Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Santa Klausz is coming to town...

Posts

Santa Klausz is coming to town...

#1

Santa Klausz is coming to town...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.


>...aka progress report on dovetails...

Earlier this week I inquired about the time it took people to dovetail a drawer (through in the back and half blind in the front). Three hours was my average to accomplish the task, too long in my book. I received lots of good (and conflicting!) advice, thanks all. I also watched the videos from Cosman and Klausz again, paying lots of attention to all the steps in their respective method...

The weather is crappy around here, so it gave me the opportunity to go in the shop to take another stab at it... Since these drawers are for the shop, and are dovetailed only to give me some "dovetail mileage", if the result looks crappy that's no big deal. So I decided to go "all out" and streamline the process as much as I can. Today I did the following (adapted from my posting earlier this week):

- Plane boards' ends clean and square (Cosman)

- Use the marking gauge (Tite-Mark) to set the various thicknesses to mark. Make the mark just a hair thicker than the board to cut down on planing after the drawer is completed

- Gang up the sides together (Becksvoort)

- Saw the tails freehand, like Klausz does for his pins

- Cut off the half pin waste to the line, leaving it just a hair fat

- Chop the waste down to the baseline, undercutting ever so slightly (Klausz)

- Put the pin board in the vise, set the height using a plane, register the tail board on top, and mark with a knife (Cosman).

- Saw the pins to the line (or at least try to), on the waste side, leaving them just a hair thick (very important)

- For through dovetails, use the coping saw to remove most of the waste. For half-blinds, use the drill press with a 1/4" Forstner bit (using the depth stop) to remove as much waste as possible, and drill from the pin board's ends with an 1/8" drill inside the waste

- Chisel the remaining waste, again undercutting just a whiff.

- No test-fitting

- Take off with a kinfe the inside corners of the tails (the side that won't show), to help in driving the tails in the pin board (Rosewood, Cosman).

- Hammer home

If you noticed, other than transferring the tails to the pin board there's no measuring and/or layout done anymore. I do like Klausz does, I figure that if he can do it I should be able to too.

Bottom line, I've managed to cut an hour (from the three in the beginning) in my process. With a bit of practice I'll find out how much more I can trim...

As for the joint itself, they're much much tighter. By leaving one of the two parts just a hair thick, the geometry of the joint forces the joint together tightly. That's the dirty little secret no one tells you... You see these guys in the videos, putting together the joint and it comes out perfect, you think that your skills are the reason for your less than perfect fit, while all the time all one had to do was to leave one side just a tad fat... Cosman used aspen and walnut in his video... Aspen is basically softer than pine, so even if the fit isn't perfect the aspen will get crushed in place with a seemingly perfect fit... Klausz used pine (I think) in his video, again it is soft enough to "conform" to the mating piece. I'd like to see these guys to a half-blind in hard maple or cocobolo...

And in case anyone is wondering, I've had no splits in my boards, it could be due to me using the same wood (which is not that hard) on both parts of the joint.

A few things that will help the process will be to get some butt chisels (I get cramps in my fingers after handling my long bench chisels for a while) and a couple skew chisels to help clean the half-blind corners. Also, I should get a forged hold-down soon, I don't know how Cosman can "chase" his board on the bench when he chops the waste, it is so frustrating and inefficient...

As for the choice of saws, I've come to like my LN dovetail saw more than at the beginning once I used it for a while, but my small rip dozuki remains my saw of choice when precision is critical, like when cutting the pins in the half-blind joints. I only wish it were sharper... I might try the LV professional rip dozuki, but I really like the size of the small one... We'll see...

That's all for now...

DC

Re: Santa Klausz is coming to town...

#2

Re: Dirty secret

Thom D


>Actually I don't think the dirty little secret is that they just force them together. Any wood that is softer is generally also that much easier to split. Woods don't necessarily vary directly, since there are grain features also, but it's sure pretty direct for some of the woods mentioned.

Earlier in this thread someone mentioned that they sand in dust to cover the errors. I haven't seen that be effective either, you might fool your dog, but not someone who doesn't love you. There are ways of hiding minors errors and they largely have to do with finishing the ends (filing is good) so that the result is a kind of peening of material right at the joint itself, You can cover a multitude of sins, and it works in hard woods. Krenov mentioned it in his dovetailing section. However, when I have to do this, it's how I am hiding 5% of the joint not 95%. Mine fit together tightly, but somewhere on a utilitarian set there may be a minor goof, and I can hide it. It's not like I'm caulking with a 1/4" nozzle.

