Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Dado planes? 46/47 vs 39s

Posts

Dado planes? 46/47 vs 39s

#1

Dado planes? 46/47 vs 39s

Dave Thompson

>Just wondering if there are any dado plane users and whether people had opinions on the mutli plane dados vs dedicated dado sizes.

I see iron fixed size dado planes seem to go for a premium relative to #78 type rabbet plane, especially if they're 3/4" wide (e.g. Stanley 39 3/4 or Sargent 36). Though I guess a #46 relative to a #45 is also pricey.

Thanks for sharing your experiences and opnions,

Dave

Moses, do you still have your #46? How do you like it? or have you given it up for a stacked dado set in a RAS? ;-)

Re: Dado planes? 46/47 vs 39s

#2

Re: Dado planes? 46/47 vs 39s

David Miller from Iowa

>In my experience, the 45 works fine for plowing and rabbeting in soft, clear, very straight grained wood - the 46 even a lttle better. For dadoes, I would go with the 78 instead of the 45/46 - the presence of a throat and the ease of tacking down a fence any distance from the board end makes it more functional, IMO. Except my 78 has only one nicker so I score the one side with a utility knife when working cross grain - actually, I've come to just score both sides and not use the knicker because the utility knife is far sharper than I could ever get a knicker.

The 39 series skew planes are very good but also very expensive. They can be a bear to get aligned once you regrind the cutters, but they work great (again, choosing straight, clear wood and watching the grain is almost as important as the plane you choose).

Re: Dado planes? 46/47 vs 39s

#3

Re: Dado planes? 46/47 vs 39s

wilbur

>How about the use of a router plane for this purpose? Could you score both sides of the dado and use the router plane to start clearing the dado out?

I'm just getting into woodworking, and am interested in doing things by hand as much as possible to start. But cutting dadoes by hand is something that I am still trying to figure out.

Re: Dado planes? 46/47 vs 39s

#4

Re: Dado planes? 46/47 vs 39s vs 71

jim reed @ tallahassee

>I think the #46 works best. It seems to be the quickest for me--the #39s are finicky about setup and also a little hard to hold. #46 has a nice handle, a nice knob, and also rods to grip. As for the #71, it is best for cleaning up the bottom after the dado is already cut. A #71 is also good for hinge mortising.

Re: Dado planes? 46/47 vs 39s

#5

Re: Dado planes? 46/47 vs 39s

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I would skip the 47, it's way to collectible and they go for a premium. By the time you got all the sizes of the 39's, you would have spent a small fortune.

Besides, the 39's are uncomfortable to hold IMHO.

My choice here is the 46. A bit pricey to get a complete one. Try to find one without blades and then get a set of blades from Jim Reed.

Re: Dado planes? 46/47 vs 39s

#6

Re: Dado planes? 46/47 vs 39s

Dean J in MN

>Any reason you are shying away from wood dado planes?

-Dean

Re: Dado planes? 46/47 vs 39s

#7

Ever see a set of woodies?

jim reed @ tallahassee

>I have never seen a set of dodo woodies & think getting them together would be harder than collecting a set of #39s. There are many variations and using a harlequin set where each plane is slightly different would drive me nuts. This also goes for H&Rs and side beads. Get a set from the same mfg or prepare for frustration.

Re: Dado planes? 46/47 vs 39s

#8

Re: Ever see a set of woodies?

Dean J in MN

>I have never seen a set of dodo woodies & think getting them together would be harder than collecting a set of #39s. There are many variations and using a harlequin set where each plane is slightly different would drive me nuts. This also goes for H&Rs and side beads. Get a set from the same mfg or prepare for frustration.

I have a set of woodies in my toolchest, so I know they are out there. :-) Kidding aside, it wasn't real hard; note I am in MN, not the worlds best place to find woodies. You just need to find a nice guy like Tom Bruce to help you out.

My set is a mix of makers, but I've not been bothered by that. They do need a little TLC and tune up, but work just fine. It is more important to me that they match other tools in my shop (in width) rather than match each other, so I'm not afraid to tweak them a bit.

I do know some folk just don't like messing with woodies, so understand where you are coming from.

-Dean

Re: Dado planes? 46/47 vs 39s

#9

Re: Ever see a set of woodies?

Dave Thompson

>Well I have 7/8" woodie dado, but these seem to be a pretty common woodie size dado. If I saw a 3/4" woodie, I'd buy it.

With the bench plane type woodies, I just tollerate them so I can play around. They help me appreciate having depth stops and lateral adjustors. That hasn't stopped me from working on an H&R set of woodies. Frankly I haven't used my 7/8" woodie dado. I can't remember the last time if ever I needed to make a 7/8" dado.

Thanks,

Dave

Re: Dado planes? 46/47 vs 39s

#10

Re: Ever see a set of woodies?

Jamey Amrine

>I have 1/2" wooden dado plane which is one of my best performers, and has been extremely useful in the limited number of projects I have done in my short time working wood. $5 on ebay made it one of my best purchases also. 10 minutes honing the iron and I was off and running. If I come across others in decent condition on the cheap, you can be sure I will be buying them. They are really handy, I think.

Re: Dado planes? 46/47 vs 39s

#11

Re: Dado planes? 46/47 vs 39s

Dave Thompson

>Thanks David, I'm not quite sure I follow on how to use the #78 for a dado, unless you mean for a full #78 width cut.

Dave

Re: Dado planes? 46/47 vs 39s

#13

Re: Ever see a set of woodies?

steve knight

>I need to update those pics too. the planes have changed a bit.

Re: Dado planes? 46/47 vs 39s

#14

Re: Dado planes? 46/47 vs 39s

Dave Thompson

>Thanks for the tips. I ended up getting a #46 that still had a single 1/2" blade. Interesting what a difference in price these are with and without a full set of blades. Much more significant than the same situation with a #45.

I noticed that these never came with a 3/4" blade, but rather a 13/16" blade. Does anybody have any theories as to why?

thanks again,

Dave

Re: Dado planes? 46/47 vs 39s

#15

Re: Dado planes? 46/47 vs 39s

Ted Shuck

>I seem to remember reading somewhere that 4/4 stock used to be thicker and usually resulted in 13/16" thick boards after planing. Stock just kept getting thinner over time, so now we have 3/4" as the standard.

Ted

Re: Dado planes? 46/47 vs 39s

#16

My theory

jim reed @ tallahassee

>is that 13/16 (4/4 surfaced) is a typical size for a shelf dado. Larger blades are for open dados (cross grained rabbets) and the 3/4 is too small. By the time you get the fence in place and get everything adjusted the extra width of blade comes in handy for balance. As for blade sets, it seems that I only use the 3/16, 1/2, and the 1 1/4. Others just take up room in the box. The large dados are hard to do. I find it easier to sneak up on them with a smaller blade. Two small curls are much easier to make than one large one. Good luck with your plane.

Re: Dado planes? 46/47 vs 39s

#17

Glad to hear it...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I think you'll realy like it. I know I like mine.

Yea, the cost of one with out blades or only one can make all the difference in the world...