Re: Greg, what's a good angle then?
Greg Sloop, Portland Oregon
>What�s a good angle:
Good question.
First, a good angle is one that works well for the woods you use. If you use more common stuff like maple oak, jatoba, etc. then you probably don�t need the highest angles. If you do use tougher exotics � especially with a lot of figure then the higher angles are useful. In short, use the lowest angle that will still produce a decent surface.
In my experience in testing a whole range of cut angles, 37, 40, 45, 47, 50, 52, 55, 57, 60, 62 and 65 degrees I�ve found three that work best for me. (This probably isn�t every one I�ve tried/tested, but it�s most of them.)
37 degrees: This is what I use for end grain and puttering around. Long-grain/side grain Oak often planes just fine, so does poplar. You�d be surprised how much you can do. This is generally where I start if I�m not sure what to use.
LN also does a toothed iron at 37 degrees that I liked a lot. I think LV�s is at 45 total angle, and it works well as well. If you�re trying to remove deep tear-out or a lot of material, this is a great way to do it without generating even more tear-out. Less work than a regular iron, and since it�s toothed, it doesn�t produce tear-out. A few final passes with a high angle iron will clean it all up and leave a very nice surface. It�s a very nice trick to have in the bag, IMHO.
50 degrees: This is what I use on nearly everything else. Some Lacewood and QS Sycamore as well as some Walnut with inclusions/knots are recent examples of something that I couldn�t do on 50 degrees, but most stuff works well here. It�s a lot less work pushing 50 degrees than 65 too. I�ve tried 45 and 47, as well as 52. 50 doesn�t seem much worse to push than 45, and it�s a bit cleaner in some cases too. 52 isn�t much better, and it seems a fair bit harder to push. 50�s a nice compromise.
65 degrees: As you can see above, I�ve tried a whole host of angles from 50 up to 65. Above 57, things appear to get better � quite a lot, but still not as easy to get great results. Iron sharpness has to be very good, Mouth size and depth of cut is really sensitive. 62 works pretty well too. 65 seems optimal and not a lot different than 57 or 62 in terms of force needed. (You won�t be taking a very rank cut at anything above 55 or so anyway�) It�s easiest to get the perfect finish on the stuff I�ve worked with at 65 degrees, without having to resort to a whole host of gimmicks.
That�s it. Three irons covers everything I�ve ever done. There might be a case or two where you�d still have to pull out a scraper, but it sure isn�t going to be often. I tend to believe with a little futzing you can make almost anything end up perfect or virtually so with these three.
Edge retention:
Ah, here we get theoretical.
First, how would one test for this?
Second, do we even care much what the result is? (Perhaps, but I doubt it will make much difference.)
A board I�m going to plane at 65, simply won�t plane well at 50. Often the reverse is true too. So, lets assume, just for the sake of argument that a 65 degree iron will last half as long as a 50. (I don�t think for a minute this is true, but assume the fiction is fact.) Even if that�s true, what does it net a person? It�s not like I�m going to crank out twice as many tear-out filled boards with my 50 vs. perfect boards with the 65. I want a perfect board, or nearly so.
So, to test this, you�d have to use an objective, absolute measure of sharpness like Brent Beach does. (Hope I�ve spelled his name right�) You couldn�t use the surface of the board to measure it, because one will probably turn out a good surface and the other won�t.
Further, I�m not sure edge retention will be worse on a 65 degree iron.
As angles get larger you have two factors working against each other.
A) You have a larger angle. Larger angles tend to have more support and tend to last longer.
B) Larger angles will have higher forces acting on them (and the wood) thus likely losing a keen edge faster.
So at what angles does B overcome A? I sure don�t know. I don�t think anyone does. And, what�s the curve for the change. Is it linear, or an accelerating curve etc.
Knowing these things _might_ help us make more informed and scientific decisions for the proper angle given that several work equally as well in producing a perfect surface.
Finally, go look at the chip formation issues in the Sharpening book by Leonard Lee. You�ll note that all those cutting edges have no mouth at all. None.
The wood simply fails differently when a higher angle is applied, and IMHO, there�s an appropriate angle for every wood. When the proper angle is used, the results can be fairly startling as I�ve found.
Hope that�s food for thought.
I�ll also answer Dan here.
Dan, I don�t believe you�re even close to objective. You have a serious bent against LV for who knows why. You continue to claim that 50 degrees ought to be enough for everybody. You�ve even claimed that I should quit using QS Sycamore since it will prevent me from doing any wood-working etc. So, I don�t think it�s worth wasting anyone�s time and effort to send you a piece. (I guess I say, �Enjoy your Jihad.�)
What I can say is this, and it�s final. If you like 50 degrees and it works for everything you do, that�s great. I have no problem with it. Enjoy.
However, Lynn, myself, Derek and numerous others have found that 50 degrees isn�t enough for quite a number of situations. Since I�ve sampled literally like a dozen different angles on a single set of boards with no less than 5 different plane bodies I feel pretty confident in my conclusions. I don�t need you to confirm for me what I already know to be true. (I�ve tried most of these angles on a LN 62, at least a couple of LV 62.5�s, a LV heavy smoother, a LV BU Jointer, a LN 60.5 block and a Baily #7 at 45 degrees � and perhaps a few others I�ve forgotten�.)
The original poster asked about mouth size, and since I�ve done some pretty extensive personal testing I think I�ve got a pretty good handle on that discussion.
I�m not the only one that�s found the profound difference that total cut angle makes. Lynn, myself and Derek seemed to have reached the 65 degrees as our preferred angle pretty much independently. But perhaps you�re right and the rest of us are all on crank.
Oh, and BTW, there�s huge variation on QS anything. QS simply means it�s been sawn on the quarter. The figure on QS Sycamore, Lacewood etc, can go from looking nearly plain flat sawn to incredible.
The hardest stuff to plane is that where the rings are nearly tangential to the face of the board. (The rings are intersecting the board face at angles nearly parallel to the face.) Really big trees produce the best boards with lots of figure across the whole face. Usually you also get a lot of sapwood on these boards too and the sapwood is a lot softer and tears out a lot easier and deeper.
Cheers,
Greg