Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Tried & True Varnish Oil Sucks??? (FWW)

Posts

Tried & True Varnish Oil Sucks??? (FWW)

#1

Tried & True Varnish Oil Sucks??? (FWW)

Paul Kierstead

>Ok, I am somewhat behind on my reading. I was just reading the "Wipe on Finish Test" in FWW last night (#178, July/August '05 I think?).

On my favorites -- Tried & True Varnish Oil -- got the worse rating. I have used it quite a few times. He said it was hard to wipe on, hard to wipe off, didn't dry (in over 30 days!!!) and wasn't water resistent. Now I don't know about the last item (but admit I probably wouldn't use it somewhere prone to water spillage), but I find it extremely easy to apply (one of the most pleasant and easy actually) and generally quite decently dry in 1-2 days; it isn't exactly speedy, but I have never seen it wet beyond 2 days.

So, am I on crack, lucked into the 'good' can, did he just get a bad batch, what? Do other people have such abysmal results with it? I am curious how his experience could be so different then mine.

Re: Tried & True Varnish Oil Sucks??? (FWW)

#2

Re: Tried & True Varnish Oil Sucks??? (FWW)

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Who is the writer? One thing for sure, he doesn't work for or represent T&T. :)

Pam

Re: Tried & True Varnish Oil Sucks??? (FWW)

#3

Article Author is Chris A. Minick

Paul Kierstead

>

Re: Tried & True Varnish Oil Sucks??? (FWW)

#4

Re: Tried & True Varnish Oil Sucks??? (FWW)

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Paul, people seem to be at extremes when it comes to T&T. I used the varnish oil, and while I didn't find the application difficult, it indeed took forever to dry. The rags I used still werent dry after a month (and they of course were hung with plenty of air circulation), and the desk top I used it on still felt "not dry" after the same amount of time. I also did not get the "thick build" that is claimed (after three coats). Other than its lack of toxicity (i.e. no solvents) I don't see any advantages to the product. The polymerized tung oil sold at LV is miles ahead of T&T IMHO; I used it on a maple hall table I built 10 years ago, and I can vouch as to its ease of application and durability, as this table has seen all kinds of abuse and still looks great.

Yet there are some who swear by T&T. Chris Becksvoort uses it exclusively AFAIK, and likes it very much. But he warms the oil up to the "unbearably hot to the hand" temperature, it is supposed to help in absorption (and possibly in drying time too). My shop hovers around the 70 degree mark year round, and ranges between 30 and 60% RH, so I would tend to believe that my shop conditions are within the bounds of "normalcy" as to atmospheric conditions. Yet the product doesn't work well for me, and I followed the instructions on the can. Maybe there have been bad batches, and Minick (I believe he's the author of that article) and I both received a can from that batch. But given my experience with the product I will not use it again.

DC

Re: Tried & True Varnish Oil Sucks??? (FWW)

#5

Re: Tried & True Varnish Oil Sucks??? (FWW)

Brad in Ottawa

>Paul,

I read the article when it first came out so you will have to excuse my failing memory but... in one of the next issues a letter to the editor made a case for T&T and questioned the factors for the comparison and the applicability of the factors to T&T.

On the other hand, I do know that T&T does seem to have a number of people that have had problems with the finish not drying despite following the directions. I personally used T&T and thought it was a great finish.

T&T does have a shelf life, this might be the reason why some people have problems with the finish. Even a newly purchased can of the finish might have had a long life due to time on the shelf.

Not much here but a suggestion to dig out that next issue for the letter to the editor.

Brad

Re: Tried & True Varnish Oil Sucks??? (FWW)

#6

Re: Tried & True Varnish Oil Sucks??? (FWW)

Tony Zaffuto

>Paul,

Finishing is like using your tools: the more familiar you are with a particular tool (in this case finishing product), the better the results! Personally, I have great results using "General" products, but in fairness, I've got to say I've used this brand far more than any other.

T.Z.

Re: Tried & True Varnish Oil Sucks??? (FWW)

#7

I'm dubious of those results, too...

David Barnett - SW Florida

>"...Tried & True Varnish Oil -- got the worse rating. I have used it quite a few times. He said it was hard to wipe on, hard to wipe off, didn't dry (in over 30 days!!!) and wasn't water resistent."

