Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

shooting shoulders

Posts

shooting shoulders

#1

shooting shoulders

les winter

>Can anyone point me at a good article on shooting tenon shoulders with shoulder planes?

thanks

Les

Re: shooting shoulders

#2

Dog it and go

jim reed @ tallahassee

>Don't know of an article, but I know how. I just dog the workpiece to the bench (dog under working spot on tenon) and plane away. A Stanley #93 is good for this task. Remove the board often and test fit. I like my tenons snug but not tight. Good luck.

Re: shooting shoulders

#3

define "snug but not tight" for us novices

V Parisian

>Does tight mean forced to use an implement such as a hammer or something less? Snug meaning able to force together by hand with great effort or with slight effort. The lid on the pickle jar is tight, but when I'm desperate, I can usually get it loose with my bare hands but I feel like I'm about to bust something in my gut.

Regards from Houston

Victor

Re: shooting shoulders

#4

For me

jim reed @ tallahassee

>Snug means that I can force the tenon home with the soft part of my fist (and not leave a bruse). It also means that I can take the joint apart with my fist or with a slight tap of a mallet. This leaves room for the joint to swell without busting apart. It also can shrink without falling apart. Hope this helps.

Re: shooting shoulders

#5

Re: shooting shoulders

Charles

>If you incise deep lines and pare back with a chisel to give the saw a channel to run in you should never have to shoot a shoulder.

Re: shooting shoulders

#6

Re: Dog it and go

Charles

>Sounds like you're talking about planing tenon CHEEKS to fit the mortise wall.

The question was about shooting the shoulders.

Re: shooting shoulders

#7

Re: define "snug but not tight" for us novices

Ron in Kokomo

>I used to call it a piston fit. all surfaces touching. Should be able to join without whacking....but no slop.

Re: shooting shoulders

#8

Re: For me

Dan Clermont in Burnaby

>You don't want the joint so tight their is no room for glue so a tight - tight fit is not good. Take a couple of extra shavings of each side and chamfer the end grain so the glue works around the tenon.

As far as articles go ... I dunno....

Cheers

Dan Clermont

Re: shooting shoulders

#9

Re: Hook it and go

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>Jim,

Snug but not tight would be applicable to trimming cheeks, but not shoulders. Maybe that's why I'm having trouble visualizing your dog arrangement.

Les,

In any case, when trimming shoulders, I prefer using a bench hook (or better, two bench hooks, especially for long rails). The important consideration is the height and squareness of the end of the hook's fence, to prevent blowout (or spelching) of the far end of the cut. Short hooks work better for me than a deeper shooting board for this operation, because they keep the work up closer for a better grip on the shoulder plane, and keep more of the bench surface free for all the components that need to be at hand for the necessary trial fits you mention. Two hooks seem to work better than one, because they are lighter and easier to move around and to stow away when I'm done.

I'll try to describe the setup and positions in words, as I don't have a photo immediately available to post. Terminology is for tenons for frame and panel doors, but the concepts are universal. Also, this description is for left handers: Left edge of primary bench hook aligned with left side of rib cage (so left arm swings naturally straight forward and back. Secondary bench hook to your right, positioned depending on length of rail. Bench space to left of end of tenon cleared to lay shoulder plane down. Rail flat on top of both hooks, with tenon shoulder to be trimmed face up, aligned precisely with end of fence (using fingertip touch). Right hand pushes the rail down and back against both bench hook fences. Left hand picks up shoulder plane and places it on its side on top of the tenon, with sole facing towards the right. Trim cut is made with a push stroke. The cut usually removes a bit of the end of the fence as well as the end of the shoulder. You have to consider the fence expendable, and it will require a bit of maintenance from time to time.

If you are trimming the shoulder of a rail with a bead on the inside edge and you want to avoid spelching, you have two alternatives. Either make a coped sacrificial fence from a scrap offcut from the stile, and place it between the rail and the permanent fence, or learn to use the shoulder plane with either hand, so you can trim shoulders at either end of the rail, with a square face against the fence. If you are fitting a center rail between two panels, the coped scrap is the most effective alternative.

