We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>Check me out on this - there are two bedrocks from the same original owner on eBay that clearly have Type 5 (first flat top)patent dates and tall knobs. However, they are are obviously round tops. If there had been just one I might have been lured into believing that I had found a super rare prototype, but both a 604 and 606 leads me to believe that the guy ground them off. What do you think?
Still, it kind of begs the question: why would someone do that?
I can imagine some crusty old libertine woodworker suddenly receiving a windfall inheritance. He says to himself: "Finally, at long last, I'm gonna get myself a set of new Bedrocks!"
Off he goes to the nearest Western Auto or Marshal-Wells store. The clerks look at his money and dig out the newest Stanley catalogs. Confronted with the facts, he reacts, "What the hell is this! What'dya mean they switched over to flat-tops? I don't want no stinking flat-topped Bedrock."
Just fantasy on my part, obviously.
But, here in Oregon, Grants Pass (selling location on the Ebay ad) has a number of connotations. During the cold war, several publications that marked out the most "survivable" (nuclear attack) locations in the USA, ranked Grants Pass high on the list. Thus, what had been a lumber camp, became a survivalist village of sorts. Marry that with caravans of '60's California hippies looking for rural peace and serenity. The last 10 or 20 years my mental associations about Grants Pass run in the vein of cannabis and methamphetamine. But I'm probably wrong about all this (no Chamber of Commerce emails please).
At any rate, I can imagine a hand-tool lover, years ago, flush with cash and a sense of impending doom, lusting for Bedrocks of a certain profile, heading off to a machine shop after receiving his special order from the local hardware store.
For those wanting to consider more of the details from a Bedrock type study, I suggest:
Personally, I much prefer the round top look to the square top. It has a flow that I find more aesthetic. Perhaps this was the reason for the modification. It is also likely, if the owner went to this trouble, and because he did a good, careful job, that the planes will work well, perhaps even better than new -?! If the price reflected the non-original status, I would go for them as users.
> However, they are are obviously round tops. If there had been just one I might have been lured into believing that I had found a super rare prototype, but both a 604 and 606 leads me to believe that the guy ground them off. What do you think?
Well, I see no structural need for the flat top design (the extra metal doesn't appear in the right place for strength), and ergonomically, there is scope to foul your wrist on the front corner.
I think the square edges may have be removed for the same reason that one might rasp away the arrises on a modern saw handle.