Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Mathieson gouges

Posts

Mathieson gouges

#1

Mathieson gouges

Dean Lapinel

>What is the general feeling about Mathieson gouges as compared to Addis? They look heavier, (which I prefer) but I've not been able to find much on the quality of their metals/edge holding.

Re: Mathieson gouges

#2

Re: Mathieson gouges

Adam Cherubini

>Since nobody else is responding...

If you are comparing mathieson to Addis, I assume you are talking about carving tools.

As for firming gouges, I have several mathiesons and i find them fine for the task (which is rather rough in my work). Mathieson are at least as good as any Sheffield maker in terms of steel.

As for carving tools, I'm not an experienced carver, but my addis tools seem unparalleled. They have marvelously thin blades and seem to have very fine grain. The worn nature of their handles, bolsters, and blades makes them particularly nice to hold, unlike, say, new Henry Taylor gouges.

I hope that helps.

Adam

Re: Mathieson gouges

#3

Thanks Adam!

Dean Lapinel

>

Re: Mathieson gouges

#4

Re: Mathieson gouges

paul womack

>The worn nature of their handles, bolsters, and blades makes them particularly nice to hold, unlike, say, new Henry Taylor gouges.


Isn't that an "old vs new" kinda' deal, as opposed to an "Addis vs Taylor" kinda' deal?

BugBear