I've used Tried & True Varnish Oil and Original Finish for years with excellent results, but am also a big fan of both Sutherland Welles and Waterlox and use them perhaps a bit more often. I've tried many if not most of the finishes in this test over the years and have found most to work just fine and pretty much the same with often only subtle differences. The ones I prefer have 'differences that make a difference' to me, however subtle. On the other hand, I find the top-rated Minwax finish to appear somewhat filmy, cheap, and cheesy as it ages, but that's a matter of personal taste, of course.

If Mr. Minick applied T&T in exactly the manner that he applied the other products I could imagine he'd end up with very disappointing results, esp. since speed of drying was a top criterion. The advantages of using T&T products; thick build, superb appearance, low toxicity, almost endless shelf-life, and so on) are often lost on woodworkers used to other wipe-on finishes and I've known one to get downright angry at the drying and curing times, and this was during the same period, in the same shop, from the same batch (same can, even), and on the same wood. Only the techniques and temperments varied.

T&T has superb build properties if and only if one allows a thorough initial soak-in and gives it plenty of time to 'set up'. Wiping it off too early results in low build. You need good penetration on the first coat and plenty of initial oxidation time for those organic chains or subsequent coats will fail. You'll likely end up with results like Minick's. Lately, some cans have stickers that warn about thin coats. Heed this admonition on all subsequent coats.

If anyone's having trouble with T&T, watch Chris Becksvoort's FWW video clip for application method. It isn't hard to do at all. I rather enjoy the process. Don't just wait a given interval (twelve hours, one day, whatever) before reapplying, however. Examine it. See how it feels. Is it colder than the unfinished wood? Wipe it with a towel. Any oil, no matter how faintly if appears? It could take two days, or three, or five depending on humidity, temperatures, air flow, wood characteristics and thoroughness of extraneous wet oil removal. If it takes longer, though, consider you may have overapplied (it needs thin subsequent coats to facilitate cross-linking reactions), and that wipe-off may have been less than complete. I wipe my finish down several times with dry paper towels between coats to remove any oil that may have bled from pores before setting up. Full cure may take weeks and longer after the piece is delivered and in use.

I've never found it extra trouble to work this way. On the contrary, the time it took wasn't in the labor but in the waiting, and the advantages of quick build, ease of application, and being able to breathe easily (I'm asthmatic), and above all, the final appearance (especially with final coats of Original Finish in some instances) was well worth any extended overall time.

So why do I also like Sutherland Welles and Waterlox? Sutherland Welles looks better than anything I've ever used on mahogany and walnut, penetration and build can be controlled with severl solids concentrations, and blue-magenta range components offset some of the ambering effect. Most of all, I love the velvety matte finishes I get (I'm not a glossy kind o' guy). Waterlox, however, is the most versatile all-round finish I've found. It penetrates so well I often lay down a coat of shellac to control speed and depth. It sets up really quickly, builds well, 'cooks' well with reasonable rubbing, crosslinks like crazy (helps to work in sections on subsequent coats), and can be rubbed out, matted, deluxed in little time. Sands in like a charm and dries very hard.

But for maple, cherry, walnut (if you want the warmer tones), and especially if it's something I'm building for myself and will maintain over the years, then it's apt to be Tried & True.

Re: Tried & True Varnish Oil Sucks??? (FWW)

#8

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Tried & True Varnish Oil Sucks??? (FWW)

Jim in Burlington On

>It can take months to dry. I put it inside my tool cabinet and you can still smell it more than a year later. Personally I put my in a squeeze bottle and heat it in boiling water. It does require a fair bit of elbow work. I often wipe on Minwax satin wipe on poly over it.

Re: Tried & True Varnish Oil Sucks??? (FWW)

#9

Re: Tried & True Varnish Oil Sucks??? (FWW)

Wendell @ Murphy, TX

>I've never tried the T&T Varnish Oil myself but I've heard at least three guys at my woodworking club complain that the finish never dried for them. I have tried the T&T Danish Oil and it works fine for me.

Wendell

Re: Tried & True Varnish Oil Sucks??? (FWW)

#10

Re: Tried & True Varnish Oil Sucks??? (FWW)

Dan Clermont in Burnaby

>I have used T & T with no problems.

It does take longer to dry and I think the key is to heat it up so it penetrates and wipes better

I too was surprised with the test results and negative feedback in FWW

Dan Clermont

Re: Tried & True Varnish Oil Sucks??? (FWW)

#11

Re: I'm dubious of those results, too...

Paul Kierstead

>Don't just wait a given interval (twelve hours, one day, whatever) before reapplying, however. Examine it. See how it feels. Is it colder than the unfinished wood? Wipe it with a towel. Any oil, no matter how faintly if appears?

