Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

I'm skeptical

Posts

I'm skeptical

#1

I'm skeptical

Thom D

>Just so it isn't missed, Pics are in the thread below:

Well who can blame you? Maybe it is hard to believe that one can go straight from the 80 grit/shaping wheel to the buff, though you can see the same process performed in Tage Frid's half lap dovetailing video for FWW. Which presumably means everyone who went through his courses at RSD has seen it too. Inconvenient isn't it?

Anyway, occasionally I confuse even myself, so I went out to the shop for a minute to see if I was exaggerating. Freehanded a really nasty course white stone wire edge on a chisel, and then buffed it on the adjacent green wheel, not even a dab of the green stuff in much evidence and I didn't refresh it. 20 seconds later tested the end on a piece of pine and then maple, both of which it cut with ease. Then I shaved a big bloody patch on my arm, smooth as a baby's bottom, and I have a 19 day old baby in the house for comparison purposes. I then applied the barber's test to the edge. Wet your thumb nail and go in for a low angle catch, this is evidence you have properly honed an edge. Passed fine. Then wet a fingertip and go in for a catch, this test it failed, meaning it is not sharp enough to actually shave a face with and get a tip, but I am confident with a few more seconds on the wheel with fresh green compound it would probably pass. Most razor edges do not pass test 2, since typically in woodworking it was not the practice to strop an edge after wetting it on a fine Arkansas stone. That is the dividing line the barber's test identifies, when to move on to the strop, and when to move on to the face. I also ran my finger along the edge very carefully and it felt dead smooth to the touch, I didn't get cut, so it certainly isn't ragged in the least.

I would have no problem making money or giving a dovetailing demo with this edge just as it is.

Let's be clear, at 1800 rpm on an 8" wheel for ten seconds it's like dragging the edge along a scary sharp/diamond strop 628' long, 2 seconds is 125'. The average sharpening stroke I see with a jig is probably about 4" long so that is like 375-1800 passes. Most grinders are 3600 at 6" for 942'/ten seconds.

I'm not saying this is a perfect method, there isn't a perfect method. But it is perfectly fast, and relatively cheap. The whole rig including the motor is about the price of a shapton 8000.

Just what is there to be skeptical about?

Re: I'm skeptical

#2

Re: I'm skeptical

steve knight

>a good way to really see how sharp it is without looking is to lightly run your finger over the edge. the sharper it is the more oily/glassy it feels.if it wants to cut your finger it is not sharp enough shaving hair is a bit pointless as razors are not all that sharp. I bet that edge under a maginfying glass looks like the moon full of crators.

another one I discovered it it can cut a totamto skin with little effort it is not very sharp if it is super sharp it can't catch on the skin and really needs some sawying.

Re: I'm skeptical

#3

Re: I'm skeptical

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)

>So Thom, did you try out the edge by planing a wooden surface? As Steve is saying, an edge may be sharp but it may also be serrated. This will be fine for chisels or a scrub plane but poor for a smoother (unless you enjoy a serrated finish). Sharp is not necessarily smooth, and the aim should be both for smoothers. This is the argument against the use of machines like the Tormek, and why a finishing waterstone is still used after the edge has been prepared on one.

Yes I saw Tage's video, and it inspired me to develop a belt sander as a grinding tool. He got quite an edge on his chisels using a 220 belt and a motorized strop. Does anyone know if he did this for his plane blades as well (and whether he sanded after planing)?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: I'm skeptical

#4

Re: I'm skeptical

Dan Clermont in Burnaby

>I have a friend who teaches courses at a LV store and has been a professional woodworker his whole life. He doesn't get paid or make money spending allot of time sharpening and for years he has done exactly what Thom D describes. Apparently the results are incredible

I still use stones as I gon't have a grinder but someda would like to test his method in my own shop.

Cheers

Dan C

Re: I'm skeptical

#5

Re: I'm skeptical

Thom D

>The ability to strip hair off your forearm tells you something but it isn't the ultimate edge by any means. An edge that pops hair is very sharp with my fur (which this test didn't). A shaving edge, however, as properly produced by a knowledgeable user of a straight razor is a "Japanese" sharp edge, and the test of that edge is the wet finger. If you don't want to butcher your client you need a way of verifying that the full edge meets a certain standard before you start shaving, and it needs to be non-destructive.

I actually couldn't get a better edge from more buffing, but the original edge was serviceable for a chisel. I tried the wheel and a natural awase toishi (#4), and it brought up a much better edge in relatively short time. A hollow ground edge is the ultimate micro bevel.

I ran Frid again, and he uses a 220 belt sander, which is faster cutting in my Klingspour clad 2hp version than any vitrious wheel. I will have to give that a try tommorow.

