Santa Klausz is coming to town...
Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.
>...aka progress report on dovetails...
Earlier this week I inquired about the time it took people to dovetail a drawer (through in the back and half blind in the front). Three hours was my average to accomplish the task, too long in my book. I received lots of good (and conflicting!) advice, thanks all. I also watched the videos from Cosman and Klausz again, paying lots of attention to all the steps in their respective method...
The weather is crappy around here, so it gave me the opportunity to go in the shop to take another stab at it... Since these drawers are for the shop, and are dovetailed only to give me some "dovetail mileage", if the result looks crappy that's no big deal. So I decided to go "all out" and streamline the process as much as I can. Today I did the following (adapted from my posting earlier this week):
- Plane boards' ends clean and square (Cosman)
- Use the marking gauge (Tite-Mark) to set the various thicknesses to mark. Make the mark just a hair thicker than the board to cut down on planing after the drawer is completed
- Gang up the sides together (Becksvoort)
- Saw the tails freehand, like Klausz does for his pins
- Cut off the half pin waste to the line, leaving it just a hair fat
- Chop the waste down to the baseline, undercutting ever so slightly (Klausz)
- Put the pin board in the vise, set the height using a plane, register the tail board on top, and mark with a knife (Cosman).
- Saw the pins to the line (or at least try to), on the waste side, leaving them just a hair thick (very important)
- For through dovetails, use the coping saw to remove most of the waste. For half-blinds, use the drill press with a 1/4" Forstner bit (using the depth stop) to remove as much waste as possible, and drill from the pin board's ends with an 1/8" drill inside the waste
- Chisel the remaining waste, again undercutting just a whiff.
- No test-fitting
- Take off with a kinfe the inside corners of the tails (the side that won't show), to help in driving the tails in the pin board (Rosewood, Cosman).
- Hammer home
If you noticed, other than transferring the tails to the pin board there's no measuring and/or layout done anymore. I do like Klausz does, I figure that if he can do it I should be able to too.
Bottom line, I've managed to cut an hour (from the three in the beginning) in my process. With a bit of practice I'll find out how much more I can trim...
As for the joint itself, they're much much tighter. By leaving one of the two parts just a hair thick, the geometry of the joint forces the joint together tightly. That's the dirty little secret no one tells you... You see these guys in the videos, putting together the joint and it comes out perfect, you think that your skills are the reason for your less than perfect fit, while all the time all one had to do was to leave one side just a tad fat... Cosman used aspen and walnut in his video... Aspen is basically softer than pine, so even if the fit isn't perfect the aspen will get crushed in place with a seemingly perfect fit... Klausz used pine (I think) in his video, again it is soft enough to "conform" to the mating piece. I'd like to see these guys to a half-blind in hard maple or cocobolo...
And in case anyone is wondering, I've had no splits in my boards, it could be due to me using the same wood (which is not that hard) on both parts of the joint.
A few things that will help the process will be to get some butt chisels (I get cramps in my fingers after handling my long bench chisels for a while) and a couple skew chisels to help clean the half-blind corners. Also, I should get a forged hold-down soon, I don't know how Cosman can "chase" his board on the bench when he chops the waste, it is so frustrating and inefficient...
As for the choice of saws, I've come to like my LN dovetail saw more than at the beginning once I used it for a while, but my small rip dozuki remains my saw of choice when precision is critical, like when cutting the pins in the half-blind joints. I only wish it were sharper... I might try the LV professional rip dozuki, but I really like the size of the small one... We'll see...
That's all for now...
DC



