Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

do i need a cross-cut saw?

Posts

do i need a cross-cut saw?

#1

do i need a cross-cut saw?

les winter

>Lately I am working with small section stock: 1 1/2 x 3/4" rails. I can cut the tenons with my rip-filed dovetail saw pretty easily. Same with the tenon shoulders. It seems that my rip dovetail does a better job on the tenon shoulders than my cross-cut-filed saw. Am I missing something?

Any comments would be most welcome.

thanks

Les

Re: do i need a cross-cut saw?

#2

Re: do i need a cross-cut saw?

Ted Shuck, Centennial, CO

>If the two saws have a comparable blade thickness and TPI, then the crosscut saw should give a smoother crosscut than the rip saw, if it is sharp. If the crosscut saw has fewer TPI, and a wider blade, it may not cut as smoothly even if it is sharp.

If your two saws have comparable specs, you may need to sharpen your crosscut saw.

Ted

Re: do i need a cross-cut saw?

#3

Re: do i need a cross-cut saw?

Thom D

>To look at it from a slightly non-perfectionist approach, I would say that in the last 20 years it has been very difficult to get a good dovetail saw at all, and it remains expensive. I can ace a tenon shoulder with a 5 dollar replaceable x-saw blade, so far I haven't had quite the luck with dovetail saws though LV carried a good one that was under 40 for a while there. It's certainly within the last ten years, or so, that I wrote Leeonarnd Lee to say that they didn't carry a single pro grade saw, chisel, or plane. Rodriguez who seems to have written the bulk of his FWW articles from '98 on wrote an article on how to refile a x-cut saw into a dovetails saw. Again, the glutt of good dovetail saws,even Japanese ones, is recent. Things have changed but a lot of us got our tools when a good dovetail saw was a cherished thing.

Even if saws are equally available to you in every size, there still remains the fact that it is easier to sharpen rip teeth and they dull faster. So if you find a good x-cut, by the time you wear it out it won't be made any more if it is a replaceaable blade saw, or you will have a very nice little job to do.

So it's kinda like owning sports specific shoes. If you do enough rock climbing you will not only climb better with the right shoes, but they will last longer and you will save money on pushing you runners into service, or something like that.

Re: do i need a cross-cut saw?

#4

Jim in Burlington Ont.

I think so

Jim in Burlington On

>I have a pair of LN saw's and wouldn't bother to get the cross cut saw out for small tennon's. It makes a difference with older saw's that have thicker blades. The LN dovetail saw is still so sharp after 5 years of use it boggles my mind.

Re: do i need a cross-cut saw?

#5

Re: do i need a cross-cut saw?

paul womack

>Lately I am working with small section stock: 1 1/2 x 3/4" rails. I can cut the tenons with my rip-filed dovetail saw pretty easily. Same with the tenon shoulders.

I'd expect that.


I wouldn't expect that. I'd check the sharpening job on the X-cut.

In general, while a DT saw can be used for many light tasks, the small teeth are rather fiddly to file and set.

Therefore one should save it for tasks were the DT is essential, and not use it on tasks where it is merely "OK" (or even good).

BugBear

Re: do i need a cross-cut saw?

#6

Here is my little study and the evidence. *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)

>Hi Les

I took some pictures and posted them here about a month ago. The link is below.

Short version: the crosscut saw is better for crosscutting than a rip saw, even when the rip has the sharper blade.

Regards from Perth

Derek


Crosscut vs Ripcut backsaws

Re: do i need a cross-cut saw?

#7

Re: Here is my little study and the evidence.

les winter

>Thanks for all the input. You forced me into it. I ordered a LN xcut. I'll report my findings shortly.

regards

Les

Re: do i need a cross-cut saw?

#8

Re: Here is my little study and the evidence.

les winter

>Thanks for all the help. I bought a LN cross cut. Yes it works better than the rip cut on cutting shoulders. It needed a few strokes of a fine stone to reduce the kerf just a bit. Good advice all. Thanks again.

Les