Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Follow-up on LN iron adventure

Posts

Follow-up on LN iron adventure

#1

Follow-up on LN iron adventure

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)


>Executive summary: Advice was requested owing to the difficulty experienced in obtaining an even shaving with a 6 year old NOS (new old stock) iron in a equally NOS LN #4 1/2 plane. After careful examination, the plane checked out as fitting perfectly in all important aspects pertinent to controling the cut. The conclusion drawn was that there was something wrong with the blade, and the conclusion drawn was that fault(s) lay with either the sharpening technique, the composition of the steel, the construction of the iron, or a combination of the above. Since an alternative iron, from Clifton, was honed on the same waterstones and thereafter worked correctly, the finger appeared to point more at the construction or composition of the iron.

The iron was returned to LN for examination. Below is the reply I have just received from Thomas L-N:

Derek,

I was away at a show this week, and when I returned your blade was on my desk. We tested hardness, which was fine, and then I put a straight edge on the edge - there is a very small hollow in the blade, but enough to produce the symptoms you described. We tested the blade in a plane and found that the center portion did in fact not cut while the edges were cutting a fine shaving. I hope you have the new blade by now, and that you are getting great results with the tool. Please let me know!

Thanks for sending the blade back so I could check it out.

Best wishes,

Thomas

So scratch difficulties with the composition of the iron. The message does not explain why the hollow was there. Whether it was due to construction (and, inspite of a "DC Ruler Trick Backbevel", that the back of the iron was not flattened sufficiently), or because (and politely not mentioned!) that the user (yours truly) stuffed up the sharpening. While I would be surprised at the latter, I do not exclude it!

Throughout, LN have been wonderfully supportive and helpful (as usual). I have also received a beautiful new replacement iron. It is flat and looks quite different to the original. It is now Saturday morning and this weekend I shall hone it up and make some shavings and report on it. Until later (as I dash off to do the demands of my dear wife).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure

#2

detecting a flat back

Dave Thompson


>Hi Derek, Thanks for the update. I�m glad you got your issue sorted out, and it sounds like you got a new A2 iron upgrade too�.

FWIW, I don�t use the ruler trick. I just presume that any new blade I get, the back is not flat and proceed to flatten it. Out of the last 100 or so plane blades and chisels I�ve bought and tuned up (both used and new), I�d guess more than 95% of the backs need some degree of flattening or polishing. Just rub the back of the blade on a piece of sand paper attached to some glass, and in about 5-10 seconds, the slightest hollows will clearly show themselves. If the back of the blade is already a mirror finish and you want to check it without introducing scratches, just use 2000 grit sand paper and a sharpie pen.

Good luck,

Dave

Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure

#3

Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure

Dan Clermont in Burnaby


>Glad it al got sorted out in a timely manner.

Just curious, do you lap the backs of blades when you recieve a new plane or do you simply do the Charlesworth ruler trick?

FWIW I tend to skip back flattenings and go straight to the ruler trick without any problems.

Looking Forward to your LV vs LN review

Dan C

Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure

#4

Re: detecting a flat back

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)


>FWIW, I don�t use the ruler trick. I just presume that any new blade I get, the back is not flat and proceed to flatten it. Out of the last 100 or so plane blades and chisels I�ve bought and tuned up (both used and new), I�d guess more than 95% of the backs need some degree of flattening or polishing.

Hi Dave

I, too, never assume that the back of a new blade is flat. The replacement LN blade looks quite different from the original. The back is flat. Looks like it was flattened around the bevel area with 1200 or there abouts in the picture but was much shinier in reality so could be a higher grit. The bevel looks like a 1200 grit. This is all pre-honing on my waterstones, which I will do before I use the blade in earnest.



Here is a picture of the original blade after flattening on a 800 waterstone. I did not finish at this point, and did take it all the way to the edge, but I stopped here having had the inspiration to take a picture (because I was surprised at the amount I was having to remove - as I have mentioned before, I have several LN planes plus many more LN aftermarket blades, and I considered this one a rogue).



Incidentally, just before I returned this blade I noted that it did not have any labeling, that is, did not have the LN name on it (ws just blank). Someone might use this to date it?