I think you might be onto something there. Examining my application methods, it is quite a lot like that; especially for the first few hours after application, I examine it a few times, make sure the oil is not coming up out of pores, go over it, etc. Between application and the first 'wipe off the excess', I am fairly attentive to make sure it is nicely covered etc and wipe off the excess pretty vigorously to make sure excess oil is not there. Perhaps it is style.

Re: Tried & True Varnish Oil Sucks??? (FWW)

#12

Interesting stuff.

Paul Kierstead

>Interesting to see that the experiences with it are so widely varied; at least I know the magazine author is not an 'isolated incident'. I use the method in the Becksvoort (sp) video to apply it, which mostly involves being messy about it and wiping down really well.

I guess it re-enforces that many aspects of such things are 'fact' (especially the parts like application), more personal experience, preference and habit.

Re: Tried & True Varnish Oil Sucks??? (FWW)

#13

An obvious blunder...

David Barnett - SW Florida

>Minick states early on: "I applied the first coat with a lint-free cloth, adding more finish as dry spots appeared. After 15 minutes, I wiped off the excess and allowed the panel to dry for 24 hours."

Quite plainly, that is not how Tried & True Varnish Oil is applied, and might as well have been designed to insure failure. It was neither competent nor fair. Ignorance? Arrogance? Stubborness?Sloppiness? An axe to grind? Inadvertantly embedded bias? Who knows? It's like the guy who told his doc that the suppositories he'd prescribed were "...greasy, tasted awful, bloody 'ell to swallow and for all the good they done me, I might as well have shoved 'em up me bum!"

Re: Tried & True Varnish Oil Sucks??? (FWW)

#14

What the Inventor Said

Phil Gaudio

>When I first used the T&T varnish oil, I also had less than stellar results, but since I was a total finishing amateur, I assumed that it was operator error and not the fault of the product. I called the manufacturer and talked to the guy who runs the company and invented this product. The can I bought had a label on top that read "apply thin coats". That is apparently the "secret" to success with this product. The owner of the company said half jokingly something to the effect that if the piece your finishing is in the same room with an open can of T&T varnish oil, you've applied almost enough finish. Sure enough, when I backed off on the application rate, the finish dried in a reasonable time. I have a set of cherry end tables and other pieces that look great, years later. He also mentioned that it was NOT a good idea to heat the product before application (a concept that I believe was mentioned in a FWW article involving a shaker piece if I am remembering correctly). He indicated that by heating the product, you were more likely to apply too much. I think the fatal flaw in the subject review of the product was failure to follow directions for that specific product (imagine that: not reading the directions?).

Re: Tried & True Varnish Oil Sucks??? (FWW)

#15

Correction

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>What I used was the Danish oil, not the varnish oil.

I just went to read Minick's article again, and what he says about the varnish oil applies verbatim to the Danish oil nevertheless...

DC

Re: Tried & True Varnish Oil Sucks??? (FWW)

#16

That would be Joe Robson (longish)

David Barnett - SW Florida

>"Sherman, set the Way-Back Machine to July 1994... "

I'd just read Chris Becksvoort's "Tried & True varnish oil and wood finish" on page 36 of my just off-the-press Fine Woodworking, No. 107, and wasted no time calling the number at the end of the article, ordered a quart of each finish and spoke at length to a very enthusiastic Joe Robson, who gave me a crash course on the history of oil finishing, how Tried & True was developed and how to use it. He explained why you must apply so very little of this semi-polymerized oil for each coat and why you need to wait longer before wiping it off than other oils and oil-varnish mixtures. He joked about whether he could sell enough if customers applied it correctly, and that Becksvoort would need to make a lot of furniture to use up his supply (as he was apparently taking no chances). I could hardly wait to try it (he had me at "non-toxic", though).

I can't remember if it was Robson or Becksvoort who suggested how to get a sense for how this oil spreads and how little will do the job (Becksvoort now warms the oil before applying to bare wood and aggresively pushes it around, wiping it off thoroughly, however, which is quicker*). So I put a drop of the honey-like varnish oil every four inches in a grid pattern, then spread each one in all directions until they overlapped. There weren't many spots where more was needed. This was a worthwhile experiment but I find it better to use more on initial coats and wipe down for longer, preferring paper towels to cloth rags as does Becksvoort. You really want to remove the excess oil and you're more likely to than with rags, IMO. Extra time, energy and paper towels pay off here. I keep rubbing until I can hold the paper to a light without any visible oil.*

That fall, I showed T&T to a few students at One Cottage Street and Leeds Design in Easthampton, MA and a couple caught on and took it up, although oil-varnish mixtures (adding turps and extra oil to McClosky's Spar Varnish was very popular then) and sprayed films didn't lose any advocates, as I remember.

