Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Confusion over grit size: LV vs. Shapton

Posts

Confusion over grit size: LV vs. Shapton

#1

Confusion over grit size: LV vs. Shapton

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>The LV catalog lists their finest micro-abrasive sheets as being 0.5 micron, or 9000X. Shapton lists its finest stone as being 30,000X, or 0.49 micron.

Even assuming that they use different grit scales, the particle size seems to be basically the same. So either should provide the same finish,right? I'm assuming both are hard enough particle-wise for the type of steel used, like O1 or A2, not the "exotics" like CPM3V, S53 and others.

Or is the type of abrasive a factor here?

Either I'm completely missing something here, or the whole thing is a no-brainer, less than $2 a sheet vs. $635 for the stone...

Can't be that easy, right?

DC

Re: Confusion over grit size: LV vs. Shapton

#2

Re: Confusion over grit size: LV vs. Shapton

Dan Clermont in Burnaby

>Hi Denis,

I can't speak for the particle size in microns of the sandpaper vs stones but the ratings of about 2000 grit sandpaper is equal to approx an 8000 grit stone I believe.

So very loosely speaking it wouldn't surprise me if a 9000 grit sandpaper sold by LV was equivalent to a 30000 grit shapton or other stone.

Guess the question is do most woodworkers need to achieve an edge on a 30000 shapton or equivalent paper? I tend to do all of my edge tools on an 8000 grit stone and call it quits.

Cheers

Dan C

Re: Confusion over grit size: LV vs. Shapton

#3

Re: Confusion over grit size: LV vs. Shapton

Thom D

>Particle size is not the be all and end all of sharpening. I think at these rarified levels we can guess what is happening, and the technology exist to know what is happening, but I haven't seen a truly scientific explanation. With that caveat, I draw my own conclusions, some of which are as follows.

1) good luck getting the full value out of any of the finest available abrasive. Buffing works pretty well but morphs edges, and maintaining perfection on down through the run of different grits is pretty difficult when working with geometrically perfect surfaces, however these fine abrassives are all good, and like other fine tools it's up to the craftman to get the best results.

2) Grit size is a measurement of the particle, as far as I know. So a basketball is the same size as a basketball sized piece of quarts. The quarts is more likely to cut having a rough, hard and sharp surface. Particle size is like comparing two ten inch saw blades one with sharp 25 tpi, while the other has 12 dull teeth to the inch.

3) Grit wise a lot of sandpaper hits out of it's league. One can get sharp edges from 600 grit paper while a 600 grit stone is a different animal.

4) stones are hard right through so the substrate, is more stone, not paper. This has some effect on sharpening methods and results. However the finer mylar backed fills are pretty hard. I atill don't do most of my sandpaper sharpening right into the edge. As I might when sharpening on stones.

The boutique japanese stone market is full of people trying to match stones to particular tools. So at those levels there isn't any confidence that it's all the same, but those are pretty rarified levels and most people don't work at those levels.

The exotics are cut mostly with sanding belts, cut and sharpened, sometimes even buffed. So I wouldn't worry about sandpaper cutting those materials.

I agree with Dan that a real 8000 grit King sharpening job is formidable, and good enough for 4/10000" shavings.

Re: Confusion over grit size: LV vs. Shapton

#4

Re: Confusion over grit size: LV vs. Shapton

Rob Lee

>Hi Denis -

Grit standards are different between NA, and Japan...they are not numerically the same...

However - a micron is always a micron, in normal space, anyway.

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Confusion over grit size: LV vs. Shapton

#5

Chris Scholz

Re: Confusion over grit size: LV vs. Shapton

Chris Scholz

>In addition to grit size doesn't size distribution also matter?

Thinking about it, defining 'size' of a randomly shaped particle is not a completely trivial problem. Depending how you define it, the same number could mean completely different things (and completely different numbers could describe the same abrasive particles). Are there any standards (ISO or otherwise) on how to define/measure grit size and grit size distribution?

Re: Confusion over grit size: LV vs. Shapton

#6

Re: Confusion over grit size: LV vs. Shapton

Thom D

>Exactly, a 6" dagger, single edge knife and, banana all cut a little differently. One can cut through the hype by hitting the stones and figuring out what's what from there.

Re: Confusion over grit size: LV vs. Shapton

#7

Re: Confusion over grit size: LV vs. Shapton

paul womack

>In addition to grit size doesn't size distribution also matter?

... as well as particle shape, hardness, distribution over the substrate, hardness of substrate, pressure during abrasion, abrasion resistance characterisitics of the tool ...

BugBear

Re: Confusion over grit size: LV vs. Shapton

#8

Re: Confusion over grit size: LV vs. Shapton

Rob Lee

>Good answer - you beat me to it... (but also missed relative velocity... :) )

Cheers -

Rob