My opinion of DC's Ruler Trick is that it is not for flattening a blade's back but really for making certain that the edge of the bevel is in one plane and smooth. What I meant to say is that I did this inaddition to flattening the back. I haven't heard anything in this regard back from LN (I sent them the blade "as is" from the last shaving it made).

Since I had also honed the already-discussed Clifton blade, plus a LN "Stanley Replacement" for another #4 1/2, plus two irons for my Spiers infill smoother, and all of these performed satisfactorally, I was mystified what was going on. Still am.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure

#5

Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)


>Dan

I have just replied to Dave on this matter.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure

#6

Re: detecting a flat back

Dave Thompson


>Incidentally, just before I returned this blade I noted that it did not have any labeling, that is, did not have the LN name on it (ws just blank). Someone might use this to date it?

In 2002 they switched to A2 and started labeling their blades.

My opinion of DC's Ruler Trick is that it is not for flattening a blade's back but really for making certain that the edge of the bevel is in one plane and smooth.

I kind of combined two points into one and probably confused my message. The second point was that rubbing the back on some 2k grit sand paper attached to glass for about ~5 seconds can be used as a detection method. The advantages is if the back is not flat, this will leave a permanent profile of the hollows on the back of the blade. Of course, if you don't always have sand paper attached to a piece of glass in your shop, like I do, it may not be as convenient ;-)

enjoy,

Dave

Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure

#7

Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure

charles


>Why all the rigamarole when you could have/should have just lapped it flat? As somebody else said, a swipe or two on a fine stone or abrasive-on-glass would have revealed the 'problem.'

Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure

#8

Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure

Hound_va


>He stated that he did in fact lap the back flat to the edge. That said, it would appear that he has a slight problem either in, most likely technique, or equipment for making things flat. I suspect the blade had a slight hollow to begin with and either because of technique or equipment he inadvertantly managed to mask the slight hollow with the scratch marks and therefore left the hollow rather than removing it. Since he has successfully flattened other blades, which now work as expected, that would lead me to believe his equipment is at least OK and his technique is typically sound. It just happens that somehow he managed to hide the hollow during and after his efforts at flattening.

Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure

#9

Re: detecting a flat back

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)


>The second point was that rubbing the back on some 2k grit sand paper attached to glass for about ~5 seconds can be used as a detection method.

I essentially do the same. In place of sandpaper, I use a waterproof blue sharpie ("texta" in Oz) to mark the back of the blade, then run this over a freshly flattened 8000 waterstone (you can see the edges of blue in the photo of the original blade, in the post above). For reference, I flatten my waterstones on 220 grit drywall mesh using DC's suggestion of scribbling lines over the 'stones to judge wear patterns.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure

#10

Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure

charles


>Cool.

I turned iron lapping chores over to my son when he was around 12 years old. I haven't had any complaints so far. He's 16 now.

Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure

#11

Two problems w/ technique

woodburnbob


>Sounds like you're still trying to figure out how you put that belly in the formerly (presumably) straight cutting edge of the LN blade.

I think everyone goes through this when they start sharpening plane blades. But, I also think you generate too many untested assumptions for yourself and prematurely rule-out potential explanations with too little evidence to rule them out. And, it keeps you from understanding what's going on.

What you've just posted are two cases in point:

1. "...I use a waterproof blue sharpie ... to mark the back of the blade, then run this over a freshly flattened 8000 waterstone (you can see the edges of blue in the photo of the original blade, in the post above)."



Even if you "run this over" a metrologist's cast iron surface plate certified at 0.0001 per 12", there's no guarantee you'll get good information using that technique. The issue is unavoidable slight rotations of the blade with hand held movement. The witness marks over many points of time and many locations won't necessary mirror standard measures of flatness such as "blued" spot marks to a flat reference plate, surface gauging, or optical methods.

Perform this experiment for yourself. Find a plane blade with a flat back. Use a machinist's straight edge and check flatness by linearity of width, length, and diagonals (just on the last inch or so next to the cutting edge). Of course, if you have a good surface plate and some bluing compound, use that for inspection along with the straightedge.

