the blade out. Hold a straightedge up in front of a light. Place the blade edge against the straightedge. Any light between the two shows the amount of deviation from straight. But, this isn't quite foolproof. Now do the same thing but rather than holding the blade vertical, hold it at a 45 degree tilt just like when it's in the plane. A dished out bevel can project a line vertically but show the edges dropping at 45 degrees.

Oh, well. You'll probably figure this out on your own anyway. Hope you report back. No doubt we all have various ideas about the cause of your problem and would like to know.

Re: plane cuts a groove

#5

Re: Plane tracks

jvairin


>That makes good sense, and I'll give that a try. I'll let you all know what happens next.

Re: plane cuts a groove

#6

Couple of suggestions....

Wiley Horne


>The Blade

Take a straight edge and place it right along the sharpened edge, and hold the blade/straight edge up to back lighting. Look at the light leaks. What do you see? If the blade edge is flat against the straight edge all the way across, then you've probably got the aforementioned 'straight blade' problem, which is cured by camber. And some camber is always good on a bench plane anyway--even a smoother (IMO). Now if the blade ends are touching the square, but light is coming through in the middle of the blade, then you will need to figure out how a belly got in the middle of the blade. This would cause the plane to score the wood on both sides, leaving torn fibers and not shavings.

If the plane is giving a torn surface on one side or the other, but not both sides, you've almost surely got what the others have said--the straight blade problem. However, if the plane really is cutting a groove, and tearing the fibers on both sides of the blade, then you've likely got a belly in the blade. If so, then there are a few other things to check (including the sharpening gear) to figure out what is happening.

The Plane

While you're at it, take your straight edge to the plane sole, with the blade in the plane but retracted, and check side to side, right in front of the mouth. You want to see no light. Then take the straight edge and check stem to stern in a few places. You want to see the front of the mouth sitting down on the straightedge with no light coming through. Here's the point--if the leading edge of the plane mouth is not sitting down on the work, you will never get good performance, and various odd things happen that are not easy to diagnose. Such as the blade not making contact, and then digging in and tearing out. I mention this possibility because it is typical for the mouth to be in the air on this type plane.

Wiley

Re: plane cuts a groove

#7

Re: Plane tracks

jvairin


>Tried what you said and beveled the blade edges and it seems to be doing better. I actually used a file to speed up the process and then honed it afterwards. I think I'm on the right track and need to take it down a little more. The grooves are gone on one side and less pronounced on the the other, so I think that I need to even it out to get where I need to be. Thanks for the advice.

Re: plane cuts a groove

#8

Re: Plane tracks

mikew


>If you can use a file to shape a plane blade, the blade is too soft. Perhaps it was overheated at some point in its past from grinding...or was simply not hardened properly or over tempered.

I would consider getting a replacement blade from Hock or LN. Call either place to make sure you get the proper one if you go this route.

Take care, Mike

Re: plane cuts a groove

#9

Re: Plane tracks

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI


>Christopher Schwartz, if I remember correctly, promotes use of a file for slightly rounding the corner of a smoothing iron. I of course told him he was full of pink baloney, and promptly afterwards I tried it myself just to prove it wouldn't work. Of course, it ends up working just fine, and better than most options I have tried.

Re: plane cuts a groove

#10

Re: Plane tracks

mikew


>Hi Moses, I know I cannot shape the old woodie laminated blades I have and would be surprised if the new A2 ones can. Is this what you tried it on?

The hardest files I do have are 72 RC, so I could always try one of the LN blades...If the OEM Stanleys can, well...

Thanks, Mike

Re: plane cuts a groove

#11

Re: Plane tracks

Todd Stock


>I used to knock the corners off with a grinder, then hone, but it's easier to just use the pressure shifting method from Charlesworth using an Eclipse guide (allows the proper rockin movement). Jacks get a bit more relief, but smoothers only need .002 or so to avoid tracks.