Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Record Type Info?

Posts

Record Type Info?

#1

Record Type Info?

Dave Thompson

>I was wondering if anyone might have some typing information to share regarding Record planes. In particular, I am curious to find out when the plane on the left might have been made. The others I know, (starting 2nd and going right) are made after 1978. in 1995, in 2001. Ofcourse the 2001 should have brown plastic handles instead of the cocobolo ones that are on there.

The older (left) plane in question is different from the other three in that:

  • It has a heavier casting at 8lbs, 2 oz. The others are 7lbs 4oz (corragated), 7lbs 11oz, 7lbs 12oz.

  • No rib down the middle in casting.

  • Yoke is cast rather than cut pressed metal

  • Depth adjustor has turn direction printed in it. (off - cut - on)

  • Hard angle cuts on iron and cap iron (rather than rounded over)

  • Record decal on tote is gold on blue rather than gold on transparent (in the ~'78)

  • Machining is mirror like on sole and sides.... reminiscent of a PM66 table top. Others are a bit rougher.

  • Frog bedding is solid.

  • Iron says "Best Crucible Cast Tungsten Steel" as opposed to "Tungsten Vanadium Steel"


While many of the aspects match up with drawing in my 1935 Record catalog, the details in the catalog are too lacking to draw much more than speculation from.

Thanks for any and all info you can share.

Dave


img

Re: Record Type Info?

#2

Record frog bedding 

Dave Thompson

>


img

Re: Record Type Info?

#3

Trying to help, but might not be any...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>The later year frog look a lot like a Stanley type 17 or so. Although Stanley's made in the USA never used ribs in thier castings.

Re: Record Type Info?

#4

Not sure I can help, but...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>The SS mention on the lever cap refers to Stay-Set cap iron. It should be in two parts (check the Clifton two piece cap iron for an idea of what it should look like), the idea being that you could sharpen the iron without taking the chip breaker off, and in theory it should clamp the iron more securely.

If the cap iron is one piece then you should question the authenticity of the plane. The frog is great, though, reminescent of the Stanley Type 11's, much more blade support...

HTH,

DC

Re: Record Type Info?

#5

Re: Record Type Info?

Alice Frampton, UK

>I'll see what I can do by culling info from the notes in the front of the 1938 Record catalogue reprint. Most is irrelevant anyway 'cos it's obviously before a lot of these cut off dates, but might as well do the thing properly!

- Stay Set: 1931 - mid-sixties. If it's got the patent number on the correct two-part cap iron (chip breaker) then it's pre-1947. Except confusingly it says "after 1947 production ceased so subsequently cap irons were not marked until they were eventually deleted from the range in the mid 1960's". Well hard to mark something you're not making, I agree... Anyway, make of that what you will.

- No rib: pre-1963

- Cast yoke: pre- to late 60s

- Depth adjuster markings: from my own observation this seems to be pre-war

- Angled corners to iron: pre-1953 to 1959

- Gold on blue decal: pre-1960

- Frog design: Straight sides and flat cutter seating pre-1957

- "Best Crucible Cast Tungsten Steel": pre-1960

In additon to your list of features, a few others that may help:

- Ground finish to top of curved edge of sides, toe and heel of body until about 1955-60

- Frog receiver changed from central rib to wishbone between 1955-60

- Revolving disc on lateral adjusment until WW2, replaced with solid disc until around 1985 when one piece pressed steel lever introduced.

- Handle and knob in rosewood until WW2 - which is probably your best age indicator. Subsequently stained beech until 1998 when plastic was introduced (yuck).

Other indicators depend on being able to tell the difference between cellulose paint and stove enamel, and nickel plating as opposed to it's substitues, so I didn't bother. ;~)

My gut instinct straight away was pre-war or thereabouts. The whole "pre-war" or not thing should be taken with a pinch of salt I think; I don't assume it means pre-1939 because inevitably they'd have been using up existing stock for some time. Plus you'll get the usual mixing of features depending what ran out first and so forth. It's a good plane though; Record at its best.

Cheers, Alf

Re: Record Type Info?

#6

Re: Rubbish!

paul womack

>Don't listen to a word Alice says. The plane on the left is utterly without merit, but as a personal favour, I'll dispose of it for you :-)

BugBear

Re: Record Type Info?

#7

Silly me!

Alice Frampton, UK

>Of course he's right.

Sorry, BB. That'll teach me to post early in the morning... ;~)

Cheers, Alf

Re: Record Type Info?

#8

Re: Record Type Info?

Dave Thompson


>- Stay Set: 1931 - mid-sixties. If it's got the patent number on the correct two-part cap iron (chip breaker) then it's pre-1947.

It has a patent no 362743 on the upper half of the SS cap iron.

- Ground finish to top of curved edge of sides, toe and heel of body until about 1955-60

The curved edges are ground. Unlike the other three.

- Revolving disc on lateral adjusment until WW2, replaced with solid disc until around 1985 when one piece pressed steel lever introduced.

Great, this helps me narrow down the second from the left to be pre-1985, and confirms the other two to be post 85.

