Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Shapton 8000's compared to Norton 8000's

Posts

Shapton 8000's compared to Norton 8000's

#1

Shapton 8000's compared to Norton 8000's

Dan Clermont in Burnaby

>Hello Everyone,

I read somewhere the Shapton numbering system is different from the standard stone numbering system. If I recall the Shapton 8000 Pro is equivalent to a 6500 grit size. Is this true? Anybody noticed a difference in scratch patterns along the bevel or the finished surface?

TIA

Dan Clermont

Re: Shapton 8000's compared to Norton 8000's

#2

Data

Christopher Schwarz

>Dan,

Here's the data I have:

Shaptons

4,000 grit = 3.68 micron

8,000 grit = 1.84 micron

16,000 grit = 0.92 micron

Nortons

4,000 grit = 6 micron

8,000 grit = 3 micron

As to the second part of your question, I'm sure that it makes a difference to some people. And I'm sure that it makes no difference to others. I use Shaptons at work and Nortons at home. For me, the difference between the systems is *not* in the final polish.

Chris

Re: Shapton 8000's compared to Norton 8000's

#3

Re: Data

john in KS

>Chris,

Which of the two would you purchase if you had neither and could only get one or the other? The price difference is not as great until you figure in the flattening plate for the Shaptons. Is that what you use to flatten yours.

Thanks in advance!

John

Re: Shapton 8000's compared to Norton 8000's

#4

Re: Data

Christopher Schwarz

>I don't think you have to use the Shapton plate to flatten the Shapton stones. People will disagree, I know. I flatten my Shaptons and Nortons with an old worn-out DMT x-coarse stone and some silicon-carbide powder (#80-grit?) from Lee Valley.

This works great for me, but I am not as persinckety as some, so take that with a grain of silicon-carbide.

On buying a waterstone set-up, I like the Norton 1,000/8,000 combo stone. It handles most of my needs at home. The only time I want the intermediate grit is when I'm flattening the unbeveled face of a tool during setup (there's a lot of metal there). Otherwise, those two grits will do your edge shaping and polishing if you are a micro-bevel person like me.

Shapton has a new set of less-expensive stones coming out very shortly, however, that has a thinner layer bonded to a piece of plate glass. I've been using them since June and like them a lot, too. They should be available soon. And they are real close to the Nortons in price.

So with that, it's a toss-up between the two systems. Both do the job. With the Shaptons, the extra cash means you don't have to soak them before use and they wear more slowly and cut a little faster.

As always, it's a matter of money buying time.

Chris

Re: Shapton 8000's compared to Norton 8000's

#5

Thanks!

john in KS

>Thanks Chris for the response!

John

Re: Shapton 8000's compared to Norton 8000's

#6

grit size is not the whole story

bill tindall

>The scratch depth and profile from an abrasive is dependent on more factors than just grit particle size. This fact make comparisons between different abrasive formats not easy to predict with out testing.

Re: Shapton 8000's compared to Norton 8000's

#7

Re: Data

paul womack

> an old worn-out DMT x-coarse stone

Worn out? (chuckle) I though the high price of those things was predicated on infinite life...

BugBear

Re: Shapton 8000's compared to Norton 8000's

#8

Re: Data

Christopher Schwarz

>The DMT still cuts, just really slowly. The silicon carbide speeds things nicely. And it's still flat, so that's good for flattening stones.

I think the high price is due mostly to the domestic manufacturing and the tricky process they use to do it. I toured the DMT plant once and it was like a cross between a factory and a mad scientist's lab.

This stone is six years old (according to its date stamp) and has seen a lot of edges. I don't consider it a bad value for the work I got out of it.

Chris