Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Best way to put a camber on a plane iron?

Posts

Best way to put a camber on a plane iron?

#1

Best way to put a camber on a plane iron?

wilbur


>I've been practicing my plane iron sharpening with some old Stanley plane irons using a set of waterstones. I've gotten pretty good at getting a sharp square edge on the plane irons -- so much so that when I use the planes, I get a nice square plane track. So I'd like to round off the edges a little.

What would be the best way to do this? Looking around, I've found these options:

1. Sharpen the bevel as normal, but put more pressure on the edges, one side at a time. I haven't been able to get a clear answer on is whether you should use a coarse (1000) grit or fine (8000) grit for this purpose.

2. Hold the plane iron perpendicular to the stone, and put a camber on, effectively destroying the sharp edge at the corners, and then resharpen the bevel as you would normally.

Thanks!

Re: Best way to put a camber on a plane iron?

#2

Re: Best way to put a camber on a plane iron?

arw01


>Personally, I'm awaiting the new cambered roller for the Mark II to arrive at my local Woodcraft store.

I've not been too successful doing it by hand, or with the old LV sharpener either. Always had some plane tracks, mostly on one side from adjusting the lateral, and then I would work across the wood.

Better to get rid of them I think.

Alan

Re: Best way to put a camber on a plane iron?

#3

Re: Best way to put a camber on a plane iron?

Dick Schafer


>Your #1 method is the way that I do it, and it works quite well. You don't need very much camber, as you should be taking a very thin cut for smoothing anyway.

Re: Best way to put a camber on a plane iron?

#4

Re: Best way to put a camber on a plane iron?

Thom D


>You two methods aren't that different. Since in both cases the actual bevel sharpening requires you to put extra presure on the edges. And I think that's basically it. You can do it with a cambered jig, by distorting the balde within the jig, or by putting something like tape down one side of the stone to tip the blade on edge, or just by repositioning your fingers, you can even do it by letting your stone get hollowed out a little.

I only blunt the end when I am regrinding an edge as can happen with a scrub planes or jack plane where the edge is really curved. blunting is mostly a mater of controlling heat. I don't find it helps much with contouring really fine blades since the curvature is barely visible. But it does help wiht blades that have a really tight curvature like 12" radius.

Re: Best way to put a camber on a plane iron?

#5

Re: Best way to put a camber on a plane iron?

Todd Stock


>The Eclipse type honing guide does a nice job of allowing just enough rock to provide a nice camber, and is a heck of a lot cheaper than other honing guide options or diamond cambering plates.

I've kept my old Veritas guide for skew blades, but the Eclipse does an excellent job on this sort of thing, and you are not locked into a specific camber. I think David Charleworth has the flick on this.

Re: Best way to put a camber on a plane iron?

#6

Which waterstone should I use?

wilbur


>Thanks for all of the input! When doing the cambering, is it better to use a coarse (1000) grit or fine (8000) grit for this purpose?

Re: Best way to put a camber on a plane iron?

#7

Re: 4000 for me

Dave Mount


>I have 800, 4000, and 8000 water stones and I use the "edge pressure" approach starting at 4000. Just a couple strokes each side. Not sure that's the "right" way to do it, but it works for me. Once in a while I'll have to go back and re-run the edges if I didn't get enough the first time. Depends in part on how thin a shaving you're taking. If they're really thin, then very little camber is required. If they're thicker, then more is required. If you put on a lot and then go for thin shavings, you may not end up with a very wide cut. Just start somewhere and adjust from there.

I'd suggest trying it at the 8000 and if you don't get enough, go back to the 1000 and start it there.

YMMV,

Dave

Re: Best way to put a camber on a plane iron?

#8

Re: Which waterstone should I use?

Thom D


>If you want to be a little careful start with the finer stone. If nothing seems to be happening go coarser. I do all this kind of stuff on the coarsest stones I have. At least for setting the shape. My 4000 doesn't do much. I just got a Norton medium, I think it is a 4000, I haven't used it yet, if it's faster maybe it will work for me. Obviously the finer the curve the more realistic using a fine stone will be.

Re: Best way to put a camber on a plane iron?

#9

Re: Which waterstone should I use?

david charlesworth


>I think it rather depends on how wide your honing bevel is.

If wide, say over 1 mm, suggest 800 or 1000grit stone.

If very narrow, say less than 1 mm then a finer stone might do it.

David Charlesworth

Re: Best way to put a camber on a plane iron?

#10

Agree, and you

Wiley Horne


>can put progressively more pressure towards the edge to get a smooth taper. I like to camber in an elliptical pattern, where it's almost nothing in the center, and getting noticeable about 1/2" from the edge. But it's all personal preference. For the initial camber, do it starting with the 1000 stone, or whatever you're using that's close to that. Then with each additional stone. If you're using waterstones or Shaptons, I would suggest using, say, 15-20 strokes per side per grit, and see how that works out. count them. You can see what you've done if the plane will let you close up the mouth to just a few thousandths--with the mouth closed up, you can sight down the throat of the plane (into back lighting) and actually see even a small amount of camber that you've put on the blade.

Wiley

Re: Best way to put a camber on a plane iron?

#11

Me too!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA


>The Eclipse guide works great for this. You can always grind a small radii on the edges of the blade and sharpen flat across. That's what I do with smoothers.

Re: Best way to put a camber on a plane iron?

#12

Steve Kubien

Here's my most recent experience...

Steve Kubien


>Hi Wilbur,

I may catch some flak for this but here it goes.... I recently attended a sharpening symposium, of sorts. While there I got to test-drive the new cambered roller from Lee Valley on one of the 2-1/4" irons for the bevel-up line of planes. It worked like a dream. I went from a 1000 grit stone for the primary bevel and straight to the 8000 for the secondary (cambered roller only used on the secondary). Results? Nothing but fluff for shavings.

My 2 cents,

Steve Kubien