Just to set the clock straight...
Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.
>As I mentioned earlier, I used the Danish oil, not the varnish oil. I bought it before Minick's review (which is for the varnish oil), and after reading from Chris Becksvoort about how good the product was, thick build and all. The lack of harmful solvents was the "cherry on top of the sundae", that allowed me to finish projects inside my basement shop without endangering my family.
I just went and fetched the can, just to make sure I did read the instructions correctly and applied the product properly.
Here are the instructions on the can:
--------------------------
The shop rule for a traditional hand rubbed finish is warm, thin, dry, and cure. You can obtain good results by following and repeating this simple procedure:
1. Wood and finish should be at room temperature (70 or higher) throughout the finishing process
2. Apply a thorough but thin wet coat
3. Allow to penetrate 5 minutes
4. Wipe off (rub in) briskly with lint-free soft cloths until the surface is completely dry. A clean cloth should not drag or pick up any oil
5. Allow to stand (cure) 8-10 hours
6. Buff with a soft cloth. The more you rub the better it will look
Additional coats deepen the shine and increase protection.
-----------------------------------
I did follow the instructions TO THE LETTER, except for 5. where I gave the piece one or two days to cure between each coat, much more than indicated, which should help, not hinder the process. I did not invent my own application method, and I still don't need corrective glasses to read...
I think the maker tried to oversell the product in an unrealistic manner. If you had read on the can that the product will need at least a month to dry (if that), would you buy the product?...
Maybe I got a bad batch. Quality control problems? Monday morning or Friday afternoon batch? I don't know, and frankly I don't care. All I know is that I bought the product based on its promises, followed the instructions to the letter, and the product did not live up to said promises. Based on what what I've read (haven't tried it myself), the product performed no better than cheap raw linseed oil.
Oh, and the finish... The desk I used it on is built from glued up boards (all solid maple), and some boards hardly took any finish, while others took quite a bit more and turned blotchy.
I can't judge on the varnish oil, and after reading all the comments here I'm willing to give it a try. I'm not trying to put down T&T (what reasons would I have for doing that?) as a company, and I really appreciate the fact that the product is nontoxic. But in the end it has to work as advertized, which for the Danish oil is definitely not the case, in my experience.
My confusion (varnish vs. Danish) stems from Minick's review, whose experience was so similar to mine that I didn't pay attention to the fact that he reviewed a different product. Mea culpa...
I will therefore buy a can of the varnish oil and report back when I use it...
DC