Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Renovation of a Spiers infill smoother *LINK*

Posts

Renovation of a Spiers infill smoother *LINK*

#1

Renovation of a Spiers infill smoother *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)

>Dear friends

The link below will take you to a project of mine that has now come to an end. I'm sure that some of you will find it as interesting as I did.

The short story is that I won a derelict infill smoother on eBay for little money. My plan was to use it as the basis for a project. It looked craftsman-made, in other words nothing special or precious. However, it turned out to be made by Spiers, who is up there with Norris as the doyen of classic infill makers.

This is the story of discovery and the work I have done. It is not a restoration, for that would suggest that I returned the plane to its original state. What I have instead done is use a little Artist's Licence to create something to which I hope Stewart Spiers would give his nod of approval. All I really had was the original Spiers dovetailed steel body and lever cap. I constructed a new level cap screw and new infills, and added a 3/16" parallel Sorby iron (reduced from 2 1/4" to 2"). The bed is 47 degrees.

The link is to the discussion and contrubutions that was made on the Old Tools forum. This is still ongoing , and the article is constantly updated.

This is the original plane:



Then along came this Spiers example to act as a model for my work.



So here is what I came up with: Australians hardwoods - Tasmanian Blackwood for the infills and Jarrah for the tote.



And a few more pictures for perspective:



Thanks for looking.

Regards from Perth

Derek


WKfinetools website

Re: Renovation of a Spiers infill smoother *LINK*

#2

Re: Renovation of a Spiers infill smoother

Marc in Luxembourg

>Hi Derek,

Thank you for sharing your plane project with us. Your work is inspiring and I wonder how you people do for spending all this time on woodworking. Great!

Thanks again, Marc

Re: Renovation of a Spiers infill smoother *LINK*

#3

Re: Renovation of a Spiers infill smoother

Paul in NJ

>Derek,

Excellent job on your infill renovation. I seem to recall reading somewhere that since the infills were hand fitted that the parts were stamped to keep the correct pieces together. I'm not sure if this is correct but it makes sense to me. I am looking forward to seeing shavings once the tuning is complete.

Regards,

Paul Dzioba

Re: Renovation of a Spiers infill smoother *LINK*

#4

Great Job Derek

Scott Burr rockin' Ben Lomond, CA

>I think Mr. Spires would have offered you a job. That's a pretty one!

Now get it tuned up and show us some shavings!

Re: Renovation of a Spiers infill smoother *LINK*

#5

Re: Renovation of a Spiers infill smoother

Dan Clermont in Burnaby

>Very nicely done Derek

The 5's and 7's stamped on the bodies, blades, lever caps represent the parts which belong to each individual plane. From what I understand the the planes were made in batches and the way to keep the parts matched up for individual planes was to stamp them with a number.

Cheers

Dan Clermont

Re: Renovation of a Spiers infill smoother *LINK*

#6

Pictures, and a question for all

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)

>Hi Scott

There was quite a bit of tuning required (all documented in the article in the above link). Eventually, I was able to get the following consistently:

Easy planing on Cherry:



Planing Jarrah against the grain:



Now the question. After all the work done on the Sorby 3/16" iron, it is not doing the job. It hones up to take a very sharp edge, but it loses this very quickly. So I will either need to re-temper it, or replace it. Advice here please. Note that this is a laminated blade.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Renovation of a Spiers infill smoother *LINK*

#7

The blade

Jim Reed @ Tallahassee

>If the blade is not working, then you have nothing to lose by trying to re-temper. 3/16 is stout enough to prevent chatter, but quick dulling means very soft or extremely brittle edge. Since this is a laminated blade, the edge could be too brittle and may be fracturing to dullness. I suggest the *country boy* hardness test. Get a good blade to use as a reference. Put both on the bench and scratch with a pocketknife on the flat side near the cutting edge. On a good plane blade, your knife will slide easily and leave only the faintest scratch. You will be able to tell which is the hardest. Good luck.

Re: Renovation of a Spiers infill smoother *LINK*

#8

Blade Hardness

Steve Elliott

>Nice job on that plane, Derek!

I'd guess that the poor edge retention of the Sorby blade is a result of the amount of steel you had to remove to get past the pits. Laminated blades were made with water-hardening steel, which gets somewhat harder at the surface than oil-hardening steels. If I remember right, the surface is hardened to a depth of about .050", or a good 1/32". The inside of the blade remains softer and tougher, which is great for knives that need to hold a sharp edge but not break easily.

Heat treating the blade might do the trick.

Re: Renovation of a Spiers infill smoother *LINK*

#9

Nice Shavings!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Looks like you made a winner. I have a Hock infill replacement iron in my Preston infilled smoother and I'm very happy with it.