"Flaten" the back vigorously with a coarse stone with only side-to-side left-right movements. Use the straighedge to see what happened. [You put in a major left-right convexity.]

Now, with another flat back, vigorously use only back-and-forth fore-aft movements. Do as much abrading as your endurance will permit. Again use the staightedge to see what happened. [You put in a major fore-aft convexity.]

Spend another day on another blade but alternate fore-aft strokes with right-left stroke and behold a nice dome.

Until you do this and prove to yourself the falacies involved in blue markers, scratch marks and so forth you may not be able to get to the point where you can imagine the three dimensional effect this has on how straight a cutting edge will or will not be.

This whole issue of how a "flat" determines the linearity of one of it's edges, is the same for the bevel side "flat" (micro-bevel or not). If you come back and mess around with another "flat", a back bevel, no matter how small, according to what's being called the "ruler trick" these days...well, no telling what higher order polynomial curve best represents what one wrongly assumes is a "straight" cutting edge.

Don't get me wrong. I use a process analogous to the "ruler trick" sometimes, but recognize the potential risks and trade-offs.


2. "For reference, I flatten my waterstones on 220 grit drywall mesh..."

Assuming the mesh accurately parallels it's substrate, the substrate determines the surface topography. At the extreme, imagine the mesh is atop a bowling ball versus inside a mixing bowl, rather than atop a theoretically assumed "flat" surface. These spherical surfaces have a radius of less than a foot. Imagine a spherical surface with a radius of twenty feet. Over the surface of your 3" X 8" stone could you be expected to detect the transferred spherical surface.

Indeed, this abrading one surface against another is how the ancients made lenses, as everyone knows. And, their ancestors determined the earth was flat through inferences drawn erroneously because of matters of scale and point of view!

Incidentally, I believe there are standards or guidelines by which a small object to be flattened can be moved against a larger flat abrasive object without rounding the small object or degrading the flatness of the large object. Those standards have to do with the size ratio of the objects, the nature of the movements, and how much relative time the small object spends moving on various segments of the large object.

An interesting experiment would be to try flattening down a waterstone a half inch or so by the drywall mesh technique. I'd predict you cannot avoid producing a domed waterstone...which, by the way, would produce a cutting edge identical to the one you show.

Those interest in pursuing such topics more might want google material on "originating a flat surface" from three roughly flat surfaces.



Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure

#12

Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure

nap


>Why is it so hard to admit that you messed up sharpening the blade? You've got the same thread on a couple different boards all trying to find some sort of fault with LN. You put to much finger pressure in the middle of the blade while sharpening... no big deal just admit it.

Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure

#13

Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)


>Why is it so hard to admit that you messed up sharpening the blade?

Actually Neil I have never discounted that and, in fact, have emphasised it on several occasions. I am still in contact with Thomas L-N (had an email from him last night about the blade), and I am more than willing to take the rap here.

From the thoughts of others and, especially the feedback so far from LN (there will be more coming), it looks like a poor sharpening job. My posting here at this time is not to re-open a thread, but to bring to all the information I have since the last thread. What I would like to better understand is why I obtained the different result I did using various similar planes and blades having honed them on the same substrates.

I regret having originally referred to LN as the maker of the blade (all I can say is that I was in a rush and did not consider the ramifications). Perhaps if I had just stated the facts (as I detailed) without a plane identification, the subsequent discussion would have been more intellectual and less emotional.

For a reference on the factor that you raised, in addition to urging you to re-read my second last paragraph to my opening post here, here a link to one of the times I discussed the possible cause.

Regards from Perth

Derek (getting out the cutlery in preparation to eating crow)


Link to discussion

Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure

#14

Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure

Joel


>"What I would like to better understand is why I obtained the different result I did using various similar planes and blades having honed them on the same substrates."

real simple.

if you have a slightly convex stone (which is easy on screens) it is next to impossible to flatten them truly on a wire mesh screen. the stone rocks and the convexity is kept. For most people stones are concave so flattening them on screens (or anything) is easy as long as you don't over flatten (then they go convex).

