Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Truing up the edges of long boards?

Posts

Truing up the edges of long boards?

#1

Truing up the edges of long boards?

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>OK, I have some 30-60" long 3/4" oak boards that have rough sawn edges. I don't have a power jointer, and not even a jointer plane. I do have a 16 inch jack (the LV LA). I've tried a couple of methods of truing up the edges (including attaching a straight edge to one side and then running that on the table saw, and trying to rout along a straight edge), but none worked particularly well. My only long straight edge is probably a bit questionable at 60" too. I tried using the jack plane to take the edge down, and it seems to have done a decent job. I ran a line using my (questionable) straight edge, and then planed down that. The board stands without much gap on my workbench.

I'm not going to glue up the boards, but I do not to make some long edge strips. Is there any better way of truing up that long of an edge, with a limited set of tools. I also usually cut a little oversize, and then fit the pieces during assembly.

Re: Truing up the edges of long boards?

#2

Re: Truing up the edges of long boards?

George Makowski

>Steve, I am sure brighter heads will chime in too, but here are a couple of things to think about.

1. How straight do you need these edges to be?

--If you are not going to glue these edges into a panel, they don't need to be matched to the point that there is not glimmer of light against a reference edge (within a few thousandths).

2. Do the edges have to be jointed in long lengths or can you cut your pieces to rough length and then work the edges?

--You may be able to get within the accurate working limits of your longest plane this way.

A rule of thumb that some accept and some don't is that you can joint well up to 3x the length of your plane, in your case ~48". You can work around this to longer lengths by planing as straight as you can then testing against a straight edge or the edge to which you will be gluing, or fitting, and looking for light. Then work down the high spots until you have good contact overall.

The key is to establish what the tolerances are for this job. Then, match the method to the required accuracy. 1/64" looks huge when its between a reference edge and the edge you are working on, but take the reference away and it is unilkely that you will notice it unles it is part of a fitted assembly.

Good jointing!

George in AL

Re: Truing up the edges of long boards?

#3

Re: Truing up the edges of long boards?

Marc in Luxembourg

>Stephen,

I had to join 10 feet long boards in order to make a rabbeted miter joint on the whole length. Tolerances had to be minimized, so I came up with the following solution. I screwed 5 mm thick battens under a cheap noname woodie and clamped two al straightedges on the boards faces. It was like planing on rails.

After this work the plane is not lost, planing thin battens to consistent thickness works quite easy and fast. I remember there is a japanese version of this form.

But if your tolerances are not as important, this method is quite luxury.

Regards, Marc


img

Re: Truing up the edges of long boards?

#4

Re: Truing up the edges of long boards?

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>I'm making a bookshelf which is about 60" wide, and these pieces will act as the face frame (it's plywood construction), and as a base. So, I think I can get away with being a little out of perfectly straight, especially if I leave a little wiggle room fro the final fitting. As long as things are a bit wider/longer than I need, I figure I can trim them to look good during the fitting.

Thanks for reminding me that sometimes pretty straight is indeed straight enough. I will be ripping stock on the table saw, so I want them straight enough that I don't have issues with kickbacks or binding. When I put the bookcase together, I'll like work on site - if it looks good, it probably is. Fortunately, I only have a couple of pieces this long, and the rest are under 30", so my jack plane will work fine.

Re: Truing up the edges of long boards?

#5

Re: Truing up the edges of long boards?

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>That's a neat idea, but I don't think my tolerances are quite that tight. As I said in the above post, this is for the face frame and base of a bookcase, and I'll probably have wiggle room during the fit to make it look right. But, I'm sure I will have a need for something like this at some time.

A question, though. How do you keep the aluminum straight edge from sagging in the middle. That was my problem using the long straight edge on the table saw, it would bow a bit in the center. I was a bit loathe to drive nails or screws to hold it in place.

Re: Truing up the edges of long boards?

#6

Re: Truing up the edges of long boards?

Dave Thompson

>I agree with the points George made, especially with the key lies in how straight you need them to be. Fortunately, it sounds like you're not going to be edge gluing them.