- Handle and knob in rosewood until WW2 - which is probably your best age indicator. Subsequently stained beech until 1998 when plastic was introduced (yuck).

It does appear to be rosewood unlike the others.



Other indicators depend on being able to tell the difference between cellulose paint and stove enamel, and nickel plating as opposed to it's substitues, so I didn't bother. ;~)


Yes, I'm not very good at distinguishing among these. The detail might be lost on me.

Excellent information! Thanks for taking the time to post all of the extra details Alice. It sounds like you have the makings for a full type study. Do you have any plans to archive this on the web? or I guess you just did ;-)

Do you happen to know when Record first produced iron bench planes? I had thought this coincided with the purchase of Preston's iron works with a short overlap of both brands continuing to be made, though not sure about this. A while back I saw the below rare beauty listed on e-bay, and presumed it to be a great uncle to my Record in question.

Thanks again,

Dave


img

Re: Record Type Info?

#9

You guys are indeed too kind... ;-)

Dave Thompson

Re: Record Type Info?

#10

Re: Record Type Info?

Alice Frampton, UK


>Well really I doubt I should have posted that much, it being from a book currently in print and so forth... However, might as well be hanged for a sheep as well as a lamb:

C & J Hampton introduced Record bench planes in January 1931. The takeover of Preston is the usual confused information; officially it doesn't seem to have been until October 1934 (via John Rabone & Sons who bought Preston in 1932 apparently). However in Harrison's notes to the catalogue reprint he says the August 1933 price list from Record has obviously Preston-manufactured shoulder and bullnose planes listed. Either way, it's after Record bench planes hit the market. I think Preston was more the source for the less common designs for Record, bench planes being much of a muchness, but my knowledge of Preston is sketchy verging on non-existant and goodness knows what deals were done prior to Preston's sale to Rabone.

Cheers, Alf

Re: Record Type Info?

#11

Which book?

Dave Thompson


>Which book did you get the Record type info from? I think I might like to get a copy...

Thanks,

Dave

Re: Record Type Info?

#12

Re: Which book?

Alice Frampton, UK


>D'oh! Didn't I say? I left my head around here somewhere too... "Record Tools; A reprint of Catalogue No.15 of 1938 with a guide for plane collectors" by Leslie Harrison, printed by Roy Arnold 2003. ISBN 0 904638 14 6 I imagine all the usual suspects for such books in the US would have it. It's probably a bit of a duplicate of your 1935 catalogue though, Dave, so if you want to have that disposed of...? (Now I'm more on the ball, see BB?)

Cheers, Alf

Re: Record Type Info?

#13

Thanks again!

Dave Thompson

Re: Record Type Info?

#14

Re: Trying to help, but might not be any...

Dave Thompson


>Nice try.... According to Alice's info, it looks like it matches up in time with a Stanley type 16.

Thanks,

Dave

Re: Record Type Info?

#15

Ahh, Leave it to the folks form the UK!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

Re: Record Type Info?

#16

Re: Record Type Info?

John Horobin


>The plane on the left is mid 1950's or earlier. I would have to see a closer view of the depth adjuster and rear handle to date it more closely.

John

Re: Record Type Info?

#17

Re: Record frog bedding

John Horobin


>The early frogs can be changed with the Stanley type 14-15 - more or less exact copies!

John

Re: Record Type Info?

#18

Re: Record Type Info?

John Horobin


>Some early to mid 1950 planes had rosewood handles - these can easily be identified from the prewar examples.

John

Re: Record Type Info?

#19

More photos - depth adjuster

Dave Thompson


>Thanks for taking the time John. Here's a photo of the depth adjuster.


img

Re: Record Type Info?

#20

picture of the tote

Dave Thompson


>The dark spot on the tote is from an ancient $15 price tag that was held on by some now very difficult to remove scotch tape.


img

Re: Record Type Info?

#21

Picture of the rear and blade assembly 

Dave Thompson



img

Re: Record Type Info?

#22

Re: Picture of the rear and blade assembly

John Horobin


>Dave - I would put this one late 1940's to early 1950's. Its not a very early 1930's one assuming all parts are original. I've got a 1951/52 T5 & 010 with very similar rosewood handles and similar adjuster.

Hope this helps

John

Re: Record Type Info?

#23

Re: Picture of the rear and blade assembly

Dave Thompson


>Thanks for taking the time John. I appreciate your input.

BTW, I'm making good use of the 010 1/2 and 043 I bought from you a while back. They cleaned up nicely.

Dave

Re: Record Type Info?

#24

Re: Picture of the rear and blade assembly

Alice Frampton, UK


>So John exactly how much begging do we have to do to get a type study from you? Harrison's info, as you can see, is letting us down very badly. :~(

BTW, I actually checked my #4 with the marked depth adjuster wheel and see it has stained beech handles so definitely not when I thought it was. Apologies for going on my memory instead of checking, Dave.

Cheers, Alf

Re: Record Type Info?

#25

Re: Picture of the rear and blade assembly

John Horobin


>Thats good Dave - glad they were useful.

John