Matching dark and light wood also hides errors a little bit. So for instance the Klausz joints in pine are probably harder to fool people with than poplar and walnut. Also I give some credence to Kluasz's explanation that he used pine in the horrid desk he built because it didn't justify better wood. I would be pretty surprised if he was faced with some maple on maple joints if they didn't turn out perfectly, certainly the joints in the tool tray of his bench look good. He is a very competent guy, I just don't see why he couldn't do it. I can do maple on maple dovetails by hand, and I'm just a beginner comparatively.

Overall, though, nothing succeed like just getting them right. For me the hardest part was learning to leave the right allowance. I couldn't describe it really, it's just an acquired tolerance relative to the tools and my layout.

Re: Santa Klausz is coming to town...

#3

Re: Santa Klausz is coming to town...

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown, PA


>I've only cut a few practice dovertails by hand. At first, my experiences were not too good at all. A lot of paring down to the line, then they were too thin, etc etc.

After watching Cosmans video a few times, I finally started to understand what cutting to the line, and then splitting the line meant. I tried again, cutting as close as I could manage to my lines on the tails, coped the waste out and chiseled, and then transferred that to the pins board. Then, like Rob did, I split the line, putting a little more of the saw on the waste side. Cope and chisel the waste again, and then put them together. Much to my suprise, they went together. A lot tighter than I would have liked (my sawing isn't that good yet), but it definitely worked. I was using poplar for practice.

Now the problem I have to work on is chiseling to my knife line (for the thickness). I have a tendency to dig down into the board, leaving an unseemly line. Practice there, too, and I should take my chisels to the sharpening stones again.

I agree about getting a holdfast - I ended up bracing my boards against a bench dog to keep them in place.

Re: Santa Klausz is coming to town...

#4

Re: Santa Klausz is coming to town...

Dave Burnard


>Which (rip?) dozuki are you using for your dovetails? I might be able to recommend something better. I use the Izeamon rip dozuki that Japan woodworker sells. Very fast and accurate.

Re: Santa Klausz is coming to town...

#5

Re: Santa Klausz is coming to town...

Ted Wong


>Well I'm a lot slower than you and I guess I really don't care. A wise old woodworker once told me, "slow is good". I won't mention his name but his work speaks for itself and I don't ever recall him being in a hurry to knock out his dovetails.

Re: Santa Klausz is coming to town...

#6

Re: Santa Klausz is coming to town...

John Pappas


>"I split the line, putting a little more of the saw on the waste side."

I have never been able to understand the logic of "splitting the line". Graham Blackburn demonstrated dovetails at a show here and he pointed out that if you look carefully at the piece you have marked (while still holding the parts together) you can see the line, and therefore if you make the cut correctly, you should still be able to see the line. What he was saying, I believe, is that the cut should just touch the edge of the line. When you say you leave a little more of the saw on the waste side you are, in essence, leaving the line, not splitting the line. Maybe I'm splitting hairs here.

Re: Santa Klausz is coming to town...

#7

Re: Santa Klausz is coming to town...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.


>I checked JWW, your saw better be good, at the price...

The one I use is this one:

http://www.leevalley.com/wood/page.aspx?c=1&p=50663&cat=1,42884

I like its small size, feels perfect in the hand (I think a regular dozuki would feel awkward for cutting DTs because of its size). For the price it can't be beat I think (I sure wouldn't expect better). But it would be nice if it were sharper...

DC

Re: Santa Klausz is coming to town...

#8

Re: Santa Klausz is coming to town...

Thom D


>". What he was saying, I believe, is that the cut should just touch the edge of the line. When you say you leave a little more of the saw on the waste side you are, in essence, leaving the line, not splitting the line. Maybe I'm splitting hairs here."

That's logical for the second cut, because you are matching up the parts. But in a lot of cases one is doing initial cuts, and if someone feels they are getting better results leaving something behind, so be it.

Also, knife lines are pretty close to zero thickness, and can be placed flush, so spliting then is a precise location with zero set-off from the piece. Pencil lines are a different mater, and cover a lot of geography, which is why, for me it's a feel thing.

Also, whenever I lay in a pencil line I aways give it another look and try to pick which point on it actually representative of the dimension I want, then I knife or cut that line. Having a pencil line there is often faster than laying the line in accurately, but it won't be accurate unless one picks a reference point on the line. Often I lay a line like that in a little askew, that makes it easy to pick the precise point, for instance, half way along the line.

There is also the question of whether one actually tries to trace a line, or simple uses it to aim at an endpoint. I'm moreso in the later camp. When driving I look where I want to go, and not at the edge of the road trying to trace the car along it. In that case one has a starting point and a finish point, that there should be a line between the two is not all that significant.

Re: Santa Klausz is coming to town...

#9

Re: Santa Klausz is coming to town...