By the way, the Original Finish goes on far easier than the Varnish Oil. The emulsified beeswax makes it spread almost effortlessly and wiping off the excess is quick, although you should still do the light test. This stuff is my go-to finish for hard maple bench tops that get a lot of wear. Wipe on a bit from time to time and the dings and scratches look downright beautiful to me, cleans easily, and spilled glue just pops right off. This is a lower to medium lustre finish, which I prefer in most cases, so I often apply it as the final coats to pieces with Varnish Oil, but it's good on bare wood, too.

__________________________________________________________

*As my shop was even colder than Becksvoort's during the winter, I sometimes used a heat gun on the low setting to warm the wood before and after application, and occasionally I'd set a jar of the oil in a water-filled glue pot, but this never really got the oil warm enough.

**Apparently, this wasn't how Minick did it. Why? I don't know, although you'd have thought he might've read at least one FWW piece where T&T was successfully applied or talked to at least one woodworker who uses the stuff and likes it. As you said, "I think the fatal flaw in the subject review of the product was failure to follow directions for that specific product (imagine that: not reading the directions?)."

Re: Tried & True Varnish Oil Sucks??? (FWW)

#17

Re: That would be Joe Robson (longish)

Phil Gaudio

>Yes, I believe you are correct, that would be Joe Robson I was referring to. Very helpful I might add, and in my opinion, he has produced a very good product that I've enjoyed using. As a matter of fact, I've used all three of the T&T products, with great success. It would be a shame if potential users were dissuaded from using these products as a result of that review in FWW.

Re: Tried & True Varnish Oil Sucks??? (FWW)

#18

I have little doubt...

David Barnett - SW Florida

>...this review cost the Robson's money. Even Ellis, who is as fair-minded as they come, was surprised I use Tried & True when I mentioned it during a Finishing Chat recently, and seemed to think it was more trouble than it was worth, although I can't recall whether he'd tried it himself with poor results or had read or heard it. So experiences certainly vary for whatever reasons. If Paul and you and I hadn't already had good results with T&T, I sincerely doubt we'd have plopped twenty-five bucks down to try a can after that review.

Denis and others had less than glorious results so who can blame them for agreeing, at least in part, with Minick's findings. I think you're probably right about a plain failure to realize that all application techniques for wiping finishes cannot be judged alike, rather than any lack of veracity on his part.

In fairness to all, because T&T is so different, perhaps more extensive instructions should be included, even it if means printing a separate brochure. The small typefaces on T&T and most other finishes can be amazingly hard to read for some of us presbyopic fossils. No excuse for someone conducting a comparison for publication, however.

Re: Tried & True Varnish Oil Sucks??? (FWW)

#19

Just to set the clock straight...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>As I mentioned earlier, I used the Danish oil, not the varnish oil. I bought it before Minick's review (which is for the varnish oil), and after reading from Chris Becksvoort about how good the product was, thick build and all. The lack of harmful solvents was the "cherry on top of the sundae", that allowed me to finish projects inside my basement shop without endangering my family.

I just went and fetched the can, just to make sure I did read the instructions correctly and applied the product properly.

Here are the instructions on the can:

--------------------------

The shop rule for a traditional hand rubbed finish is warm, thin, dry, and cure. You can obtain good results by following and repeating this simple procedure:

1. Wood and finish should be at room temperature (70 or higher) throughout the finishing process

2. Apply a thorough but thin wet coat

3. Allow to penetrate 5 minutes

4. Wipe off (rub in) briskly with lint-free soft cloths until the surface is completely dry. A clean cloth should not drag or pick up any oil

5. Allow to stand (cure) 8-10 hours

6. Buff with a soft cloth. The more you rub the better it will look

Additional coats deepen the shine and increase protection.

-----------------------------------

I did follow the instructions TO THE LETTER, except for 5. where I gave the piece one or two days to cure between each coat, much more than indicated, which should help, not hinder the process. I did not invent my own application method, and I still don't need corrective glasses to read...

