We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I was checking out my local used tool store and saw this Sears plane model #107-37039. It look like it has hardly if ever been used. The sole plate is 2 1/2" x 9 1/4". Is it a smoothing plane? There was a similar one that had Made in England in raised letters just behind the front knob. I think it was green and has Stanley on the frog. I didn't see any number on the body. It is a little bigger and has the same iron angle but they want twice as much as I paid for this one. This one set me back a penny short of $15. I couldn't find any info on the plane using the numbers stamped on the side.
I am figuring it was an OK acquisition. Any information about the plane will be greatly appreciated.
Yes, it is a smoothing plane - the equivalent to a Stanley #4. It looks to my eye like a Millers Falls plane made for Sears. In the Millers Falls line I believe it would be a #9 or #900 depending on when it was made. It looks like you got a pretty good deal to me.
>I agree with Skip that it's probably a Miller Falls make. If I remember correctly, sears sold craftsman, fulton, and Dunlap (sears)brand planes. Craftsman were Stanley make. The Dunlap were made by either Sargent or Miller Falls depending on the period. I have two Sargent Dunlaps, and a Miller Falls Dunlap. My MF Dunlap is a little different than yours... chrome lever cap, different color, and different wood finish.
Dunlaps are generally undervalued. It makes a great light scrub or carpentry plane.
>Under the handle there is the number 308 that appears to have been made during forging. On the back side of the clamp is the number 494 and 4 to the upper left of the number. Again the numbers appear to have been formed during forging. There are no numbers under the front knob just 6 or 8 ridges that apparently keep the knob from turning.
It weighs in at 3 lbs 14 ozs. The plane I saw that had Made in England is a little bigger and heavier and is priced at $29.99. Should I buy it at that price?
>Dave, I take it you're new to hand planes. Congratulations on getting one and asking questions about it. I can't tell if your intentions are to teach yourself handplaning or get into used tool collecting.
I have grave doubts either purpose is well served by your first $15 plane there. The numbers mean nothing to me. The plane looks to be an unsigned(no maker) Bailey-oid knock-off of cheap quality, as indicated by the crude tote, the stamped pot metal lateral adjuster, and what I presume is a fresh spray paint job on the lever cap and inner body. Indeed, some of these things (especially the cheap Stanley Defiance) are in really really fine shape. They don't work. The buyers fiddled with them for an afternoon, gave up, and put them away.
Your plane might be tuned to work, but it's unlikely. Most of these have a terminally inadequate frog attachment. Pick it up by the top of the blade and give the side of the body a few raps with a plastic handled screw driver. If it feels like your holding a tuning fork, you'll understand the problem.
I remember one of the very first planes I bought off ebay. It was advertized as a "Union" because of a little "u" in a circle cast on the body. What did I know. It was a close cousin of your plane there. In time I understood that I'd simply paid the price of admission for that "Union".
Looks like you have a digital camera. Take the frog off your plane and lets see the bosses. Also, take your camera down to this store and tell them you want to take a few pictures of the "English" Stanley. If they say anything, tell them you're new to this and want your uncle's opinion and he doesn't get out anymore. We'll help you "type" it and give you better feedback about it's value. If it's a 4 or 5, $30 might be a fair price in Longview. It could somehow be something better, but I doubt it.
This part of the Pacific Northwest is handplane barren. A few years back I circulated through every used-tool-joint/antique-shop/flee-market from Centralia to Eugene. Believe me, when you find something worth having, the uneducated seller will want twice the everyday ebay price.
If you really want to get into this, do yourself a really big favor: join the Pacific Northwest Tool Collectors and attend a few meetings. Follow the link and be sure to take a picture tour of what the monthly meetings look like at the Jon Williams photo site link at the bottom. Here you can find some really sweet things at really rock bottom prices and the bonus is you get to inspect things in the presence of some very smart and helpful guys.
I agree with Woodburnbob that a few more pictures are in order for identification. Oddly enough, since I think it may be of Millers Falls parentage - based on appearance, that honking big solid steel adjuster wheel and what appears to be the stamping of the model number on the cheek, I'd suggest a shot of the underside of the lever cap. (That's the red thing with the lever at the top holding the blade assembly down. :) ) The Millers Falls lever cap is very characteristic, the end of the lever cap should feel loose. I've included a picture of a Stanley lever cap and a Millers Falls lever cap. The Millers Falls is the bottom one and the Stanley has the "kidney" shape hole.
*If* it's a Millers Falls, it's a pretty good plane IMO - definitely worth a tune up and a little use. If it's not - I think it would be a good plane to practice tuning up on. After all, if it's not worth much then you don't need to worry about screwing it up. :)
>I'm afraid I might have been unintentionally misleading by trying to be gentle. There are nicer planes for the same money or less to be found. Though, this class of plane may not be what you're looking for.
The fact that I have ended up with three Dunlap planes is certainly not something to boast about, but rather fits in for some self-deprecating humor within this community ;-) Though I did get them for roughly $5- $10 which is a common price. "good carpentry and light scrub" translates to they're good for bottom of the barrel planes. These planes are the ones that no one bids on on e-bay even though they have a $5 or $10 opening bid.
If you can do it, Bob's suggest on a regional tool club is an excellent one. Chances are high that you'll find some very knowledgeable people who can steer you to a good user.
This group has assumed that you're a beginner - this message is written with that assumption. If you're advanced and are just asking for opinions on this purchase, please accept my apologies.
