Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Steel grain size in plane blades and chisels

Posts

Steel grain size in plane blades and chisels

#1

Steel grain size in plane blades and chisels

Peter Evans


>Does anyone have an info on the grain size in the steels used for edge tools?

This question arises from the speculation that there is little point in honing with abrasive finer than the steel. For example if the grain size of the steel averages 5 microns is there any point going past a 2500 grit waterstone?

Any metalurgists out there?

Re: Steel grain size in plane blades and chisels

#2

Re: Steel grain size in plane blades and chisels

Thom D


>I don't think that will help as soon as sticking to the basics. What is grain? Is that a molecule an atom, is grain the particle smaller than which one can't sharpen? I think that kind of stuff is happening at a much finer granularity than the granularity beyond which it just ins't practical to sharpen any further, even in a competition. I have seen pictures of steel that has been sharpened with very fine stones and it is still a homogenous material, I the tracks cut by the abrassive are much heaftier than the surface character of the material.

While one sharpens finer, the abrassive only cuts uniformey to the extent that it is cutting at the same angle as previous cuts (or micro bevels at odds with it). And each new abrassive requires more accuracy because it finer and finer and will require more time to remove any irregularity. I think the sharpenign process grinds to a halt before the material.

I could be wrong.

Re: Steel grain size in plane blades and chisels

#3

Re: Steel grain size in plane blades and chisels *LINK*

Deirdre Saoirse Moen


>I'm not a metallurgist, but the external reference on the Wikipedia tempering page shows images at 1 micrometer and 200 nanometers, which should give you a sense that the particles are much smaller than the grits you're sharpening with.

The external link doesn't mention the cryogenic treatment typically associated with A2 tool steels (e.g. Hock and Lie-Nielsen).


Wikipedia page on Tempering

Re: Steel grain size in plane blades and chisels

#4

Grain Size and Sharpening

Steve Elliott


>I'm also not a metallurgist, but I've read up on the microstructure of steel. My short answer to your question is that the size of the grain structure does not limit the ability of the steel to be honed using fine abrasives.

The longer answer is that Fine Woodworking had an article in the March 1985 issue that reported the results of having ten chisels analyzed by a lab. The grain sizes of the chisel steel ranged from 6 to 11. Those aren't micron sizes--the grain size of steel is rated using a formula that counts the number of grains per square inch on an acid-etched steel surface. An average size grain in the steel of an average chisel or plane blade might be somewhere around 10 microns across. Although finer-grained steel has better edge-holding qualities, the finer grain isn't necessary for attaining sharpness.

There's a graphic on this page that shows grain size 8 and the relative size of the carbide particles produced in particle-metallurgy steels. On the left-hand side is a scale showing microns and thousandths of an inch.

Re: Steel grain size in plane blades and chisels

#5

One in Sydney (ish), Peter,

Andrew F in Australia


>Hi Peter,

A properly heat treated blade has a grain size a lot less than 5 microns.

And, yes, you could sharpen/hone/grind off part of a grain to make things sharper.

Shoot me an email with your phone # and I'll give you a call.

Cheers,

Andrew

(who hasn't read the other responses and apologises if this is duplicate info)

Re: Steel grain size in plane blades and chisels

#6

Grain Size

Warren in Lancaster, PA


>Grain size is the dimension of individual crystals in the steel. If you had a chisel made froma single crystal of steel, it would have large grain size and could be sharpened to a fine edge. However it would be vulnerable to fracturing along certain planes like a rock crystal, and also easy to bend as groups of atoms can slide along these same planes.

Creating smaller crystals limits how far a slide or split can occur in a single plane, thus affecting hardness and toughness. You can see grain boundaries with a microscope because individual crystals with different orientations reflect light differently, but the boundaries themselves occur on an atomic level, and the boundaries are still tightly bonded. It is not like grains of sandstone with weak bonds between individual crystals. The size of abrasives would not be too small even if they were smaller than grain size.

Re: Steel grain size in plane blades and chisels

#7

Re: Steel grain size in plane blades and chisels

bill tindall


>This issue can become complex, but the bottom line is that the proper abrasive can/does abrade the "grains" so that their size is not a limitation on the fineness of the edge imposed by grain size. We got a picture once of a diamond scratch going through a vanadium carbide particle/grain/domain in CPM 3V. The diamond would therefore abrade this hard region and its size not be a limitation.

However, a less hard abrasive might not cut these hard regions. In this case the size of the vanadium carbide domains could become a limitation.