I think the maker tried to oversell the product in an unrealistic manner. If you had read on the can that the product will need at least a month to dry (if that), would you buy the product?...

Maybe I got a bad batch. Quality control problems? Monday morning or Friday afternoon batch? I don't know, and frankly I don't care. All I know is that I bought the product based on its promises, followed the instructions to the letter, and the product did not live up to said promises. Based on what what I've read (haven't tried it myself), the product performed no better than cheap raw linseed oil.

Oh, and the finish... The desk I used it on is built from glued up boards (all solid maple), and some boards hardly took any finish, while others took quite a bit more and turned blotchy.

I can't judge on the varnish oil, and after reading all the comments here I'm willing to give it a try. I'm not trying to put down T&T (what reasons would I have for doing that?) as a company, and I really appreciate the fact that the product is nontoxic. But in the end it has to work as advertized, which for the Danish oil is definitely not the case, in my experience.

My confusion (varnish vs. Danish) stems from Minick's review, whose experience was so similar to mine that I didn't pay attention to the fact that he reviewed a different product. Mea culpa...

I will therefore buy a can of the varnish oil and report back when I use it...

DC

Re: Tried & True Varnish Oil Sucks??? (FWW)

#20

Aha! They've changed the instructions. *LINK*

David Barnett - SW Florida

>If the can said 8-10 hours, then 8-10 hours it should've been. Although I've never seen those instructions nor used T&T Danish Oil, I had to wonder how even a low-viscosity oil without solvents or metallic driers could cure enough to recoat in so few hours, and sure enough, when I went to Tried & True's website your suspicion: "I think the maker tried to oversell the product in an unrealistic manner." appears confirmed. The instructions now call for 24 hours between coats, and based on your experience, I'd not be surprised if a longer wait might not improve things, even at the recommended 70F or higher ambient temperature. Also, I was surprised that no mention of recoat intervals was mentioned in the online Varnish Oil instructions, whereas the Original Finish states: "Allow at least 24 hours between coats."

These instructions are inconsistent and inadequate, and if they're presented with overly optimistic or atypical recoat intervals in an attempt to gain parity with other products, I'd say that's one bonehead marketing strategy. I'd much rather read that T&T crawls to a cure but is entirely non-toxic tham get your disappointing results, Denis.


"Additional Information about Danish Oil"

Re: Tried & True Varnish Oil Sucks??? (FWW)

#21

Re: Just to set the clock straight...

Paul Kierstead

>I think the maker tried to oversell the product in an unrealistic manner. If you had read on the can that the product will need at least a month to dry (if that), would you buy the product?...

To be fair, I have never had it not dry in 2 days. In fact, I can only recall once when it wasn't dry in 1 day, and I was pretty slack in wiping it dry.

I *really* needs to be thoroughly wiped dry in the "wipe off the excess" part. I haven't used the Danish oil (only the original and varnish oil). I think characterizing it in general as requiring 30 days is unfair. At least you could add "in my experience".

Re: Tried & True Varnish Oil Sucks??? (FWW)

#22

Paul, I did wipe it dry

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>--------------------

I *really* needs to be thoroughly wiped dry in the "wipe off the excess" part. I haven't used the Danish oil (only the original and varnish oil). I think characterizing it in general as requiring 30 days is unfair. At least you could add "in my experience".

---------------------

I refer you to instruction #4: "A clean cloth should not drag or pick up any oil", which is exactly what I did.

The 30 day mention was used to illustrate that the product would not sell if that was mentioned as part of the instructions. It just also happened to be "my experience", which I described it in my first posting in this thread. I just didn't think that I needed to repeat it again.

DC

Re: Tried & True Varnish Oil Sucks??? (FWW)

#23

I will tell you...

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>That a friend of mine uses these products excluisely to finish his turnings and it has vastly improved the look and sale of his work.

Prior to the T&T he was sanding in the oil(Watco,Waterlox,etc) and his work always looked "muddy".We both use native burl,curl,etc and he wanted the depth and popped figure that I was getting without the many hours(my wife says "Untold hours") of sanding I commit to my work.

The T&T has improved his work to where it`s(almost;^) as good as mine with about 1/2 the work.He likes that it takes so long to dry as it adds to the time he can sand it in and the results speak for themselves.

Other turners I`ve talked to who use it also swear by it,and turners are a notoriously impatient bunch.

I may even have to pony up the cash for a can and give up my 4 part finish.Then I can give my brother Bill back all his measuring cups.;^)

Mainely,Bob