For trimming the ends of the shoulders in thin stock (e.g., 4/4) I use a completely different method, using a paring chisel wider than the thickness of the tenon, but narrower than the thickness of the rail. Therefore, a 5/8" chisel is the one I use most often. I stand at the end of the bench, and hold the rail upright in the face vise, with the tenon pointing upwards, and with the surface to be pared facing towards me. I have a metal face vise, and place the near edge of the rail beyond the guide rods and screw, and pull it up against the far edge of the rod while I tighten the vise. This keeps the work from pivoting away from me as I push the paring chisel into the end of the shoulder, because most of the force of the vise against the rail is at the top edge of the vise. A long chisel, or a chisel with a short blade and a long handle, helps considerably with the alignment of the cut. To start the cut, it usually helps to rest one end of the chisel's edge on the reference surface of the long shoulder you have just trimmed with the shoulder plane. After getting a good, straight cut I have an edge all the way across the shoulder that I can rest the chisel on, and I make another paring cut angled slightly downward to relieve the shoulder. Emphasizing what I noted above, the paring chisel must be narrower than the stock thickness if this relief cut is not to be visible on the show surfaces.

I hope this is clear. I've described these methods before, and they should be available in the archives. If you need more info on constructing a pair of bench hooks, that should be available in the archives or elsewhere, as well.

Re: shooting shoulders

#10

Excellent advice!!

Wiley Horne

>Paring shoulders is a game you can't win. It's not tough getting a shoulder face square and plumb. But then you've got 3 other faces that have to align with it in the same plane; after piddling around getting all 4 faces to align, you're beginning to encroach on the reference lines; plus it'll be a miracle if you don't spelch a sliver off the corner somewhere along the line.

Charles has good advice here.

Wiley

Re: shooting shoulders

#11

Re: Excellent advice!!

Charles

>Right on, Wiley! If I need to shoot a shoulder I've screwed up somewhere and shooting them is as likely to make it worse.

Cutting tenons is like cutting dovetails - the aim is a fit STRAIGHT FROM THE SAW. Anything else is, more or less, a failed effort. A swipe or two across the checks with a rasp is no big deal but extensive remodeling with a shoulder plane is a problem, whether you're having to work cheeks OR shoulders.

Re: shooting shoulders

#12

Re: shooting shoulders

Dean J in MN

>I agree, one of the benifits of using a marking knife are the witness lines it leaves behind. If you really need to adjust a shoulder they guide your chisel, never remove them from the work or you are walking down a path to disaster. Saw to the line, if you leave a bit proud of the lines clean up with the chisel, if you remove the witness mark, start over as you have spoiled the piece.

I havn't used my shoulder plane in a long long time. I keep pondering why on earth you need a tight mouth on a plane which was supposed to be doing end grain work to begin with? In other words, who designed this tool, craftsmen or salesmen?

-Dean

Re: shooting shoulders

#13

Re: Excellent advice!!

Thom D

>And if your effort does fail, it is faster to just pare the non perimeter section away, and then pare the perimeter if necesarry though it rarely is. The endgrain compression strength of wood is > 5000 psi, so the shoulder engagement is more than sufficient.

Re: shooting shoulders

#14

Agreed...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I try my best to saw to the lines. Then very little clean-up if any is nessary. Shoulder planes are for the shoulders, so you get a nice fit between the 2 (or more) pieces being assembled.

Re: shooting shoulders

#15

Re: shooting shoulders

John Hoffman

>I plane from the opposite end toward the middle then plane the near side toward the middle to avoid blowing out the end grain. Don't need to plane a fence. That said I agree that it is quite easy to make things worse this way. I usually drawbore the joint so the non-show side shoulder is cut back and does not make contact with the other member. Only the show side makes contact.

JH

Re: shooting shoulders

#16

Re: shooting shoulders

Angus Barclay, in New Zealand

>Another way of getting tight-fitting M&T shoulders is to never shoot shoulders - use loose tenons and shoot the whole board end.

If you use loose tenons and a matching mortice in both rail and stile, you can very accurately shoot all rails to EXACTLY the same length using any old shooting board. This helps enormously in getting the final assembly square.

1 - Gang the rails together, mark for exact length with a knife, then saw both ends to the waste side of the line.

2 - Mark and chop mortices in the ends of the rails.

3 - Soot a couple of thou off both ends. If you've squared your reference faces accurately, all the rails end up exactly the same length.

The loose tenon method makes tenon fitting a snap too. You don't need to worry about sawing individual tenons accurately because you make one single strip of tenon stock that you can plane easily using a finely set smoothing plane. Then you crosscut lengths off the strip that are about 1/8th sghorter than the depth of BOTH mortices. Until the tenon is glued into the mortice, it is just a very small board and can be worked on your bench like any other board.

With loose tenons the real skill is in cutting mortices accurately. Use whatever morticing method works best for you - router, drill and pare, morticing machine, or hand cut.

regards

Angus Barclay