Gary B in Central NY


>Denis,

I use the same saw as you and concur, it's a great saw for the money, I have a disston that I set and sharpened, but I find myself reaching for that little dozuki more often.

Gary

Re: Santa Klausz is coming to town...

#10

Re: Santa Klausz is coming to town...

charles


>Anything over an hour for a small drawer becomes more an academic exercise than a reasonable dovetailing strategy in the shop. Your intuition is correct, you must pick up speed.

Two of the dovetails in a drawer are through-dovetails and in thin stock (drawer sides and back). You ought TO BE ABLE TO FLY on these. You should be able to clear sockets with two to four 'chops' in thin, soft drawer side and back material (Pine, Poplar). Not too many more than that if you use a harder species.

Put the coping saw away. You need a saw, mallet, an old dull scraper blade, a sharp pencil, and a few chisels.

Re: Santa Klausz is coming to town...

#11

Re: Why the hurry?

Ted Shuck, Centennial, CO


>If you are working in a production shop and time means money, then efficiency and speed are of the utmost importance. However, most of the people on this board are hobbyists and do this "work" for personal satisfcation and relaxation. I feel no need to push myself for a time goal while working on a project. It is much more important for me to enjoy the process, work carefully, and avoid the screwups that can spoil a good day in the shop for a hobbyist.

Best Regards,

Ted

Re: Santa Klausz is coming to town...

#12

Re: Why the hurry?

charlesstanford


>Dovetails are just another joint on the way to finishing a project.

Maybe I've lost that lovin' feeling but I don't really savor a three hour drawer. That's almost an hour a corner and I think that's objectively way too long regardless of one's hobbyist status. The reasonably adept would almost have to try to make the process take that long. Once you have a few under your belt, it just doesn't take 45 minutes a corner.

I get the impression that the original poster wants to get them done more quickly. Maybe I got the wrong impression.

Re: Santa Klausz is coming to town...

#13

The original poster...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.


>That would be me...

This thread (and the one before) was an attempt to gauge myself against other woodworkers, to compare methods and time used. At the same time I want to make my dovetails tighter.

There is progress on both sides, the last drawer is down to 1h 45m (nearly cut the time in half), but I don't think I'll be able to trim much more time off this.

I'd really love to watch someone do a whole drawer in an hour...

DC

Seven down, seven to go

Re: Santa Klausz is coming to town...

#14

Re: The original poster...

charlesstanford


>You can watch Tage Frid's video, he's super fast. plus I'm thinking of doing one myself (on the cheap). There's too much B/S floating around the internet about cutting dovetails.

I have always loved Frid's presentation - a relaxed 'means to an end' approach instead of an 'end in themselves' approach.

Just for $hits and giggles, I've cut them with a bowsaw and the beauty of using one is that you're done in one long stroke of the saw - all the way down to your incised line. Boom.

Like I said in my earlier post - two of the corners in drawer construction are through dovetails and in thin stock to boot. There is no reason these ought not to go extremely well and fast. Obviously the half-blinds are a little more ticklish because you don't want to bugger nice drawer front material, but if you've done your stock selection well it should go just fine.

I'd also suggest just using a pencil for layout like Klausz. Just learn where to cut and you don't have to fool around with a marking knife which can follow the grain if you aren't careful. You don't have to press hard. Just make one pencil stroke makes all the line you'll need.

All other things being equal, IMO pins first is faster.

Re: Santa Klausz is coming to town...

#15

Re: The original poster...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.


>Thanks, I'll try to find the Frid video (where, though?)

I don't think I'm ready for the bowsaw yet. Controlling a small saw is hard enough right now...

I lean towards the pencil too, maybe it's just my knife that's too sharp... Besides, when you "cut to the line" if you're just a bit too close to the knife line the saw wants to sit in the line and ride it, making the joint loose... A pencil line avoids the problem.

Why do you think that pins first is faster? I do tails for both sides at once, something you can't do with pins first...

DC

Re: Santa Klausz is coming to town...

#16

Re: The original poster...

Thom D


>If you're fast, you aren't hurried, working faster than someone who is slow. It might seem to someone who can barely walk at 90 that all the young people are just rushing about, but for the youg'ns, it is a pleasant pace. For me, part of the hobby is personal improvement as a woodworker. So I enjoy trying to be faster. Also, the best work can be done fast. I have seen lots of people who can go as slow as they want and it won't improve the result one bit. While speed implies organization, and a well thought out process going from task to task as efficiently as possible. There certainly is a speed where quality will start to suffer. One needs to find one's own pace.

Re: Santa Klausz is coming to town...

#17

Speed vs Competence

Dan Clermont in Burnaby


>If I understand correctly Denis is quite new to HandCut dovetails and as time goes on he will get faster and faster once he is happy with the quality of the joint he is cutting.