Like George mentioned, for the longer boards you can work them down, finding the high spots. Some other things to consider for future projects... pick up a jointer plane. You can probably find a decent #7 used one on e-bay for around $35. You'll likely need to know how to tune it. Also, not sure if you have a router table, but some people that lack jointing tools do just fine edge jointing on a router table.... I'll defer to the power tool forum for details. Since I'm on this forum, I am obliged to say, it's noisy as heck and makes alot of dust ;-)

good luck,

Dave

Re: Truing up the edges of long boards?

#7

Re: Truing up the edges of long boards?

Jerry Nicholson

>A longer plane than your jack is not a necessity for truing an edge. To be sure, a #7 would make the job easier and faster but an edge can be trued with a plane of any length in combination with your Mark I standard issue eyeball. If I have an edge that is really crooked or a board that is too clumsy to work on my little 6 inch power jointer, I work the edge down to "fairly flat" (usually with a #7 or #8 because I have them) and then use that as the reference edge to make the first cut on the table saw. Your jack plane should then smooth out any rip marks just fine.

Jerry

Re: Truing up the edges of long boards?

#8

Re: Truing up the edges of long boards?

Marc in Luxembourg

>I clamped first at the ends, then the board's face lying on the edge of the bench I clamped in the middle. The whole clamped in the front vice 2 feet from the end and the other end rested on a sawhorse of good height. So the clamp in the middle had room to hang free. Clamping on the sawhorse possible with two clamps and a batten or two wooden clamps.

Regards, Marc

Re: Truing up the edges of long boards?

#9

Re: Truing up the edges of long boards?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>I first jointed long boards by placing them edge up on a workbench, held with a vise, used a LN LA jack even shorter than your LV. Then I added a planing beam to the back of my bench and used the bench edge for the guide, also worked great. Then got an ECE Primus jointer for this job, it was easier than the jack for jointing, but not really better from the standpoint of the end result.

I've also jointed edges using just a table saw, in classes at the local CC. Basically you nible away on one edge until the grain is followed without bumps or hollows (it's better to take smaller cuts to avoid burning), then use that edge against the fence and the opposite edge will be in harmony.

Pam

Re: Truing up the edges of long boards?

#10

Some progress on getting straight!

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>Well, on some of my shorter boards (3-4'), I made pretty good progress. I ended up continuing to use my long aluminum cutting guide as a straight edge. I'd pick an edge of the board that looked good, then work the high spots, expanding out until I got something reasonably close, then take a couple of full lenghth passes. After that, a little to clean up any spots that were out of square, and I was looking pretty good.

I had a real challenge with a board that sloped off on one end. Any planing I did just followed the slope. The edge was smooth, but still sloped. I finally figured that I could start planing close to the highest edge, and then continuously longer passes as I worked back along the board. It took doing this 4 or 5 times, but then I got pretty close. That one was tricky because I would occasionally make some other part of the edge worse, and then have to fix more.

I wish I could use my bench as reference, but I have an MDF top, and even with 1/2" maple edging, it's still bowed in the center. Guess that stuff really does sag under it's own weight.

Thanks for all the replies everyone.

Re: Truing up the edges of long boards?

#11

What kind of straight edges do you use?

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>I just wondered what you used for straight edges. I have the Sears kind that join in the center, and it is sometimes clumsy to use, and can easily bow under it's own weight. Have you found something that is better?

Re: Truing up the edges of long boards?

#12

Re: What kind of straight edges do you use?

paul womack

>Decent spririt levels can be helpful; they're spec'd quite tightly, and since they're produced in good numbers, can be cost effective.

BugBear

Re: Truing up the edges of long boards?

#13

Re: What kind of straight edges do you use?

Marc in Luxembourg

>I don't know what the Sears kind is, mine are almost 4 inches by 1/2 by 10 feet and have two bridges in the al profile. It's something you find here in every hardware store. So far I don't know if you can get them over the pond.

For sure mine are clumsy too. But so they don't sag as much as they are stiffer.

Marc