Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Replacement blades: Hock vs. Lie Nielsen

Posts

Replacement blades: Hock vs. Lie Nielsen

#1

Replacement blades: Hock vs. Lie Nielsen

wilbur

>You would think that someone would have asked this question already, but I searched the forum and archives and haven't found an answer.

For a Stanley Bailey type plane, if you were to choose between a replacement Hock blade/chipbreaker (either high carbon steel or A2) combination, and a Lie-Nielsen replacement blade, which would you pick?

(My understanding is that the Lie-Nielsen chipbreaker is too thick for a Bailey type plane without altering the plane, which I'm NOT interested in doing.)

Re: Replacement blades: Hock vs. Lie Nielsen

#2

Thickness of blade

jim reed @ tallahassee

>Most original Stanley bench plane blades are 1/16" thick. Thicker aftermarket blades outperform them everytime because of reduced chatter. Cannot speak for the others, but I make blades for my own bench planes that are 3/32" and they work great. Sometimes I need to open the mouth about the thickness of a sheet of paper. Depends on the plane.

Find out who makes the blade thicker than Stanley but less than 1/8" and you will have less adapting to do.

Re: Replacement blades: Hock vs. Lie Nielsen

#3

Re: Replacement blades: Hock vs. Lie Nielsen

arw01

>I have Veritas A2 blades in most of my planes.

On my NO 8 I have a LN and a LN chipbreaker. It is NOT too thick to fit, but my LN chip breaker will not go way down on the blade. I have one of those non standard Stanleys. Someday I may of LN "fix" it with a re-machine.

ANY of those blades are way better, but the LN I think are a bit thicker even to the naked eye.

All things considered I'd buy the LN goodies, but as i said I bought all Veritas except 1 No 8 blade.

Alan

Re: Replacement blades: Hock vs. Lie Nielsen

#4

Re: Replacement blades: Japanese

Barryvabeach

>I have used Veritas, Hock ( o 1 , not A2) , Clifton, LN and several home made versions up to 1/4 thick. In general the thicker the better ( though I haven't gone over 1/4 ). My favorite thin replacement blade is the Japanese version that Woodcraft carried and it works great on a Stanley 07 - I think the Japanwoodworker carries a version now though not sure if it is the same manufaturer.

Re: Replacement blades: Hock vs. Lie Nielsen

#5

Re: Replacement blades: Hock vs. Lie Nielsen

Hank Knight from SC

>I have both Hock and LN replacement blades in my Stanley plnaes. I can't tell much differnece in the performance; both are a huge improvemnet over standard Stanley blades. I have not tried the Hock chipbreaker; I've used the Stanley chipbreakers with my Hock replacement blades. I do have a number of LN chipbreakers and I like them a lot - much better than the regular Stanley chipbreaker. That said, I think you would be satisfied either the Hock or the LN replacements. I have more LN replacements, but that's because I like LN stuff, not because I think they are better than the Hocks.

My .$02

Hank

Re: Replacement blades: Hock vs. Lie Nielsen

#6

Re: Replacement blades: Hock vs. Lie Nielsen

Jerry Nicholson

>I use Lee Valley blades and either Hock or Clifton chip breakers. I can't claim that this is better than any other combination of blades and chip breakers but it works for me. The Hock chip breakers come with the screw, the Cliftons do not.

Re: Replacement blades: Hock vs. Lie Nielsen

#7

Re: Replacement blades: Japanese

Thom D

>I have bought the Japanese ones from a variety of sources. Going back 25 years Lee Valley sold them. And I bought some for ECE and Record planes. I also bought some from Masterpiece tools. The MTs might have been a little better, but they are all good. It's a cutting through the fog exercise. These are just as nasty looking as the ones the planes came with originally. And they lack a number of key features of the hand made blades. Still cut like a house on fire, and you can't beat them, so far, with the stuff from the west.

I've used lots of lee nielsen and Hock stuff. One cool thing about hock is they will make you whatever you want within reason. LN is a bit like that with customizing planes, but they aren't going to make you a 2.5" wide Krenov blade, I'm guessing. Both are good tools. Maybe the LN holds an edge a little better, and the Hock is easier to sharpen. I haven't tried the LN A2.

Re: Replacement blades: Hock vs. Lie Nielsen

#8

Re: Hock

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>There really is not a big difference between Hock and LN irons performance. I like buying Hock replacement irons because that is his specialty. He is not also making and selling planes, he is simply selling irons. In theory, he should have a little bit better blade than LN, which in my opinion is in fact true. I plan on being at the planing competition in Pennsylvania, perhaps we will find out ;) I wonder what type of iron Ellis uses?

Re: Replacement blades: Hock vs. Lie Nielsen

#9

Re: Replacement blades: Hock vs. Lie Nielsen

Tony Zaffuto

>Anyone know if you can still buy Clifton blades? I got a Clifton #3 that has become my "goto" smoother: the blade just lasts and lasts and lasts (QS white oak, cherry and a couple of South American woods of unknown name, but seem to be like a walnut).