No point in going really fast and claiming to have done a joint in under 1 hour if you are unhappy with the way it looks or fits.

Speed comes after you become comfortable with your technique and the quality of your joint is meeting your standards

Cheers

Dan Clermont

Re: Santa Klausz is coming to town...

#18

Re: The original poster...

charles


>I think it's faster to manipulate the pin board on top of the tail board without bringing the vise into play. You don't need any sort of clamps at all except on big drawers or a carcase side and maybe not even then - if the pin board is cut off truly square and the tail board is flat then the pin board will sit up on it pretty easily with only a light touch needed from the non-marking hand to keep it still.

Re: Santa Klausz is coming to town...

#19

Re: The original poster...

charles


>You'll cut 'em fast and fine soon enough.

FWIW, Klausz and Frid always show how to repair a gap. It happens to everybody from time-to-time. Even guys of that repute.

Woodworking is a lot like golf, you can't let a mistake every now and then freak you out. In golf, the most important shot is the next one. In woodworking, just fix it and move on. Going painfully slow to avoid the psychological impact of having made a 'mistake' will not serve you well in the long run.

Re: Santa Klausz is coming to town...

#20

I like this lesson....

Wiley Horne


>Quote: "Going painfully slow to avoid the psychological impact of having made a 'mistake' will not serve you well in the long run."

__________

Actually, I think Denis is doing great, and needs no lessons from me.

But this statement by Charles captures something that I think is at the heart of hand work. Not that I particularly do things Charles' way--I'm way more prissy than what he describes, clamping stuff in vises and the like.

But I have learned the hard way to go for the money cut and deal with the consequences. As opposed to saw fat and pare, or mortise thin and pare. For me, the lesson is not about the time that is used or saved--it's getting past the fear of mistakes that is important. Working with confidence, knowing that everything is survivable, is the main pleasure I get from hand wood working.

Wiley

Re: Santa Klausz is coming to town...

#21

Re: I like this lesson....

Dan Clermont


>Good points Wiley.

I have built many projects and always find the time to challenge myself.

Each project I build could have been done using easier methods but the addition of trying to do a sliding dovetail with handtools and then trying to figure out how you could have made it better are what draw me to the hand tool side.

Same goes with sharpening. How sharp is sharp enough along with how wel can you plane a board without tearing out.

Cheers

Dan Clermont

Re: Santa Klausz is coming to town...

#22

Trimming more time from your dovetails

Angus Barclay, in New Zealand


>Hello Denis,

. . . but I don't think I'll be able to trim much more time off this.

You most certainly CAN trim more time off your current 1 hour 45 minutes.

For the pins on half-blind dovetails you're cutting trapezoid shapes, not round holes, so you can save time by eliminating the drill press.

Save yourself the time spent chucking a drill bit, setting the depth stop, taking each workpiece from bench to machine, aligning the board, and drilling.

The fastest tool to remove this waste is a chisel, not a drillpress.

Removing waste from half-blind pins

Step 1: Put a chisel about 1/16th into the waste from the baseline and chop about 3/16ths into the board.

Step 2: Drive a narrower chisel in from the end of the board and lever out the resulting chip.

Step 3: Line up chisel with sawn sides of pins and chop vertically into the blind corner.

Step 4: Rinse. Repeat. Wipe Hands on Pants.

Step 5: Pare away the final 1/16th to get to your marked lines.

When starting with this technique, chop with light mallet taps on your chisels. When you've built up a bit of confidence you'll soon figure out how hard you can hit a chisel to drive it to the depth you want. I usually take two blows - one fairly light tap to "set" the chisel into the wood and one powerful whack to drive it in.

BTW, I believe the real pros don't even do step 5. They're confident enough to chop right to their marks.

regards

Angus Barclay

Re: Santa Klausz is coming to town...

#23

Re: I like this lesson....

charles


>Wiley, most guys think cutting a joint that's too tight is not a 'mistake' but it really is as big a mistake as a slightly gappy joint. It's faster to fix a gap. Cutting dovetails fat and then *painfully* paring each tail to a fit just makes me cringe.

You're exactly right,,,, go for the money cut (hey, who's watching anyway?),,, the joint that fits straight from the saw,,,, try to split the line,,, not cut wide and pare back,,,,

Getting into the habit of cutting wide and paring all your joints will turn you back into a power tool woodworker faster than anything I know. For hobbyists, with limited time at night after work and on weekends, it just seems unfeasible from a time perspective.

Re: Santa Klausz is coming to town...

#24

Re: Why the hurry?

GolfSteve in Calgary


>My theory is that I should get good first and speed will follow. Then I'll practice for thirty more years.