Follow-up on LN iron adventure
Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)
>Executive summary: Advice was requested owing to the difficulty experienced in obtaining an even shaving with a 6 year old NOS (new old stock) iron in a equally NOS LN #4 1/2 plane. After careful examination, the plane checked out as fitting perfectly in all important aspects pertinent to controling the cut. The conclusion drawn was that there was something wrong with the blade, and the conclusion drawn was that fault(s) lay with either the sharpening technique, the composition of the steel, the construction of the iron, or a combination of the above. Since an alternative iron, from Clifton, was honed on the same waterstones and thereafter worked correctly, the finger appeared to point more at the construction or composition of the iron.
The iron was returned to LN for examination. Below is the reply I have just received from Thomas L-N:
Derek,
I was away at a show this week, and when I returned your blade was on my desk. We tested hardness, which was fine, and then I put a straight edge on the edge - there is a very small hollow in the blade, but enough to produce the symptoms you described. We tested the blade in a plane and found that the center portion did in fact not cut while the edges were cutting a fine shaving. I hope you have the new blade by now, and that you are getting great results with the tool. Please let me know!
Thanks for sending the blade back so I could check it out.
Best wishes,
Thomas
So scratch difficulties with the composition of the iron. The message does not explain why the hollow was there. Whether it was due to construction (and, inspite of a "DC Ruler Trick Backbevel", that the back of the iron was not flattened sufficiently), or because (and politely not mentioned!) that the user (yours truly) stuffed up the sharpening. While I would be surprised at the latter, I do not exclude it!
Throughout, LN have been wonderfully supportive and helpful (as usual). I have also received a beautiful new replacement iron. It is flat and looks quite different to the original. It is now Saturday morning and this weekend I shall hone it up and make some shavings and report on it. Until later (as I dash off to do the demands of my dear wife).
Regards from Perth
Derek