Re: Replacement blades: Hock vs. Lie Nielsen

#10

Re: Replacement blades: Hock vs. Lie Nielsen

Fred Krow

>Joel has Clifton blades available.

http://www.toolsforworkingwood.com/Merchant/merchant.mvc?Screen=PROD&Store_Code=toolshop&Product_Code=EE-PI635.XX&Category_Code=TR

Regards,

Fred Krow

Re: Replacement blades: Hock vs. Lie Nielsen

#11

Re: Replacement blades: Hock vs. Lie Nielsen

Tony Zaffuto

>Thanks Fred,

I have LN, Hock and Clifton, as well as my old Stanleys and I rate Cliftons right up there at the top (at least my experience). Take a real nice edge and holds it.

Also suggest the Clifton 2 piece chip breaker.

T.Z.

Re: Replacement blades: Hock vs. Lie Nielsen

#12

Beware the length of the Y lever

David Charlesworth

>To answer the original question;

There should be no problem using the L-N improved chipbreaker, or Ron Hock's thick chipbreaker.

I have found both L-N & Hock A2 replacement blades to be excellent.

They keep you working much longer than Carbon steel if you can sharpen them well. A2 responds very well to waterstones.

Both these replacement blades are about 2.4 mm thick about 95 thou".

Thicker blades may not always work as the Y lever has to pass through the thickness of the blade to engage the chipbreaker slot.

David Charlesworth

Re: Replacement blades: Hock vs. Lie Nielsen

#13

Re: Beware the length of the Y lever

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

>I wish some ingenious machinist could come up with a adjuster slot/y lever extension to allow easier thick blade upgrades. IIRC there were some atempts at this back on Badger Pond/Neanderthal Haven. One I rember was a neat plate similar to the adjuster slot plate on a L-N #9. Careful engineering could also reduce backlash.JR

Re: Replacement blades: Hock vs. Lie Nielsen

#14

Re: Replacement blades: Hock vs. Lie Nielsen

arw01

>To follow on what I posted about my plane being a bit non-standard.

David Charlesworth brought up the proper term.

My depth adjuster Yoke does not hit the chipbreaker in the proper position to allow me to put the chipbreaker way down on the blade as one should.

I have to put the chipbreaker up the blade a fair ways, not an issue on a no 8 in my experience. That thicker blade sure makes a difference.

Alan

Re: Replacement blades: Hock vs. Lie Nielsen

#15

Re: Extend chibreafker slot

Barryvabeach

>While it was not a "pretty" solution, I used a very thick blade ( 3/16 IIRC) on a stanley by soldering metal blocks on the top and bottom side of the slot hole on the underside of chipbreaker. The blocks were slightly narrower than the hole in the blade so they rested in that hole and then I filed the blocks so that the y lever engaged with a slight backlash. Don't know if this is understandable, but it was a very quick modification - the hardest part was then finding a longer screw for the chipbreaker.

Re: Replacement blades: Hock vs. Lie Nielsen

#16

Don't k know about Lie Nielsen but...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I have a Hock (A2) iron and thick chip breaker in my 604-1/2. No fit problems at all. I also like the fact that Hock includes a longer screw with his chip breakers (don't know if LN does). I do own LN planes with their improved chip breakers and A2 blades. They seem very close to me. Thit the exception the LN blades in their planes are thicker than Hocks of LN's replacement blades. I feel you can't go wrong with either one.

Hock blades are a blackish-gray, LN are shinny steel, if that makes a difference to you...

Re: Replacement blades: Hock vs. Lie Nielsen

#17

Re: Replacement blades: Hock vs. Lie Nielsen

Frank

>Howdy guys

I stay away from Hock blades now because the last two that I ordered came all nice and wrapped but rust spots all over them. About 80% of my planes have Hock blades but that number will come down with time. Plus they were not made in the USA...

Frank

Re: Replacement blades: Hock vs. Lie Nielsen

#18

Hmmmm...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>I have lot's of Ron's blades too. I've never seen a spot of rust on any of mine. Did you order them from him directly or through someone else?

If it was some other company, this probably the way they stored the blades. If not, I'd take it up with him.

AFAIK Only his infill replacement blades are made in France, you got a problem with that?

Re: Replacement blades: Hock vs. Lie Nielsen

#19

Re: outsourced Hock

paul womack

>AFAIK Only his infill replacement blades are made in France

From his web site: http://www.hocktools.com/#aboutus

But we've grown so much in the last couple of years that we've started "outsourcing" some of the blades to high-precision factories in the United States and France.

From OLDTOOLS Aug 2000 (potentially out dated information)

http://nika.frontier.iarc.uaf.edu/~cswingle/archive/get.phtml?message_id=82233#message

Sound like Ron stands by their work.

BugBear

Re: Replacement blades: Hock vs. Lie Nielsen

#20

Re: Beware the length of the Y lever

Hank Knight from SC

>I had problems with the "Y" lever on two of my Stanleys when I replaced the chipbreakers with LNs. I spoke with LN about the problem and ended up e-mailing them a photocopy of the Stanley chipbreakers on these two planes with measurements I took of them with a fractional caliper. They made new chipbreakers to my specs and they work fine. They were willing to exchange the specially machined ones for the originals without charge, but I kept the origianl LNs because they fit two of my other Stanleys with no problem, and I paid for the replacements. I offered to pay extra for the custom machining but they charged me regular price. They said they will machine your Stanley chipbreakers to your specifications without additional charge if you ask them to do it up front. I assume they still do it without charge. Another testamonial to LN's great customer service.

Hank