This comment isn't terribly important to your issue - is this a good plane or not - but the body of the plane was probably cast iron (like making a jello mold, but with iron) rather than forged steel (pounded into shape while hot from steel, which is generally stronger than iron). Cast objects are cheaper to make, and the random nature of the crystalline structure can contribute to absorbing vibration, but prone to cracking when dropped. Forged objects are generally stronger, and, when made of the right type of steel, can be sharpened. Plane irons (the cutting part) and chisels were traditionally forged. Again, not terribly important, but using right terminology both flows from and contributes to right understanding.
A suggestion: in addition to meeting people from whom you can learn, it's helpful to do some reading. Your local library will have books on hand tools; get them all out and read through them. "The Hand Plane Book," by Garrett Hack, is often suggested as a good book for understanding planes; I personally find "Planecraft," probably not available in your library (unless you've got an awesome library), but available for about $10 from www.woodcraft.com, a more useful introduction to the art of using a plane, if you can get through the rather fusty British language.
General hand tool books will have an advantage over books on planes: there are many useful hand tools, and focusing too much on the use of planes will limit you. A lot can be done with a well-manipulated chisel, for instance.
Magazines can be helpful too. Probably the best current American magazine for hand tool users is Popular Woodworking, which regularly runs articles on hand tool use.
Nothing will replace practice and experience. You will, like most of us, make some mistakes; you may have here, though I would clean up the plane, get the iron sharp (probably the single most important skill in using hand tools is learning how to sharpen), learn how to adjust it (smaller cuts better than bigger ones), and give it a whirl on some gentle wood like pine or poplar. If it works well, you'll get to come back here and do a little victory dance in front of all the folks expressing concern that you bought the wrong tool; if it doesn't, it's part of your tuition, and you'll either find a use for it later or find someone to whom you can pass it on (in my case, the dogmeat Craftsman plane that was my first handplane now belongs to my brother, who is more intrigued by the idea of owning one than he is by the idea of actually using it).
Well, that doesn't look like a Millers Falls lever cap of the vintage I have. Still, nothing wrong with sharpening the blade up and do as Bill suggests. I learned my plane tuning skills on a worse plane than that - and tuning skills will stand you in good stead if you buy any older planes. It can't hurt even if you decide to buy one of the new, better, planes on the market.
Would you like to try a plane that really works well - without a lot of fussing and such? (Further, by the time you've fiddled and bought half a dozen of the bay or such, I think you're financially at the same place anyway...)
I'd be glad to lend you either my LV BU Smoother or Jack - perhaps even both. You can keep them for a a couple weeks to a month.
Personally, I *REALLY* don't care for the "fix-em-up" route for handplanes. Further, given what your time may be worth and your tolerance for aggrevation and such, buying a more expensive plane that works really well might make sense.
I'm much too busy to do any projects now, and I'm likely not to get to anything before well into July. So, they're just depreciating at the moment. I'd be glad to let you try them.
The email addys right there. If you want, let me know. (You'll have to stop by here (gateway district) and pick up/drop off, but I suspect you're down here more regularly than you'd like anyway... *grin*
>Your frog looks well-intentioned if cheaply cast - that is, the iron is supported all the way to the sole and there's lots of flat surface for it to sit on. The lever cap is missing the flat spring steel that usually goes under the cam of the lever, a sign that this is a cheap tool; adding a spring, if you've got the skills, will help it (office supply stores sell a kind of flat paper clip that's just about perfect; you may even be able to find one free by looking about a bit; all you need is springy, smooth, and about half an inch wide).
this isn't going to be your lifetime plane, but I'm conscious that many of us struggle with the tradeoff between time and money. If you've got little of the latter, you'd best be prepared to spend more of the former. On the other hand, if you've got enough money, buying a good used Stanley from a reliable dealer or going upscale and buying a Lie-Nielsen or Lee Valley plane will probably serve you better in the short run. The strongest vote among this group in the "spend money" category is for Lee Valley; don't know, as I've always been in the no-money-spend-time-instead group.
>You'll be able to tune and customize that plane to work as well as any traditional Bailey out there. There's nothing structural that would prevent it. The front of the frog sets on a pair of machined bosses and doesn't dangle out like a diving board as I expected. Go through the RJ Whelan 19 steps and then concentrate on the skill of sharpening a plane blade.
>Hey Dave, shoot me an e-mail with your phone number please, if you don't mind. I should have your number somewhere but don't feel like looking for it. If you send it once, I promise I'll save it. Have to run out for dinner now ;)
>I am a flat woodworker temporarily side tracked by the lathe. The problem started when I bought a lathe in 1999 to turn furniture legs. I have turned 2 sets of legs since then but now have more turning wood than lumber. I find myself needing a smoothing plane because a coffee table I have been commissioned to make has a top too large for my power planner and sander. The air dried(8 years) black walnut I got from a local sawyer will be easy to work with.
You guys were very patient we me when I used the wrong terminology. I do know the difference between forging and casting but I didn't prove it from my post. We drove to Seattle Friday afternoon to attend a Mariner baseball game so I haven't had a chance to respond. I didn't want you guys to think I was ignoring your advise. I am heading out the door to fetch some more walnut because my feeble mind didn't calculate correctly for knots.
I appreciate the information about collecting but that is not my thing. I visited Ernie Miller's cave in 2001 and saw enough planes to last a life time. I also had the good fortune to visit Moses Yoder and he showed me all kinds of old hand tools he was particularly proud of and I tried not to let my eye glass over. Thanks for reference to the article on tuning a metal bodied plan it is exactly what I needed.
Moses you can find my phone number on the links page of my web site. Good luck catching me on the phone.
Dave Smith
I don't trust tools that don't make noise in Longview, WA.