If the iron starts out slightly hollow - very common BTW and you have a slightly convex stone it stays slightly hollow. expecially on harder allows. you would get a consistent scratch pattern but a straightedge would reveal the problem. ona flat stone the concavity would dissapear in a flash.

if you have a flat iron on a convex stone - expecially on harder alloys it stays flat for the same reason. going back and forth on a convex stone takes longer but the natural rocking of the hands get you a consistent scratch pattern and remove metal evenly.

Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure

#15

Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure

Joel


>I should mention that you are using the planes in your test as fine smoothers and taking a very very thin shavings. If the planes were being really used - not in a test - but for real as smoothers the irons would have a camber across them and putting on the camber on the irons would have negated any concavity in the iron no matter how it came to be there. Which is probably why nobody noticed it before your test (if the iron wasn't new).

Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure

#16

Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX


>Geesh, maybe one day people will read what you've actually written rather than making assumptions about what you will write and responding accordingly. Or even better, not be so critical until all the evidence is in.

Pam

Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure

#17

Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure

Todd Stock


>FWIW, the older LN blades sometimes needed a fair amount of work to flatten - almost as much as some of the old Hocks that I have. Both Hock and LN have improved with the A2 irons, with the last four irons from LN (#4 A2 replacement, #62 A2 replacement, #5-1/2, #7) taking on the order of fifteen minutes or so each to flatten (really just verify flatness), polish with diamond paste through 1 micron, an hone.

Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure

#18

Excellent, Joel!

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)


>Hi Joel

Excellent! I recognise that both points you make - the creation of a concave surface and the negation of this when using a cambered smoother - is the likely explanation. I am writing this as I take a quick lunch break inbetween the shelving and drywalls I am building in my wife's new office, but when I get back into my workshop I shall take a very close look at the 'stones. I should point out that I did use a straight edge to check them at the time, and they looked flat. But I will take a closer, more critical look this time.

Thanks for that.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure

#19

this affair is getting tiresome

bill tindall


>I wouldn't have thought that a problem with one plane out of thousands would merit so much discussion. One person's customer service problem should not have escalated into so much discussion.

Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure

#20

For me, too : )

Ted Owen, Moderator

Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure

#21

Inspecting the 'stones

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)


>Joel

I had a close look at the watertones I use - 800, 1200 and 8000 King.

They were all as flat as my reference Starrett rules. So I scribbled on each and flattened again on the 'stones, keeping a close eye on the manner in which the scribble was removed. It came away evenly.

For reference, the drywall screens are on a flat substrate made out of an old 2" thick and laminated kitchen benchtop. I frequently check that it is flat.

I really was hoping that one of the softer 800 or 1200 surfaces was rounded as you suggested earlier. It would have been easy to just blame this and get rid of this issue. In any event I will not post anymore about it (unless others really want me to continue for what we might learn here) [edited]. I will let all know what LN finds when they rehone and use the original blade. As I noted at the start, the only reason I began this particular thread was to keep everyone abreast of LN's findings.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure

#22

Best point of the thread!!

Bob Hackett

Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure

#23

there was no customer service problem

Larry Williams


>It appears to me that Lie-Nielsen has shown how far they will go to help people develop the most basic skills. [edited]

Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure

#24

Man, you got that right! (yeah, rant mode and all)

John in NM


>I'd guess the moral of this one is don't come here with a problem unless its an easy one to solve [edited] and it involves generic and preferable low quality products that will not offend anyone's brand loyalties. I usually prefer to stay out of these sorts of threads, but they seem to be coming up a lot more often, which I find to be a disturbing trend. It lowers the quality of this forum and makes many of us look elsewhere for hand tool discussion.

John

Re: Follow-up on LN iron adventure

#25

Re: this affair is getting tiresome

Geppetto


>I am glad Derek posted the results of his blade problem.It was a basic problem and should have never been overlooked

Doesn't really give me allot of faith in a true "plane off" between brands to determine which one is better as the blades need to get sharpened by someone.

One also needs to consider he has recieved several products from one manufacturer.

It ought to be interesting.

Gep