Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

First pass at power diamond lap

Posts

First pass at power diamond lap

#1

First pass at power diamond lap

Phil Smith

>From previous post Bill Tindall and I have looked for various ways to find inexpensive sources of cast iron for use as a substrate for diamond powder for sharpening hand tools. The picture below shows my first pass at a powered diamond lap. The source of the lap is a used rotor off the front of 1991 Saab 900. The rotor diameter is just over 11" and the width of the usable rotor surface for diamond powder is 2 inches. The front rotors off a Saab 9 5 Aero are just over 12" in diameter have a usable width of 2.75"

I had the rotor turned at a local parts store for $8.00 for one face. They are relucant to turn rotors which are too thin for reuse as brake disk but they were willing to turn just one face. The surface off the brake lathe is not suitable for use as a lap as the surface is too rough for the 1 micron diamond powder and this disk was slightly dished after turning, as determined by machinist square. What I mean by dished is that the inside edge of the disk was slightly lower that the outside edge of the disk. The machined surface itself was straight. I used 150 grit self adhesive sand paper on a 1/2" thick X 2" wide X 12" long cast iron lapping plate to true and smooth the disk surface. You could use a large diamond stone for this purpose but I don't have any fixed diamond stones. I pressed the lapping plate aganist the disk while the disk was slowly running on the lathe. The lathe is equipped with a variable speed DC motor so I can run the lathe very slowly. The brake disk was held on the lathe with a 4 jaw chuck, but a face plate should work just as well.

To use the disk for sharpening I charged the disk with 1 micron diamond powder using WD 40 as the lubricant. Run the disk slowly and slowly press the tool aganist the disk with the cutting edge facing away from the lathe rotation. I will post pictures of tools and disk in 2nd post.


img

Re: First pass at power diamond lap

#2

Picture of disk after use and chisels

Phil Smith

>Below is a picture of the brake disk after sharpeing a set of CPM 3V chisels. On a chisel where the edge is ground straight it took two passes on the disk of about 15 seconds each to get a bright shiney edge of about 1/32" across the width of the chisel. The disk did not seem any worse for wear after this short trial.

The chisels are all razor sharp. I am still learning how to get a good finish on the back. Technique is important I am learning for the backs. If you contact with the sharp edge first it takes a while to grind out the back bevel you put on the back.

With three disk and lapping compound you should be able to make 3 dead flat lapping surfaces in relatively short order. The cost of the disk are such that if one happens to get messed up you can easily get another.


img

Re: First pass at power diamond lap

#3

Back side of disk

Phil Smith

>Below is a picture of the backside of the brake disk.


img

Re: First pass at power diamond lap

#4

Re: Back side of disk

Thom D

>Nice experiment! Metal is always aluring for it's supposed dimensional stability. Have you also tried wood, as some like Boggs use?

Sees as though a lot of face plates are castings also.

Re: First pass at power diamond lap

#5

Re: First pass at power diamond lap

philip marcou

>Phil,

I am wandering why you have attched the the disc to the inboard side. If you had it on the outboard then it could remain there semi permanently?Or am I being dense?

Re: First pass at power diamond lap

#6

Re: Back side of disk

Phil Smith

>Yes we tried wood early on but is far too soft to be reasonalbe substrate for diamond. The diamond gets lost in the wood and does not cut effectively when compared to cast iron.

Re: First pass at power diamond lap

#7

Re: First pass at power diamond lap

Phil Smith

>You are absoutely right and I am considering that. But that means I will have to clean the shop to make room.

Re: First pass at power diamond lap

#8

Re: Back side of disk

James Watriss

>The fella that taught me about diamond lapping used MDF, because it was cheap, and easy to re-flatten. Have you tried this? I'd imagine it'd be a little harder than (some) woods, and a lot less porous, so you'd (conceivably) lose less of the diamond powder in it.

