Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Drawknives - Back bevel?

Posts

Drawknives - Back bevel?

#1

Drawknives - Back bevel?

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>I used a drawkinfe for the first time a week ago at our association's show. We had a member (Terry McLean) who set up a pole lathe and a shaving horse just outside our venue for us to experiment.

Yesterday at the Rosewood Studio Fine Furniture Conference (check main board for details) I purchased a drawknife blank from Doug Orr (only needs handles). When I used Terry's drawknives the week before I felt that the drawknives were very sensitive in the angle of attack department, angle them down just a hair more and the drawknife would dig in instead of taking a shaving.

Now all of Terry's drawknives have a flat bottom. I think I remember reading from Mike Dunbar that a slightly rounded bevel at the bottom (instead of flat) makes the drawknife more easy to control.

Any opinions on this? I don't want to round up the sole only to find out that it doesn't help, and lose a fair chunk of blade in the process...

TIA,

DC

Re: Drawknives - Back bevel?

#2

Re: Drawknives - Back bevel?

paul womack

>Now all of Terry's drawknives have a flat bottom. I think I remember reading from Mike Dunbar that a slightly rounded bevel at the bottom (instead of flat) makes the drawknife more easy to control.


I think it varies with purpose; the drawknife is a very versatile tool.

For example, in the case of bow makers (bowyers), a slightly blunt (gasp!) drawknife is preferred for removing bark, since it has a slightly greater tendancy to follow the bark/wood boundary; a truly sharp drawknife would go where is was directed.

BugBear

Re: Drawknives - Back bevel?

#3

Re: Drawknives - Back bevel?

Fred Krow

>I have enjoyed drawknives for many years. My preferred style is to have the back flat and convex the bevel side. When using the convex side it is much easier to rotate out of the cut if the wood grain makes it dig deeper. I do not like secondary bevels for drawknives, a leather strop used often is my method for maintaining the edge.

Regards,

Fred Krow

Re: Drawknives - Back bevel?

#4

Use it bevel down :)

Paul Kierstead

>Actually, I am serious. although it is a matter of preference, in my (admittedly fairly limited) experience, I found you really really need to go with the grain and in cases where it is difficult to control, going bevel down helped since you can use it to keep from digging in. YMMV

Re: Drawknives - Back bevel?

#5

Re: Drawknives - Back bevel?

Thom D

>I prefer to use drawknives that have an airfoil section vs. a section like a planer blade. When I use the type that have a "planer blade" I use them with the bevel down. In his DVD Boggs says he prefers to use the planer blade type with the flat down for most chairmaking since he is mainly keeping the cuts traight, however he does apply a slight, shallow curve to the "flat", just at the edge, in order to make it more controlable, which seems a lot like a franken-airfoil section in the end. What I find about using the bevel down on a planer section knife is that while it steers great, it gets tiring since your wrist rather than the tool are providing the stability. With the proper edge geometry you can pull right from you back.

Re: Drawknives - Back bevel?

#6

Re: I do

Dave Mount

>I use a backbevel as Dunbar recommends, but I think what you do in regard to sharpening depends heavily on what you're going to do with the drawknife, as well as personal preference.

My primary use has been shaving green rivings into chair parts. I also use my drawknife bevel up (which counter to many), except when I'm cutting a significant concavity, then bevel down. I'm not going to argue this is "right", but the hand position and closer reference to the working plane just feel better to me. In addition, I like the gently curved drawknives better than the dead straight ones. If you shave bevel up, then your blade is pretty much in the same plane wherever you are on the knife edge. But if you're bevel down, then you have to change your hand position if you change positions on the blade if you are to keep the cut in the same plane. Not that these are big things, it's just stuff that influences me.

Anyway, if one uses a drawknife bevel up, then I think the back bevel is important to providing steerage to the cut (you can move the cut up by rocking the blade all the way flat which would be harder without a backbevel). Even someone that is primarily a bevel down user may sometimes want to switch for a particular cut.

Another thing that may factor in are the sharpening angles. If I remember correctly, Dunbar also suggests a pretty shallow primary bevel (20 degrees comes to mind). I'm not an expert on edge retention, but I think 20 degrees can start to become a pretty fragile edge, particularly when one tends to lever on the edge of a drawknife when steering a cut. Using a 5 degree back bevel increases the stoutness of the cutting edge a little. It also rocks your hand position down a little bit when in the bevel position, which I find more comfortable -- it's that cranked wrist aspect of bevel down use that I dislike.

My $0.02,

Dave

Re: Drawknives - Back bevel?

#7

Re: Drawknives - Back bevel? *LINK*

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>I highly recommend Boggs' dvd "Chairmaker's Tool Kit" available from LN. In particular situations, you need/want to use a draw knife bevel in different orientations; and Boggs explains the options. He also shows how to sharpen and adjust the handles. I learned a lot and am still watching it for things I might have missed the first couple of times through. Nice horse, too.

Pam


Boggs videos half way down this page

Re: Drawknives - Back bevel?

#8

Re: Drawknives - Back bevel?

Tom Price

>Do what Dunbar suggests. The man knows whereof he speaks. It does work well and allows you to pull the knife with the blade in the same plane as the handles. Bevel down is more awkward and you will have less fine control. You can still flip the knife and use it bevel down if you wish.

- Tom

Re: Drawknives - Back bevel?

#9

Thanks all, you've sold me on the idea

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>The rationale for the back bevel makes sense to me. So I'll start with a small "airfoil" bevel and increase it as needed. What's your preferred way to make it?

The way I see it, in order to "balance" the forces in action I only need a fairly small bevel, as it sits solidly on the blank, while the regular bevel pulls the already broken shaving, so little force is applied.

Thanks all,

DC

Re: Drawknives - Back bevel?

#10

Re: Sharpening

Dave Mount

>I like curved knives, so I freehand sharpen with diamond stones (because they don't dish as a result). I took a block of 2x4 about as long as the cutting edge and cut a kerf in it at 20 degrees from horizontal as wide was the spine of the knife. I put the knife in it bevel up and pointing away, then run the stone over it holding it horizontally by eye. Mounting the knife in a block holds it with the handles out of the way, and you can see horizontal pretty easily by eye to gauge the bevel angle.

To work the back, I just lay the knive flat on the edge of the block bevel down and work it with the stone held just above horizontal (circa 5 degrees). Variability in this freehand sharpening tends to give you a slightly convex bevel, but I think this serves you well in controlling the drawknife. Follow with the strop/buff of your choice.

Works for me,

Dave