There are going to be a lot of disappointed owners of Jepanese vegetables knives out there, after they read you review of a sharp blade.

Re: I'm skeptical

#6

Re: I'm skeptical

Thom D

>Derek, he was an advocate of the scraper. I don't think most western arty pros hand plane to a finish, I am still waiting for an explanation of where/why this is really practical on wood that receives a finish... Krenov claims to do it, and I would be interested to see him blending one of his marketry pieces with a hand plane.

Frid also said he was just as happy using a hand belt sander if he could make more money doing it, which is a practical attitude but a miserable tool unless your shop has very few nooks and crannies to clean.

I think it is pretty unlikely the serations are left on the edge. If you aren't carefull the edge isn't left on the edge, green compound removes metal visibly. Now will one end up with a geometrically perfect blade, no. But does the Charlesworth faceted curved edge sharpening on a waterstone provide perfect shapes. I doubt it. Is the Odate camber sharpening system confirmation that Japanese masters find perfect edges tenable. Not really. Lots of theoretical perfection out there. Anyway, I'm not claiming this is the perfect system, it's not the one I generally use, just saying that the green compound buffs an edge fast, and that our pal with the 10 step system could cut out a few steps and still get there.

Re: I'm skeptical

#7

THANKS for all the info

Angus Barclay, in New Zealand

>" . . . our pal with the 10 step system could cut out a few steps and still get there."

That about sums up the reason I asked the original question. I want to work with word; and I don't particularly want to spend time using complicated sharpening systems to work with metal (i.e. blades).

This thrread and the precursor thread have both provided me with a lot of information and opinions. I'll sort through them all (and a few other info sources too) and try to figure out what is likely to be the "best" sharpening method and technology for me and the way I work.

Many thanks to all who contributed. The variety and quality of well stated opinions, personal observations, and hard facts are what makes WoodCentral such a great place.

regards

Angus Barclay

Re: I'm skeptical

#8

Re: I'm skeptical

charles

>Tage Frid used a worn out, glazed over belt. I can assure you that its effective grit was not 80 grit.

Re: I'm skeptical

#9

Re: I'm skeptical

charles

>On the other hand if it works that's great. I don't have any electric tools (buffing wheel, grinder, etc.) nor do I have a treadle wheel so this won't work for me.

And as I mentioned in another response, Frid always used a worn out belt. It was not a fresh 80 grit belt. It was, quite literally, years old.

Re: I'm skeptical

#10

Re: I'm skeptical

arw01

>Steve can you rewrite the tomatoe skin story?

You have too many reverses in there to really tell for sure..

Alan

Re: I'm skeptical

#11

Re: I'm skeptical

Charles

>And that 220 grit belt was worn out... probably more like 600 grit...

Re: I'm skeptical

#12

Re: I'm skeptical

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)

>Aahh, that makes more sense to me now. Veritas green rouge is really excellent at removing fine scratches, but it cannot cope with those from a 220 grit belt. Also, a 220 grit belt would remove a fair amount of steel on each occasion if the bevel was ground freehand, as Tage did in his video.

For reference, when starting from scratch, I use my belt sander with a guide to remove the minimum amount of metal, and establish the primary bevel with a 120 grit belt. I can then move to microbevels on 1200 and 8000 waterstones. I need only use the latter if honing. This only takes a couple of minutes.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: I'm skeptical

#13

Re: I'm skeptical

Charles

>My posts in this thread are kind of disjointed. I've always disliked this forum software, but it's not my forum.... so.....

Frid used worn out belts to hone edges. Who knows what the 'effective' grit really was but it was certainly much more than the original, stated grit on the belt.

I wouldn't run out and do an edge with a fresh belt sander belt and take it to the buffing wheel and expect a great result. But I've never tried it so I can't say FOR CERTAIN.

A simple oilstone 'system', three or four grits of sandpaper, this is all you need to hone an edge. One can rough grind wherever. I rough grind with 80X Norton paper-on-glass. I don't hone secondary bevels so I only have to go back to the 80X if I chip an edge somehow. Frankly, I can't remember the last time I did a rough grind - my kit is in place, my edges are all single-bevel, I don't often drop tools, so now all I do is hone.

That's it.

Most guys never quit working edges because they won't put a kit of tools together that will work for them. Too much buying and trading tools and all that rot. There's always some fettling or honing task to be accomplished instead of putting tool to wood. That $hit would drive me batty. I don't see how people stand it.

Sharpening is certainly one thing I feel comfortable saying people make much too difficult and spend too much time gnashing teeth over.

Re: I'm skeptical

#14

Re: I'm skeptical

Charles

>I should have said a simple oilstone 'system' OR three or four grits of sandpaper is all you need...

One doesn't need both.