Also, it'd make sharpening things like carving chisels, molding plane irons, etc, a lot easier, as you can shape custom molded slipstones and such on the cheap...

The brake rotor idea is genius. This is why I love real woodworkers. I've been working a store, run by a certain well-known (and respected, I think) woodworking tool supply company, for about a year now while simultaneously learning at North Bennet Street School. It's a weird transition leaving the so-called "flat earth society," with all of the traditional hand-skill lessons, to walk into the land of anodized aluminum, phenolic whatzits, and expensive brand new shiny Lie Nielsen and Swiss made tools. Some of the customers fall for the latest in anodized wonder widgets, but some of them come in with stories.

Like the guy who was a patternmaker and retrofitted an old school bus to run on veggie oil. He was building it into a mobile home, with a shop in the back. He was doing this, because he was planning on moving to Virginia to work on timber frames. He passed on this website to me:

www.lindsaybks.com

They sell a variety of old and new books on old-school methods of making things. From stills to foundries and crucibles, to gassy food, to other things. On one page of their paper catalog I saw a warning explaing that some of the books were written before the advent of a lot of the modern safety standards and practices. Therefore, if the reader did not think himself competent to be safe, and to use a little common sense if he chose to practice the things in this book, perhaps said reader should put the catalog down and go watch TV. Awesome little outfit, and you all shoudl order the catalog. Even if you don't buy most of what's in it, there's a lot of cool information to be found.

But it's that last bit, about the disclaimer, that gets me. Common sense, and the ability to use your brain. Very nice, coming up with a cheap way to make a rotor for power-lapping. A brand new surface plate for a rotary lapper from an outfit like mine (if we sold power lapping stuff) would likely cost you hundreds.

Now that's what I call recycling.

Re: First pass at power diamond lap

#9

why not to use MDF or wood

bill tindall

>Imagine how tall a 1 micron diamond particle is. Put a 10X magnifing lens on some wood or MDF. Imagine how much of your diamond is going to be resting uselessly in the chasms. One will soon easily pay for a cast iron plate in the wasted diamond one uses on these materials. Now imagine how soft MDF is relative to a diamond and imagine how deep the steel will push the particle into the MDF in those places where it isn't sitting uselessly in a chasm. Diamond on these soft materials cuts as though it was a much finer particle, I suppose because most of it is buried. Then there is the gunge problem. It accumulates on these porous materials and eventually chokes the cutting action.

If you can't find a piece of cast iron then use acrylic. It is almost as good and I think better for the coarser diamond grits.

Re: First pass at power diamond lap

#10

Re: Picture of disk after use and chisels

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

>Good Idea! Our shop throws 5 or 6 away every week. Drive around any industrial park with car shops and you can fill your trunk with used (non servicable) rotors. JR

Re: First pass at power diamond lap

#11

Re: why not to use MDF or wood

Thom D

>Fair and all that, but Boggs is/was using maple so it can't be an unmitigated disaster. Also scarry sharp uses particles on top of paper, My money is on maple any day. MDF takes epoxy resin very nicely and that stuff significantly hardens it.

Iron can also be pretty coarse. Cast iron seems kinda knee jerk to me. I don't like the feel with carbide where the particles skate around, I haven't used diamond so obviously there are people loving it. I do recall the thread a while back, an ellegy to a certain cast iron, all sorts of amazing claims till I pointed out the main stock is for sewer pipe. Not that there is anything wrong with that.

Has anyone tried aluminum. Soft enough to grab your particles. Comes dead nuts flat and cheap almost anywhere.

I'm just hoping for a local source for the diamond.

Re: First pass at power diamond lap

#12

Stropping vs. honing

Wiley Horne

>In choosing a substrate, one of the early considerations is whether you want to strop, or to hone. In my experience, you get two different kinds of edges, according to whether you strop or hone. Each has its place, and they're not interchangeable.

The soft substrates let you strop. The metal substrates let you hone or strop.

Wiley